5 ms·
I’m not a sailor, but I was struck when touring various mueseum ships, including ships in service into the late 70s. They were pretty barebones in terms of equi
by Spooky23 8y ago
I’m not a sailor, but I was struck when touring various mueseum ships, including ships in service into the late 70s. They were pretty barebones in terms of equipment, comfort and distraction.
With the light distraction of screens, reliance on automated systems, reduced crew levels, and leadership focused on things other than sailing ships, it seems to be an argument that has some merit to me.
- kristofferR 8y agoIt was also a few minutes after a shift change too.
- pdonis 8y agoThis in itself is a red flag: you should not be changing the watch during transit of a heavy traffic area. You do that well before you get into the heavy traffic area, and you put your highest skilled watchstanders on the bridge, so they have both the experience to handle heavy traffic and the time to build proper situational awareness before the heavy traffic builds up.
- zentiggr 8y agoThis - my time as control room crew on a sub, we knew we were in for as long a maneuvering watch as we had to stand, to get from open water to a pier or vice versa. Only in very unusual circumstances did the watchstanders rotate, with the exception of the helmsman and his relief. Especially not Sonar, Fire Control, Radar and the Quaartermaster. If that discipline has broken down, ah, crap, may as well leave em pierside, or you're just pushing around REALLY expensive bumper cars.
- hansthehorse 8y agoSurface nuclear ops here. Served in the engine room of a nuclear destoyer in the 70s and early 80's. We did not relieve the watch leaving port until we cleared into open water. Same with proceding to dock. You stayed until done. When docking the crew that would have relieved the engine room assisted in pulling shore power cables then went to relieve the watch and shut down the reactors and engine room.
- seszett 8y agoI'm just speculating here, but I don't think the Norwegian navy actually operates as if it could potentially be in combat situation at any time. Not sure if what I'm saying is clear (and I don't have the correct terms, especially in English) but on French navy ships and I guess on US ships as well, the general ambiance is that the situation is always serious and whatever operation is done as if it was in the context of combat. I have been on a few ships of "less relevant" navies (no offense but the Australian or South African navies just see less action) and there the whole crew was usually more relaxed and would behave more casually with regards to unforeseen events. This is not criticism, but I think frequent action does help with keeping discipline, while infrequent action makes it easy to slip into more comfortable routine.
- angry_octet 8y agoThis is an epically uninformed comment.
- seszett 8y agoIt's just my observation from my time aboard ships of the French, Australian and South African navies in the South Indian Ocean. I didn't work as closely with the men aboard the South African and Australian ships, so maybe I got a wrong idea there.
- dotancohen 8y agoA few years ago in Tromso I had the pleasure of talking with a Norwegian infantry soldier. Having served in Israeli infantry it was very interesting to both of us to share what we could. Note that this was 2013, before Russia invaded Ukraine. From what I gathered, the Norwegian army (don't know about navy) is on constant alert for a Russian attack. Norway is very oil rich, and sits right at Russia's border. Russia outguns and outnumbers Norway, and they have experience in similar climates. From what I gathered, the Norwegian military is about as vigilant as I felt the Israeli military is. They may not be attacked constantly as we are, but they know that a single attack could end their way of life in minutes.
- i_am_proteus 8y agoThis. The watch in that situation would be the A-team, and wouldn't get relieved until the ship is in a lower-traffic area. That watch team would also brief the entire transit for expected hazards, i.e. "watch for tankers leaving the terminal." But also, a sub on the surface puts the conning officer on the bridge, which provides insanely good situational awareness compared to just having a periscope.
- mjlee 8y agoThe light distraction thing has been taken into account on all ships I've been on, including warships. Everything that can be dimmed is dimmed, normally to the point where it's not really usable without a hood or turning up the brightness when you need it. Everything that can't be dimmed gets a curtain made up for it.
- quickben 8y agoInteresting. What wouldn't be usually dimmable?
- mjlee 8y agoNormally equipment that's still in development or is bought off the shelf[1]. Power LEDs on a laptop charger for example. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_off-the-shelf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_off-the-shelf
- short_sells_poo 8y agoLight distraction is real. It's like trying to drive with your headlights off, while a bright lcd panel is glaring into your eyes. Your vision is going to be seriously compromised. Another good reason for relatively barebones or simple equipment is the old Murphy's law that anything that can go wrong, will go wrong. Both electric and mechanical systems will routinely break, and things that can be repaired with a duct tape, hammer or screwdriver will be much less of a hassle than a fancy digital doodad.