7 ms·
My personal suspicion is that the integrated approach can eventually be a liability. If you have an integrated process/design house, process can count on desig
by dnautics 8y ago
My personal suspicion is that the integrated approach can eventually be a liability. If you have an integrated process/design house, process can count on design to work around its shortcomings and failures. By contrast, if you are process only, and multiple firms make designs for the process, you have to make your process robust, which means that your process staff is ready and has good practices down when it's time to shrink.
^^ Note that this is entirely baseless speculation.
- Nokinside 8y agoIntel has always been a process first, design second company. The company was founded by physicists and chemists. Their process has always been the best in the world until just recently. Intel brings in or buys design talent when needed, but their R&D in process technology is their strongest suit even today.
- stcredzero 8y agoIntel has always been a process first, design second company. The company was founded by physicists and chemists. Their process has always been the best in the world until just recently. So they had a particular advantage, and exploited the heck out of it, but now the potency of that advantage is largely gone?
- n-gatedotcom 8y agoI don't know what country you're in but in cricket there's a concept of innings and scoring runs. There's this dude who averaged nearly a 100 in every innings, most others average 50. Now think of the situation as him scoring a few knots. Is he old and retiring? Or is this just a slump in form? Nobody knows! I worked for a design team and we were proud of our material engineers.
- stcredzero 8y agoBack in about 1996, most of the profs were going on about how x86 would crumble under the weight of the ISA, and RISC was the future. One of my profs knew people at Intel, and talked of a roadmap they had for kicking butt for the next dozen years. Turns out, the road map was more or less right. Is there more roadmap?
- hermitdev 8y agoIntel chips are RISC under the hood these days (for a long while - decade or more). They're CISC at the ASM layer before the instructions are decoded and dispatched by the microcode.
- earenndil 8y agoCISC is still an asset rather than a liability, though, as it means you can fit more code into cache.
- n-gatedotcom 8y agoWhat is an example of a commonly used complex instruction that is "simplified"/DNE in RISC? (in asm, not binary)
- gpderetta 8y agoLoad-op instructions do not normally exist on RISC, but are common on CISC.
- adrianN 8y agoYou do have to worry about the µ-op cache nowadays.
- wtallis 8y agoYou can fit more code into the same sized cache, but you also need an extra cache layer for the decoded µops, and a much more complicated fetch/decode/dispatch part of the pipeline. It clearly works, at least for the high per-core power levels that Intel targets, but it's not obvious whether it saves transistors or improves performance compared to having an instruction set that accurately reflects the true execution resources, and just increasing the L1i$ size. Ultimately, only one of the strategies is viable when you're trying to maintain binary compatibility across dozens of microarchitecture generations.
- oblio 8y agoYour parallel is hard to follow for people who don't watch cricket. I have no idea how 100 or 50 "innings" relate to a few "knots". Are they like some sort of weird imperial measures? (furlongs vs fathoms?)
- jholman 8y agoI suspect that "knots" was supposed to be "noughts", a.k.a zeros. That is, the last few times the 100-point batsman was at bat, he got struck out without scoring any points. Is he washed up? I don't think it's a very useful analogy. :)
- ctack 8y agoKnots as in ducks?
- pcnix 8y agoWhat you speculate is actually happening to some extent, Intel's designs work around their fabrication quirks in order to achieve their performance, and this makes Intel unable to easily separate out their fabrication business in order to take up external contracts, or unable to effectively change designs easily in order to use external fabricators.
- bloomer 8y agoIt turns out that the effect is typically exactly the opposite. Design and process are already coupled where a given process will have design rules that must be adhered to to achieve a successfully manufacturable design. Intel only has to support their own designs so can have very strict design rules. Fabs like TSMC have to be more lenient in what they allow from their customers so have looser design rules that result in a less optimized process to achieve the same yield.
- dnautics 8y agoThe speculation is exactly that what you describe is indeed a short term gain, but that the pressure of having to accommodate looser design rules nets a stronger process discipline which pays off in the long term as feature size shrinkage gets closer to physical limits.