12 ms·
Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cjslep 8y agoNextCloud, ForgeFed, ValueFlows, MoodleNet, Pleroma, Mastodon, PixelFed ("soon"), PeerTube, WriteFreely, Anancus... (so many more) The ActivityPub grassroots is slowly growing.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoMy hope is that as the fediverse grows, support becomes a must-have feature for any new social site/app. A nascent social site doesn't need to attract an initial core community if it can plug you into one that already exists.
- api 8y agoHow will these systems defend against spam, click farms, troll armies, and AI assisted or powered sock puppeting when they get big and/or influential? This is usually what kills federated and decentralized communication platforms. They can work fine as long as they are too niche for bad actors to target, but as soon as there is money to be made or political influence to be had from targeting them they are destroyed by abuse. It's a major threat for the centralized platforms, and those are easier to defend. Today's Internet is a battlefield in a global information war and new systems must be designed accordingly. Unfortunately most efforts that I see in these areas still make optimistic assumptions and underestimate the sophistication and determination of bad actors.
- Kye 8y agoInstances that don't police this get silenced or defederated. Much of the fediverse is made up of small invite-only instances that share information on bad actors like this. The bigger ones have mod teams and are generally run by people who don't equivocate on keeping bad actors to protect ad revenue. edit: This is, at a minimum, a good experiment to see if these kinds of propaganda are inherent to social media or only possible because ad-funded silos are loathe to ban obvious bad actors and not enable them with their tools. I'm on the side of blaming Facebook and Twitter. They didn't create propaganda, but they sure did make it cheap and easy.
- api 8y agoThat's a start, but my concern is that the volunteer militia will get swamped and burnt out when the real attacks come. Right now Mastodon and other ActivityPub platforms are too small for a Cambridge Analytica / Russian FSB or other similar caliber actors to bother with. Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, etc. are where most of the users are so that's where most of the effort will go. If these platforms ever "tip" into mainstream adoption, prepare to be targeted by organized crime gangs running financial scams, nation states, corporate PR firms, and other organizations with hundred million to billion dollar budgets. What I really wanted to do was to stress the fact that this is a battlefield. One of the trends I see in the early 21st century is the dematerialization of warfare. Wars can now be fought entirely online. Governments can be toppled. Economies can be destroyed. Corporations can be imploded. All this can be done with a mixture of cyber attacks and propaganda. As a result we are seeing the redirection of military budgets toward these things. The sort of spam and amateur brigading that most volunteers are used to dealing with on social forums and platforms is nothing compared to what the big social media platforms are facing now and that is nothing compared to what's coming. Billions of dollars are currently being spent by PR firms, advertisers, and governments to develop increasingly advanced AI and big data powered propaganda platforms to weaponize the Internet. In the future we'll probably see fully automated AI driven propaganda, what I've started calling "con artistry at scale." Federated and decentralized platforms are very vulnerable in ways that silos are not, and this has to be thought about. It's easy to create quiet apparently friendly and normal Sybil nodes that passively suck down data and then use that data to mount active attacks from other directions. Volunteers may fight active attacks, but they may have no way of knowing which apparently normal nodes are actually passive participants in those attacks. Also keep in mind that "attacks only get better." With each attack the attackers learn, and it's generally easier to attack than to defend (in cyber-security in general, not just here).
- sascha_sl 8y agoI don't think the important question to ask here is if it can survive, it's how can it survive. These sort of tools should be in the commons anyway, just like social media. Monolithic social media is not sustainable and often times quite harmful because it optimizes for engagement. The Fediverse will deal with this one way or another, worst case everyone switches to whitelisting. I've been in favor of adding a limit - once you can remove by deleting a few lines of code of course - to the number of users an instance can hold. Purely for symbolism. It worked when Elasticsearch was added to Mastodon and a "viewable_by" property was added so you could only search for things you had engaged with.
- cjslep 8y agoGiven the kinds of communities that have flocked to the fediverse the past year, moderation tools have always been a top priority of apps adopting ActivityPub. Features have been killed due to the potential for abuse, too.
- creshal 8y agoHow about a working, documented plugin API? Or sync clients that work? Instead of taping more random crap onto a base product that only barely works?
- Kye 8y agoedit: I thought they were talking about ActivityPub since the issues look similar to ones people raise about it. Whoops. - I am of two minds here: 1. Minimal specification worked for HTTP. 2. Most problems with HTTP come from it being minimally specified. ActivityPub is exploding the way HTTP did. At worst, it's as imperfect as HTTP. At best, it's a way to get people used to federation for whatever comes next and improves on it.
- StavrosK 8y agoHe's talking about NextCloud, not ActivityPub, by the way. My experience has not been that it "barely works", it works quite well for me.
- artonge 8y agoI think parent talk about nextcloud and their plugin documentation being pore and their slow sync client. I agree with him, they put a lot of energy on non crucial features when a lot of their core features could be improved.
- IOT_Apprentice 8y agoThat sounds eerily similar to Plex and their focus these days.
- phito 8y agoThis. Their sync on android sucks big time. I go to my gallery, select 20 pictures and send them to Nextcloud, only to find only 5 of them have been actually uploaded. It happens every.single.time. Gonna switch to Seafile really soon.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vahji 8y agoBecause if they were competent they wouldn't be a group of ex-KDE developers working on a PHP dinosaur of spaghetti code.
- sctb 8y agoMany of your posts so far have been breaking the guidelines. We ban accounts that won't comment civilly and substantively. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- lwh 8y agoUgh I just wanted a working file manager
- Tharkun 8y agoAgreed. All this added complexity only serves to increase the attack surface of something I really want to keep safe and secure.
- creeble 8y ago+1 on this. My whole reason for using NC has been to remove anything like social features, and let me control sharing. Maybe all this will be optional, but the direction seems opposite to my needs. And the risks from 'extending' the network too.
- jospoortvliet 8y agoIt is all apps. You can even disable sharing. Heck, you can disable the Files UI... Note that most people use Nextcloud to work with others and features like these are crucial to their productivity. In the end, we're guided by community contributions and customer demand... Luckily you can disable things you don't like :D
- franga2000 8y agoTo be fair, most of the extra features (including this one) are apps that you either have to enable or can disable. And even though I initially installed Nextcloud as basically an FTP alternative too, I absolutely love how I've been able to migrate my contacts and calendar over (away from Google) with basically no hassle.
- gHacxZ5e 8y agoHave you tried ownCloud recently?
- reacharavindh 8y agoThese extra features and thus the complexity are the opposite of what I'd like in a self-hosted file share system. Why does everything have to be bloated into oblivion like this. We need more purpose built software... What i like? OpenBSD for firewalls, and public facing terminal servers. Just lovely. /rant.
- SJk7TAy 8y agoIn the other hand, as a home user I like to be able to install only one base system (Nextcloud) and use it for all of my online life. This will free me up from setting up yet another system (Mastodon etc) only to host my social networking needs. And this is implemented as a separate app, so you can dismiss it if you don't need it.
- arendtio 8y agoMost of those features are optional. So if you don't care about some functionality just uninstall the specific 'App'. Sure that is not as secure as not having those Apps in the first place, but I think, in general, Nextcloud is moving into the right direction, as many of their use-cases require a tightly integrated but wide set of features.
- privong 8y ago> Most of those features are optional. So if you don't care about some functionality just uninstall the specific 'App'. That's true, but unless there are new developers joining to create/support these apps the addition of these new features may spread the developers too thin. Personally I'd rather have a robust set of smaller features than a buggy implementation of a lot of features. The latter is okay if it's just a "for fun" type of project. But I use nextcloud to keep my calendar/contacts/file-sync, so it's really not okay if the core functionality is unstable. So while I can uninstall these apps, I personally worry that it means less attention will be paid to the core features.
- jospoortvliet 8y agoThat is like saying ice cream makers should focus on the 'core' tastes, claiming that that is banana and vanilla because you like those. For you calendar and contacts are core for a file sync and share software? Above somebody also asked us to focus on 'core', meaning adding ACL's and probably dropping the calendar/contacts. So it's like the fable where god decides to ask people what weather they want and everyone wants something different so he decides to go back to doing whatever the fuck he wanted. We just keep letting ourselves guided by contributors and customers...
- AdmiralAsshat 8y agoAre these guys courting VC funding? This looks less like a feature their users actually asked for than a bullet point for a sales pitch.
- Kye 8y agoThey've been on Mastodon for over a year. I think they just wanted to be able to see their Nextcloud stuff from there. https://mastodon.xyz/@nextcloud https://mastodon.xyz/@nextcloud
- jospoortvliet 8y agoYup. Also, VC funding? Heck no, we started Nextcloud because VC funding had bankrupted and blown up ownCloud... I mean, seriously. It is now owned by a German real estate agent...
- unixhero 8y agoBy the way. Thanks a lot for your work with Nedtcloud. It's really great.
- jospoortvliet 8y agoPleasure, thanks for the kind words!
- bjt2n3904 8y agoEnd user of NC here, have it setup on a little Digital Ocean droplet. I switched from OwnCloud shortly after the fork, and sync contacts/calendar/notes between my desktop and android. Pleasantly surprised with how well things work. My favorite thing to do is upload a short video from my phone, and send my family the share link. Much better than uploading to YouTube / Facebook. I also do photography, and love how easy it is to share a gallery in a few seconds. When I'm done in Lightroom, I just export JPGs to the directory, and copy over the share link to the gallery app. Great user experience! I'm glad NC is continuing development, and it's interesting that they're adding federation to the client, but I'm not sure it's a feature I'd use. Though I'd like to setup a mastodon instance for myself, there's too much docker/nodejs bloat and hastle, and I've yet to successfully get an instance online. (Even if I did, I'm not sure I'd use it very much.)
- thomnottom 8y agoSimilar situation here. I'm wondering if this might be enough to stop me from trying my own Mastodon instance. Might be nice to not have to support even more platforms.
- mgbmtl 8y agoAre you using Joplin for notes sync? I like Nextcloud, but I have to admit that I quickly get lost when I explore addons/integrations.
- yogthos 8y agoI started using NC for docs and calendar. Really happy with it. things work great and sharing things via links works great. Especially like how you can add expiry to shared links.
- bayesian_horse 8y agoMy impression is that the less users there are on an NC instance, and the less complicated the use case, the less trouble you run into.
- bfdm 8y agoDid you follow a guide to set this up? I'm not an expert in cloud envs, but I have set up a run machines in GCP and consider myself capable. I had a really hard time finding a guide for setting up NC in a GCP VM and following the instructions. When I ultimately wound my way through them to the point of testing something, I hit a brick wall regarding some kind of auth, if I recall.
- nisa 8y agoAs an admin of a 500 user instance I'm having mixed feelings about Nextcloud. Sure it's GPL and free and it got a lot better than the old owncloud mess that broke always but it's still somewhat a gamble. My install is just a no-warranty, non-commercial use case and I wouldn't use it for any large commercial installation without having at least one dedicated and skilled PHP-dev on-site. I came to resent their marketing blog posts. If you look it's just an alpha version that just got hacked together, often with problems, often not fixed long after the release. There still lot's of serious bugs in end to end encryption for instance. There does not seem to be a lot of work to improve the base features. Syncing, ACLs, User Mangement leave a lot to be desired. It's not easy but they are in a position where they really could be a perfect solution for a lot of people and probably also charge good money for it - but at the moment it feels like they just build alpha-grade fancy addons. Me and probably most users would love a no-feature, we just fix the most serious bugs on our github issues release-cycle. I'm fine when it's called Nextcloud 16 and takes a year, hell take your time, but basic functionality should be rock solid. I also don't get why they ignore the existing open-source ecosystem. Make it possible to integrate SOGo for Calenders and Mail - it's all webdav in the browser anyway. SOGo at least has somewhat working ActiveSync. Same with SAML/Shibboleth/Kerberos - some things got fixed, very late. No deployment story for Active Directory or even Linux. User management is a mess - the Circles app is a good idea that is crippled by usability and functionality bugs... that possibility to have self-selecting groups and decentralized management is a huge win for them, but they don't seem to realize that this is an important use-case. Nextcloud is very close to what would be ideal for a lot of smaller organisations, but they somehow are unable to polish what they have but decided to pile alpha-quality on alpha-quality code (and ignore the bug reports)... That beeing said, it mostly works but your users won't be happy.
- jospoortvliet 8y agoLet's be honest, if we did a release with only stabilization, it might get us more users. Not more customers. And it is customers who pay for the development. Everyone asks us to focus "on the basics" and then claim their pet feature requests are, of course, basics. ACL's and user mgmt in your case, perfectly fine features, but features nonetheless. In the end, our development is guided by the community and customers. If you're not either, we might not do what you want... That's the reality of any open source project. And you're right, for a large installation, you should obviously get an onsite engineer, or, much better, a contract with us which is both cheaper and better. That's what most larger installations do, and that is how we earn the money to make Nextcloud better. WRT the E2E, that sadly took a whole lot longer to get working than we had expected. Of course, if you think it is important or need it, time and money can speed it up, we have only so much of those.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Nux 8y agoI have been using NC for a few years now and I am mostly happy with it. Contacts, calendars, sharing, photo auto uploads all work with my Android phone. My problem is the software is pretty slow and from a security perspective I'd be hesitant to expose it to the greater internet. That's just my gut feeling.
- SJk7TAy 8y agoI feel the same. Basically, I wouldn't like to publish the address of my personal Nextcloud server to anyone (unless I am sharing a file privately with a friend). Fortunately, the social features are not built into the Nextcloud core, rather they are in a separate app. So we can just forget about it if we don't like it.
- jospoortvliet 8y agoIf you're not sure about the security you can firewall it of course, but keep in mind we pay 5K to anyone who can find a remote execute vulnerability in Nextcloud (and smaller amounts for smaller bugs).
- krn 8y agoThe personal issue I have with ownCloud / Nextcloud, is that I simply don't trust the technical competence of the developers, who picked PHP as the most suitable programming language for a multi-platform network-intensive application in 2010. There were simply no technical reasons for doing this – and there are still none.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- PeterMikhailov 8y agoModern php dev with packages managed by composer is fine. Its not perfect but I think immediately dismissing anything written in php is wrong.
- krn 8y ago> I think immediately dismissing anything written in php is wrong I have specifically pointed at multi-platform, network-intensive applications, and never claimed that PHP is not suitable for anything. If someone is not able to choose the right tool for the job, how can you trust him to do the job right?
- bauerd 8y agoPlease elaborate why PHP is an inadequate tool for developing multi-platform, network-intensive applications?
- krn 8y agoGo has much better concurrency, networking, and packaging capabilities. NodeJS can be used for both, front-end and back-end, including iOS / Android. Clojure(Script) provides more than Go and NodeJS combined, but was too new at the time. Even Python would be a much more powerful choice than PHP for anything, that is not a simple LAMP application.
- 8y ago
- arendtio 8y agoSounds great, but honestly I hoped that federated calls would finally make it... I mean, Federation is a core feature of Nextcloud and instead of finishing the work on Talk, we have a second (probably similarly incomplete) feature now, which needs to be polished for the next major releases. I don't want to be negative here. I love Nextcloud and the work that is being done around it! It is just that sometimes I wonder about the priorities and in this case, I wish improving existing things would have come before introducing new things. Besides that, I am quite excited to try out the new social features :-)
- dreamdu5t 8y agoAm I the only one that hates that the “fediverse” is not on the web? We didn’t need a separate protocol/app and closed servers to do what are actually just blog posts and replies.
- SJk7TAy 8y agoWhat do you mean by "not on the web"? It is accessible on the web. Everybody with a web browser can see public posts and replies. For writing new posts, you need an account though. Here is the public account of Mastodon's founder: https://mastodon.social/@Gargron https://mastodon.social/@Gargron
- jospoortvliet 8y ago... and it is all over HTTPS, so certainly very 'web', no need for special ports etc. See https://www.w3.org/TR/activitypub/ https://www.w3.org/TR/activitypub/
- dreamdu5t 8y agoIt’s on the web like Facebook is on the web. I can’t post or reply by creating a web page, and identity is not email or dns, but specific to whatever mastadon instance I register with. I already have a domain, blog, and email. Posts, replies, likes, etc. But mastadon doesn’t work with the web, or my existing web identity - instead it’s entirely based on federated ActivityPub servers plus various extensions.
- gHacxZ5e 8y agoSo get a blog that complies with ActivityPub or host a Pleroma instance with an account that mirrors your blogposts / posts them on the fediverse. Shouldn't be hard.
- type0 8y agoit is on the web, every instance can tweak their page to be publicly visible or not
- Arkanosis 8y ago« and soon Diaspora are part of this same network [ie. ActivityPub] » — I was surprised to read that, and after a quick check, it's not looking like it'll happen anytime soon, sadly. diaspora* is one of the most famous and successful open, federated social networks out there, yet it does not implement the protocol which is gaining unprecedented traction across a large number of implementations. Hopefully, Nextcloud implementing ActivityPub is yet another reason for diaspora* to follow the move.
- thomnottom 8y agoIs it really? Not being snarky here, but I joined diaspora early on and a year or so after the untimely death of the co-founder the project felt like it was going no where. 6 years later it feels like I never hear anything about it, and ActivityPub is almost a must for any serious "open" social network now.
- donedealomg 8y agoSorry guys, nextcloud is the biggest piece of crap software on this planet. Protip: DO NOT INTRODUCE NEXTCLOUD IN YOUR ORGANISATION!!!
- relouleco97 8y agomy org just moved to FileCloud from NextCloud and it's working out so far. FileCloud is not opensource. but the base functionalities are solid especially sync and user management.
- pa7ch 8y agoI really like the upspin approach for federated self-hosting of userdata (for lack of a better term) in that it builds a platform for it that apps like nextcloud and others would build on top of. I'm not saying its the right solution, but I think trying to get the layers right to make self-hosting a wider and more reliable reality is only going to happen by building the right opensource platforms/components first.