5 ms·
Everywhere and everyone is different, obviously, but I would love to see autonomous electric vehicles become our future. I really don't care for public transpo
by rootusrootus 8y ago
Everywhere and everyone is different, obviously, but I would love to see autonomous electric vehicles become our future. I really don't care for public transportation, I find it uncomfortable in many ways, and I don't see any way that it will ever not be about half the speed of a private point-to-point transport.
So a highway filled with self driving cars zipping along bumper to bumper may not technically be able to carry as much as a fully loaded subway train, but it's so much more useful. Take away the casualties and pollution, and it's as close to perfect as we are likely to get.
- codyb 8y agoCan you explain to me how it's more useful than a train that carries more people with less energy? Because, to me, it sounds like you just don't want to be uncomfortable, and that's fine, nobody does, but it doesn't make something more useful.
- lgas 8y agoBeing more comfortable is useful to me.
- enraged_camel 8y agoTrains can be extremely comfortable, actually. You can have things like food/drink service on them, not to mention WiFi.
- sverige 8y agoThe lack of comfort people refer to usually involves the other passengers, not the amenities. But everyone knows you're not supposed to talk specifically about that aspect of public transportation.
- rootusrootus 8y agoHa, I will! I once had a guy behind me on the train whip out his penis and pee on the floor. Looked right at me in the reflection of the window as he did it. He wasn't even crazy, either, as far as I could tell, just antisocial. And yes, before you say it, that isn't an everyday occurrence. But jackasses refusing to take their bag off the seat so you can sit down is. As are people who can't be bothered to take a shower, or think that cologne will make up for it. The list goes on. Many people are just unpleasant to be around, and I don't see any problem with that observation. For me, public transit comfort comes down to a couple things. First, the hard plastic seats make my butt hurt, and standing makes my left foot ache. Sorry, I'm getting old :). Second, the 2x time it takes to get anywhere means I'm on that terrible seat for even longer. And third, because yes, it's absolutely true, I find that perhaps one in ten people is unpleasant enough that I want to be out of visual and/or aromatic range.
- mirimir 8y ago> First, the hard plastic seats make my butt hurt, Yeah, same for me. And I've heard that the ~80s crop of NYC subway cars were made in Japan. Except there, they have upholstered seats. But that wouldn't work out well in NYC, so they got hard plastic. But on the other hand, the oldest LIRR cars (refurbished for the 1966 World's Fair) had upholstered seats, and they were ~OK.
- prepend 8y agoNever in my life have I experienced a puddle of urine in my personal vehicle. This happens about 5% of the time with my city’s public transport. Similarly, never have I been given religious literature or panhandled. This happens about 90% of the time.
- Filligree 8y agoSounds like you just have poor public transport. It doesn't have to be that way, and I've never experienced anything like it in Europe.
- mirimir 8y agoOr maybe a dysfunctional society :(
- xtracto 8y agoOh i did in the UK: A guy masturbating at the end of a bus. A stupid kid throwing a can of Vimto to me from the top of the 2story bus. Car it is for me.
- prepend 8y agoYes,precisely. I found Vienna and Tokyo’s subway pretty immaculate. But London, Paris, Bilbao, Amsterdam all had some experiences similar to my other post. Much smaller sample so hard to say how frequently it occurs in any useful way.
- codyb 8y ago5% is a staggering number! I rode the trains for four and a half years in NYC and just avoided the empty cars and never had too many issues. Also people seem to focus exclusively on the negative interactions which is a very human thing to do, but this discounts the positive interactions. It can be really nice seeing people offer their seats to the elderly, or kids meeting and playing, or the occasional furry companion in a cute bag. But I enjoy people watching in general. It can be neat to try to imagine a persons world and how it looks.
- 8y ago
- rootusrootus 8y agoMy car has WiFi, and it is not even automated yet. And food & drink are perfectly feasible as well, remember we're talking about automated cars now. All kinds of options suddenly make sense when you don't have to worry about the chore of driving.
- stevekemp 8y agoSome Finnish trains have play-areas for children on them. I was pleasantly surprised the last time I rode a train with my 1.5 year old child. He had a lot of fun going up and down the slide, sitting in the toy-train (on a train!) and reading books in the "library".
- IshKebab 8y agoBecause trains don't go door to door. Obviously. Except in lucky places with great underground railways you basically have awkward last-mile journeys where you have to take a taxi or hit a car or take a bus and that adds a lot of time to the journey. It would be great if there were trains everywhere but frankly that's even harder than making a reliable driverless car.
- wongarsu 8y agoWhich is why driverless cars are great for bringing people from and to public transport. They are a great ingredient for improving public transport, but they don't replace it (at least as soon as road capacity becomes an issue).
- rootusrootus 8y agoHow do I get from my house to the train? Do I have to make transfers? How long will they take? What if I have to carry groceries, or take young children with me, or my elderly grandma? If I have a car, I load everyone and everything up, and we go. We get to our destination and unload, ta-da! Is this not an order of magnitude more useful than taking a train? Sometimes I think HN is filled with young people with uncomplicated lives :).
- Barrin92 8y ago>Sometimes I think HN is filled with young people with uncomplicated lives :). No, if these are big issues for you, you likely live in an American low density area where public transportation is scarce. In large metropolitan areas (which is after all, where most of the world already lives, and will live), getting on and off public transport is usually not a problem. I have relocated to Tokyo for example about a year ago, and for me, a trip to the grocery store is usually done by foot (same is true for other appliances), and multiple forms of public transport are in walking distance.
- rootusrootus 8y agoI live in a city with about 700,000 residents inside the official limits, and 3,000,000 residents in the metro. The nearest bus stop is approximately a quarter mile away. With all due respect, the number of people who live in cities as dense as Tokyo are the minority, most of us don't.
- Barrin92 8y agoNo offense but if you think walking a quarter mile is a hindrance to access public transport then the car culture has done even more damage than I thought.
- rootusrootus 8y agoOn the contrary, I think a quarter mile is perfectly reasonable for a public transit stop in my city. Sorry to suggest otherwise. However, when I think about loading up my young children with all of their stuff, loading me up with everything I need, etc, and then dragging that down the street a quarter mile, then waiting for the bus, boarding it, riding to the transit center, transferring, riding another bus to the light rail station, riding that downtown, and then doing it all again the other direction... well, I'm pretty confident in my original point that the car is a hell of a lot more useful. Sure, you can exist with only the public transport option, but I was not asserting otherwise. But a lot of people on HN seem to think that not only is it possible, but that it is the superior choice. So, no offense taken, in fact I appreciate you affirming my original comment about so many folks on HN commenting from the viewpoint of someone with a young, uncomplicated life :-).
- cameldrv 8y agoI doubt that a train is significantly more energy efficient than an electric car with 3-4 people in it. Most people will probably use pool type autonomous cars which get you to your destination door to door much faster than trains.
- codyb 8y agoTrains can fit far more people than cars.
- dgzl 8y ago> I would love to see autonomous electric vehicles become our future. I really don't care for public transportation, I find it uncomfortable in many ways I imagine (edit: many) people who use public transportation would agree with you. You now, since they're usually using it out of necessity and not enjoyment.
- IshKebab 8y agoFor lots of people maybe but no way all. A lot of public transport is faster than driving and it avoids having to park.
- rootusrootus 8y agoIs that true for anything less than a subway/metro train? Light rail is slow, buses even worse, there are many benefits to public transit but speed is rarely one of them. And in the rare cases when it is faster, it's in a handful of extremely dense cities that only represent a fraction of the population, and only for specific use cases.
- jellicle 8y ago> I really don't care for public transportation Right. We get that. It's very obvious that much of the hype around self-driving cars is premised around people who simply reject mass transit outright and therefore believe that somehow, somewhere, they'll get to ride around in a spacious, individual vehicle in the middle of a packed city and so will everyone else and somehow it will all work out because "technology".
- rootusrootus 8y agoYou have managed to build a mighty straw man which you then knocked down with skill borne of experience. Congrats.
- colordrops 8y agoI admit that I'm only doing rough math in my head, but it seems to me that cars bumper to bumper at 100kpm is definitely going to have a greater carrying capacity than intermittent larger vehicles that stop a lot. (Or at least a similar magnitude)
- jerf 8y agoI don't expect self-driving cars to drive much more densely than current cars, though, because all or almost all the same reasons we drive with separation still apply for self-driving cars. Where you might think you get some advantages, they will also have disadvantages, too, like being able to compute exactly how risky their behaviors are. People making the cars and writing the car software aren't going to want to stand in court and explain why their car crashed the 50-car dense train because their car software left no possibility of the brakes going out at that exact moment (i.e., no previous sign of brake failure), and caused a huge crash because none of the cars had any buffer for failure. Personally I expect self-driving cars to drive a great deal more conservatively than humans as a result, and I think self-driving cars are going to end up demanding a lot more space and buffer on the freeways. And if they don't at first, one day you'll way up and they suddenly all will, because somebody won some lawsuit and a software update was pushed overnight to double the buffers.
- rootusrootus 8y agoI tend to agree, I expect that as a practical matter autonomous cars will be conservatively driven, e.g. with large buffer zones, gentle acceleration, safety-above-all-else. I think other drivers will adapt to this and start taking advantage. Think of what happens when you leave a legal following distance in front of you now, in traffic. Now imagine an autonomous car in the same situation. It would probably end up stopped.
- freeopinion 8y agoMight as well imagine autonomous-only lanes while we're speculating.
- 8y ago
- com2kid 8y ago> and I don't see any way that it will ever not be about half the speed of a private point-to-point transport. Subways / trains in Tokyo are faster than driving, same in London. No stop lights, no intersections, no delays on the road. Buses aren't faster, but once you go underground, the speed improves dramatically. Even if there is a 2 minute stop once every mile, that is still less time waiting than comparable stop lights in a car.
- rootusrootus 8y agoAs far as I can tell, that's only true in fairly unique situations, though, in the super-cities. I live in a decently sized city (metro population of perhaps 3 million people, around 25th in the US I believe) with a transit system mostly regarded as 'pretty good' (but no subway, just light rail and buses) and it would be rare even at rush hour for a car not to be faster. Usually signficantly so. I think what it comes down to is that if you have a subway system, that will probably beat cars, in the limited area it serves. Once you have to do transfers to buses, it gets much slower. In the places I've visited with subway systems (SF, DC primarily) this is definitely the case.
- dragonwriter 8y agoThe US, even cities with “pretty good” transit by local standards, had appallingly bad transit and car-optimized cities.
- stevenwoo 8y agoHere's an interesting overview of US cities mass transit by an urban planner from Houston (an admittedly vary car centric place.) https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2018/12/7/18131132/public-transportation-bus-subway-america-us https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2018/12/7/18131132/public-tran...
- loeg 8y agoUS transit is heavily optimized for cars, even in places with pretty good mass transit. Don't let your personal experience with US metros color your expectations for what public transit can be.
- ben-schaaf 8y agoAnecdotally I commute to work because it's faster and much less stressful. Granted I do need to cover the first leg by car due to the public transport in my area, but the little bit of walking and the free time I get in the train are so much better than sitting alone in city traffic.
- rootusrootus 8y agoSounds like a friend of mine who loves the time to read a book or work on his laptop. I look out the window of the train, though, because otherwise I get motion sick. It's lost time to me.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I don't see any way that it will ever not be about half the speed of a private point-to-point transport. Private point-to-point loses out mostly for long-distance already, short-distance currently either allows last-mile, station overhead, and related concerns to big down shared transportation or suffers from sharing infrastructure optimized for private point-to-point. Ubiquitous automated (on-demand, not personal cars actually make the station problem easier, since you need less parking at stations, making station footprints smaller, and reducing delay from arrival at station to boarding. They could also merge with buses: instead of fixed routes and schedules, vehicle sizes and routing are demand driven for efficiency (perhaps allowing you to pay a premium to guarantee a dedicated vehicle for your party.)
- rootusrootus 8y agoI would be comfortable saying that subways and above (e.g. high speed rail, airplanes) are a special case of public transport that will always make sense and will nearly always beat out a car for transit time. Aside from that, I agree with what appears to be your premise -- that we could invent public transport devices that mitigate and perhaps mostly erase the advantage of the car. But then I'd ask ... why? Why are we supposed to hate cars? It's okay to like scooters and bikes, but nothing larger until we get to a bus? I imagine a future with all sorts of automated cars that never get into an accident and roll silently along emitting not a whiff of noxious fumes, while being big enough to carry just the right amount. If nobody needs to own their own car, then they can call a car that is sized for their exact needs. One passenger or ten. They efficiently get to exactly where they are going in the minimum time possible with minimum effort. What a dream!
- wbl 8y agoCars take up massive amounts of public space. Look at a car dependent suburb vs. a train dependent suburb.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I agree with what appears to be your premise -- that we could invent public transport devices that mitigate and perhaps mostly erase the advantage of the car. That's not quite my premise. Rather, it is that shared self-driving automobiles (cars through vans through buses) with centralized automated dispatch are the missing element of the mix of public transport devices that, alongside existing options, does that. > Why are we supposed to hate cars? Recognizing that public transport has social benefits does not require hating privately owned cars, much less cars more generally. > It's okay to like scooters and bikes, but nothing larger until we get to a bus? Size has nothing to do with anything (well, it has to do.with efficiency for long-distance transport.)