4 ms·
> toward what U.S. President Donald Trump has branded as "energy independence." That seems unnecessarily charitable. I don't think this is a novel idea (in 20
by loeg 8y ago
> toward what U.S. President Donald Trump has branded as "energy independence."
That seems unnecessarily charitable. I don't think this is a novel idea (in 2018), or one that can be credited to Trump in particular in any way.
Google trends puts the peak since 2004 (for the US) in 2008[0] — when US gas prices were at a relative height[1] — and basically declining interest since, as gas prices have fallen. But the concept long predates even that (initial interest in the US probably largely driven the 1973 OPEC oil embargo).[2]
[0]: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=energy%20independence https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=e...
[1]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/204740/retail-price-of-gasoline-in-the-united-states-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/204740/retail-price-of-g...
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_energy_independence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_energy_independe...
- Animats 8y agoEvery president since the 1970s oil crisis has talked about energy independence. Now we're there. Now we can start to disengage from the Middle East and let them sink back into the sand. That would save the US a trillion a year.
- loeg 8y ago> Every president since the 1970s oil crisis has talked about energy independence. Now we're there. Sure. This gradual trend has been a long time coming. I agree it's hugely significant, but I object to the attribution to Trump in the opening paragraph of the piece. > Now we can start to disengage from the Middle East and let them sink back into the sand. I agree there are huge benefits to the US in ceasing to fund the Saudis in particular, and to a lesser degree, other members of OPEC. Re "disengage" in particular, I don't think we should totally tear down diplomatic relations and abandon foreign policy goals, though. Maybe that's not what you meant. > That would save the US a trillion a year. Where does this figure come from? What are you comparing? Our oil production rate didn't change overnight and it seems unlikely that the difference from yesterday amounts to $2.7 billion per day ($1T annualized).
- thx11389793 8y agoThe trillion/year I believe was in reference to military expenditures.
- loeg 8y agoAre we comparing 2017 against 2018? Or 2017 against some hypothetical future year where the military's energy use is completely free?
- Animats 8y agoUS military activity in the Middle East cost.
- accipehoc 8y agoWould it be possible with decades of mission creep for the US to seriously consider disengagement from the Middle East?
- adventured 8y agoSure, the American people have long since had enough. There was zero support for a wider escalation in Syria years ago; there's less than that now to do anything further over there. Trump partially got elected on a populist platform of ending the global deployments and perma wars in the Middle East. When even the Republican base is done with it, it's done. Oil security used to be an argument, it's blatantly not any longer. Even US generals are proclaiming Afghanistan a stalemate and that it's time to go home. It would require a vast number of soldiers on the ground to decimate the Taliban at this point. There's nothing left that can be accomplished there, short of staying forever and deploying a vast number of soldiers to prop up the central government perpetually. The original mission was accomplished long ago. The US has only a few thousand soldiers in Iraq, helping with training, support and limited ISIS resistance issues. Mostly Iraq is operating entirely independently as a nation, with near record high oil production (and plans for much more output). Short of a near-term catastrophy, they should be able to stand on their own from here. People think the current cost problem in the US military has to do with the Middle East. Unfortunately it doesn't. Ending everything we're doing over there will only save about $50 billion. The other unnecessary $200 billion the military industrial complex is spending, they're not giving back, even though they should. They'll pivot any spending reduction from the Middle East to Asia (China containment). They even have the audacity right now to proclaim that they need more money.