10 ms·
An interview with the documentary filmmaker Adam Curtis
- dmos62 8y agoAdam Curtis is great. He's been making films for about 30 years and has a large fimography. Early in his career he's made some 20th century history documentary series, very recommended. Lately he's been making great films about contemporary phenomenon, I loved both of his last films, Bitter Lake (2015) and HyperNormalisation (2016). Highly recommended, especially the latter.
- simongray 8y agoI love all the films I've seen by him, but I feel like Hypernormalisation was a cut above the rest. Adam Curtis feels like a continental philosopher (yes, I know he's British) making films instead of writing books and Hypernormalisation feels like his Magnum Opus. This interview is probably a great way to get the same in writing.
- dmos62 8y agoI feel similarly. I try not to stress this point, so that people don't ignore the rest of his filmography, which would be a great pity.
- wslh 8y agoGreat recommendations, just read the HyperNormalization excerpt and it is like world gamification and something that Nassim Taleb was writing with other words since Fooled by Randomness.
- Fnoord 8y agoI've only seen "The Century Of The Self" and "The Power Of Nightmares". Both were great documentaries, of historic value IMO. One can find them here [1]. Not only there, they're also available on Archive.org. Dutch public broadcasting TV (NPO) has broadcasted various of his documentaries in the past, including with subtitles. [1] https://thoughtmaybe.com/by/adam-curtis/ https://thoughtmaybe.com/by/adam-curtis/
- salty_biscuits 8y agoHN crowd should be all over "All watched over by machines of loving grace".
- gedy 8y agoThis is very insightful: "Every morning Donald Trump wakes up in the White House, he tweets something absolutely outrageous which he knows the liberals will get upset by, the liberals read his tweets and go “This is terrible, this is outrageous,” and then tell each other via social media how terrible it all is. It becomes a feedback loop in which they are locked together. In my mind, it’s like they’re together in a theatre watching a pantomime villain. The pantomime villain comes forward into the light, looks at them and says something terrible, and they go “Boo!!”. Meanwhile, outside the theatre, real power is carrying on but no one is really analysing it."
- madengr 8y agoHe is trolling them, and I find it hilarious, though it’s also about keeping himself in the spotlight. I suppose a narcissist.
- ForHackernews 8y agoThe President of the United States wields real power, full stop. He is not an absolute monarch, and other powerful forces may have their own designs, but it's disingenuous to suggest the head of government in the world's largest economy and biggest military power is purely a sideshow to "real power" carrying on elsewhere.
- claudiawerner 8y agoThe fact of wielding real power means very little in the face of impersonal structures and systems beyond anyone's (and this includes the president's) control. These systems often appear natural and wield powerful ideologies. This was discussed since the early 50s and continued into the studies of Althusser, Marcuse, Debord (Society of the Spectacle) and the like. They allege no sinister concrete plot, only awareness of the very real motions of a system abstracted away from any individual or group, and that includes any and every politician, CEO, etc.
- flavor8 8y agoRussell Brand also interviewed Adam Curtis about this film also, on his podcast - https://www.podchaser.com/podcasts/under-the-skin-with-russell-br-455708/episodes/003-adam-curtis-do-we-really-w-15260116 https://www.podchaser.com/podcasts/under-the-skin-with-russe...
- smcl 8y agoJust adding to the Adam Curtis podcast appearances - he was also on Chapo Trap House: https://soundcloud.com/chapo-trap-house/episode-65-no-future-feat-adam-curtis-121216 https://soundcloud.com/chapo-trap-house/episode-65-no-future...
- pizza 8y agoGood interview with Adam Curtis and comedian Tim Heidecker (yes, that Tim Heidecker from Tim and Eric) here, too: https://soundcloud.com/thetalkhouse/tim-heidecker-with-adam-curtis https://soundcloud.com/thetalkhouse/tim-heidecker-with-adam-...
- kmf 8y agoThis episode is great! One of my favorite podcast episodes, well, ever. Curtis' last monologue at the end is really something else - I find myself listening to it pretty regularly.
- kaycebasques 8y agoI wrote off Russell Brand at first, frankly probably because he’s a handsome, charismatic, successful man. But after listening to his stuff at length, I had to admit to myself that I liked him and respected him. I don’t agree with some of the stuff he says, but I respect his passion and intellect.
- ripsawridge 8y agoCompletely agree, +1.
- baybal2 8y agoA great article. This is pretty much summarises everything I an raging about on HN. Every citizen of a self respecting nation has a personal responsibility to fight wrongs, and be sensible and rational in how he treats others. Western society has become greatly desensitised to idiocy and wrongs. Today's popular culture celebrates the "war on reason." We should reject and destroy it.
- zaro 8y ago> Every citizen of a self respecting nation has a personal responsibility to fight wrongs, and be sensible and rational in how he treats others. I think everybody already does so. But right and wrong are very subjective things and this fighting the wrongs is contributing a lot to the global mess.
- homarp 8y ago>But right and wrong are very subjective things is "the earth is flat" a subjective wrong ? is "climate changes unless you change" a subjective wrong ? is "poverty" a subjective wrong ? is "education is important" a subjective right ? is "rules of law" a subjective wrong ? is "same gender, same pay" a subjective right ?
- zaro 8y agoI think you are misunderstanding the meaning of subjective. "the earth is flat" let's say this is clearly wrong for you and me, is it wrong for the guy who wants to launch a rocket to prove it's right (there were news about him few weeks ago)? So while his views are wrong from the viewpoint of the majority, they are right from his own viewpoint. Same for the rest of your examples.
- homarp 8y agoto me, subjective: a thing/a thought based on or influenced by personal feelings, tastes, or opinions. The parent was saying "personal responsibility to fight wrongs": to me, it means some people are wrong (as in they believe something that is wrong, even, if of course, they think they are right). But it is just wrong, not subjectively wrong. And it is my duty to do something about it (either convince, educate, or even censor,...). So I guess you are right, I don't understand your point about "But right and wrong are very subjective things and this fighting the wrongs is contributing a lot to the global mess." Because the way I read you is "stop trying to 'fight' the wrong, and the mess will be less".
- seren 8y agoAn anecdata on that topic. I am working for a subsidiary of big company. Six months ago, while other parts of the company were divested, the plan was to keep us. Evey internal communications from the top management were saying basically "we are proud to be a strong pillar of BigCo going forward" Now, it seems the plan have changed and we are going to be divested as well. Now the same top managers have all the same discourse (literally copy paste): "This is a new chapter opening, we are all very excited, and this will open new opportunities". I don't blame top management or internal communication, but really you cannot have two opposite strategies in six months, and in both case think that is the best thing since sliced bread because it is basically meaningless. So, top management knows they are repeating the empty official party line, employees knows that it is essentially a smokescreen, but everyone pretends everything is planned and this is working as intended, and everything's going to be great. The reality is that no one as the slightest idea of what is going on. If you step back, this is actually quite comical.
- davemp 8y agoCorporate communications get auto trashed in my inboxes. These emails are nothing more than propaganda. The only CCs that I’ve seen to be somewhat useful were Q&A sessions. I guess it’s harder to lie directly to someone face without the help an editor. Sidenote: At least with PizzaCo’s daily email spam I get a $8 supreme pizza if I’m ever in the mood for some delivery style pies.
- fallingfrog 8y agoIt’s equally frustrating to listen to them speak in person, going on and on about how enthusiastic they are and about our incredible growth potential, and knowing that every word is entirely disconnected from base reality or indeed anything that anyone in the room cares about. Then they fire a bunch of people, issue some stock buybacks, and quit.
- anoncoward111 8y agoSounds right to me. All you can do is collect paychecks and find another pirate ship to climb aboard to repeat the process in hopes of continued/better gains.
- vanderZwan 8y ago> The opposite of stability is a politics of imagination. There is a yearning that there must be something more than the repetition we hear every day that “if you like this you’ll like that”. I think it’s coming but I take your point, you are right, there is fear of that. But the job of a good politician is to say, “Yes, I understand your fears but look, it’s not right and we can do better than this”. I’m waiting for a politician on the left to come along and say that. So far, I haven't seen one. I'm very curious why he thinks Bernie Sanders doesn't qualify. Regardless of what you think of his political views, the political story he was selling fits this description to a T. I suspect it's not that these politicians don't exist, it's that the rest of the political establishment also is afraid of them and cooperates to keep them out. Kind of like how managers never fire themselves.
- oyji 8y agoYanis Varoufakis - Either we end up with a Star Trek-like utopia where we harness technology and use its wealth-producing capacity for the common good, or we get The Matrix, a dystopia in which the miserable masses have their energy sucked out of them by unseen forces and are fed illusions to keep them quiet. Eventually even the elites will become servants to the machine
- anentropic 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma
- TheCowboy 8y agoThe constant railing against this vague concept of "the establishment" doesn't really help progress the discussion to limit the influence of the establishment either. It's essentially a strawman. I can't argue about the establishment because it means something different to everyone and varies depending on the circumstances. I'd find it ridiculous to argue that Bernie's influence doesn't represent one part of the political establishment these days. Bernie has been a member of congress for how long now? He also ran a relatively successful campaign for the Democratic nomination and gained a lot more influence as a result.
- baybal2 8y agoIt is good to note that they passed over Ayn Rand. Many Americans are surprised when I tell them that so much of Ayn Rand's maxims are a direct copy and paste from different communist manifestos. Maligned societies look much like each others once you scrape off their ideological facades. Best quote: > I often think that one of the reasons why there is so much pessimism around, especially among the baby-boomer generation, is that they cannot face the terrible fact of their own mortality. So what they have to do is project that onto the whole planet.
- claudiawerner 8y agoWhich maxims are those? It doesn't help to ccompare societies on the basis of rhetoric (appearance) rather than logic (essence), so I'm skeptical of your point.
- baybal2 8y agoWell, a good one to begin with is: "whose don't work, don't deserve to eat" a line common to many on that political axis Second to that is to "judge everybody on its own worth" – just add some imagination to see how different definitions of "worthlessness" been thrown left and right in totalitarian states. In the end, the meat under the sauce is the same.
- baybal2 8y agoThen it will be her maxims like "family is legalized prostitution" (literally, the same quote from either Lenin or Trotsky and her,) statement on "setting man free from men" and on and on and on with her equating any social process to material/financial interaction. No wonder, some reasonably suggest that she might have been an actual cryptocommunist as the "objectivism" she birthed is strikingly similar to whatever rationalisations communist regimes around the world made for their existence. The biggest selling point that second world country regimes had for the masses was the material abundance out of nowhere, second to "liberation" of common men from moral norms and duties. Back in twenties, the unwashed masses did genuinely believe that they are instating the communist system for their own rational self interest
- 8y ago
- Comevius 8y ago"If you take climate change, which is a serious issue, it’s been co-opted by pessimistic baby-boomers and turned into a dark nightmarish scenario, rather than saying that we need to restructure power and resources in a way that could make the world a better place. That would have been a really good way to deal with climate change. Instead, it got possessed by a dystopia which I think reflects that generation’s fear of mortality because they can’t see anything going on beyond their own death." Ultimately this is true, we preach dystopia because we cannot see beyond our lack of power (ability, influence), our fear of instability, fear of death. We cannot even begin to imagine what such restructuring would look like. All the while the dystopia is steadily becoming reality. And that's the hard part, and imagination, especially political imagination, and very especially progressive political imagination should be the antidote. Less static, and less managerial. Let's feedback management. I guess he is right that dystopianism and right-wing populism (racism and so on) are governed by (the same kind of) fear and anger. This interview certainly gave me things to think about.
- davemp 8y ago> “ ... it’s been co-opted by pessimistic baby-boomers and turned into a dark nightmarish scenario ... “ Similarly, this is how Christianity's public image was killed in the West.
- rorykoehler 8y agoCan you explain what you mean by this? Priests raping kids did it for me with Catholiscm....and people like Blair and Bush murdering people en masse to serve their fairy overlord sealed the deal for protestantism. Not sure how this ties in?
- davemp 8y agoIt's certainly multifaceted. I could write a pretty substantial article on this topic. My comment was mostly alluding to the unsupported imagery of a fire and brimstone pit of eternal torment for all non-believers. There's also excessive pessimism about the implications of Christian values not being mandated by legislature (ex: abortion). For your concerns, I would attribute those to the collapse and corruption of internal governance systems. Without much exposition, churches do a pretty terrible job of ensuring their leaders are moral and capable of conveying responsible interpretations of doctrine. Again this is more or less due to fatalism. EG: "Humans are inherently sinful, therefore there's nothing we can do about awful leaders" If anyone is actually interested in a related article, send me an email. I'll assume that, if a few people spend the effort to send me an email, it will be worth the effort to synthesize a responsible article.
- lunchladydoris 8y agoAdam Curtis is amazing. If you don't know his work, I would highly recommend checking it out [0]. [0] https://thoughtmaybe.com/by/adam-curtis/ https://thoughtmaybe.com/by/adam-curtis/
- montalbano 8y agoFans of Adam Curtis, particularly his characteristic use of 'historical collage' to create a compelling narrative, might be interested in the book trilogy 'U.S.A' by John Dos Passos. It's a great read. A quote from Adam himself: "The biggest influence I’ve ever had was actually a novel my father gave me to read at the age of about 13. It was a novel called USA by John Dos Passos. At that age, it just got me. You can trace back everything I do to that novel because it’s all about grand history, individual experience, their relationship. And also collages, quotes from newsreels, cinema, newspapers. And it’s about collage of history as well. That’s where I get it all from."* *https://web.archive.org/web/20140116091402/http://filmcomment.com/entry/interview-adam-curtis https://web.archive.org/web/20140116091402/http://filmcommen...
- ripsawridge 8y agoWow, thanks for the recommendation...this interview is blowing me away. So much insight.
- frabbit 8y ago> know very well that in 200 years the world > won’t look much like the world we’re living in now." This will happen not because of AI or nuclear fusion reactors or space travel or lab-grown meat. I love Curtis's documentaries and agree with the central thesis that the models/stories to describe the world leave us trapped and need to be switched for better ones, but I think he is underestimating the potential for Climate Destruction to force a reconfiguration. Politicians have always been mountebanks surfing on the wave of change initiated by either physical realities or collective imaginings... they don't create new models, they just latch onto whatever seems opportune.
- jules-jules 8y agoBased on his repeated mention of climate change in the interview, I wouldn't conclude that he is disregarding the possibility of climate change reconfiguring human civilization, rather, I'd venture that it is perhaps so obvious, that he failed to mention it?
- frabbit 8y agoI'm not sure. Although it is an excellent interview it feels like some follow-up would be good on a couple of points, one of them being whether he believes that climate destruction is going to leave anything resembling a civilization behind. There is a slight suggestion that he believes that liberal pessimism is ignoring some wonderful new opportunities inherent in the complete destruction of a stable, predictable climate. Also he completely ignores that the Corbyn manifesto and recent speaking tours have emphasized that a reshaping of the UK economy to emphasize green jobs in a low-growth, post-Brexit world is exactly the sort of inspiring leadership which claims is lacking. I suspect he just does not want to look at what the left of the Labour Party is proposing.
- buboard 8y agoA lot of his points are echoes of what the economist Mark Blyth uses to point out the lack of narratives in politics of today. While it is true that people do respond to narratives, it's questionable how far that goes. Both brexiters and Trump offered narratives (of some vision of britain and an american economic rennaissance) , and it did work. Yet the majorities were feeble, not overwhelming (especially considering the lack of narrative on the other sides). Even trump could not motivate the US today to go on another space race like in the 60s. It is thus possible that democracies have transformed away from the collectivist spirit irrevocably. Indivudualism has been on the rise since forever, and (apart from an alien invasion) there doesnt seem to be any major forces countering it. Today's collectivist politics are either identitarian (the easy solution / instead of endless politics, vote by color) or mildly globalist, like climate change politics. While both have fierce supporters and detractors, the main mass of voters says "meh" to both. Then again, even the mega monolith called China will not be able to control its well-trained citizenry when the hypergrowth stops. Despite remarkable progress and optimism, the chinese don't seem to be going for "space races", instead those megaprojects appear to be more driven by personal ambition of their leader. Maybe bowling alone is the future of politics, more personalized, individualized and decentralized societies. The republics of large narratives may already belong to history and maybe we should stop expecting the "return of religions".
- samizdis 8y agoFrom the article, this is so incisive: The problem I have with a lot of investigative journalism, is that they always say: “There should be more investigative journalism” and I think, “When you tell me that a lot of rich people aren't paying tax, I’m shocked but I’m not surprised because I know that. I don’t want to read another article that tells me that”. What I want is an article that tells me why, when I’m told that, nothing happens and nothing changes. And no one has ever explained that to me.
- polskibus 8y agoWhy was the title changed? Will all interviews be changed like this?
- erentz 8y ago> “Everyone knew it was fake, but because no one had any alternative vision for a different kind of society, they just accepted this sense of total fakeness as normal.” I don’t think there is a lack of vision out there, see the book Four Futures for example. In the case of the Soviet Union speaking out about things not working was a good way to get punished. Most of us have experienced the same thing in corporate america. Everyone around the cooler says “this is broke” one guy says as much and loses his head. It seems we are just incapable now of agreeing to collective visions, which require compromise, and supporting each other in making that happen. Something has caused us to become incapable of compromise. Everyone is beaten down by the past century and no longer want to trust each other, or something like that. Perhaps communication now is just too impossible to allow this to happen. It’s become seemingly much much easier to attack and divide people than bring them together. Hard to see how to change that without some really low level change happening.
- zzzeek 8y agoThat's quite a piece where he simultaneously laments the common sense that leadership is corrupt and everyone knows it, and at the same time dismissively mocks "liberal hysteria" over Russian election interference and their compromising of the president, which is literally the giant glowing core of executive branch corruption in this administration.
- maxxxxx 8y ago"The problem I have with a lot of investigative journalism, is that they always say: “There should be more investigative journalism” and I think, “When you tell me that a lot of rich people aren't paying tax, I’m shocked but I’m not surprised because I know that. I don’t want to read another article that tells me that”. What I want is an article that tells me why, when I’m told that, nothing happens and nothing changes. And no one has ever explained that to me." I think he is making a big mistake here. There are a lot of things we "already know" that aren't actually true or we don't know the extent. We should appreciate people who deliver data that we can then try to explain. there is already way too much opinion going around that has no data to back it up.
- kiliantics 8y agoWhile that may be true about misinformation/underinformation, it still seems ultimately pointless if nothing is being done about it...
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt seems that way but nothing should be done without hard facts.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bogomipz 8y agoThe director states: >"With the rise of that hyper-individualism in society, politics got screwed. That sense of being part of a movement that could challenge power and change the world began to die away and was replaced by a technocratic management system." I understand that in the US, election campaigns are data-driven but beyond that are either of the two major political parties platforms managed and/or guided by a "technocratic management system"?
- hliyan 8y agoOne of the more unique insights here: "Its downside is that it’s a static world. It doesn’t have any vision of the future because the way it works is by constantly monitoring what you did yesterday and the day before, and the day before that. And monitoring what I did yesterday and the day before and the day before that and doing the same to billions of other people. And then looking at patterns and then saying: “If you liked that, you’ll like this”." "They’re constantly playing back to you the ghosts of your own behaviour. We live in a modern ghost story. We are haunted by our past behaviour played back to us through the machines in its comparison to millions of other people’s behaviour. We are guided and nudged and shaped by that."
- PavlovsCat 8y agothat made me think of one of the more unique 4k demos: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PcMxdFo7RAc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PcMxdFo7RAc (can't call this an intro, it's more of a demo than many demos)
- l33tbro 8y agoThe obvious counterpoint is that much of civilization has been stasis. Also, the sum total of years in the post-surveillence world we now live in may be too small a sample-duration to conclude that it isn't subject to the same fluctuations of disruption that have occured throughout history. Tldr: history teaches us that it's only a matter of time before shit goes bananas.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- olivermarks 8y agoI'm a huge Curtis fan and have seen and read just about everything he has done, even his early appearances with talking dogs on That's Life! https://youtu.be/ajsCY8SjJ1Y https://youtu.be/ajsCY8SjJ1Y I flew to NY to see Massive Attack vs Adam Curtis in 2014 and it was probably the best live event I've seen this century so far https://youtu.be/25g6ShHtzWo https://youtu.be/25g6ShHtzWo Excited to hear Curtis is back in action and doing more films, presumably still for the BBC where he seems to be a lifer. I thought this was a great, thought provoking interview. He did tackle the darker side of banking he briefly discusses in relation to UK economic austerity in this short Newswipe piece 'oh dearism' https://youtu.be/3UstNBrmJFc https://youtu.be/3UstNBrmJFc An interesting aside though - before Hypernormalization Curtis literally disappeared online for about 14 months - no news stories or Google alerts and quite a few links about him disappeared. Glad he's back and looking forward to seeing the new material.
- everdrive 8y agoThis is very interesting, and Curtis has a lot of great insights, but it seems like moves from accurate insight to hyperbolic and emotional conclusion many times during the interview. For example: "No one is really sure what Trump represents. My working theory is that he’s part of the pantomime-isation of politics. Every morning Donald Trump wakes up in the White House, he tweets something absolutely outrageous which he knows the liberals will get upset by, the liberals read his tweets and go “This is terrible, this is outrageous,” and then tell each other via social media how terrible it all is. It becomes a feedback loop in which they are locked together. In my mind, it’s like they’re together in a theatre watching a pantomime villain. The pantomime villain comes forward into the light, looks at them and says something terrible, and they go “Boo!!”. Meanwhile, outside the theatre, real power is carrying on but no one is really analysing it." I think this is a great insight, and it's true: but is "no one" paying attention to any other news? Surely many organizations are provably doing so every day. Why don't they count as "someone?" Presumably because they don't fit Curtis' definition of the cultural mainstream. But, Curtis (at least in the interview) never defines the cultural mainstream. What is inside it, what is outside it, and why? Would two individuals define the cultural mainstream the same way? What if my cultural mainstream does include people who are "analyzing the real power?" It seems that the conclusion based on his insight is meant to be emotionally powerful and impactful, except that anyone should be able to think of counterexamples. He makes this mistake the whole article. Here's another extraordinarily brilliant insight: (I'm not being sarcastic here, I think this is genius and he's really onto something) "I think the old mass democracies sort of died in the early 90s and have been replaced by a system that manages us as individuals. Because the fundamental problem is that politicians can’t manage individuals, they need us to join parties and support them and let them represent us as a group identified with them. What modern management systems worked out, especially when computer networks came into being, was that you could actually manage people as groups by using data to understand how they were behaving in the mass, but you could create a system that allowed them to keep on thinking that they were individuals." He expands on this idea, adding more insight and precision until finally stumbles into this: "They’re constantly playing back to you the ghosts of your own behaviour. We live in a modern ghost story. We are haunted by our past behaviour played back to us through the machines in its comparison to millions of other people’s behaviour. We are guided and nudged and shaped by that. It’s benign in a way and it’s an alternative to the old kind of politics. But it locks us into a static world because it’s always looking to the past. It can never imagine something new." I can't possibly see how this can be true. Creativity is dead? We can't imagine new things because facebook (or the internet, or modern media) exists? I'm being a bit dismissive here, but I don't see how he can support this claim. People are coming up with new ideas all the time. Again, his insight about how the internet and algorithms allow systems to cater to and control individuals was genius. But, the conclusion he draws from that insight is deeply emotional, catastrophic, and not very well constructed. It sounds like the sort of emotional mistake someone might make in therapy: "I'll never find another girlfriend again," or "I'll always be socially unpopular," etc.
- frabbit 8y agoLove Adam Curtis's work but he is completely wrong about a lack of story/vision being presented by current leaders: under Jeremy Corbyn the Labour Party is poised to present a complete re-envisioning of manufacturing and employment, based upon a Left-exit from the European Union: something anathema to majority of "educated thinkers" in the U.K. https://novaramedia.com/2018/06/24/financial-globalisation-has-been-a-disaster-brexit-gives-us-a-chance-to-resist-it/ https://novaramedia.com/2018/06/24/financial-globalisation-h...
- subsubsub 8y agoThe is an excellent 3 min deconstruction of Adam Curtis' work on YouTube [1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1bX3F7uTrg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1bX3F7uTrg