5 ms·
>> This is a laudable first step in advocacy for real regulation of a technology... Perhaps I'm jaded, but I don't agree at all. They're trying to get it regul
by phkahler 8y ago
>> This is a laudable first step in advocacy for real regulation of a technology...
Perhaps I'm jaded, but I don't agree at all. They're trying to get it regulated so they can be creepy without fear. One of the first "good" uses listed was finding 3000 children. "Think of the children" is a common rallying cry for evil. Nothing else mentioned was really relevant.
The line IMHO needs to be drawn at anything that you'd call stalking if it were done by a human. If a store wants to recognize me as a prior visitor, that's fine because an actual employee might do the same. But when my presence (just my presence, not even my purchase history) is shared among more than one location, that's like someone following me around. Stalking. This tracking of people and creating databases about them is at its essence a form of automated cyber stalking and should be illegal. The "societal benefits" of this are nothing more than claiming what's good for corporations is good for society. It is not. Please stop pretending this shit is OK.
- markus_orlandis 8y agoThat's a really good line in the sand, and relatively practical as well. Unfortunately, I don't think it will be put into the books with all the interests corporations would have in keeping it out.
- DubiousPusher 8y agoReally?! I don't think it is a good line in the sand. Because even though we can draw lines around how an AI might act like a human in a certain case, recognize you as a frequenter of a store, when we connect that AI to the rest of the computer capabilities out there it quickly becomes something a human couldn't do. A convencience store clerk might remember several dozen, even several hundered frequent customers but it tops out somewhere. And after some time the clerk will forget many of those who stop coming in. But an AI with a database for recollection suffers from neither of those issues. But you might say the recall has nothing at all to do with what the AI is basically doing. We have to look at this much more wholistically.
- phkahler 8y ago>> when we connect that AI to the rest of the computer capabilities out there it quickly becomes something a human couldn't do. Connecting the AI face recognizer to the cloud or any other system is exactly where the line needs to be.
- crawfordcomeaux 8y agoDisagree. This is a technology that can be secretly or openly deployed in businesses for the sake of emotional exploitation via dynamic displays targeting specific emotional states. I'm against turning the world into anymore of an emotional hunting ground than it naturally is. http://eqradio.csail.mi.edu http://eqradio.csail.mi.edu
- phkahler 8y agoYou may have just convinced me that this technology needs to be banned outright.
- crawfordcomeaux 8y agoIf we rely on the law for protection, we're doomed. This calls for much harder and higher action: We need a framework for programming ourselves so as to be able to systematically protect ourselves at emotional, mental, and spiritual levels. Further, any system incentivizing such emotional exploitation needs to leave now. I'm looking at you, capitalism.
- efreak 8y agoDead link? I'm on mobile if that makes a difference.
- crawfordcomeaux 8y agoFixed link http://eqradio.csail.mit.edu/ http://eqradio.csail.mit.edu/
- sdenton4 8y agoI'm unclear on how LACK of regulation leads to fears around being creepy... Torches and pitchforks are orthogonal to the state, either way.
- ukulele 8y ago> "Think of the children" is a common rallying cry for evil. I'm not familiar with this line of reasoning -- can you elaborate, or are there any good examples?
- saghm 8y agoInterestingly, there's a Wikipedia article on this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children
- nickrivadeneira 8y agoThat wiki doesn't describe anything related to using the phrase for evil.
- saghm 8y agoThe wording isn't as strong, but I think this paragraph explains a bit what GP is talking about: > Ethicist Jack Marshall described "Think of the children!" as a tactic used in an attempt to end discussion by invoking an unanswerable argument.[2] According to Marshall, the strategy succeeds in preventing rational debate.[2] He called its use an unethical manner of obfuscating debate, misdirecting empathy towards an object which may not have been the focus of the original argument.[2] Marshall wrote that although the phrase's use may have a positive intention, it evokes irrationality when repeatedly used by both sides of a debate.[2] He concluded that the phrase can transform the observance of regulations into an ethical quandary, cautioning society to avoid using "Think of the children!" as a final argument.[2]
- ambicapter 8y ago> called the use of the phrase "Think of the children" in debate a type of logical fallacy and an appeal to emotion.[1] According to the authors, a debater may use the phrase to emotionally sway members of the audience and avoid logical discussion.[1] They provide an example: "I know this national missile defense plan has its detractors, but won't someone please think of the children?"
- 8y ago
- kromem 8y agoExcept with a warrant, it's entirely legal (and has been for a long time) currently for a surveillance team to physically stalk you in areas with an expectation of privacy (TEMPEST, wiretaps, etc), and in public areas they don't even need a warrant (actually, in public areas, it's legal for anyone to stalk you - just ask celebrities about their paparazzi stalkers). As best I can tell, from a surveillance standpoint what Microsoft is encouraging to become standardized is to apply the same level of legal rigor for wiretaps to facial recognition, which would be a significant step beyond matching legal standards for physical surveillance (which is as it should be, as there's a scaling potential with automated surveillance that needs to be kept in check beyond simply the legal limits of physical surveillance). Microsoft's stance is a pretty good one "in a perfect world." The problem is that it isn't a perfect world, and we've already seen a good system of FISA courts established after the uncovered abuses from the 1975 Church committee turn into a revolving door for exponentially increased secret warrants for NSA surveillance, even to the point of that surveillance becoming available to local police forces. What doesn't help is that Hollywood has already normalized a lot of surveillance tech so that most of the public assumes things are already legal/implemented in much broader ways than they are, so it's normalized the very idea of the surveillance state that we are growing into. If anything, private corporate abuses of the technology is the only thing that will generate enough public outrage to lead to a generalized reform. Self-governance at a corporate level may seem good, but I suspect it will simply mitigate the necessary outrage. The necessary conversation starter would be the ACLU running a personalized erectile dysfunction out-of-home display advertising campaign in Washington, DC. As long as that level of abuse is against the terms of use of the intermediate providers, it protects the less visible abuses of the technology. Ironically, a "race to the bottom" is precisely what will result in the appropriate level of regulation - corporate self-governance will always be a half-measure that seems good on paper but leaves a lot of procedural loopholes for systemic abuses that go unnoticed for a very long time.
- phkahler 8y ago>> Except with a warrant, it's entirely legal I don't think Microsoft and their partners are interested in building a warrants-only surveillance system. Businesses already have camera systems and one could run face recognition on stored video after something has happened. Nobody is talking about that. This is all about real-time cloud connected face recognition.
- bad_user 8y ago>> If a store wants to recognize me as a prior visitor, that's fine because an actual employee might do the same It’s not the same. That employee is not always there, not always paying attention and he doesn’t keep a log. A machine on the other hand is very efficient and it’ll recognize you every single time.