4 ms·
One of the most insidious portions of non-competes IMO is that they are often non-enforceable. Depending on how wide or restricted the target of the non-compet
by munk-a 8y ago
One of the most insidious portions of non-competes IMO is that they are often non-enforceable. Depending on how wide or restricted the target of the non-compete is it can be ruled invalid. A lot of the more questioning people have probably discovered this but consider that there are probably janitors laid off by amazon who read their non-competes as the word of law and end up suffering hardships because of it.
Also, as an aside, a non-compete is not required to prevent corporate espionage, it's just easier to prove violation of. A lot of the sales teams worried about losing leads when team members departed could have pursued them with law suits focusing on the theft of corporate resources, it's regrettable non-competes have even gotten this far.
- TallGuyShort 8y agoThe problem with things being non-enforceable is that they're often enforced anyway, with intimidation and legal actions that are more relatively costly for the individual than the company. Non-competes are illegal for physicians in my state, but I know of a case in which the clinic dragged the case out so much with various technicalities that eventually the Dr. settled. Now, in a subsequent case with a different defendant, lawyers are refusing to take the case for that reason. So the doctor in question is waiting for the non-compete to expire before retrying opening a private practice anywhere near their home again. It's not enforceable legally, but they're doing so via other means.
- ghaff 8y agoAnd they have a chilling effect even when they're probably not going to be invoked or are unenforceable. I worked for a very small consulting firm for a number of years and we passed on pretty much anyone who had a non-compete. Management wasn't willing to take even a relatively small risk that we might get involved in a lawsuit.
- wpietri 8y agoFrom the perspective of any normal employee, "non-enforceable" doesn't matter. That I can eventually win in court doesn't matter if I can't afford the time, money, and stress to get that ruling. Exactly the goal, I'm sure, of the people writing up these agreements.
- paulie_a 8y agoFrom the perspective of the normal employee they should understand they pretty much won't be enforced. The threat will be made. And then no follow up.
- chii 8y agoIn most cases, yes, it is an empty threat. However, the possibility is there. The company (or, individuals in the company who dislike you) can selectively use it against you to make your life harder. Or, if you whistleblow, they can use it to retaliate.
- munk-a 8y agoA curious parallel to this is a lot of company's "no reference" policies. Due to the fact that a negative reference can have legal ramifications in a lot of jurisdictions a number of companies have adopted a policy where they publicly state that no reference will be given to leaving employees. I've known several companies like this that will then inform employees that are leaving privately that they'll be happy to give them a positive reference. Some parts of society can be really weird and distorting and I have no idea how we'd go about solving them.
- ghaff 8y agoI've always given individuals as references, not companies. Not sure the degree to which anyone's ever checked.
- munk-a 8y agoI have always given specific individuals as references as well. The companies I was referencing were ones where the management had a policy of agreeing not to give references. Again this is super weird because the only thing that is an issue is giving a negative reference so a lack of a positive reference could be interpreted as a negative reference... thus, not giving everyone a positive reference should be a similar issue. That entire law is sort of silly in most cases though, but the cases where it isn't (ex. a malicious boss for stupid reasons) are serious enough that I understand why it's around while being sad that we need it.