6 ms·
This is my favorite part: Another former senior employee noted a growing sense of paranoia among current employees. “Now, people now have burner phones to talk
by reaperducer 8y ago
This is my favorite part:
Another former senior employee noted a growing sense of paranoia among current employees. “Now, people now have burner phones to talk shit about the company — not even to reporters, just to other employees,” they told BuzzFeed News.
Facebook employees so afraid of Facebook spying on them, that they need burners. Presumably, not loaded with any Facebook apps.
- compiler-guy 8y agoMore likely just phones without access to facebook's internal corporate network, which grants many more privileges to the app and the company than everyday facebook access gets. They likely also dodge accounts connected to the one their employer recognizes. Calling these "burner phones" is a little silly. They are just completely private, non-corporate phones. I've never trusted any company to either pay for my own phone or plan, if that requires allowing it special access.
- iamdave 8y agoCalling these "burner phones" is a little silly. They are just completely private, non-corporate phones. So a phone used to duck surveillance from a powerful entity to conduct discussions about things you don't want that entity knowing about, colloquially goes by what other name then? I get it if the implicit association between a "real" burner phone and these devices might not be a complete and perfect parallel but I think here the term is apt (unless we're legitimately just talking about someone's every day personal phone, but that wasn't the impression I got-the article doesn't really talk more about what these devices are)
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoMeh, typically burner would be disposable. He’s arguing you don’t need to ‘burn’ this device after using. It’s just a normal phone that you can keep using. Burner-like if it works better for you.
- iamdave 8y agoHe’s arguing you don’t need to ‘burn’ this device after using. It’s just a normal phone that you can keep using We don't know that as a fact, do we? In this specific case I mean, I know how burner phones are used, but we have from the piece an interesting nugget that isn't really fleshed out. Maybe the employee just used 'burner phone' to get the point across quickly of the lengths employees were going through, maybe it's an allusion to something more but it's a nugget I found interesting nonetheless.
- compiler-guy 8y agoThey don't duck surveillance from facebook as you and I know it, but from facebook as an employer, which is very different. If a company provides your phone, then it has access to it, and if you don't want your company to have access to what you do on it, you use a different phone. If you want the convenience of a personal phone that you can check your work mail (or work facebook groups) on, then you grant access to that company. It isn't any different from when a law firm or bank provides its employees phones. If you don't want that firm or bank to read what you write on it, then you need another phone. A "burner phone" gets thrown away--"burned"--to prevent the someone from tracking you. You don't allow anyone to know you use it. No one at facebook cares if you use a second phone. So some better terms would be "personal phone" or "non-corporate phone".
- iamdave 8y agoIf a company provides your phone, then it has access to it, and if you don't want your company to have access to what you do on it, you use a different phone. If you want the convenience of a personal phone that you can check your work mail (or work facebook groups) on, then you grant access to that company. Right, and as I said in another comment, my statement here isn't to suggest I don't know what a burner phone is. My statement above is because I'd think someone would either say "We use our personal phones" or something similar to describe how they talk about FB without FB knowing it. Describing your personal phone as a "burner phone" seems odd and possibly telling that there's something else there. There very well might NOT be, but as I mentioned before: the article doesn't really say much further so it's hard to know.
- diminoten 8y ago> Describing your personal phone as a "burner phone" seems odd and possibly telling that there's something else there. Doesn't seem odd to me, in the context of a) a former employee sensationalizing the situation and/or b) hiding behavior from any employer.
- Varcht 8y agoNext you will tell us that Trump really had his "wires tapped"...
- rrix2 8y ago> So a phone used to duck surveillance from a powerful entity to conduct discussions about things you don't want that entity knowing about, colloquially goes by what other name then? A "personal device"
- babygoat 8y agoSurely you jest.
- lisper 8y agoA burner phone is one that you intend to discard after using it to conduct some clandestine, often illegal, activity. Just because a phone is private doesn't make it a burner.
- philipov 8y agoA burner is a phone you intend to discard if it becomes compromised. Just because you don't have to burn it doesn't make it not a burner.
- FPGAhacker 8y agoBecause you will definitely know when your phone is compromised.
- diminoten 8y agoSo then this most certainly isn't a burner phone situation, because Facebook employees wouldn't actually "burn" these phones.
- mbrumlow 8y agoIt is not when compromised. It all depends on your threat level and what you are using it for. Some people use once and burn, some burn one a day, or once a week, and some -- like you said, burn when they think it is compromised.
- chongli 8y agoOften illegal, but not always. Prudent travelers use burner phones when they cross borders in order to avoid dragnet searches by customs.
- asauce 8y agoFacebook gives employees corporate phones. It seemed to me that these "burner" phones were just personal phones sensationalized for the article. At my last job I was given a corporate phone as well as my own personal phone. Some coworkers decided to do everything on their corporate phone. I chose to keep the two separate, but I wouldn't say that I was using my personal phone as a "burner".
- iamdave 8y agoIt seemed to me that these "burner" phones were just personal phones sensationalized for the article. Definitely do not want to rule that out, you're right to bring this up, but agreed. Calling your personal phone a 'burner', seems novel? Not sure if there's a better word there.
- craftyguy 8y ago> So a phone used to duck surveillance from a powerful entity to conduct discussions about things you don't want that entity knowing about, colloquially goes by what other name then? Yes. A burner phone is a device you use once or twice, then dump (burn). I seriously doubt bookface employees are dumping their personal cell phones after sending a couple shit talk messages to their friends about their employer.
- garmaine 8y ago> So a phone used to duck surveillance from a powerful entity to conduct discussions about things you don't want that entity knowing about, colloquially goes by what other name then? A non-corporate phone. “Burner phone” is something very specific and refers to prepaid phones without attached identity at the network level. Which, as the name implies, can be “burned” (discarded) after use.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pvarangot 8y agoIt is a burner phone. What's silly is you have to use those techniques to discuss office politics with your coworkers.
- randyrand 8y agoIs it? I do the same thing. My 'burner phone' is my personal phone that I use 24/7 for everything, and I have a separate work phone with default VPN required, etc. It's not really a burner phone.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Calling these "burner phones" is a little silly Calling a personal phone your "burner phone" is silly. But if you work at Facebook, you're aware your personal phone may be leaking data. A phone purchased specifically to talk about things you don't want Facebook to hear is roughly accurately described as a "burner," even if it isn't discarded after use. (Broadly speaking, this is a prudent step for whistleblowers to take. Buy a cheap phone, turn off all non-essential services, and install Signal.)
- neves 8y agoYou have a high quality phone given to you from the company you work. Since you don't trust your company, you fell the need to buy another phone that will depreciate in a couple of years. You also need to carry another brick in your pocket or purse. Just to be able to talk freely. Sure it is a burn phone. I have wifi access when I'm on my company, but I don't feel the need to buy another phone just to be able to speak freely.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> I don't feel the need to buy another phone just to be able to speak freely If you aren’t whistleblowing, that’s reasonable. Companies have every tool available to pursue NDA breachers, trader secret stealers and insider traders on their hands to chase whistleblowers. Phones are cheaper than heavy litigation and the threat of prison time.
- disgruntledphd2 8y agoEven when a company gives me a phone, I keep my personal. If you leave a company unexpectedly (which can happen), it's good if you don't give up the ability to be contacted. I made this mistake in my twenties, and never again.
- neves 8y agoGood point. When a company gives you a phone, can't you mantain the number when you leave?
- jbigelow76 8y agoI've never trusted any company to either pay for my own phone or plan, if that requires allowing it special access. Lot's of companies provide a limited scope Wifi access for contractors, vendors, etc, when on campus. The level of insight might not be as high but the host company can potentially still track things like local network traffic without requiring "special access" beyond Wifi usage. If the FB employees don't want to acknowledge the existence of these phones then they are definitely "burners".
- unethical_ban 8y agoAny phone with mobile device management (MDM) like SecureWeb or "Good" or others, can see at the least, all the apps installed on the phone, as well as the ability to remote wipe phones. Don't know if they have the capacity to read data for individual apps. And if you have your employer manage your phone plan, I assume they have access to your call records.
- 3pt14159 8y agoI've seen first hand people high up in startups monitoring what their employees say in assumed-to-be-private chats to each other. Technically it was part of the employee agreement that nobody read. It's not a perfect, but one way to tell that the startup you're in is monitoring you is that they hand you a computer with your login already created. If you're opening up the Apple box yourself then it's much more likely to be free from keyloggers, etc. But don't trust shared sign-in stuff like Google Apps for Business to be private.
- Consultant32452 8y agoIt always amazes me how many people are willing to bash management over work chat. Like... you can be 99% sure they're reading that.
- jtwaleson 8y agoAbsolutely not 99%. More like 1%.
- ben_w 8y agoI suspect that the more likely you are to moan about the management, the more likely (1) the management wants to look at you because you’re always negative, and (2) the more likely the management wants to look at you because they’re the sort of control freaks that you want to moan about in the first place. I’m glad I don’t have that problem.
- forapurpose 8y ago> More likely just phones without access to facebook's internal corporate network ... Do you know that or is it just a guess?
- trhway 8y ago>Calling these "burner phones" is a little silly. They are just completely private, non-corporate phones. there is significant difference. Private non-corporate phones are usually connected to your name just by virtue of you having an account with cell phone provider in your name or activating the phone in a way that still naturally leads to you. A burner is typically cash-based bought/prepaid phone activated without any direct/indirect connection to your name or any other of your accounts/profiles/etc. Given the power of FB (and money involved - i mean every scandal moves like $100B of valuation - the cost of one year war in Iraq) i think it is very reasonable and prudent of its employees to use actual burners not just private phones.
- calhoun137 8y ago>> Calling these "burner phones" is a little silly. I agree, but it's still not as silly as how many people are commenting in here about whether or not its ok to call it a "burner phone" lol
- wDCzI78WRQaC1e3 8y agoIf Facebook employees aren't literally setting those phones on fire then we shouldn't call them burner phones.
- stillmotion 8y agoAll FB employees have a phone provided by Facebook with MDM software.
- bpchaps 8y agoIt's pretty understandable. My last job was in ad tech, and as part of the employment agreement, we effectively signed away our privacy rights through a clause that effectively waived the privacy rights on any machine that interfaced with any thing related to the company. Problem was - how does someone make the distinction between viewing an ad for work purposes and viewing it for work? Not to mention the company gave very reasonable incentives to use your own phone for work, etc.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoDon't use your own equipment for work then. It's your employer's responsibility to provide the resources needed for your job, not yours.
- bpchaps 8y agoWell, yes, but sometimes it's not that simple. For example, when the oncall person is unavailable and you get an emergency work call and only have your personal laptop on you.
- eropple 8y agoIt is that simple, though. Your management structure needs a better on-call strategy. Or needs to both compensate you for, and indemnify you for the use of, your personal gear.
- bpchaps 8y agoI don't work there anymore, but I'm genuinely curious why you think that's simple. In theory, absolutely. In practice, though? Trust me - I tried to get a better on-call strategy. You're making a lot of assumptions there without knowing much about the company, their management structure, etc etc etc.
- rleigh 8y agoWhy is it simple? Because you should never, ever need to use personal equipment or other resources for work use. If you're on-call, then the company should be providing the equipment needed to do those on-call duties, and pay for phone and internet charges accrued. If you're needing to use your personal stuff, then there's a problem, and the first thing to do would be to communicate this to your boss, and get the necessary equipment provisioned, be it a laptop to take back, or something else. Implicit reliance on your kit isn't even in the company's interest--what if it broke down, infected a customer with a virus or whatever. They and/or you might bear some liability for inability to provide service or to provide a bad service.
- akhilcacharya 8y agoFacebook provides all employees free phones with corporate device management and data plans so I can see why.
- atomical 8y agoI'm sure some are using BlindApp, but that app is not very censorship resistant.
- kerng 8y agoThat's why surveillance technology is so dangerous. The environment (company, government, people... ) changes but the tech surveillance capabilities remain. Facebook engineers know exactly what surveillance powers the company has, and how easily those can be exercised.
- WestCoastJustin 8y agoThey only need to slip up once and connect to facebook for it to unmask the employee from their device. I highly suspect they are not as anonymous as they think. Especially if they are connecting to an internal guest wifi at the office. You can get so much from metadata that you almost don't even need to know the content. Guess it all depends on how good their internal logs are at connecting wifi access macs with facebook logs. I'd wager it's pretty good as they already do this type of stuff to guess who your friends might be based on access proximity.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoThey don't even have to slip up. If someone they are communicating with does, they'll be found out.
- dbatten 8y agoI recently man-in-the-middled a smartphone (I won't mention the manufacturer) for work purposes. It was factory reset, with no apps installed (other than what ships with the phone). Started hitting Facebook APIs within seconds of each boot. I had no words.
- r00fus 8y agoSo it must be the default OS - why don't you reveal the manufacturer? Clearly an FB app in some form is bundled.
- casefields 8y agoClearly an Android, since Apple removed that weird Facebook/Twitter integration in the early days.
- jplayer01 8y agoCompanies like this should be named and shamed. It's the only power we have as consumers.
- dbatten 8y ago
- fipple 8y agoLet me explain: if you want to read your work email and access work files on your personal phone at most large companies, you need to install a mobile device management app like Lookout, Microsoft Intune, etc. These have deep spying permissions on your phone. Burners are just a phone without that.
- umichguy 8y agoDon't know why you would want to do that on your personal phone. I ain't reading any work stuff on my personal phone, even if they are willing to pay for it. Let them give me a work phone if they think it's important that I have access to work stuff on the go, outside the office.
- rleigh 8y agoAbsolutely. What I find slightly disturbing is that there are plenty of people who are more than willing to do this with their personal property. What's worse, I've had some of them rage at me for arguing against it and refusing to "comply". I don't like that weakness become the norm, and then enforced. The company has no rights to one's personal property.
- on_and_off 8y agoI have the same preoccupation about internal wifis at my past 2 employers. Slack I always consider as something my employer can see freely. For other means of communications, when I am on a company device and private network, I also have some paranoia that conversations are not private.
- notyourday 8y agoPortable WiFi VPN devices that masquarade with your phone wifi MAC aren't just for cruise ships anymore
- rleigh 8y agoIt's right there in the small print for the Slack terms of service. Any private communications can be observed by the company paying for the service. It certainly made me think twice about ever expressing any opinion in personal chat, and in fact reduced my use of it in favour of face to face talks.
- TomK32 8y agoI'm pretty sure they'd have no problem setting up their own cell towers at the facebook campus/offices.
- dymk 8y agoI work here and I've literally never seen or heard of this happening. It's just FUD.
- bpchaps 8y agoFirst rule of burner phones: don't talk about burner phones. Just because you haven't seen it, doesn't mean it's not happening.
- dymk 8y agoIt also doesn't mean it _is_ happening. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. Except on HN when it's about this year's boogeyman.
- bpchaps 8y agoEh, people are strange about their privacy. When I worked in adtech, I had a flip phone up until the point that my boss made me get a smartphone so that I could get hipchat. It's believable to me, because I was only inches away from having a burner phone myself.