6 ms·
Here's an argument: If you think about it, "mass" actually means two different things. One one hand, there is mass as the "charge" of gravitational interaction
by andrepd 8y ago
Here's an argument:
If you think about it, "mass" actually means two different things. One one hand, there is mass as the "charge" of gravitational interaction, that is, the gravitational field generated by a body is proportional to its mass. Let's call this concept "gravitational mass". On the other hand, you have mass in the sense of "intertial mass", a body's resistance to change of velocity. Although we kinda take it for granted, it's weird that these two concepts coincide, and not something that would be necessarily true a priori.
Asserting this equivalence as a principle is the starting point for Einstein's theory of General Relativity, which is one of the most beautiful and thoroughly tested theories in modern physics.
On the other hand, you can show that the inertial mass cannot be negative (else the Lagrangian would not be bounded from below and therefore you could not minimise it; the whole of physics then comes crumbling down). Therefore, if that equivalence stands, the gravitational mass also cannot be negative.
- baybal2 8y agoWell, even the possibility of inertial mass not exactly equaling gravitational mass on interstellar scale open a big can of worms for physics
- smaddox 8y agoWhat happens if the gravitational mass is the exact negative of the inertial mass for some fraction of matter, though? Does that break GR?
- dogma1138 8y agoI’m not sure this stands true when you think about fields. Think of charged particles in a magnetic field and how polarity and and strength of the charge impacts their interaction the strength would do the same thing for both particles while the polarity would mirror their interaction. I need to read the paper a few more times tho.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> On the other hand, you can show that the inertial mass cannot be negative (else the Lagrangian would not be bounded from below and therefore you could not minimise it; the whole of physics then comes crumbling down). Here's a purely thought-experiment argument for inertial mass not being negative: If you had an object with negative inertial mass, then pushing on that object would cause it to accelerate into your hand. This is a positive feedback loop that immediately results in the object and your hand exerting infinite amounts of force on each other, because applying force just leads to applying more force.
- perfmode 8y agoThis assumes that the objects of opposite inertial mass are able to interact in the way you describe.
- TrainedMonkey 8y agoSpecifically the interaction is: objects with positive inertia being able to 'push' objects with negative inertia. This brings up an interesting question, is gravity about exchanging momentum? My mental model of gravity being spacetime curvature would imply no, but that intuition is likely wrong.
- staplers 8y agoThat's assuming your hand has negative inertial mass.. which I'm assuming it doesn't. Your scenario could create a black hole if I'm understanding correctly. Enough 'negative inertial mass' trapped in a feedback loop..
- wallace_f 8y agoIf inertia is resistance to change then negative inertia would be promotion of change? I really dont know, the idea of negative inertia seems wildly counterintuitive.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoInertia isn't "resistance to change". It's defined by Newton's second law, F = ma. Force and acceleration are directional vectors, and mass is scalar. In the form of the equation favored by my high school physics teacher, a = F/m, we see that when a force is exerted on an object with positive mass, the object will accelerate in the same direction as the force, in inverse proportion to its own mass. But it's very easy to put a negative number in for the mass, and then you see that such an object would accelerate in response to force just as much as an object of equal positive mass, but in the opposite direction.
- 8y ago
- starbeast 8y agoDon't you have two things that can generate gravitational fields though? As distortions in spacetime can be caused by either mass or the momentum of massless particles, such as photons. Or do I have that wrong and photons merely follow the distortions and not cause any of their own? As presumably, you could have a negative gravitational field from a photon traveling backward in time, without having any issues with changes in inertial mass.
- marcosdumay 8y ago> Or do I have that wrong and photons merely follow the distortions and not cause any of their own? You have that wrong in the momentum of massless particle has mass, independently of its carrier. Massless particles do not actually exist, what exist are particles with zero "mass at rest" and that are never at rest.
- starbeast 8y agoAhh, I was getting a bit confused from photons distorting spacetime off their wavelength and plank's constant, given they also apparently have no mass. Thanks for that. I have to go and re-read a lot of stuff now though. ;)
- marcosdumay 8y agoYou may like to make a quick read of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy%E2%80%93momentum_relation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy%E2%80%93momentum_relati... Besides it being a basic relation for relativity, there's also an entire "parallel" quantum mechanics for particles that have too much energy at the momentum component based on it.
- feanaro 8y agoYou're talking about relativistic mass, but that isn't a commonly used concept anymore. Today it is indeed the norm to think of "mass" as being the mass at rest. Massless particles are really massless and have momentum without having mass.
- ravar 8y agoActually the lagrangian is not minimized, it is merely stationary. An example of this is the harmonic oscillator, the lagrangian is clearly not bounded from below.
- andrepd 8y agoYes, I realised that but I couldn't edit the post anymore :) I mean the action, not the Lagrangian, must have a minimum.
- ravar 8y agoThe action of a trajectory is not minimized either, it is usually at a saddle point, maximal relative to some trajectories and minimal to others. The linked paper has a detailed discussion of this. http://www.eftaylor.com/pub/Gray&TaylorAJP.pdf http://www.eftaylor.com/pub/Gray&TaylorAJP.pdf
- abakker 8y agoI think this might be dumb, but, what if negative mass was just positive mass in some alternative dimension? If mass could be negative with respect to our observable space time, does that actually mean it is a binary kind of thing, or could there be lots of mass in lots of others semi-or-non-interacting dimensions? Maybe even the mass we can observe is only part of anything’s actual substance...
- feanaro 8y agoPerhaps gravitational mass is indeed polarised and inertial mass corresponds to the absolute value of the gravitational mass?
- davibu 8y agoI was thinking, what if body's resistance is actually the norm, even when there is no change of velocity ? But the negative mass would provide the energy to let the body's in movement ? From our point of view it seems that body's can move by theirselves and it seems also that we have to provide energy to change their velocities. But if we think the universe as a fluid, body's should be constantly slowed. It's very strange to have two distinct behavior, except if we have a negative mass in the universe.
- amalcon 8y agoAnother framing of the issue with negative inertial+gravitational mass is that it would result in perpetual acceleration. E.g. assume two bodies, one with mass M, the other with mass -M. The standard gravitational model describes a "repulsive" force on each of these objects, in the direction opposite each other. However, since the object of mass -M has negative inertial mass, this force would cause it to accelerate toward the object of mass M. This results in these objects not accelerating relative to each other, and perpetually accelerating relative to an independent observer. One might attempt to explain this by saying that the negative mass has a growing negative kinetic energy level, but (it seems as a layman) this would violate the second law of thermodynamics. Edit: Actually just negative inertial mass does this all by itself; it is just in the opposite direction if the gravitational mass is positive.