10 ms·
> Facebook used data provided by the Israeli analytics firm Onavo to determine which other mobile apps were being downloaded and used by the public. It then use
by paganel 8y ago
> Facebook used data provided by the Israeli analytics firm Onavo to determine which other mobile apps were being downloaded and used by the public. It then used this knowledge to decide which apps to acquire or otherwise treat as a threat
> there was evidence that Facebook's refusal to share data with some apps caused them to fail
Stuff like this should trigger the EU Commissioner for Competition to withdraw the authorization that “allowed” FB to acquire Whatsapp and should force a split between the two entities. A fine (no matter how big) will be seen by FB and its investors just as “cost of doing business”. Facebook in its current form needs to be split up back again.
- danarmak 8y agoHow do you force a split when one part (Whatsapp) may not have enough revenue to sustain itself?
- M2Ys4U 8y agoLet it fail?
- zaarn 8y agoYou split and one part dies. If the commission involved put up rules on the merger and FB broke the rules, this is what happens.
- iddqd 8y agoI'll happily chip in a dollar a year or so.
- soziawa 8y agoSeize it and then sell it in an auction. WhatsApp is so insanely popular that it will for sure find a buyer.
- cmsonger 8y agoI've long held a theory that many of the "basic infrastructure" pieces of technology would best be put forward by non-profits. The profit imperative can be an insidious corrosive influence.
- stuaxo 8y agoOT: Similar for health, in the UK you can see once some parts were privatised more and more gets privatised - not surprisingly, these companies have a duty to grow.
- krrrh 8y agoWhen the WhatsApp acquisition happened while they had only a few dozen employees and were reportedly profitable off of their $1 per year business model, it was clear to me that the days when a small non-profit could run the world’s chat infrastructure weren’t far off. That the Signal Foundation is now basically funded by interest earned on money made from that very WhatsApp sale is quite poetic. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/story/signal-foundation-whatsapp-brian-acton/amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/story/signal-foun...
- aljones 8y agoSame way you do when they may have enough revenue.
- athrowaway3z 8y agoI can't answer your question but i think you should be more specific. Your phrasing obviously comes with the interpretation that if a split-up would bankrupt a part, it shouldn't be done. Why should this be taken into consideration? Secondly. It has value. A different party could invest and keep it going. Why is it important that it sustains itself?
- michaelt 8y agoIf the objective is to increase competition, by making WhatsApp into the Facebook competitor they currently aren't, you need them to stay in business. Of course, if you just wanted to punish facebook by destroying shareholder value, or you're certain WhatsApp users will move to an FB competitor rather than to FB itself, you might not care if WhatsApp stays in business post-breakup.
- maemilius 8y agoAs far as I'm aware, the only thing WhatsApp competed with Facebook over is Messenger, and even that seems like a stretch to me. My impression of the situation is that Facebook bought WhatsApp for its data and user-base; not because it was competition.
- kypro 8y agoI guess it's not like anyone is employed to work on Whatsapp or anything. It's not like millions of people use it to stay in contact with their families every day.
- empath75 8y agoWhy should we support exploitative business models?
- ysavir 8y agoWhatsapp has enough of a userbase and a usecase that enough people will be willing to pay to sustain it. What _will_ happen is that other free services will pop up and be used, and some users will migrate to those. Which is a good thing. We'll have actual competition on the field instead of a single dominant player.
- ionised 8y agoWhy should we care if WhatsApp can't sustain itself?
- btown 8y agoA world in which companies are not allowed to selectively withhold proprietary data from some competitors, and form partnerships with others, is a world that suboptimally promotes innovation and economic growth.
- kitd 8y ago... so long as everyone is complying with the law.
- dec0dedab0de 8y agoA world in which companies are not allowed to selectively withhold proprietary data from some competitors, and form partnerships with others, is a world that suboptimally promotes innovation and economic growth. Maybe economic growth, but how is innovation promoted by limiting access?
- PavlovsCat 8y agoHow so?
- dyeje 8y agoI'm not advocating for anything here, but isn't hurting innovation and economic growth exactly what FB is doing by snuffing out promising products based on analytics?
- dnadler 8y agoWould it be better if, instead of analytics, they flipped a coin?
- notahacker 8y agoUsing analytics to restrict apps based on their popularity - if that's what Facebook did - is definitely much more anti-competitive behaviour and even more likely to hurt growth than simply being arbitrary or completely random in their decision making. But yes, a non-arbitrary policy of allowing developers access if they followed a transparent set of rules would obviously be better.
- isostatic 8y ago> A fine (no matter how big) $200 billion, and a review in 12 months time? That's 5 years revenue. $100 per user, sounds reasonable. Facebook can put in an easy "claim your $100" button on their site. Would that just be a "cost of doing business"?
- dwighttk 8y agowould you take that money?
- ddalex 8y agoyes, sure. I'm not a FB shareholder. I'll take the 100, and the GDPR them to make them forget that I ever took the money.
- thecatspaw 8y agoExcept you couldnt GDPR them, as they are allowed to save data if its business critical, which I would argue "XYZ took the 100$" is
- notahacker 8y agoInteresting challenge: how to design that button to make it conform to mandated guidelines on its appearance, size, position and wording whilst also making it look enough like the sort of probable-scam advert users generally ignore to limit the number of Facebook members who actually claim it. Facebook probably has data to help them with that too :D
- breischl 8y agoI have no particular love for FB or what they've done with data, but these I don't understand why either of those points is particularly controversial or even unusual. > Facebook used data provided by the Israeli analytics firm Onavo to determine which other mobile apps were being downloaded and used by the public. It then used this knowledge to decide which apps to acquire or otherwise treat as a threat Checking out your competition is pretty standard among all businesses, as is buying out the ones you can't beat. > there was evidence that Facebook's refusal to share data with some apps caused them to fail Sharing or not sharing data with another app is likewise not an unusual decision. FB is not a public utility - they can not work with other apps for any reason, or no reason at all. And this is a particularly ironic thing to point out, considering that the main thrust is complaining that they _did_ share data with other apps. So it's bad if they do share data, but also bad if they don't?
- empath75 8y ago> Checking out your competition is pretty standard among all businesses, as is buying out the ones you can't beat. To be clear-- they marketed Onava as a VPN service to protect your personal data from spying and then they spied on your personal data to figure out what products you were using.
- dao- 8y ago> So it's bad if they do share data, but also bad if they don't? Yeah. I'm guessing they have a bad business model.
- johnnyfaehell 8y ago> Sharing or not sharing data with another app is likewise not an unusual decision. FB is not a public utility - they can not work with other apps for any reason, or no reason at all. And this is a particularly ironic thing to point out, considering that the main thrust is complaining that they _did_ share data with other apps. So it's bad if they do share data, but also bad if they don't? To me, this would be Facebook taking advantage of their stronghold on the market to continue to dominate the market. Let's remember this is not Facebook's data, this is their users' data. It should be up to the User who they can share their data with, but they weren't given the choice to use their data with an app because Facebook decided they didn't like the way the other business competes with them in some aspect or how they aren't making money out of the third party app. An example is Facebook won't grant Influencer Marketing Companies access to their API even though the user (The Influencer) wants them to have the data so they can get paid based on the views, shares, comments, and likes of the posts they've been contracted for. User has a legit desire to share that data to the point where they will take screenshots, GDPR deletions, etc to fulfil the need for that data to be shared. Facebook's reason for not allowing them access is simple, they don't make any money out of the deal. So if they refuse to allow you to share your data with people you want to share it with, that is bad. Sharing your data with companies you don't want to share with is also bad.
- raverbashing 8y ago> Facebook's refusal to share data with some apps caused them to fail It's not clear what this means. Is it an API that returns '403 forbideen' or more of a case of lack of competitive information
- ceejayoz 8y agohttps://www.digitaltrends.com/opinion/facebook-cuts-off-access-to-vine/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/opinion/facebook-cuts-off-acce... > Yes, within a day of Vine’s launch, Facebook pulled the ability for Vine users to find Facebook friends who were also using the new app.
- raverbashing 8y agoThanks
- mcintyre1994 8y agoThe good news is that Onavo was removed from the App Store. For some reason Google seem to be happy letting it stay on Android though.
- pmart123 8y ago"Don't be evil" -> "Don't be the most evil"
- netcan 8y agoI agree with the conclusion, but I don't think it should be done through the current antitrust framework. Your first point and most of the others others may or may not be illegal. If they are legal, what the MPs need to do is their jobs.. make laws. But, most are not directly related to company size and/or market share. Your second point does sound like a trust and I think you're right to link this to the WhatsApp sale. But... Regardless of the FB/WhatsApp conclusion, that is a one-off that won't lead to much systemic change whether it's a fine or an order to de-merge. What we need (imo) is a whole new approach to antitrust that doesn't hinge on a definition of monopoly. Companies beyond a certain size should just be put under a different set of obligations than smaller ones. They should be assumed to have market power by merit of their size. When it comes to gdpr and such, these need to be written differently for large companies. Basically, no more equality before the law for companies. What we get in return is rule of law.
- nradov 8y agoExxonMobil is a huge company. How much market power do they have over the price of crude oil? Not much, because it's a commodity. Other factors matter far more than size.
- netcan 8y agoIn theory and on paper.... Making that into a functional legal system, hasn't happened. In any case, half my point is that pricing power is not the operative definition of market power anymore. If xonmobile can/do have all sorts of influence on governments, job markets and such. They can do tax stuff a restraint can't. What I am proposing is that the definition of a monopoly is not useable, for policy. It's fine as an economic & academic concept, not as a legal one.
- int_19h 8y agoLarge companies aren't bad just because they tend to monopolize the market they operate in. They can also lobby far more effectively, then there's the issue of the job market competitiveness etc.
- crunchlibrarian 8y agoAnti-trust. Anti-monopoly. We needed to revive these movements five years ago.
- spunker540 8y agoCan you really blame FB for not providing API access to competitors? If you want make Farmville with FB login go ahead, but if you try to make "FB 2.0" with FB Login and all friend connections preserved but keep all the ad revenue yourself obviously Facebook is gonna put their foot down.
- rmc 8y ago> A fine (no matter how big) will be seen by FB and its investors just as “cost of doing business" Depends how big you think. FB had revenues of $40bil. So let's fine them $50 billion.