3 ms·
> The two types of people I’ve encountered who desire the notion of free will: 1) Person with ego who needs to have a belief in free will. 2) Persons who has eg
by naasking 8y ago
> The two types of people I’ve encountered who desire the notion of free will: 1) Person with ego who needs to have a belief in free will. 2) Persons who has ego, gets annoyed by free will being a facade and refuses to think about it because “it doesn’t matter” to this person.
This is a complete straw man. Let me describe the contrary claim: in my experience, the type of person who desire giving up free will either a) want to give up punishment and so confuse justice with moral responsibility, and/or b) are confused about what determinism and choice really mean. You appear to fall in the former category at the very least.
I suggest you read up a little more on the meaning of free will and Compatibilism specifically. There's a reason why the majority of professional philosophers are Compatibilists.
- dubya23 8y agoEvery time free will comes up on HN these bizarre statements arise. Compatabilism is crap and even Dan Dennett perhaps the most famous compatabilist knows it. He often says "You have free will, it's just not what you think it is." This totally obfuscates the problem. Laypeople when thinking of free will imagine Libertarian Free Will which virtually no philosophers think actually exists but this is exactly the kind of free will that matters to people. All these arguments that folks like you make are just semantic and in my opinion meaningless. Its a simple fact that the type of free will that most people subjectively feel they have simply doesn't exist, everything else is word play. People are using two different definitions and only 1 really matters.
- intralizee 8y agoYou don’t have a good grasp on philosophy to suggest the meaning of free will and complatiblism. Yes the justic system is a disgrace to humanity and I understand determinism. Prove otherwise please from what I wrote and I’ll be thankful. Instead it looks like someone with a hurt ego writing nonsense to me.
- naasking 8y agoThere's nothing to prove. Your comment had no substance, and advanced no arguments. It was a set of bald assertions without justification, and so can be dismissed without argument.
- intralizee 8y agoNo because it has substance and wasn’t even a straw man. Sorry your fate is to have a fragile ego in life. :/