5 ms·
The crazy thing is, their phones take amazing photos. Why do they need to fake it?
by lostlogin 8y ago
The crazy thing is, their phones take amazing photos. Why do they need to fake it?
- setquk 8y agoBecause they’re actually nowhere near as good as a DSLR and they want you to think they are.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoThe same reason anybody uses a stock photo for anything. You can spend $10,000 and a bunch of time to rent a set, actors, techs and a photographer or you can spend $200 to buy a stock photo in a few minutes.
- izzydata 8y agoSamsung must have a nice view from somewhere within walking distance of one of their buildings. How hard could it be to have the intern go snap some pictures. Perhaps hundreds of pictures and then choose the best.
- sowbug 8y agoThis works better if the interns are professional photographers.
- Mtinie 8y agoSo hire interns with a photography background? If they can build a rechargeable device which is capable of taking high-resolution photos without outside assistance they are more than capable, as a business, of figuring out the challenge of hiring the right people to support their engineering efforts. Edit: Or better yet, hire a professional photographer when you want to showcase the output of your high-end digital cameras.
- Rodneyj 8y agoWhy would they waste all that time and money when it doesn't matter?
- princekolt 8y agoIsn’t it the whole point of smartphone cameras that you don’t need to be a professional photographer to take good pictures?
- anoncake 8y agoThe whole point of a smartphone camera is that you don't have to carry a separate device. Easy to use cameras existed long before them. And even with a smartphonesmartphonecamera, I don't think skill is useless.
- bsenftner 8y agoYou'd be surprised, very very surprised, when asking someone to take a "good photo" they return with utter crap. One of the "thought crimes" in our society is people thinking they can take a good photo - most can't, even if their life depended upon it. It is actually shocking, because most people, seeing professional photography all the time, just assume they can shoot professional quality - until they try.
- mark-r 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
- kakwa_ 8y agoThe partial counter argument to that is $10000 is nothing compared to a promotion campaign for a product which usually costs millions. The time and delay argument is a bit more valid. But if it is at the risk of such bad press, not sure it's a good idea.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- slantyyz 8y ago>> The partial counter argument to that is $10000 is nothing compared to a promotion campaign for a product which usually costs millions. From the looks of it, it's not a promotion campaign that cost millions. It's just a bunch of microsites for a rehash of a previous Samsung product for a handful of countries (Malaysia, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan and Indonesia? India's microsite for the product doesn't appear to use the image) I would guess that it's the work from the marketing department of one of Samsung's regional offices, not HQ or US.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThey all fake it. Even those few that are taken with a phone are so far removed from what a phone owner has, I think it would be more honest to label them with a huge "FAKED photo" banner. Here's an example for iPhone where they're using some complex mounting frame to connect a 35mm prime lens to the front of an iPhone. The phone becomes more like a smart camera back. https://petapixel.com/2017/06/30/truth-shot-iphone-style-ads/ https://petapixel.com/2017/06/30/truth-shot-iphone-style-ads... I call it fraudulent, and should be in breach of advertising regulations.
- striking 8y agoOnePlus doesn't, at least https://photos.oneplus.com/gallery https://photos.oneplus.com/gallery
- reaperducer 8y agoFor years Apple was the only smartphone company that didn't have the disclaimer text "Screen images simulated" at the bottom of its TV commercials. Then it started using the disclaimer "Screen sequences shortened." Now I think it's like every other phone manufacturer with "Screen images simulated." Sad.
- FireBeyond 8y agoHah. Apple had to be sued, or threatened with a suit, in order to add the disclaimer in the first place, because they were talking about how amazing the iPhone's performance was... with shortened screen sequences.
- dwighttk 8y agoa) your article shows that there is a disclaimer on the ads about external equipment and shows a picture that it is possible to mount crazy lenses on a phone, but you are left to connect the dots yourself. b) there is a categorical difference between using a different camera and presenting it as if it came from the phone and using external equipment to supplement the phone.
- parliament32 8y agoA phone camera lens just cannot take a photo as good as a DSLR without having a proper sized sensor and a matching lens size... you can do all sorts of software tricks to make a photo look "better" but it's not physically possible, despite what their marketing teams want you to believe.
- bihnkim 8y agoI can sell anything, you know? You know how many times I fake on the streets? You know? You have to fake. The guys that don't fake, they're the ones that get it the worst.
- buryat 8y ago1. Not enough time to use the actual phones to take photos and then create final print materials. 2. Maybe some tops don't trust enough that the phone cameras are good and want to make a less risky bet.
- mtgx 8y agoWhen you say "their phones" do mean the Galaxy S and Note flagships? Because there's a huge gap in camera performance between those and the mid-tier A-series.
- gnopgnip 8y agoThese ads are made months before the product is released, and often the team making the ad does not have physical access to the product. Even if they could get access it is standard to use stock photography to keep cost down and get the ads turned around quickly. For the same reason restaurants use stock photography instead of taking their food to a studio or any other type of marketing
- mark-r 8y agoThis. Why send your device out with a photographer and hope they can get a compelling image when they can browse thousands from a stock photo outlet and get something perfect in an afternoon? The stock photo will be much cheaper as well.
- matthewdgreen 8y agoWell, for one thing: because then you don't get a bunch of viral news stories floating around saying stuff like "Samsung couldn't even use their own cameras to do their marketing." For another, because it sends a strong message that your phone cameras aren't up to professional quality standards, despite the fact that they might well be. And for a final reason: because their leading competitor has made a huge deal about using their cameras to do advertising-quality shoots, which somewhat ups the bar for Samsung. https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/10/shot-on-iphone-xs-users-share-their-best/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/10/shot-on-iphone-xs-use...
- mark-r 8y agoI wasn't aware of Apple's example; that's Apple being smart, not Samsung being stupid. Stock photos being used for simulated product images has been common nearly forever. I'll agree that maybe the time has come for that common practice to be changed. Camera companies put prototypes into selected professional's hands to get early feedback and images, maybe the phone companies should do the same.
- megy 8y agoI like the idea that it takes longer to make the ad than to make the actual device, so they need to fake it.