37 ms·
I think it's disturbing what happened to Khashoggi...but I don't understand what the U.S. or the West is supposed to do about it. We can't go to war over some g
by chrisco255 8y ago
I think it's disturbing what happened to Khashoggi...but I don't understand what the U.S. or the West is supposed to do about it. We can't go to war over some guy who wasn't even our citizen, killed in Turkey, by a foreign government. I hate to say it, but don't things like this happen all the time in certain countries?
- lozaning 8y agoArms embargoes, economic sanctions and travel restrictions I think would all be on the table as responses.
- chrisco255 8y agoFor one guy? What about the people killed in China, Russia, etc? I mean, there's dozens of countries that hit certain political targets with either imprisonment or death. I don't think that's a sustainable diplomatic policy. And when do you lift it?
- kevinh 8y agoYou might want to look into the Magnitsky Act, as that's a similar action taken against Russia. It's context for what countries are doing against murders orchestrated by the Russian government, and what they could do against the government of Saudi Arabia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnitsky_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnitsky_Act
- albertgoeswoof 8y agoYou forgot changing your Facebook profile picture
- Touche 8y agoMurdering dissidents while they are in other countries doesn't happen all of the time, no. That's why it's news.
- chrisco255 8y agoIt certainly happens: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/britain-charges-two-russians-with-attempted-murder-of-ex-spy-with-nerve-agent/2018/09/05/db99c5c8-b0f7-11e8-a20b-5f4f84429666_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.f21fb8fab484 https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/britain-charges-... We're hearing more about Khashoggi because he was a journalist, I suppose.
- Touche 8y agoI didn't say it doesn't happen. I said it doesn't happen all of the time. The incident you linked to was a big story, I remember it. If these things happened all of the time they wouldn't be reported in national papers. A mugging in San Francisco isn't in the Washington Post.
- cronix 8y agoBut we only really hear about the failures, or when the mission didn't go according to plan and someone was caught. When it does go according to plan, no one knows about it, or at least there usually isn't enough evidence to be able to attribute blame.
- Touche 8y agoHow can a person disappear from the planet without anyone knowing about it? When it's within the guilty country that's one thing, they can suppress the information from getting out. But to travel to another country and kill someone that doesn't really work.
- cronix 8y agoGovt's don't usually announce when a spy goes missing.
- spiritcat 8y agoand because he was wearing an apple watch
- roadnottaken 8y agoI think this case blew-up because the Saudi's were caught red-handed. Erdowan realized he could put extreme pressure on the Saudi's because his evidence was so strong. I think you're probably right that this sort of thing happens with some frequency, but you can only call foul if you have hard evidence which is much more rare.
- nyolfen 8y agoit was a handful of factors: erdogan having strong evidence like you said and leaking it slowly to maximize impact, the fact that it was a journalist meaning journalists paid a great deal of attention to it, the fact that the details were almost like fiction, and the many people opposed to the atrocities in yemen/general opponents of the saudi regime using it as a convenient lever against mbs. there are probably a few more notable ones but those are the main currents as i see it.
- abalone 8y agoIt's not a matter of going to war. The Saudi regime has been propped up by the U.S. since WWII as a means of projecting power over the Arabian peninsula. It's not the same as say Russia or China. The U.S. has a direct role in enabling the crimes of the Saudi regime, and very likely the withdrawal of that support would effect change.
- chrisco255 8y agoWith regards to China, we opened up trade with them in the 70s and our companies helped build up their economy by offshoring there. But again, this Khashoggi guy is one guy, a Saudi citizen...not ours. We don't deal with any other country like this...what makes Khashoggi so important as to disrupt treaties and trade deals between nations?
- wbl 8y agoHe had a Green Card which is pretty close to being a US citizen legally.
- insulanus 8y agoThat may be the way that some countries view the world. The purpose of trade is to serve people, not the other way around. Whoops, I meant make a lot of money for corporations. Also, even if you approach this from a pure self-interest angle, at some point, the US might start to lose influence if they keep undermining their own stated values, not to mention allowing other powers to murder their residents with impunity. Also, if the Americans are looking for a reason to get involved, his son is American.
- chrisco255 8y agoIf we went to war with every country that committed hits against their own people we'd be at war with half the world. There's some balance and restraint we have to have in dealing with the world. Imperialism is not a sustainable strategy in 2018.
- 8y ago
- docbrown 8y ago>I don't understand what the U.S. or the West is supposed to do about it. They’re doing what they can and should do via policy decisions. I don’t remember reading a piece thus far where going to war with Suadia Arabia and Mohammed bin Salman was even a scenario. By trying to minimize this act as something that “happens all the time” is partially due to society viewing these acts as normal for them.
- forapurpose 8y ago> We can't go to war ... There are many, many methods of leverage short of war. International relations happens all the time between every country on earth; only a tiny number of those interactions involves violence. In fact, a primary job of the people who practice international relations is to get things done without risking wars - sort of like doctors whose job is to get things done without killing the patient. > some guy who wasn't even our citizen, killed in Turkey, by a foreign government Human rights are widely considered to be universal, both in philosophy and in law. The U.S.'s own Declaration of Independence says 'all men are created equal ...'; it doesn't say 'all Americans'. Also, it's widely believed that if you let human rights deteriorate elsewhere, you are creating more risk for yourself. If your next door neighbor doesn't have freedom, there are many reasons to think you might be next. Finally, free, democratic countries tend to be much better partners on the world stage - they tend to be peaceful, stable, and prosperous. Finally, Khashoggi was a journalist, which implicates a specific human right, freedom of the press.
- chrisco255 8y agoI'm with you in theory on human rights. I believe every human deserves them. But I also understand there's practical real world constraints to enforcing our values around the world. That's a cost we can't afford. Like it or not the cost of not doing business with any non-democratic countries...would eventually be war. And a war on more fronts than we could deal with. The U.S. should serve as an inspirational example as it did in the past but we can't be nation builders and all-out imperialists.
- forapurpose 8y agoI didn't say the things you disagree with, but I'll address your points: > not doing business with any non-democratic countries That would be a pretty extreme measure; I don't think anyone, or anyone respected, is calling for it. Another drawback to disengaging completely is that you lose future leverage; it's a punishment, in a way, but once it's done then you have no more relationship with the other party. 'I'm taking my ball and going home' is very amateur diplomacy. > The U.S. should serve as an inspirational example as it did in the past but we can't be nation builders and all-out imperialists. The choice of the U.S. isn't all or nothing - be purely "inspirational" or be "all-out imperialists". The U.S.'s soft power - the inspiration - was very potent until Trump, and to a smaller degree GW Bush, said democracy and human rights weren't a priority. It still could be revived to a significant degree. But there are other solutions, including the following: * Intervene in ways that are efficient and effective. The U.S. can't help every country, and many interventions are ineffective. But lots of research and experience show what works in which scenarios. * Support international law and norms that pressure regimes in the right direction. The UN in general plays a major role. The Responsibility to Protect, for example, was developed after Rwanda's massacres in the 1990s and, generally speaking, requires each government to protect the welfare of its citizens (rather than massacre them) and says the government is illegitimate otherwise. The International Criminal Court holds political leaders legally responsible for crimes (though I don't know that the U.S. officially supports it). * Support mechanisms that provide stability, such as the World Bank (which supports infrastructure and other needs) and the International Monetary Fund (which loans governments money to prevent bankruptcies).
- elihu 8y agoWe're not likely to go to war against Saudi Arabia over this, but currently we're assisting their war in/with Yemen. I'm not really sure why we're helping them with that, and I'm not sure anyone else knows either but the easy option in this case is just to stop helping. Maybe stop selling them weapons, while we're at it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> I don't understand what the U.S. or the West is supposed to do about it Sanction the NSO Group.
- DSingularity 8y agoLol
- tareqak 8y agoOne of the asked for measures that many countries that do business with Saudi Arabia is to cancel all military equipment contracts. That measure doesn't require anyone to go to war. Unfortunately, the clauses in these contracts specify heavy fines for cancellations. One thing that I thought of that legislatures in sovereign countries could do is to pass a law that adds a clause to all military equipment contracts carried out by their constituent corporations that allows such cancellations in the case of human rights violations. It wouldn't help with the current event, but it might for future ones.
- Spooky23 8y agoThe US has considerable influence over the kingdom, and the bizarre political situation in the US has emboldened that regime to do all sorts of misbehavior, from holding rival aristocrats hostage to this killing.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> but I don't understand what the U.S. or the West is supposed to do about it. Stop actively and vocally supporting the violent consolidation of power that the murder was part of? > We can't go to war over some guy who wasn't even our citizen, killed in Turkey, by a foreign government. We could, especially since he was a US permanent resident and a journalist for US publications; we won't, but then going to war isn't exactly the only possible action. As well as he aforementioned steps, we could just stop aiding the war being wages by he regime.that committed the murder. The political threshold of support for such an action is much lower than going to war.
- BurnGpuBurn 8y agoWell, like we do with Russia, we (The US, the west in general) could sanction the hell out of them until they clean up their act. Just sanction their oil sales, crank up production everywhere else to compensate. It would hurt but could certainly be done. Then demand they stop waging genocide on Yemen, and demand they convert from a brutal dictatorial monarchy to a democratic republic with actual human rights for women. Or something like that. We could do all that, but we wont. The reason we wont is that we need Saudi Arabia to wage our (the US', the Wests') wars in the Middle East, and right now they've just lost their play in Syria, and the west is hoping that all those ISIS fighters they've deployed through Saudi Arabia that are leaving Syria will find a home in the desert in SA somewhere, instead of coming to us in the West. So right now, nobody wants to upset them, and so we get a nice show of the hypocrisy of our leaders, who speak of human rights only when convenient, while being friends with a psychopathic serial killer.