3 ms·
This completely misses the point. The problem is not "most searches". The problem is those banned ones and what is done with access to that search history. S
by mulmen 8y ago
This completely misses the point. The problem is not "most searches". The problem is those banned ones and what is done with access to that search history.
Search activity is linked to a phone number so it could be used in the social score. Do you think a message on the result page will help with that consequence?
Don't delude yourself into thinking Google is somehow making China a nicer place to live because it's easier to search for pictures of cats.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYou are thinking like an outsider and I’m thinking like an insider. It isn’t searching for cars, but things needed to get work done, so reaearch, etc..., which is all severely deficient on entertainment/medical scam focused Baidu. The use of Google would be a net positive to the productivity of anyone inside the GFW who needs to do something serious, not just “search for pictures of cats”, which by the way, could just turn up lots of porn on baidu. As for your search results on phone comment, I’ve run afoul of the GFW multiple times on my phone and never had the CIA (Chinese intelligence agency) at my door. They wouldn’t really have time for that, and if they want to target someone specifically, whether google is in China or not is irrelevant.
- mulmen 8y agoI still think you're missing the point here. Nobody disputes Google search results will be more useful than Baidu results. We all know Google is a good search engine. The point is that the benign "99%" of searches do not justify the huge negative consequences of the 1% of search censorship and association with identity and profiting from chilling of that speech. Also even framing the debate this way undermines the real ethical challenges of doing this. The major technical problem is that search results are associated with individuals (through phone number and maybe other indicators) which means they can be incorporated into social score or otherwise facilitate automated targeting of citizens. It does not require individual targeting because simply attempting to use Google to find out what "Human Rights" are could negatively impact your standing in China. You can justify the negative consequences by saying research may be a bit easier to perform but it won't help the people that are harmed directly by Google building this platform. This says nothing of Google directly contradicting their own guidelines for AI development and their stated mission of Do No Evil(tm). Insiders may benefit from thinking like outsiders from time to time. You are right about one thing, Google insiders will benefit from this product much more than outsiders.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYou still don’t get how censorship really works. Preventing access to information is the extent of it, you aren’t targeted by what you search for, you can search for Dalai Lama, human rights, or Winnie the Pooh without worrying about the police knocking on your door. Where you can get in trouble is by speaking out in public forums, but even here censorship is mostly automated (your post is rejected for using sensitive words) and/or wumaos attempt to lead the conversation away from disgruntlement. China is definitely not a police state, meaning they don’t have the resources to crack down on any dissent that isn’t notable. But here is the thing: is the harm of google not being in China more than the harm of being China? As someone who lived in China for 9 years, I say yes: there is simply lots of information (eg non scammy healthcare) that is not under censorship but useful and not easily found without google. You are condemning people to harm to satisfy your high standard of morality.
- mulmen 8y agoI admit to having a lot less experience in China than you do so I appreciate that perspective. Having said that this still sounds like a shaky justification of Google putting profits ahead of their own stated ethics.
- gaius 8y agothey don’t have the resources to crack down on any dissent that isn’t notable Engaging the services of a company specialising in doing things “at scale” would surely help with that.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThey would wind up imprisoning everyone, and no one in China wants to go back to the Maoist 70s. Again, China isn’t a 1984 police state, it is way too chaotic for that. It’s more like whack a mole.
- mulmen 8y agoDo you think Google can create an AI that plays Whack A Mole better than humans? How do you think the moles feel about that?