4 ms·
A few random thoughts: * Air presumably doesn't mean atmospheric air here, otherwise you're getting a random mix of gases and water vapour inside your nanoscal
by twic 8y ago
A few random thoughts:
* Air presumably doesn't mean atmospheric air here, otherwise you're getting a random mix of gases and water vapour inside your nanoscale wizardry - so will these be nitrogen-filled, like binoculars etc?
* What does this mean for cooling, especially in the high-density 3D architectures mentioned? Can you use air flow through the chip to cool it?
* "tungsten, gold, and platinum were evaluated as metals of choice" - compare their resistivities of 5.60e-8, 2.44e-8, and 1.06e-7 ohm-metres respectively to silicon's of 6.4e+2 [1] (i thought tungsten was much higher than that, TIL). Does this mean that chips would have less resistive heating? Is resistive heating a significant part of the TDP of a modern chip?
* "replacing silicon with metal means these ACT devices can be fabricated on any dielectric surface, provided the underlying substrate allows effective modulation of emission current from source to drain with a bottom-gate field" - is there is also a lattice-spacing constraint, where the substrate's spacing has to work with that of the conductor, as i believe there is with silicon chips?
* Is this basically the return of the thermionic valve after fifty years in the wilderness?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_resistivity_and_conductivity#Resistivity_and_conductivity_of_various_materials https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_resistivity_and_con...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jakobegger 8y ago> Does this mean that chips would have less resistive heating? No. The parts of the chip that conduct electricity to the active areas in current chips are already made from metal. Basic chips are made from layers of metal / oxide / semiconductor (MOS). Current flows through silicon only in small areas, and the way chips work is that you can "turn off" the high resistivity in those areas and make them conducting (by doping the material + applying electric currents & fields) In the presented work, an air gap is used for these "active areas" instead of a semiconductor. An air gap does have resistance, so there will be resistive heating just like in normal chips.
- daveFNbuck 8y ago> An air gap does have resistance, so there will be resistive heating just like in normal chips. They also mentioned putting these in a vacuum. Presumably that won't have as much resistance as an air gap.
- kenfox 8y agoA perfect vacuum is a perfect insulator. There are capacitors that use vacuum.
- 0db532a0 8y agoElectrons can still pass through perfect vacuums.
- arkades 8y agoI think that’s implied by his pointing out that capacitors use vacuum. A cap that doesn’t allow electron flow wouldn’t be a cap.
- Wehrdo 8y agoA capacitor shouldn't allow electron flow between its (dielectric separated) plates. The charges should build up on the plates, then exit through the terminals when discharging. If charges cross the dielectric, then you have leakage.
- arkades 8y agoHm. Apparently my Phys101-level understanding of electronics has caught up to me.
- ben_w 8y agoCaps don’t allow electrons through, do they? They resist DC, they only conduct AC?
- baybal2 8y agoThe device being described amounts to N type device as electrons are the majority carriers, and that's the problem. You can make electrons jump from emitter to collector over nanoscopic distances in "air," but how to you make a hole to do the same? With my level of understanding of physics, that's impossible. And without a P device, you can't make a CMOS pair. Thus, any logic family using it will eat tons of current. You can't use it for logic in a real world application, but if they can solve the endurance issue, that will be an enviable device for use in power gating. Active logic may also be of interest (it is still being used for ultra high frequency DACs in military radar tech)
- nine_k 8y agoHoles are virtual particles. They are spots with a missing electron. A hole "moves" when an electron moves in an opposite direction.
- twtw 8y agoTrue, but not really an answer to the question. Unlike semiconductor devices, there is only one "kind" of vacuum tube. A push-pull amplifier with vacuum tubes requires an anti phase generator before the high and low side drivers, while with both n- and p- type available you sorta get this for free.
- 0db532a0 8y agoDo you know why it makes sense to construct these devices on dielectric surfaces as opposed to other non-conductive surfaces?
- smaddox 8y agoAll non-conductive materials are dielectric to some degree. Strictly speaking, so are conductive materials.
- 0db532a0 8y agoDo they use the term dielectric to mean non-conductive — I’m aware that they’re not equivalent — or does the dielectric nature of the material have any relevance to the device? Maybe it’s relevant to the working of the gate?
- smaddox 8y agoIt's possible that the dielectric is indeed necessary to isolate the gate from the source/drain, but I can't say for sure.
- T-A 8y ago> Air presumably doesn't mean atmospheric air here, otherwise you're getting a random mix of gases and water vapour inside your nanoscale wizardry Doesn't matter, as explained in the second paragraph of the article: the air gap (35 nm) is shorter than the mean free path [1] in air, so the electrons are effectively moving in a vacuum. > Is this basically the return of the thermionic valve after fifty years in the wilderness? Yes. The paper's abstract starts out saying just that: "Scattering-free transport in vacuum tubes has always been superior to solid-state transistors. It is the advanced fabrication with mass production capability at low cost which drove solid-state nanoelectronics. Here, we combine the best of vacuum tubes with advanced nanofabrication technology." [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mean_free_path https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mean_free_path [2] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.nanolett.8b02849 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.nanolett.8b02849
- roywiggins 8y agoNanoscale vacuum tubes sounds like something out of steampunk/dieselpunk. I hope it happens for aesthetic considerations alone!
- ggm 8y agoAh yes.. the sweet sweet distortions of valve on my mp3 player!
- csours 8y agoEverything old is new again?
- ableal 8y agoTook a bit longer than usual, or maybe I'm not old enough to notice cycles longer than 30 years ...
- Retric 8y ago> so the electrons are effectively moving in a vacuum That’s true enough for a single cycle of a single transistor, not so much a billion of them doing a billion operations per second. Which is why they are calling this “vacuum-like.”
- kens 8y agoThe air doesn't matter. The article says that the 35nm gap between electrodes is less than the mean-free path of electrons in air. In other words, from the electron's perspective, it's the same as a vacuum since it doesn't (usually) encounter any air molecules when passing between the electrodes.
- marcosdumay 8y ago> What does this mean for cooling, especially in the high-density 3D architectures mentioned? Well, it's not even clear why they think it helps a 3D architecture. AFAIK, there is no mature layer deposition technique that allows gaps for the vacuum those transistors require, so I'd imagine it makes 3D harder. For cooling, keep in mind that at those scales air cooling is much less efficient than conductive cooling. > Does this mean that chips would have less resistive heating? Complementary logic (the "C" in C-MOS) sets the heat dissipation into a fixed amount per clock cycle, whatever resistance you have. When you hear about "lower resistance transistors", you should hear "higher frequency transistors". > is there is also a lattice-spacing constraint There is also a lattice-spacing constraint. Manufacture constraints don't change (they used a well known, very expensive, and hard to scale technique for their proof of concept), insulation constraints don't go away, and they replaced the charge carrier orbital constraints with a constraint on the length of the electrode separation.
- adrianratnapala 8y ago> Is this basically the return of the thermionic valve after fifty years in the wilderness? Yes, but with a twist of quantum. > The experimental data shows that influential operation mechanism is Fowler–Nordheim tunnelling in tungsten and gold devices, while Schottky emission in platinum device. The bad grammar makes this hard to understand; is FN-tunneling the influential mechanism or an influential mechanism? With the help of Wikipedia I can parse it as an explanation of how the electrons get out of the metal. When you apply an electric field, there can be a potential barrier: the electron must "climb" up out of the metal but can then "fall" down the externally applied field [1]. With Schottky emission, electrons jump the barrier using their thermal energy; increasing the field lowers the barrier, enhancing the emission. All this comes from the days of thermionic diodes. But as the field increases, the barrier also gets narrower. And when it is narrow enough, even low-energy electrons can get out via quantum tunnelling[2]. Apparently, this is called Fowler–Nordheim tunneling. Now these named effects both have equations attached to them, which predict the amount of electrons emitted under different circumstances. But real devices are complicated, and involve both of the above physical effects, plus others. So what researches have to deal with are measured curves that kind-a-sort-a fit the equations if you squint. The mangled sentence in the abstract makes me think that they have measured something (perhaps current vs.temperature curves) look a bit like the Schottky prediction in platinum, and a bit like the Fowler-Nordheim prediction in gold and tungsten. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schottky_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schottky_effect [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_tunnelling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_tunnelling
- btown 8y agoThe link in a sibling comment https://spectrum.ieee.org/semiconductors/devices/introducing-the-vacuum-transistor-a-device-made-of-nothing https://spectrum.ieee.org/semiconductors/devices/introducing... suggests that helium could be used, and that things could be designed such that "the electrons will never acquire enough energy to ionize helium."