3 ms·
> it's an extremely complex system about we have shockingly little information in the grand scheme of things (30 years' worth of satellite data!), You should s
by eesmith 8y ago
> it's an extremely complex system about we have shockingly little information in the grand scheme of things (30 years' worth of satellite data!),
You should stop making that argument as it's too much like a well-refuted talking point that climate change denialists use.
We have many different lines of evidence. “Global Warming in an Independent Record of the Past 130 Years“, for example, shows that the temperature changes are consistent across 173 different types of records, from measured temperatures to grape harvest to oxygen isotope ratios.
> "recent climate change is minute even by standards of the past two millennia"
How do you make this claim if you think we don't have good global temperature measurements more than a few decades old?
The only arguments I can easily find in support of this claim are by climate denialists who use one temperature series from Greenland. (There may be more, but that's the one that keeps popping up in my searches.)
While those who use a larger set of temperatures, to give a better sense of global temperature change, show that the recent temperature change is not "minute", like the one https://skepticalscience.com/medieval-warm-period.htm https://skepticalscience.com/medieval-warm-period.htm from Moberg et al. (2005) titled "Northern Hemisphere Temperature Reconstruction" for the last 2,000 years.
> Willis Eschenbach
And we should trust his work because .... why?
- quotemstr 8y agoThe commentator to whom you're replying isn't denying climate change. He's proposing that the insect die off is happening on too short a time scale to attribute it entirely to climate change. That you're attacking him as if he were a climate denier is an example of the sort of behavior that creates climate deniers.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoThe intellectual hostage taking you’re doing is a sad trend I have seen more and more of lately. “This horrible feminist said bad things and FORCED me to become a sexist” kind of thing. I don’t buy it. If one idiot on one side of a debate like that causes you to pick the opposite side, it’s because that’s the side you wanted to pick. There are plenty of idiots on either side to support whatever choice you want to make.
- eesmith 8y agoI was specially referring to the comments the g'parent poster made concerning climate, in a paragraph starting "As to climate". It happens that the statements made are not only incorrect, but aligned with common talking points which are predominantly made by climate change denialists. But you'll note that I carefully did not say that the poster was a CCD. I said the arguments were those used by CCD and which have been well-demonstrated to be invalid, so the poster needs to use better arguments to be convincing.
- campercoder 8y agoYes, but the rest of his posts proves he has a brain.
- eesmith 8y agoI can't figure out what you are trying to say. I think climate change denialists have a brain. I think people with a brain are perfectly capable of making bad arguments. I think that just because someone is knowledgeable and even an authority in some areas doesn't mean that knowledge or authority extends to other areas, nor even the ability to recognize the limits of one's knowledge.
- vixen99 8y agoTrust doesn't come into it. As Eschenbach puts it in his articles "My Other Request: If you believe that e.g. I’m using a method wrong or using the wrong dataset, please educate me and others by demonstrating the proper use of the method or the right dataset. Simply claiming I’m wrong about methods doesn’t advance the discussion unless you can point us to the right way to do it."
- eesmith 8y agoThat's not how it works. Climate denialists have a long history of cherry picking data, eg, picking trend lines which appear to indicate a decreasing or stable temperature, but done by picking an anomalously high temperature early on and low temperature later on. These are the sorts of trickery which require time to figure out. Since I don't have that expertise, nor do have the time to be an expert in all of the topics which affect me, I have to use some sort of trust mechanism. I presume cryptonector does as well. Why should I trust that Eschenbach isn't one of these sorts of cherry picking climate denalists? What I'm asking the g'parent is, why should I spend any time to research those points - especially since as I demonstrated some of the other points are invalid? I've dealt enough with Young Earth Creationists who make similar arguments (that is, stating they are open to the evidence, want to be told where they are wrong, etc) but, oddly, no matter what evidence is presented - and the evidence is overwhelming that the world was not created in the last 10,000 years - they still deny it. That's not to say that Eschenbach is in the same category! I bring it up to point out that the description you pointed to can be suspect. And I've DDG's enough to know that there is a wide spectrum of views about Eschenbach. https://www.skepticalscience.com/eschenbach-and-mcintyres-best-shot-at-surface-temp-record.html https://www.skepticalscience.com/eschenbach-and-mcintyres-be... is the most concrete I found in terms of identifying problems in his methods of analysis. So, what are cryptonector's reasons for trusting Eschenbach enough to bring it up on HN?
- Lkjhmnbv 8y agoYou should read a source before you go looking for other people tearing it down. It ultimately makes you incapable of forming conclusions yourself. Also expecting others to prove to you why you should trust them but offering no reason for anyone to trust you is bizarre.