5 ms·
The article says they're not just broadcasting in 8K, but 8K at 120 fps! How many displays are actually capable of not just displaying 120hz, but actually acce
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
The article says they're not just broadcasting in 8K, but 8K at 120 fps!
How many displays are actually capable of not just displaying 120hz, but actually accepting a 120 fps input (as opposed to just interpolating)?
- mrob 8y ago120fps is the real news here. Most people will see no difference between 4K and 8K, but 120fps is an immediately obvious improvement. People will probably attribute the sharper image to the higher spatial resolution, but it will really be the result of reduced sample-and-hold blur. I'd take 1080p120 over 8Kp60 any day.
- lbotos 8y ago> is an immediately obvious improvement. Technically, yes. I'm one of those weirdos who thinks movies aesthetically look better at 24 frames for the "dreamlike" quality. Racing/Action Sports, yes, please more frames.
- alex_duf 8y agoI'm with you, I remember watching the Hobbit at the theater, and being creeped out by how surreal all the movement were. I'm okay with playing video games at 60fps, but my brain keeps rejecting photorealistic content above 30fps
- Figs 8y agoAs someone who has watched a lot of Let's Plays, recordings of games done above 30 FPS kind of weird me out. I don't usually have an issue playing them myself, but if I watch a recording of someone else's session (which is interesting to me from a game design perspective -- where did they get stuck, what did they breeze through with no challenge, etc.), I get that same surreal "something's not quite right here" feeling as higher frame rate television.
- stordoff 8y agoHuh, I get the opposite (for games I've seen running at 60) - footage recorded at 30fps looks a little off to me.
- Paperweight 8y ago24 fps is an art medium with certain features and incentives. Its moving shots are automatically blurry, and the audience is used to that, so you can use them to, e.g., give the audience's attention a rest between two important still shots. Similarly, just because you can technically put the entire scene into focus all the time doesn't mean you necessarily want to!
- mrob 8y ago>Similarly, just because you can technically put the entire scene into focus all the time doesn't mean you necessarily want to! Sometimes you technically can't put the entire scene into focus. Even if you have unlimited lighting, there's only so far you can stop down the aperture before diffraction wipes out your depth-of-field improvement. Citizen Kane famously used composite shots to achieve extreme deep focus that would have been impossible as a single shot. I'd love to see another attempt at a photorealistic 100% CG movie like Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within. We'd be free from the limitations of real world optics, and could produce a "hyperrealistic" style even better than what you can see with the naked eye. I find shallow depth of field almost as annoying as low frame rate.
- ChrisSD 8y ago> I'd love to see another attempt at a photorealistic 100% CG movie Isn't that what Disney's Lion King remake is doing?
- mrob 8y agoI watched the trailer, and it has some impressive CG, but I think it's cheating to use animals. It's easier to spot flaws in CG human characters. I still count FF:TSW as the most ambitious CG animated movie ever made.
- aidenn0 8y agoI hadn't seen it since it was in the theater, so I just watched a trailer. The CG holds up surprisingly well (modulo the uncanny valley) considering it will be old enough to vote next year.
- tw04 8y agoAdd me to the list! I hate the way movies look at higher frame rates but the broad category of sports (traditional/e/motor/etc) all look much better.
- Chazprime 8y agoA movie at a frame rate higher than 24 looks strangely “cheap” to some of us. I believe it’s because on a subliminal level, the higher frame rate reminds us of a television broadcast.
- fred256 8y agoAlso known as the "soap opera effect": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_interpolation#Soap_opera_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_interpolation#Soap_oper...
- josteink 8y agoThis is definitely real. This was quite noticeable to a trained eye in the finale episode of David Lynch’s Twin Peaks returns season. As I was watching it, somewhere mid episode where the story moves between two realms of reality, I noticed the image suddenly had a much more real (or “cheap”) appearance. I was in awe. That was a super nice touch done a technical level which really helped elevate the story itself.
- jjeaff 8y agoThat's why some refer to it as the "soap opera effect". And although I remember 60fps being very noticeable at first, I don't think I notice at all any more.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoSame here, I was weirded out by it at first, but overtime got very used to it and it felt natural.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI expect that if good high frame rate content was more common, this effect would go away. It's a conditioned response, not an innate one. I also expect the effect to be lesser among younger people who are used to e.g. video games, although I have no actual evidence (anecdotal or otherwise) that this is the case.
- djsumdog 8y agoI hate 120Hz, especially TVs that try to add in the missing frames giving you the soap opera effect. Even The Hobbit films in HFR (and I think those were 60fps?) looked weird and unnatural. It was like being on the set where you could just tell how fake it was. I always disable motion smoothing on 120Hz TVs. I think high frame rates are really only good for video games and live sports. For fictional cinema/tv, it just looks weird and unnatural.
- jayflux 8y ago> I'm one of those weirdos who thinks movies aesthetically look better at 24 frames for the "dreamlike" quality. That’s not weird, that’s what the majority of people prefer. Otherwise they wouldn’t keep doing it. It would be more weird if you said you preferred films at 60fps
- ksec 8y ago>I'm one of those weirdos who thinks movies aesthetically look better at 24 frames for the "dreamlike" quality. Racing/Action Sports, yes, please more frames. No you are not Weirdos. Perfectly normal with great taste in Movies frame rate and Sports Action Frame rates.
- javagram 8y agoI notice they mentioned broadcast in 59,60,and 120 Hz. I’m wondering if the 120Hz is just frame-multiplied 24Hz video. Watching a 24Hz movie would certainly be a better experience at 120 fps than at 60, since there won’t be the experience of judder as 120 and 24 divide evenly. Regarding displays capable of accepting 120 Hz input, there are plenty of computer monitors that can do that at least.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> Regarding displays capable of accepting 120 Hz input, there are plenty of computer monitors that can do that at least. Yep, just not televisions! That's a big difference, since most people don't want to put monitors in their living rooms.
- joeblau 8y agoHow much bandwidth would you need to show that type of video? I feel like my broadband network couldn't even handle that.
- city41 8y agoI haven’t even bothered with a 4K tv yet because my internet couldn’t handle it. I think it will be a very long time before most Americans can get good 4K streaming, let alone 8k.
- ryacko 8y agoThe nitrate of 8k is high enough for them to only broadcast it via satellite. This is only going to be for sports bars.
- Symbiote 8y agoIt's fairly common to receive TV broadcast by satellite. About 10% of American households have a satellite dish, and about 20% of western European households. I think it's much higher in parts of Africa and western Asia, where there isn't the infrastructure for terrestrial broadcasts, or where satellite receivers get around state censorship. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satellite_television_by_region https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satellite_television_by_region
- jmc123 8y agohttp://www.jmcargoindia.com/ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/ Car transport in gurgaon@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/index.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/index.html Car transport in kanpur@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-kanpur.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-kanpur.html Car transport in gurgaon@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-gurgaon.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-gurgaon.html Car transport in ooty@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-ooty.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-ooty.html Car transport in navi mumbai@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-Navi-Mumbai.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-Navi-Mumbai.h... Car transport in mathura@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-Mathura.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-Mathura.html Car transport in delhi@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-bangalore.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-bangalore.htm... http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-delhi.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-delhi.html Car transport in noida@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-noida.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-noida.html Car transport in chennai@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-chennai.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-chennai.html Car transport in kolkata@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-kolkata.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-kolkata.html Car transport in mumbai@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-mumbai.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-mumbai.html Car transport in ahmedabad@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-ahmedabad.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-ahmedabad.htm... Car transport in trivendrum@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-trivendrum.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-trivendrum.ht... Car transport in cochin@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-cochin.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-cochin.html Car transport in jaipur@ http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-jaipur.html http://www.jmcargoindia.com/car-transportation-jaipur.html