9 ms·
They killed the Chevy Volt, the only interesting sedan in GM's entire line-up. Incredibly short-sighted. Love it more than any car I've ever driven, despite it
by cmrdporcupine 8y ago
They killed the Chevy Volt, the only interesting sedan in GM's entire line-up. Incredibly short-sighted. Love it more than any car I've ever driven, despite it lacking in many of the 'creature comforts' of other cars. Fun to drive with excellent acceleration, I drive it 91% electric, and when I flip over to gas it's an excellent performing highly efficient hybrid.
Sad.
EDIT: I should add that really the Volt is not a 'sedan', but a 'liftback'. Far more utility out of the trunk than a typical sedan. My medium sized dog even fits back there.
- lisper 8y agoEven sadder: the Bolt is the affordable electric car that the Tesla Model 3 promised to be but isn't. And yet no one is excited about the Bolt. In fact, probably most people are not even aware that the Bolt exists. Sad indeed.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoThey made odd choices on the body styling. It's a Chevy Trax but squished horizontally. And the naming sucks. The drivetrain is amazing. They also just don't seem to want to make enough of them or ship them to markets where people want them. Canada was starved for inventory all last last year. None went to Europe. Asia, where they'd make a lot of sense, got only a smattering. And they don't seem to be improving on this. The fate of the Volt and Bolt together makes me entirely skeptical of GM's claims to making a transition to EV production. I used to be a big advocate of GM's EV designs -- they're technically excellent -- but I don't think I can get behind the company at all. I'm somewhat tempted to sell my Volt and get a Honda Clarity PHEV.
- rconti 8y agoAh, the Honda Clarity, the only vehicle uglier than any hybrid or electric that Chevy or Toyota can muster. (I rather like the styling of the Bolt, actually)
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoYeah I'm not pro-Clarity. It's technically inferior to the Volt -- though it has more interior room. It's just that Honda isn't laying off almost 3000 people in the province of Ontario like GM is. I'm feeling a bit nationalist, maybe.
- peeters 8y agoI sometimes wonder if there's a requirement for making electric/hybrid cars "ugly". Like nobody will know you're driving an EV if they don't slap some bizarre styling on it! The new Prius models look like somebody took a spaceship from an 80's B-movie and decided to model a car from the concept. The Clarity looks as if they took an Accord but then punched it in the lip. And then they tried to make the back look like a Prius for who-knows-what reason. The Bolt and the Leaf look like they're just trying to scream "Don't take me on the highway!" at the top of their lungs. But then since that's basically true--they're made to be an efficient commuter car--the styling was probably never going to hide that. Even the Model 3 has a bizarre look to it, but I'm not sure if it's just because I'm used to expecting the hood to look a certain size which is simply not justifiable if you don't have to fill it up with a gas engine. Then you get the other end of the spectrum, where they try to retain the styling of the gas equivalent as much as possible, so you've got the Kona EV continuing to have a grill but it's actually closed and painted. It's probably somewhat lose lose. People are used to styling that makes sense for gas cars and so practical decisions for EVs lead to "abnormal" styling. As they become more popular we'll probably get used to them.
- dfxm12 8y agoI assume it's function (aerodynamics improving gas mileage) over form. I mean, when a car's selling point is its range, you should do what you can to maximize that within its class. I don't really find the Clarity or Prius or other EV's offensive looking. They look just as boring and uninspired as most other modern cars to me.
- dorfsmay 8y agoThe hybrid Camry looks exactly like the newer gas Camry from the outside.
- aeolis_mons 8y ago> They also just don't seem to want to make enough of them or ship them to markets where people want them. Canada was starved for inventory all last last year. None went to Europe. Asia, where they'd make a lot of sense, got only a smattering. And they don't seem to be improving on this. They lose several thousand dollars on each car, so the reluctance to expand production is perhaps unsurprising: https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1107604_gm-loses-9k-on-each-chevy-bolt-ev-to-become-major-player-in-electric-cars-report https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1107604_gm-loses-9k-on-...
- rblatz 8y agoDemand exceeds supply and they lose several thousand dollars on each of them? If only there was some sort of market driven mechanism to solve this issue.
- slededit 8y agoThey are willing to take the loss because they have fleet wide emissions targets. So they will sell just enough to allow them to sell the SUVs they actually want to make - but no more.
- r00fus 8y agoThat's the culprit. Fleet emissions targets should allow for credits to exceed targets so you'd get more points for over achievements.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoI've heard others (including GM) dispute those numbers. They were very back of the napkin. Yes, there's no way it's as profitable as a Silverado or Equinox. But the only really expensive part in them is the battery pack, and volume production of that could bring it down. GM _did_ sign a deal with LG Chem to open a big new battery plant in Michigan. Not sure what the status of that is. I believe battery supply is the fundamental constraint on Bolt production, not demand.
- clomond 8y ago> The fate of the Volt and Bolt together makes me entirely skeptical of GM's claims to making a transition to EV production Couldn't agree more. To add - my parents were in the market for electric cars and were evaluating the Bolt as a serious option. GM turned them away, including refusing to take a reservation and said "check again in 6 months when the new model year comes out". Seems like the production was very intentionally capped, and there was little effort to retain their business.
- burfog 8y agoThe cars probably lose money by themselves, only being profitable when looking at the big picture. (due to CAFE and similar) They are costly to make and typical car buyers are uninterested. The cars exist because various governments have made electric/hybrid/whatever quotas that need to be met. The minimum required number will be sold. In some jurisdictions that number is zero. Each one of these cars is sold at a loss, until you consider that the manufacturer is able to avoid fines or being entirely banned from selling vehicles.
- jandrese 8y agoOr GM just hates electric cars. Look at what they did with the EV-1, a vehicle they were apparently only making under duress. They had an exit plan in place from day 1, and it did not involve people commuting in electric cars.
- dade_ 8y agoWhen I bought my Volt, I found myself explaining the car to the sales guy. GM/chev did no training of sales and the dealers get far less maintenance revenue.
- ip26 8y agoThey also just don't seem to want to make enough of them or ship them to markets where people want them. The fate of the Volt and Bolt together makes me entirely skeptical of GM's claims to making a transition to EV production Supposedly, the shutdowns are expressly so that GM can devote more capital to the Bolt & it's future brethren. If they have Bolt supply problems, cutting production lines to free up capital sounds like a good move. Personally I am excited about plug-in hybrids, but allegedly a lot of the industry is starting to think PIH's will be but a flash in the pan, being totally eclipsed by all-electric by 2025.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoThe Bolt is in the "awkward middle" compared to the Leaf & the 3. We test drove all 3 and quickly dismissed the Bolt: we'd either buy the cheap car or the best car.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoWell sure, but Nissan took shortcuts that I don't think people should live with. Specifically, I am not cool with the lack of battery temperature management in the Leaf. It's basically 'designed' with battery degradation an inevitable outcome for anybody who doesn't live in a mild climate with no serious winters or hot summers. (In other words it's made for California and western Europe.)
- Brakenshire 8y agoThey’re changing that this year by the way. Nissan sold its in house battery supplier which lacked thermal management.
- varjag 8y agoThere is battery temperature management in Leaf with winter package.
- outworlder 8y agoNo, he's talking about battery cooling, not heating. Cold may make the car not start at all, but the battery should be otherwise unaffected (given adequate protection from the management system, which I think it has). Heat will destroy the battery. This is why on the previous generation Leaf the battery temperature gauge was so prominent (I haven't seen the latest one).
- varjag 8y agoHe's talking about "serious winters" as well. From the 2011 keynote: > .. the package—which includes heated seats, a duct to direct warmth to the back seat, temperature management for the battery pack
- pow_pp_-1_v 8y agoSeems like GM just doesn't care about the Bolt. They are not available at all places and they do very little marketing for the Bolt. And finally, I guess it's for cutting costs, the insides of the car seems too "plastic-y".
- geerlingguy 8y agoYeah, no way I could even buy one outside of California for the first year or so, and there are none available for a test drive anywhere near me. I don't think GM wants people to like the Bolt, just like they kind of shuffled away their previous EV platform. Not sure why, though—it seems like a pretty nice car, and the few people I know who bought one really like it. It doesn't have the fandom of the Tesla Model 3, but it's a good little car if you want an EV.
- mikeash 8y agoThe Model 3 is a bit more expensive but not hugely so, and it’s waaaayyyy better. A lot of Model 3 buyers (myself included) are aware of the Bolt and just don’t see it as competitive.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoI don't know about US pricing generally -- but up here it's like a $20k CAD gap. They are not in the same bracket at all. Once subsidies are applied the Bolt and Volt are in the mid-tier middle-class buyer category competing with things like the VW Jetta or Honda Accord, etc. The Model 3 is a luxury car, in the same price range as an Audi A4 or A5, BMW 5 series, Mercedes, etc.
- mikeash 8y agoIn the US, the Bolt starts at $37,495 and the Model 3 currently starts at $47,200. (You may be slightly behind the times, the $47,200 version just became available in October.) The base Bolt is missing various things I'd consider to be fairly essential that are included in the $46,000 Model 3, such as forward collision warning/avoidance and fast charging, so the Bolt's base price is a bit deceptive.
- JackC 8y agoThat might be sticker price, but I'm seeing the Bolt in Massachusetts for more like $32,000 before subsidies with the upgrades you mention: https://drivegreen.greenenergyconsumers.org/form_cars.php https://drivegreen.greenenergyconsumers.org/form_cars.php So after subsidies prices end up at something like $22,000 vs. $37,000 -- it's a real gap.
- mikeash 8y agoInteresting, looks similar here in the DC area, if cars.com is to be believed. Goes to show how much worse (or, at least, less appealing) the Bolt is, if it’s being so heavily discounted and is still barely selling.
- Shivetya 8y agothe next affordable EV to come to market with be the Kona. While not a sedan independent testers are already seeing 5miles per kwh which is incredible and its price points are very good. the issue is availability, in the US it is expected to be a CARB state car only for awhile. When I decided to move from my 2017 Volt to a pure EV I really wanted a sedan which led me to the TM3 I did buy but I did try to give the Bolt a chance but simply put, the killer app of the TM3 is the super charging network. That and i have found the spartan dash has made me rethink the need for dozens of buttons most cars have. Recent Kona review https://youtu.be/LATZ0g-Sz2s https://youtu.be/LATZ0g-Sz2s
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoI question whether the Kona will become universally available. Last time I looked into this it sounded like Kia and Hyundai really have no intention of bringing their next lines of EVs out to anywhere but CARB and incentive states. And since Ontario recently dropped off that list (because of the mini-Trump up here), I doubt we'll ever see it sold here.
- pitaj 8y agoIf only it had AWD. That's the deal-breaker for me. Too much snow around here to not have that feature.
- sveme 8y agoOut of curiosity: do you use winter tires, is that a thing in the US?
- pitaj 8y agoI use all-weather tires, which essentially behave the same as winter tires, but don't require a tire change for different seasons. You can, of course, buy winter tires here. However, AWD / 4WD address different problems than winter tires do. As I understand it, winter tires are useful for traction on ice or packed snow, but won't help significantly in unpacked snow, where 4WD helps immensely. Around here, it's hilly and there are many streets which won't get plowed immediately. This makes 4WD pretty vital for getting around sometimes. Plus, 4WD helps with vehicle control at speed in slick conditions.
- jseliger 8y agoThe Bolt still starts at $36,620, according to chevy.com/bolt. It's an amazing car in some ways but doesn't look very good. It's hard to imagine many people choosing it over a Tesla Model 3. Yes, right now you can't get the less-expensive Teslas, but eventually you will be able to. If GM started the Bolt at $25K and offered nicely equipped ones for $28 or $29K, there would be an interesting competition against Tesla. But they don't. BTW, like some other posts, I think the Volt is a brilliant car: https://jakeseliger.com/2018/11/29/steve-levines-the-powerhouse-and-the-chevy-volt/ https://jakeseliger.com/2018/11/29/steve-levines-the-powerho... and it's unfortunate that it's not proven popular too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cmrdporcupine 8y ago> Yes, right now you can't get the less-expensive Teslas, but eventually you will be able to. They seem to be in no rush to make it, but seem to be living with the PR that it somehow exists already. That people can make a statement like "why get a Bolt when I can get a M3 for around the same price" is beyond belief to me, considering there is no available configuration of the Model 3 that is anywhere close to $36k. The M3 is a luxury class vehicle in all actually-existing configurations. The Bolt is available at the price you state _now_. It's just GM seems entirely unwilling to market and sell it in volume.
- scythe 8y agoDoes GM actually make a profit on the Bolt? Or is it a sort of foot-in-the-door car meant to increase mindshare? I ran a search and found this: https://www.inverse.com/article/32239-why-gm-loses-money-chevy-bolt https://www.inverse.com/article/32239-why-gm-loses-money-che... It makes sense that a huge car company would be able to take a loss on an electric vehicle that they don't advertise much but which, by slowly accumulating in the market, convinces people that "GM can build affordable and good electric cars" so that when they do actually market a car they make money on, people will be less skeptical. However, according to this hypothesis, GM doesn't have a serious technical advantage over Tesla - they just have a fatter stack of cash. But sometimes that's enough.
- bduerst 8y agoThat's because Chevy, knowing they have the only Model 3 substitute product, is charging ridiculous prices for what the Bolt really is.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoThey're charging the cost of the battery pack + drivetrain. Battery supplies are constrained worldwide. Only Tesla and LG Chem have significant production. Even Nissan is switching to LG Chem.
- cbm-vic-20 8y agoThe Bolt EV is a really nice car; sure, not as nice and definitely without the cachet of the Tesla, but also much less expensive. My SO recently purchased a Bolt and has been very pleased with it- she specifically wanted a hatchback, so it was a perfect fit. The range is pretty great, "range anxiety" no longer affects her. If you've not been coddled with the "luxury car" interiors, you'll find the Bolt's interior to be perfectly fine. It's not Audi/BMW/Benz/Tesla level, but IMO it's not as "plasticky" as other commenters have mentioned: it's not the 90s Malibu crap that GM pumped out back then. The screen is nice and big (not Tesla-big), and integrates just fine with Apple and Android Auto. For 90% of the trips made by 90% of the people in the US, the Bolt is a perfectly fine car.
- ams6110 8y agoThe Bolt is still $30,000 after tax credits. That's not what most people would call "affordable." It's a car I'd consider, with some reservations, but not at that price.
- joshlemer 8y ago>the Bolt is the affordable electric car that the Tesla Model 3 promised to be but isn't It has an MSRP starting from $44,000 Canadian Dollars. This is affordable?
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoLast I looked the Model 3 comes in at north of $60k CAD for all available configurations at this point. The USD $35k model doesn't exist yet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CydeWeys 8y agoIt does seem amazingly short-sighted. EVs are the future and yet here they are scaling back on them. It's like the other manufacturers are rushing to cede the entire market to Tesla.
- sf_rob 8y agoI love my Volt, even having had a Model 3 reservation and done a test drive. I'm not saying it's a better car in any objective sense, but its compromises are areas I'm fine with. Honestly, I can't believe the Volt wasn't more popular. It's probably being due to not educating consumers enough about it, being strange looking, and being a GM.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoYep, just imagine if Toyota had launched the Volt instead of the Prius. Or VW had made a Jetta-class vehicle with the Volt's drivetrain. Assuming they could get the battery supplies, it would have sold like bonkers. In many ways the Volt is too good to be true, and I think that makes buyers skeptical. Biggest fault is insufficient cabin space.
- greglindahl 8y agoToyota has a plug-in Prius now, the Prius Prime. It isn't selling that well. Kinda like the Volt.
- ansible 8y agoI kind of wanted to get one at the end of 2017 because of the tax credits. However, even with that, the price was higher than I wanted to spend on a vehicle. The reduced cargo space was a slight concern too.
- bsder 8y agoThat's because the Prius Prime is lousy. It has less oomph than the standard Prius and is noisy as all get out. Having just test driven a whole bunch of these cars and just bought a Volt in 2018, I can tell you: 1) The Volt has really good power 2) The Volt is really quiet 3) The Volt has really good range Nothing else even came close at the same price point.
- rsync 8y ago"They killed the Chevy Volt, the only interesting sedan in GM's entire line-up." I saw that as great news: moving beyond the hybrid stop-gap towards real electric cars. The Bolt is still for sale and I hope that the platform and their technology move into other GM vehicles. FWIW, in 30 minutes I will be at the local chevy dealer purchasing a Bolt.
- burk96 8y agoHey you must be purchasing a Bolt right now, so congrats! I understand your reasoning for seeing the removal of the hybrid as a good thing, but I can't agree with that. I would much rather see hybrids stay around and see gas vehicles phased out. Gas vehicles and hybrids still have the huge advantage of distribution over electric. It doesn't matter where I am in the US, I know that a gas station will be a common site in pretty much all towns or major roadways. If I need to drive 150 miles in one direction for something and then come back the same day (not uncommon where I live), I don't want to do that in an electric vehicle! The volt is so appealing because I know it could do that using so much less gas than the average gas vehicle. And for those days I don't leave town, it would be in practice an electric vehicle.
- outworlder 8y ago> If I need to drive 150 miles in one direction for something and then come back the same day (not uncommon where I live), I don't want to do that in an electric vehicle! Why not? One way of your leg should be well within the capabilities of any modern EV(the full trip is even achievable by some). Are you going to go 150 miles and immediately return? > And for those days I don't leave town, it would be in practice an electric vehicle. The beauty of the Volt is: you are in an EV all the time. The drivetrain is all electric and it doesn't care where the electricity comes from.
- ams6110 8y agoI did that last weekend as a matter of fact. Drove about 160 miles to pick something up, was there for maybe 20 minutes, then drove home. Because I needed that thing that day. Couldn't even wait for overnight delivery. That's a little extreme, but it's not at all uncommon for me to make the same drive with a half a day or so before I come back. But in general it's too hard to find a place to charge an electric vehicle away from home to really count on it.
- whalesalad 8y agoKeeping the Bolt though.
- s0rce 8y agoHorrible blind spot though.
- sf_rob 8y agoA pillar yes, C pillar is bad but doesn't bother me because the reverse camera is fantastic (for a mid priced sedan). My only complaint is that there aren't turn signal cameras for lane changes.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoAgree it's crap, but I've gotten used to it. Every car has its quirks. But not having to pay for gas is a bonus I can't ignore.