11 ms·
> The American skies have gone from an open market with many competing airlines to a cozy oligopoly with four major airlines. It is clear why we have reached t
by ekianjo 8y ago
> The American skies have gone from an open market with many competing airlines to a cozy oligopoly with four major airlines.
It is clear why we have reached this point. Most monopolies are allowed to exist because of state influence (which happens thru many forms, regulation, patents, or plain direct support), all increasing the barrier to entry for would-be competitors. You see this in most heavily regulated markets.
There are other markets where the cost of entry is so high anyway (investment-wise) that naturally very few companies can make it - this is something that is not an issue per se.
- pdonis 8y agoWith regard to airlines, I think there's another factor in play: the core business of airlines is not selling tickets to individuals and families, it's selling tickets to businesses for work-related travel. The government and most large corporations negotiate contract fares with the airlines, and large airlines have an obvious advantage in doing this.
- jryan49 8y agoWhich markets that have huge monopolies do not have high costs of entry or capital costs?
- maxxxxx 8y agoTech would be an example. Instagram was only a dozen or so people when FB bought them. Unfortunately FB was able to do so and kill competition that way.
- nanny 8y ago>You see this in most heavily regulated markets. Except airlines were heavily deregulated in 1978. In my mind it's also "clear why we have reached this point", except that I've come to the opposite conclusion that you have.
- pdonis 8y ago> airlines were heavily deregulated in 1978. With regard to the routes they could fly and the prices they could charge, yes. But they were never de-regulated with regard to the safety requirements they had to meet or the qualifications their pilots and crew and maintenance workers have to have. Those regulations have, if anything, gotten more stringent over time. And those regulations pose a huge barrier to entry for new competitors, and favor large airlines over small ones because a large airline can more easily absorb the costs of compliance.
- thatfrenchguy 8y agoYes but none of us want to die.
- pdonis 8y agoThat's true. I'm not saying the safety regulations are a bad idea. I'm just saying that they have the side effect of giving the advantage to large airlines and posing a barrier to entry for new competitors. (And that, since they are indeed regulations and have gotten more stringent over time, it is a mistake to think of the airline industry as being "deregulated" in the sense of the term "regulation" that is being used in this discussion.)
- conanbatt 8y agoDepends on the price.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Yes but none of us want to die. This is the problematic false dichotomy. If you give someone a choice between "this specific set of onerous, expensive, competition-destroying regulations" or "you will be killed", they make the obvious choice. But those aren't the only options. Existing regulations are poorly optimized. It would be possible to save the same number of lives -- more lives -- by doing more work to improve the benefit:burden ratio of regulations. The problem is that people aren't interested in this. It's detail-oriented work that doesn't make for good sound bites, so the beneficiaries (the general public) aren't organized enough to know how to ask for it, and the organized incumbents don't want it because it would result in a larger number of viable competitors. And it's too easy for incumbents to make the sound bites go the other way, by pretending that not spending a billion dollars to save one life is irresponsible, even though the same billion dollars could save more than a thousand lives if saved here and used beneficially somewhere else.
- Ar-Curunir 8y agoYes, the problem with modern capitalism is that companies face too much regulation...
- int_19h 8y agoThat you don't need state influence for cartels to form, but they rather do it naturally, has been known for a very long time. "People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices."
- igravious 8y ago> It is clear why we have reached this point. Most monopolies are allowed to exist because of state influence (which happens thru many forms, regulation, patents, or plain direct support), all increasing the barrier to entry for would-be competitors. You see this in most heavily regulated markets. If I may disagree. Capitalism is great at allocating capital unless prevented from doing so. We collectively have come to agree that human labour can be purchased, but not humans themselves. Some things may be held publicly, some privately. Zero regulation is good because in the absence of hindrances people can do what they want but some of those choices hurt other people so regulations are introduced. Why is it virtually impermissible to point out that everything else notwithstanding certain patterns keep recurring to individual markets in particular and the economy as a whole. The first is this. In the absence of regulation in mature markets companies will form cartels/trusts/oligopolies. It is so universal it is akin to a natural law. Failure to act on that hurts the economy in general. We used to be good at recognising this, we aren't so good any more. The second is this. People want greater returns over lesser returns. This leads to ever greater financialisation and capital chasing its own tail unless prevented from doing so. It will inevitably lead to super dodgy things like stock buy-backs (which in any healthy market ought to be virtually banned). FTA: “The results were so good that in 2016 United’s board approved a stock buyback of $2 billion, which is the financial equivalent of spraying yourself with champagne.” That's terrible. There is a direct correlation between ballooning exec salaries, corporate stock buy-backs and stagnating workers' compensation. > There are other markets where the cost of entry is so high anyway (investment-wise) that naturally very few companies can make it - this is something that is not an issue per se. An incorrect analysis of what ails the economy will over time have dire consequences. It may be hard to see it if you're doing okay but lots of people are not doing okay. There's political anger. Populists will blame outsiders like immigrants (don't get me wrong, I'm for strict immigration policies – but that's the incorrect cause and effect diagnosis – but blaming immigrants (illegal or otherwise) is scapegoating). I have practically stopped reading HackerNews because too many on here appear to be too financially secure owing to the industry they are in, their backgrounds, luck, and hard work. Someone just died in Paris over protests over fuel price hikes. If those entrusted to keep the system healthy fail to do so in a controlled orderly manner then the people will introduce disorder by forceful means. I am not advocating this. I am against this. But the chances of this not happening are rapidly shrinking. I hope I'm wrong but all the macro indicators and with history as my guide tells me that I am not. edit: typos and such
- nradov 8y agoWe never really had an open market with many competing airlines. Only a few large airlines ever had full nationwide route networks covering all the major hubs and spokes. The smaller carriers might have helped hold prices down on a few less popular routes, but overall I think travelers are generally better off with four airlines that fly pretty much everywhere.
- ASalazarMX 8y agoCounterpoint: most people choose the cheaper option, which encourages a race to the bottom, and oligopolies can outlast smaller competition. Once the oligopoly has won, it starts to dictate the rules. We should make informed choices, but who has the time and energy to dig and evaluate the market share and long-term consequences of the fridge they're going to buy?