3 ms·
To be honest, I'm not sure how teachers get and keep their jobs, but as students are graded on their studying skills, I feel like teachers should be graded ever
by joe_the_user 8y ago
To be honest, I'm not sure how teachers get and keep their jobs, but as students are graded on their studying skills, I feel like teachers should be graded every fews years on their teaching skills.
Well, to be honest, I really wish everyone who wants to one more hurdle in front of teachers should understand the correlation between bad teaching and teachers having a low-paid, unrewarding and effectively abusive job.
Lousy teachers keep their job because no one highly competent wants these jobs. Lousy teachers keep their job because a huge array of bureaucratic song-and-dance exists and people good at that can be bad at teaching.
I'm sorry you had that experience but you might consider looking at the system. Corporate customer support is terrible, let's all call for more test-of-competence for these low paid flunkies too. That will address the problem.
- lliamander 8y agoTrue - stricter performance evaluations aren't going to solve problems caused by a poor hiring pool.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoPoor hiring pool and work mistreatment, that actively prevents teachers from teaching well, while simultaneously piling lots of bullshit work on them.
- dorchadas 8y agoHey, this sounds like exactly why I'm working on moving out of (secondary) teaching. I didn't mind the pay, being single on a low CoL area and the benefits were good... But the bullshit is killing me, as is the lack of respect from parents in a highly anti-intellectual county (I never realized how bad it was until I returned as a teacher) who demand that Little Johnny pass when he just wants to play Fortnite all class period and never turn in work.
- eagsalazar2 8y agoThere is something to what you are saying but it is also true that many many aspiring teachers wash out because they can't even get their first job after getting their teaching degree. It _is_ a competitive market in many places but the market _isn't_ functioning as it should because of dysfunctional relationships with unions and tenure.
- joe_the_user 8y agoIt _is_ a competitive market in many places but the market _isn't_ functioning as it should because of dysfunctional relationships with unions and tenure. Unions? Really? Not administrators and profit institutions cutting college teachers' salaries to the bone, creating a situation adjunct professors literally starve to death in the process. No, unions. And tenure is your other complaint? The job guarantee that no longer applies to most college teachers today. Why not complain that the average teach still is able to sleep at night and has roof over their head? Okay then. Unions have their flaws but it was that way well before the current disastrous regime. And sure, teaching is competitive market because even with all the horrors, lots of people want to teach because it's something to believe in, in this horrible and the bureaucracy, that unions are at best a junior partner in, do make it hard.
- briandear 8y agoAre you talking universities or K12? Because everything the parent said is true in K12. Spend 10 minutes at a Jersey City School Board meeting and you’ll see just how aggressive the union is if you even hint at reform. Can’t speak to higher ed though, except tenure for classroom instructors is a real problem. Since they have absolutely zero incentive to be good teachers but instead only engaging in activities that bring in research money for their area of interest.
- joe_the_user 8y agoThe OP is about college teaching and what I've written is applicable to that. Folks seem to have segued to K12 for some anti-union speechifying in the meantime. As far as that goes, look at the condition of teachers in Kentucky if you think unions are the problem. Unions have a fairly inflexible response to most "reform" plans but the problem is most reform plans, as can be seen here, aim to make teacher more insecure, more constrained, more "flexible" but without compensation for that flexibility. Sure, LA, Oakland or New Jersey might look bad but compared to strongholds of non-union teaching, they are paradise. It would be great to come up with a reform plan that empowered teachers. The unions might fight that but individual teachers probably wouldn't. But the kinds of reform that come often from people lips - more testing and less job security, are rightly resisted by both unions and individual teachers.