3 ms·
I like the way the news media tries to point at just one party to blame for any incident, and argues about which party should be to blame, when, like any incide
by londons_explore 8y ago
I like the way the news media tries to point at just one party to blame for any incident, and argues about which party should be to blame, when, like any incident, it was probably caused by tens of coinciding factors, and 'blame' really ought to be apportioned to all parties involved.
- amelius 8y agoFrom the article: > The findings by the National Transport Safety Committee (KNKT) suggest that Lion Air put the plane back into service despite it having had problems on earlier flights. Seems this implies there are at least two parties involved: airline and aircraft manufacturer.
- davidhyde 8y agoLet's also not forget the pilot. They are supposed to read the manual so they can respond to a badly behaving auto pilot / guidance system. There is always a pilot override. I guess you can bundle that in to airline blame though (lack of training or bad org structure). But really, this is a new plane and Boeing probably don't have adequate software testing in place for the newly written / ported software.
- qarioz 8y agoNo, you need certification to be able to fly eact plane type, which equal to 6 months retraining. For this incident Boeing "forgot" to tell companies do not do what you usually do, as it doing what you do actually worsen the situation. Boeing released emergency notice after that incident, and data from black box showed that the pilot is doing precisely what they are used to do. Plane it self is legal to fly at that time.
- thesimon 8y agoBut isn't moving "STAB TRIM" to CUT OUT a memory item even in the 737 NG in the case of a trim runaway?
- mnw21cam 8y agoYes. The newfangled plane had a new way for trim runaway to occur, but the action to take in the event of trim runaway shouldn't be (AFAICT) any different. They managed it on the previous flight.
- karmakaze 8y ago> do not do what you usually do, as it [...] worsen the situation This sounds like the worst UI evolution. Could they not have come up with something that's more natural? I don't know anything about controls and procedures for commercial aircraft, but it is so complex that nothing is natural? Like listening to Formula1 team radio where the engineer tells the driver to set some cryptic mode in the steering wheel menu. I wonder how much of a competitive advantage it would be to make easier/safer to fly commercial aircraft. It would be sad to hear that these are the results of great effort of that goal.
- _archon_ 8y agoThe FAA issued a mandatory airworthiness directive as a result of this crash. Boeing didn't include training for a new anti-stall automation regime in their type cert update class for existing 737-rated pilots moving to the 737 MAX. There was apparently a malfunctioning angle of attack sensor, which caused a software data conflict which caused the anti-stall assist (which the pilot wouldn't have known existed) to repeatedly trim the aircraft nose-down. There is also the possibility that a separate pilot assist system read a possible near-stall and enforced difficulty in pulling back on the stick (to prevent what it saw as a potential stall). So the pilot couldn't pull out of the dive that the MCAS (trim changer) had caused. The blame for this incident does not lie on the pilots failing to RTFM. Boeing changed several systems without telling anyone. Now the plane's been type rated, so software changes to fix it are significantly difficult. Imagine Boeing as a guy saying "Screw those idiots who operate our multimillion dollar safety-critical product; they're too stupid to know how to work it!" This is a closer perspective to the truth than the parent's comment. Mentour pilot overview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfQW0upkVus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfQW0upkVus FAA Emergency Airworthiness Directive: http://rgl.faa.gov/Regulatory_and_Guidance_Library/rgad.nsf/0/83ec7f95f3e5bfbd8625833e0070a070/%24FILE/2018-23-51_Emergency.pdf http://rgl.faa.gov/Regulatory_and_Guidance_Library/rgad.nsf/...
- linuxftw 8y ago> Boeing didn't include training for a new anti-stall automation regime in their type cert update class for existing 737-rated pilots moving to the 737 MAX. There was apparently a malfunctioning angle of attack sensor, which caused a software data conflict which caused the anti-stall assist (which the pilot wouldn't have known existed) to repeatedly trim the aircraft nose-down. If this is accurate, it's beyond criminal. If they're putting pilots in planes with automated systems without any knowledge of those systems, let alone how to operate/override them, someone needs to be behind bars and is responsible for the deaths of those people.
- azeotropic 8y agoNot necessarily. Lion Air could be responsible for the problems on earlier flights too (through poor pilot training or maintenance procedures).
- cm2187 8y agoBut did these problems caused the crash?
- jobigoud 8y agoYes they did. The previous pilot figured out a workaround in time, not this one.
- mannykannot 8y agoThis is not the news media trying to point at just one party, it is the reporting of Boeing doing so in order to deflect the criticism that has been directed towards it. US pilot's unions are divided over whether they think Boeing made a serious error in not disclosing the existence of the new system in question, but the fact that many pilots apparently think it was an error counts for something - in addition to actually flying aircraft, professional pilots are our safety watchdogs.