4 ms·
The FBI of the National Park Service
- notJim 8y agoI had to get my car towed while out hiking a few months back. As I was chit-chatting with the tow truck driver, we got on the subject of work. I thought he was joking when he told me his time working as a park ranger was the most stressful period of his life. This was after him telling me that being a tow truck driver meant being woken up in the early morning hours to go on a multi-hour driver multiple times per week, especially when the conditions were bad. It turned out he'd been a park ranger at a state park in a rougher, rural part of the state. He told me me that large groups of teenagers would hang out in the park in the summer. They'd get drunk and start these massive brawls with each other out in the woods, and my tow truck driver would be the only person around to respond, often in the early hours of the morning. Budget cuts meant he was the only one of course, and local police weren't going to bother driving way out to the park. He seemed like a genuinely compassionate person, but he said a lot of the time, he'd just have to let the fights happen because he was so outnumbered he couldn't break them up. He told me he only lasted a few months.
- r00fus 8y agoA classic case of defunding the public good. Another related problem was the change in policy to allow guns in public parks - a very perverse interpretation of the 2nd amendment that just made park rangers' life more dangerous without any real benefit to 99% of the population.
- nerdponx 8y agoJust look at how useless the park ranger are! We should just the whole program.
- tonyztan 8y agoI think the right to self defense is especially important in places where law enforcement cannot respond quickly and effectively. Whereas the police can respond in minutes in a densely populated city, the same cannot be said in the middle of a rural park. A person should be allowed to defend themself, with a firearm if necessary, when faced with a deadly threat. The policy you mentioned only allows people to carry a firearm if they are otherwise allowed to carry a gun in public according to state law. This means they cannot be a convicted felon or otherwise disqualified, and in most states they are also required to have a concealed carry permit: https://www.nps.gov/articles/firearms-in-national-parks.htm https://www.nps.gov/articles/firearms-in-national-parks.htm
- rb666 8y agoThis is such a nonsensical (mostly American) argument that 99% of the rest of the planet is unable to follow. Why should you need a gun for self-defense? If your "opponent" also brings a gun (or a knife), sure you may have a chance. But if they bring an RPG, should you also be allowed to bring your RPG to the park? The only way to get out of this arms race is to get rid of your toys. You know, like it's done in the civilized world...
- cdoxsey 8y agoA gun is more effective and practical than a knife or an RPG. It is easy to use, relatively safe and reliable, affordable and easy to carry. In a very rural area not every threat is a person, for example a bear, and guns aren't exactly exotic technology. They've been around for hundreds of years. Trying to put the cat back in the bag is hopeless. In particular in the US there are more guns than people. Attempting to confiscate all those guns would inevitably fail and likely lead to massive civil unrest. It would also fail to prevent criminals from still having access to guns. Perhaps an arms-race is unfortunate but unilateral disarmament on one side is not a practical solution to the problem. FWIW the US is not the only country where citizens are allowed to have guns. Look at Switzerland for an example.
- sjwright 8y agoOnly someone who didn’t understand Swiss gun culture would make that comparison.
- cdoxsey 8y agoCitizens in Switzerland are permitted to own guns: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_Switzerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_Switzerland
- sjwright 8y agoYes, permitted. You need a license, which is something that can be denied for a multitude of common reasons. Gun ownership in Switzerland is taken seriously and very heavily regulated. And the same goes for bullet ownership. Read your wikipedia link; it reads nothing like what anyone in the USA would recognise. Relative to the USA status quo, Swiss gun laws are like a far left socialist wet dream. No electable left-wing politician would ever imagine being able to get one tenth of Swiss-style laws passed in the USA.
- sneak 8y agoPeople who would shoot at park rangers would not be deterred by such a prohibition, so the change does not make them any less safe. It does, however, make normal park-goers a lot safer.
- dfsegoat 8y agoAre you serious? Have you spent any time ON YOUR OWN in a place like Rocky Mountain National Park, in Colorado? For one, there is the wildlife factor: Bears and moose are dangerous. Secondly, National forests are a very important component of public lands for hunting: I for one find it awesome that I can stock 1 year worth of organic, grass-fed meat from legally harvesting an Elk on state or national forest land [1]. Finally, hunters - with our firearms and ammunition purchases - actually supply the bulk of $$$ that go towards maintaining public lands and wildlife [2]. You are welcome! 1 - https://www.fs.fed.us/visit/know-before-you-go/hunting https://www.fs.fed.us/visit/know-before-you-go/hunting 2 - https://www.npr.org/2018/03/20/593001800/decline-in-hunters-threatens-how-u-s-pays-for-conservation https://www.npr.org/2018/03/20/593001800/decline-in-hunters-...
- razster 8y agoSame issue with California's Whiskey town. We have a lot of portable meth labs roaming the woods and trails, and only 2 rangers patrolling a huge swatch of land. They do not last long.
- runjake 8y agoIn a similar vein, NASA has its own SWAT/special operations groups, such as: https://www.nasa.gov/returntoflight/main/swat_feature.html https://www.nasa.gov/returntoflight/main/swat_feature.html https://www.wearethemighty.com/news/nasa-has-a-swat-team-and-theyre-good https://www.wearethemighty.com/news/nasa-has-a-swat-team-and...
- tomohawk 8y agoSo many federal agencies have their own SWAT teams that they have a hard time keeping the teams qualified due to limited access to suitable firing ranges around DC. Agencies like EPA, USDA, and Dept of Education have SWAT. Seems like only FBI should have SWAT.
- jfoutz 8y agoEh, domain specific knowledge can be a huge win. I’d guess space swat team would be worried about rocket fuel, but usda might be worried about herbicide. I would be on board with an fbi run certification system. Organizations send agents for extra training. I sorta like consistency though.
- figgis 8y agoYou don't call in SWAT for their domain specific knowledge though. You call them in to clear/pacify/etc a location.
- wongarsu 8y agoIf there's an active shooter hiding behind a hydrazine tank I would prefer a SWAT team trained in recognizing and handling different types of rocket fuel.
- PRmaestro 8y agoThe funding required to train swat teams is high. A course I volunteered at was over a thousand per person not including the costs of sim-munitions, actual munitions, and experts in specific areas. That was the costs before the program decided to hire more trainers instead of utilizing volunteers. Funniest thing was though was how awful SWAT teams were against unprepared volunteers.
- coleca 8y agoAm I the only one thinking this would be the perfect job for Burt Macklin? http://parksandrecreation.wikia.com/wiki/Burt_Macklin http://parksandrecreation.wikia.com/wiki/Burt_Macklin
- behringer 8y agoIn my experience, government workers are either corrupt or no longer working for the government.
- repiret 8y agoI'm not sure what government your experience is with, but my experience (mostly with governments within the United States) is that government workers also includes the lazy, the incompetent, but also the hard working who aren't given the resources they need, and also the hard working who have the resources they need and do good work. For that matter, I think you can find people in all of those categories in any large organization.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tw04 8y ago>For that matter, I think you can find people in all of those categories in any large organization. I challenge anyone who says government is inefficient to find me a single large corporation that ISN'T inefficient. It has nothing to do with government and everything to do with size.
- ghaff 8y agoThere are probably different types of inefficiencies that relate to, among other things, having to be more accountable for spending tax payer dollars. If $LARGE_CORPORATION chooses a given vendor for a major software system, the losing vendors may piss and moan but there's really nothing they can do about it in general. If it's a government agency, there will likely be formal challenges requiring lots of paperwork and effort. But, for the most part, I agree with you. Big organizations can do things smaller ones can't but that size comes with a lot of overhead. I'm often surprised not that large organizations are inefficient, but that they can get anything done at all.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't break the site guidelines by taking HN threads on extraneous flamewar tangents. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18547535 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18547535 and marked it off-topic.
- blattimwind 8y agoIs it just a criminal investigation branch or an actual secret police for parks?
- dangoor 8y agoCoincidentally, I just learned of the existence of this organization yesterday via CGP Grey's new video about federal land: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LruaD7XhQ50 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LruaD7XhQ50
- jimmaswell 8y agoI was going to ask if that was the motivation for the post.
- blocked_again 8y agoI just opened my YouTube app to watch this video. Guess what was the first video in my feed?
- B-Con 8y agoMore specifically, he uses the phrase "the FBI of the National Parks" to describe this organization.
- tjr225 8y agoOnce I get my student loans paid off I'd really like to fuck off and work for the park service. I wonder how difficult it is to get a job with the ISB...
- ghaff 8y agoGiven that there are 33 of them in the country, I would imagine quite difficult. I also wouldn't assume that working for the park service generally is an especially easy job. I've know people who were semi-retired who worked in parks on a part-time basis but I assume you have a lot more flexibility under those circumstances but don't get paid much, if anything. I'm sure it's a job that many would prefer compared to sitting in an office all day but that doesn't mean it's easy.
- tjr225 8y agoEasiness isn't really why I am interested.
- ghaff 8y agoYou did write "I'd really like to fuck off" which usually means you'd like to not work very hard. Of course, there are many jobs that get you involved in outdoor recreational activities but don't pay very well or offer a lot of financial security but do get you outside a lot.
- tjr225 8y agoThat's not really what I meant...but I guess I can see how you could interpret it that way. I do work for a certain outdoor recreation retailer that I happen to love dearly, so perhaps I shouldn't complain too much - but probably contributes to my love for the outdoors. My point was mostly that I'd love to be able to afford to be a steward of the outdoors/National Parks/Forests/Wilderness' full time, and that is something that I cannot currently do.
- matthewwiese 8y ago