3 ms·
I think what bothers me most about Apple's behaviour with the App Store is this: > Apple does nothing to increase the value of Netflix shows or Spotify music o
by AlexandrB 8y ago
I think what bothers me most about Apple's behaviour with the App Store is this:
> Apple does nothing to increase the value of Netflix shows or Spotify music or Amazon books or any number of digital services from any number of app providers; they simply skim off 30% because they can.
30% is a huge cut for what amounts to hosting, payment processing, and basic QA. Despite taking this big chunk, quality control in the App Store feels like it's on the decline - with a bunch of malware and scams slipping through in recent years. And of course, charging 30% for non-app content distributed through the App Store is completely insane.
- ubernostrum 8y agoHow does Apple get a 30% cut out of me using Netflix? If I want Netflix, I go to netflix.com, sign up and give them payment information, and then use my browser, or Netflix apps on phones, TVs, etc. The Netflix iOS app is listed as free to download. Where is Apple's 30% cut of my Netflix subscription coming from? Same for Amazon's Kindle and video apps. Same for Spotify's app. The trend there seems to be they make the app free, and let you sign up and pay for their service on their own website (which you can do in Safari on iOS, if you want to). So I don't understand how Apple's "skimming" anything out of those apps -- 30% of $0 is $0.
- scarface74 8y agoYou can buy a Netflix subscription through the App Store but you don’t have to. Netflix must have decided it was worth it.
- luigi23 8y agoHere are the rules: you can offer subscription on your site, but you can't link to it in the app. If you want to buy a subscription for Netflix/Spotify in the app, then Apple will take 30% cut. Some sites give this option with increased price by 30% to move payments to their sites, some don't.
- ubernostrum 8y agoI know you can offer subscriptions and purchases in the app. I just don't understand how anyone thinks Netflix, Amazon, etc are forced to, because they aren't.
- zapzupnz 8y agoThey're not forced to, no, but they are forced to keep the price in the app the same as elsewhere if they choose to offer in-app purchase subscriptions in their apps; to be on the App Store, you're not allowed to offer a discount to the same subscription cheaper outside the App Store. If there is a generally-available discount (say, for a promotion), that discounted price must also be reflected in the in-app purchase cost. The net effect is that sellers lose 30% of the potential earnings from the in-app purchases compared to getting subscriptions from elsewhere, and they're not allowed to increase in-app purchase prices by 30% to compensate. Because Apple disallows sellers from having messages or buttons in their apps that take users to the sellers' websites in order to make the subscription, users who don't know better than to use the in-app purchase system wind up making the sellers less money — in theory. I say "in theory" since, after all, the sellers don't have to deal with payment systems, credit card processing, the sorts of hosting costs associated with popular app downloads, and so on. On the one hand, it's clearly unfair and heavy handed for Apple to disallow those messages enticing users to the websites so sellers can take the full price. On the other hand, with apps moving to free-to-download but requiring subscriptions to function, especially big ones like Netflix and so on, it mightn't be that surprising: a 30% cut of the subscriptions might turn out to be rather reasonable given that Apple's hosting the App Store, addressing and directing complaints, handling payments, and more. On yet a third hand, companies don't need to provide in-app purchases for subscriptions at all, mandating that users go to their websites. It's up to the sellers to decide what provides users with the least friction, though.
- tedunangst 8y ago> they're not allowed to increase in-app purchase prices by 30% to compensate. This sounds like it would seriously undercut plaintiffs argument that the 30% they're paying is on top of the correct price.
- scarface74 8y agoAs opposed to the 45% it takes to sells video game in retail. https://kotaku.com/5479698/what-your-60-really-buys https://kotaku.com/5479698/what-your-60-really-buys
- kllrnohj 8y agoApples & oranges. That's physical retail, not digital distribution, and in this case Apple's 30% tax would be comparable to only the $7 platform fee, not the entire 45%, which would be 11%. The other costs from that article, like returns & any publisher cuts, you still need to handle yourself when publishing on the app store. Apple doesn't replace the role of the publisher in this case. They don't pay for marketing or put up-front money towards development, which is what a game publisher's role actually is these days.
- scarface74 8y agoThere is the retailers margins and the licensing cost. That’s 25%. That’s not including the infrastructure costs, or credit card fees. The publisher, in the case of music, charges the artist “return fees” for digital and streaming music.
- kllrnohj 8y ago> There is the retailers margins And if you bought iOS apps at Walmart you'd have those same retailer margins. You're restricting yourself to digital distribution here, which don't have retailers or retailer margins. So you can't count those against games when they don't have them in the same circumstances either.
- Shivetya 8y agoI think what bugs me most about this situation is that Apple develops an innovative product and an ecosystem for it yet people outside that ecosystem or even those who voluntarily enter it want to use the power of the government to force Apple to bend to their wishes, in effect to take Apple's work and investment and decide how Apple is allowed to use and profit from it. Nothing forces me or anyone else to buy an Apple product. Why not complain about any similar system them, from consoles to even Steam. Or is the threshold that there are billions of dollars at stake and therefor lawyers can profit from it, state AGs can make a name for themselves, and such? Too many people feel entitled to tell others what to do even when the association is purely voluntary and this is just wrong