9 ms·
The EU countries (generally) believe in positive liberty where people believe those they vote into power then have the right to tell people what to do for the g
by superkuh 8y ago
The EU countries (generally) believe in positive liberty where people believe those they vote into power then have the right to tell people what to do for the greater good of some ideology.
The USA (generally) believes in negative liberty which is based around the individual being able to do whatever they want unless it actually harms another person.
Both positive and negative liberty are valid views but generally positive liberty leads towards trouble in the form of authoritarian issues.
- barrkel 8y agoWhereas negative liberty by your definition tends towards trouble in the form of oligopoly and inequality.
- superkuh 8y agoWell, it's not my definition. It's Isaiah Berlin's and was the foundation of US policy from 1960 to about 2000. A bit less lately. Do you want to know more? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_Concepts_of_Liberty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_Concepts_of_Liberty
- buboard 8y agothanks for the link
- room271 8y agoGoing further back Mill is probably the better starting point for the negative view of freedom: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stuart_Mill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stuart_Mill. So it's really not a US/Europe thing at all - both very much value negative liberty, although it is probably fair to say that Europe also values positive liberty a bit more. It's more about the role of corporations. The US seems to view corporations as almost equivalent to people, whereas in Europe more often they are viewed as quite separate. And Europe has a broader definition of harm around monopolies than the US does currently at least, especially around the importance of data protection (but again both in respect to negative liberty).
- goto11 8y agoIn this case the authorities are telling businesses what they can and cannot do. GDPR denies business the right to track humans who have not consented (i.e. the negative liberty to be free of unwanted tracking). So the real question is whether you consider the liberties of business more important than the liberties of humans.
- hodwic 8y agoBusinesses are just groups of humans. We in the US have constitutional protections around freedom of association and assembly, of which a business is but one example. We extend other constitutional rights to businesses, because to remove them from businesses would be to remove them from the people associating under those businesses, and would thus be a limit to free assembly. Also, we definitely do not have a constitutional right to privacy in the public sphere for services that we elect to use.
- Daishiman 8y agoThis is completely invalid. Courts and legislatures in the US regumate limits to corporate behavior in ways that are the complete opposite to what you're saying.
- hodwic 8y agoI'd be interested if you could provide some examples of regulation which would be unconstitutional if applied to another form of free assembly which is currently held constitutional when applied to a business.
- Daishiman 8y agoBusinesses have to comply with regulations in the form of record-keeping, safeguarding medical data, determining the composition of its board of directors, etc. HIPAA is not for individuals, neither is Sarbanes-Oxley.
- 8y ago
- kazagistar 8y agoProperty, of course, is the one very large exception. For example, in Europe owning land might mean you can exploit it for farming, but not prohibit freedom of travel across it. In America you can put up barbed wire fence and shoot trespassers, because somehow excluding people from using stuff isn't infringing on their freedoms.
- kodablah 8y agoIt's not an exception and very much in line with the spirit of mind your own business. It's about the freedom to have your own land free of trespassers and your right to stop them. The general idea, though of course there are exceptions, is your land your rules. Also, many consider trespassing a harmful act.