10 ms·
Ask HN: Avg. replaced Karma in top bar?
Is this a bug or feature? Am I the only one getting this?
- projectileboy 16y ago107 comments?!? I can't understand why folks get so wrapped around the axle about these things, especially on HN. Is there some way to monetize karma that I'm not aware of?
- byoung2 16y agoI just noticed that about 30 seconds ago. I'm not sure if this is intentional
- olalonde 16y agoI hope it is not. I like to keep track of my karma because it usually correlates with a discussion below my more recent comments.
- pg 16y agoYou can still see it on the profile page itself.
- ScotterC 16y agoI typically watch it to remind me to check my threads for any responses. If my karma went up or down, it's likely that someone responded to one of my comments.
- yason 16y agoIt would be really helpful to have an icon appear on the top bar when there are replies to my comments in articles. Clicking on the icon would give a list of articles/threads where there are replies, easily openable into a set of new tabs. Re-loading a single article would remove it from the list and when the list would be empty the icon would disappear.
- amackera 16y agoDon't worry fellas, I think it's just a trial to see if it makes the quality of comments/submissions any better. Just keep on using the HN like you normally do, write insightful comments, provide utility for your fellow hackers.
- zaidf 16y agoBe scared. Be really scared.
- pg 16y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1853658 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1853658
- olalonde 16y agoWould it be possible to include both karma and avg. on the top bar or simply chose which one to display. I like the karma on top for 2 reasons: 1. When your karma goes up/down, it's a good indication that you might have replies to your most recent comments. 2. Karma seems to be updated not so frequently. I like the idea though of encouraging a good ratio vs total karma.
- parbo 16y agoCould we have the avg change color slightly when there is a change to the actual karma?
- Zev 16y agoYou mean like the (in)famous orange experiment? http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=467895 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=467895 and the top thread in it (the one started by jacquesm) makes for a good summary as to why it failed.
- tmsh 16y agoOr you could just store the date of the last child comment with the user information, and include that on the top bar (near the average)? So a user knows the last datetime of child comments in their threads. Personally, I like the average. Shows that HN is more 'adaptive', imho. ETA. Whoa that was fast. I like the (abs., avg.), fwiw. That does seem best.
- gsivil 16y agothey did it already :)
- pg 16y agoOk, now both are displayed.
- noodle 16y agofeature, modified by PG based on another thread (this one, i think: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1852560 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1852560)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 16y agoI'm sure it's deliberate; whether it's an improvement or not is open to debate. Personally I prefer seeing the total.
- jamesteow 16y agoSame. I'm a bit more aware of my karma now than before. Karma doesn't matter as much to me because I come to the site for content, but I like to comment on a lot of new links (especially entrepreneurs wanting some design critiques) which doesn't get nearly as much participation as the front page and thus has a much lower chance of gaining a lot of karma per comment. A total karma score doesn't discriminate against that but an average score does.
- gsivil 16y agoI am sorry for my ignorance but Avg. of what?
- spicyj 16y agoAverage karma per post. (Total karma divided by number of posts.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- melling 16y agoAdjusting the game? Trying to reduce comments and posts? I once posted a story that got 80 points. Unfortunately, the points went to the guy who posted the same story 10 minute later.
- charlesju 16y agoI feel that if the avg is important, user profiles should have the average in addition to the total.
- benologist 16y agoCan we also get thread collapsing ala reddit? Even just on the first level would be awesome.
- danieldk 16y agoWell, hopefully not as insane as Slashdot, where I end up showing all comments, since filtering completely messes up flow of messages (content-wise).
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- erikstarck 16y agoI first thought it was some sort of geek joke since the top bar had my username with the number 3.14 after it. :) "Ah, the karma point system is broken and they're showing the number pi instead, very funny."
- 3pt14159 16y agoIf that happened to me, I would be thoroughly confused. (see my handle)
- smcl 16y agoWeird, mine is at 3.1. Got me thinking that it'd be interesting to know what the mean or median karma rating is, and if by some weird coincidence we are close to it. This information is of no value whatsoever, mind, but I'm curious nonetheless!
- sachinag 16y agoI like it - I'd really be interested in knowing what the mean and median are for the HN community so I know if I'm contributing a lot or not pulling my weight. Maybe a (+0.65) next to it in the top nav or something to that effect?
- Silhouette 16y agoFor what it's worth, I hope this gets changed back. Differences in karma tend to alert me to older discussions where something is still happening. Without either that or a Reddit-style notification when replies are made, it's going to be even more difficult to identify the interesting threads and come back to them after the first visit.
- jamesteow 16y agoThat I think is one of the more odd user experiences on the site. The envelope indicator on Reddit is very tiny but extremely useful feature. As of now, I have to re-read my threads in order to notice any updates.
- citricsquid 16y agoI came here from reddit (I mainly browse here so it isn't as much of an issue) and was surprised that we don't have reply notification. I spent a few weeks ignoring replies because I wasn't notified of them, now my first port of call is my comments page to see if anything has been added as a reply.
- CWIZO 16y agoI've written a chrome exension that marks unread comments a while back: https://chrome.google.com/extensions/detail/fpndmkcfggkffpablcooicmihgcgalil https://chrome.google.com/extensions/detail/fpndmkcfggkffpab... it helps a lot with that. It has some bugs, but as far as I can see I can't get around them because of the markup used here ...
- lsc 16y agoalmost all other web boards I'm on have some easy way for me to see responses to old comments. This would be a really useful feature for hn.
- random42 16y agoWould it make sense to show average karma on profile page of a user too? (This is question, NOT a feature request, as I presume that Karma at HN serves the purpose of moderating the quality of content, rather than being a redditesque user-stickiness game)
- ashleyw 16y agoThe current version ("741, 2.41") is nicer. I'm not a karma-whore, but it's nice to know where I'm at. One feature I'd love to see also, is the # of direct replies to my comments in the head bar. Also, while we're at it, a page listing them all too. That way, I'll know if somebody replies to a comment I made last week/month/year. For example, in 'My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned' (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1850750 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1850750), a few people have ordered some of the drugs mentioned, but the story will be dead soon, so in a few weeks, when the drugs arrive, nobody will be able to share their experiences.
- sprout 16y agoOne thing I like a lot about HN's lack of comment replies is that a direct reply to one person is an indirect reply to the parent, and I think that's a valuable thing to keep. It saves re-hashing arguments in separate threads.
- Natsu 16y agoYeah, I always go to the 'threads' link in my profile because I'm interested in keeping up with the conversations I was having. An easier way to see new replies would help.
- raganwald 16y agoI'm not crazy about average points per comment. If you make a good comment very early on a popular post, you get a lot more karma for your comment than if you make the exact same comment late in the posts's life or worse still on an unpopular post. That's fine, exposing good things to fewer eyeballs is less valuable, and that's why you get less karma for it. But if it gets a few upvotes it's still helping someone, somewhere. However, average karma per post gently nudges us towards avoiding circumstances where a comment might get low karma, such as on a post that is less popular. Whereas, total karma encourages users to let a thousand flowers bloom. There's a disincentive to post anything that might get downvoted, and that's fine, but otherwise there's no harm in making a comment anywhere and not worrying about whether your seed has fallen on fertile ground. You could "fix' things by weighting karma per post by eyeballs, or disregard average karma per post. I choose the latter course as I'm not a moderator and even if I were I'm unsure how the number relates to behaviour HN is trying to encourage.
- sahillavingia 16y agoTotally agree. Sometimes I type up a controversial reply, and then scrap it because I feel like it's going to be received poorly (took me a bit of thinking to post this comment, even!). I'm sure a lot of good discussions never exist because of this. Even without avg. karma though, reputation is still at risk, so the problem won't be solved by removing/showing that statistic.
- olalonde 16y agoControversial comments sometimes get down voted but other times get up voted as hell. I think on average, it's quite safe from a karma perspective to be controversial even though you have to take the occasional down votes.
- brudgers 16y agoThere are certain topics which are more likely to be downvoted - criticism of Steve Jobs is an example (and conversely criticism of Steve Balmer is likely to be upvoted). There's nothing wrong with caring about HN karma, so long as you care about karma less than you care about speaking your mind.
- GHFigs 16y agoThe thing where you can suggest something and find that pg, slaving over a hot REPL, has implemented it by the time you reload the front page is definitely a feature of HN.
- pg 16y agoDon't worry, it's just an experiment. Since this may cause people to care about comment averages, here's how they're calculated: ; Ignore the most recent 5 comments since they may still be gaining votes. ; Also ignore the highest-scoring comment, since possibly a fluff outlier. (def comment-score (user) (aif (check (nthcdr 5 (comments user 50)) [len> _ 10]) (avg (cdr (sort > (map !score (rem !deleted it))))) nil)) Comment averages are updated asynchronously.
- kuldeep_kap 16y agoBy that theory you can also ignore the lowest-scoring karma (if negative karmas are being added), as some might have had bad day or unlucky thrashing.
- fhars 16y agoIf you continue along that line, you end up using the median comment score... which might incidentally be an interresting experiment.
- tel 16y agoSome thoughts, assuming most of everyone's comments are ignored (success being a stronger function of practice instead of inborn genius) and that commenters with high means are probably being pulled up by a number of outliers. 1. Median obviously is less suspect to a small number of very popular comments which probably describes many users pretty well. It's the "betting value" for a game where loss is linear with error. 2. I'm not sure whether median would be higher or lower for most. Poisson distribution suggests higher medians, but many probably have a bunch of 1-karma comments to weight the origin. 3. A HUGE psychological difference is that median would be discreteness. Instead of seeming to be a smooth value related (probably naively) to community engagement and improvement it'll look more like a set of clubs. 0-medkarma could be a rabble-rouser, 3-medkarma is consistently meaningful. 10-medkarma means maybe you should run for office.
- frederickcook 16y agoI think this is definitely an improvement. Putting any kind of number up there is a game mechanic that will affect people's behavior. My eyes inadvertently go there every time I open the page. An average does more to encourage the desired behavior than a total does. Even as I am about to press enter here, I can't help but think of whether this post will make that number go up or down.
- yason 16y agoIn that case you are prefiltering yourself in mere anticipation of potential acceptance from others. If everyone did that, no genuine posts would ever appear: everybody would be too concerned about how much others would like them.
- frederickcook 16y agoI'd argue that in this community, there is a better correlation between up-votes and the quality of a comment than between up-votes and how much one user likes another user. I'd also argue that there are only a few topics that are so polarizing that people up-vote or down-vote based on the position the author takes, and that the majority of discussions here aren't as opinionated, and that the number of up-votes a post receives is based on how interesting and thought-provoking it is. However, it appears that how to display karma is one of the more polarizing ones :)
- olalonde 16y agoWhile we're at it with the feature requests, why not add a down vote option to submitted stories? Wouldn't it help get a better signal-to-noise ratio in the "new" section? It would also prevent "throw spaghetti at the wall, and see what sticks" behavior. If this was debated in the past, I'd be curious to hear why it was not implemented.
- EGreg 16y agoI personally will discuss things in the same spirit of information sharing, genuineness, common sense and helpfulness that I have before and after the karma change. I'm new to HN so I don't really even know how I'm supposed to feel about the feedback from the karma. A lot of my posts which I feel are good or important aren't receiving many points, but that's ok. If I really need something, I will ask a couple of my friends who are on HN to look at it and vote it up if they like it.
- EGreg 16y agookay I got my first downvote. Maybe I care a little. Was this to see if I care about my karma? Okay Mr. Downvoter, tell me ... what was wrong in what I said? :)
- gxti 16y agoAnyone have a greasemonkey script to hide karma? I started writing one but got stuck on something simple. I'd like to no longer see the score at the top, because the instant HN loads my eyes gravitate towards that spot, looking for reassurance.
- noarchy 16y agoI wonder if this is going to kill the willingness of some people to participate in discussions on less popular postings. Here I also mean the ones that don't necessarily make it to the front page. I'm not sure that everyone even checks to see the new posts. Sometimes small discussions will pop up on those posts.
- steveklabnik 16y agoI'm not sure that this will fix anything, but it'll be helpful to me. I think those of us that care, but occasionally say something bad will be helped a lot by this. I'm always trying to ask myself "will this be upvoted" when posting things, as I'm trying to be as helpful as possible. However, people that are actually trying to troll or can't tell that they're trolling won't really stop because of this change. I don't really have an answer, either: this is a Hard Problem. Edit: I should also say that any of us can easily be in the "can't tell we're trolling" camp at any time; it's a per-comment thing, not an "I'm a good poster, what shall we do about those terrible bad ones!" deal.
- bbulkow 16y agoManagement of "karma" in systems like Hacker News is critical to long term success. Watching the community, and the flow articles, in Reddit shows that minor changes in algorithms make a big difference. One further thought: your "karma" in a site like HN is a very serious asset. Access to a post which reaches the front page can make or break a company. I would easily pay $100 for someone to post a choice blog post reference that would hit the front page, and I'm sure I'm not alone. We also know about Digg's kabal of a few high-karma individuals who tilted the entire news site to the political right. People don't game a site until it's important, and you don't find out the effects of your site's algorithms until the site becomes popular. The owners of a site must be diligent, continue to understand how articles are floating to the front page, and be willing to make changes. We as users need to be supportive of the changes & experiments they make - even at the cost of our own "karma" (ie, real-world-dollars).
- lsc 16y agoI agree that having something on the front page is worth real money (a lot more than $100, in my opinion.) but I don't see the connection between having a high personal carma and getting something on the front page. As far as I can tell, it's one user, one vote (I mean, except in the common case of dupes) to my knowledge, higher-carma users don't get extra points to vote up stories.
- toast76 16y agoI think there are to distinct issues here. The first is how articles find their way to the front page, and the second is how individuals are rewarded (or punished) for their involvement in those stories. The reality is that the earlier you post in a story, the more karma you're likely to collect. To me, that just encourages "first!" type posts. A poorly thought out comment in a story that makes the front page will inevitably earn more karma than a well thought out comment that doesn't. So is this about getting better stories to the front page, or about rewarding users for their participation?
- shalmanese 16y agoI've been advocating that sites should try h-index: http://www.quora.com/Should-Quora-ever-consider-using-H-index-for-reputation http://www.quora.com/Should-Quora-ever-consider-using-H-inde...
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- alexandros 16y agoHere's how avg. karma has affected my behaviour (including its before the latest change, moreso now): My average at this moment is 7.64. By giving all this weight to avg. karma, the message from the site to the users is clear: "higher avg. karma is better, work to improve yours". In my case, this means I should make a comment only if I expect it to get 8 upvotes or more. This in turn means that I should not respond to replies to my comments, as they rarely get to 8+. I should also not reply to articles late in the game as it's unlikely to get to the threshold also. So what will I respond to? Early threads where I feel I can make a contribution. It is also unlikely that I will make 'eccentric' comments that are a risk in terms of votes, but may help break the echo chamber as this behaviour is not encouraged. The only other case I may make a comment is when I feel strongly enough about something that I am willing to take the hit, as in the case of this comment. Now, many will say that I should ignore karma altogether and that I should just participate in the community as if it didn't exist. For one thing, this is orthogonal to the discussion here. pg has made this change to alter the community's behaviour, therefore he expects it to have an impact. Even if I chose to disregard it, nothing will change in the general case. Secondly, poster avg. karma affects ordering of comments and therefore the impact that your comments have. So it materially affects your experience in this community, and when I have something to say that I feel needs to be said, I benefit from it having the highest possible impact. This makes me care about avg. karma in all other situations. On the other hand, submitting articles is not subject to such pressures, so I will happily continue doing that.
- follower 16y ago> This in turn means that I should not respond to replies to my comments, as they rarely get to 8+. To me this is the biggest negative. A useful but non-controversial threadlet between members towards the end of a submission's life is IMO beneficial to the community overall but will be worse for average karma for participants. I'll live with the lower average karma if it means still benefitting from the community in a way average-karma-targeting replies don't.
- elai 16y agoKarma is like the star stickers that children get in kindergarden.
- iamjustlooking 16y agoIf you have a high average are your comments better? Are you bad at commenting with a low average? What should this number tell me?
- jayphelps 16y agoKarma's a bitch.
- gvb 16y agoGoing to the leader board and sorting the first 20 by average: Order Who Total Ave 2 edw519 44607 22.29 39 grellas 11208 19 45 wheels 10752 12.15 4 patio11 37809 11.23 42 mixmax 11064 10.45 66 timr 8632 9.78 78 chaosmachine 7829 8.8 93 niyazpk 6885 8.28 70 alexandros 8353 7.98 53 jerf 9873 7.8 1 tptacek 45718 7.49 16 mechanical_fish 16598 7.4 17 raganwald 16421 7.27 97 maxklein 6751 6.68 34 ryanwaggoner 11976 6.63 76 _delirium 7895 6.56 49 lionhearted 10137 6.49 87 acangiano 7001 6.39 22 Anon84 14263 6.24 9 swombat 21933 6.09 75 abstractbill 7910 6.09
- robryan 16y agoAnother aspect to the average is probably timezone, as this post for example which is being written after what would be the prime time hours when most of the discussion has already occurred. I'm sure over time this would effect average. I don't so much think average is important, possibly a derivative of it would be average amount of posts to receive down votes. We don't want to discourage people replying to threads that are falling off the front page, even if the only person who sees the post is the person that the post was in reply to, that still sounds like a net gain if it was useful or made a good point.
- rsheridan6 16y agoThis reminds me of the past short-lived misfeature in which your username changed color if you had high enough average karma per comment. The main difference is that, this time, your average karma is only in your own face, not everybody's.