6 ms·
No government should have to resort to 'sneaky' measures like this. If you have a suspicion that a company is breaking the law, you ask a judge for permission
by londons_explore 8y ago
No government should have to resort to 'sneaky' measures like this.
If you have a suspicion that a company is breaking the law, you ask a judge for permission to inspect them. If permission is granted, you show up at the main office and do your investigation.
If a judge won't grant you permission do do that inspection, you drop the case entirely. None of this 'we used sneaky laws from centuries ago to take documents from a third party'.
- kitd 8y agoIn the UK, Parliament is sovereign. FB had repeatedly refused to appear before a parliamentary committee to give evidence in the Cambridge Analytica case. Now, I'm not totally certain of the precise legal position, but because of its sovereignty, Parliament can act in a quasi-judicial way, so in effect, FB's actions can be seen as roughly equivalent to refusing a subpoena. FB's refusal authorised Parliament to seize the evidence they needed while the exec was on UK soil. FB have only themselves to blame.
- wtfstatists 8y agoYou are basically normalizing violent response to a non-violent action. US can do that because FB is US company. UK cannot just because you happen to visit. Please realize that other states are taking notes at this situation. They are waiting for US/UK/etc exec to visit and make the same excuse.
- kitd 8y agoThat's a ridiculous argument. If I refuse to appear in court, I can be arrested and charged with contempt of court. Is that normalising a "violent response to a nonviolent action"? Justice would be impotent in such a setup.
- throwaway2048 8y agoViolence is how the government enforces law, harmful acts don't necessarily have to have a component of physical violence to be extremely bad for society (white collar fraud, misuse of identity documents to get stuff like loans, counterfeiting of currency, etc).
- dragonwriter 8y ago> US can do that because FB is US company The US Congress can and has compelled appearance of non-US parties, and, while it may not have had occasion to resort to this for a non-US person (and hasn't used it's arrest power since 1935, relying instead on executive enforcement bodies and criminal statutes instead of it's recognized contempt and arrest powers), absolutely does have the legal power to send the Sergeants-at-Arms of each House to enforce such compulsory summons with force, to bring either materials or persons before the chamber.
- tankenmate 8y ago> Please realize that other states are taking notes at this situation. They are waiting for US/UK/etc exec to visit and make the same excuse. Other states aren't waiting for this at all; least of all the US. In the past when UK based executives of online gambling firms have travelled in transit via the US they have been arrested even before going through customs, in effect in international law it is somewhat akin to piracy, USG sanctioned piracy. This sort of creative use of laws to acquire information and/or people by various governments world wide has been happening for a very very long time.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> In the past when UK based executives of online gambling firms have travelled in transit via the US they have been arrested even before going through customs, in effect in international law it is somewhat akin to piracy No, arresting people who are not subject to any privilege against arrest in international law, who are on your territory, whether or not they have passed through customs, is not, in international law, in even the slightest way “akin to piracy.”
- ahartmetz 8y agoPutting somebody in jail for fraud is the same kind of infraction and response - it is normal.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 8y agoThe UK is a sovereign nation and absolutely can enforce its laws against anyone within its borders, regardless of citizenship. The only potential exception is diplomatic immunity, and that is only granted to the few people who are directly employed to represent a foreign nation. (And even then, such immunity is voluntarily granted by the UK government.)
- reaperducer 8y agoUS can do that because FB is US company. UK cannot just because you happen to visit. Didn't the U.S. arrest a Volkswagen exec wanted in connection with the emissions scandal, when he visited?
- JJMcJ 8y agoContempt of Congress is a real thing in the USA, so refusing a Congressional subpoena can result in enforcement and criminal charges.
- dragonwriter 8y agoAnd, while the usual modern method is resort to executive enforcement and criminal charges, Congress has and has used (though not used since 1935) inherent arrest and detention powers which have been confirmed as intrinsic to their Constitutional authority by the Supreme Court. So while it would be newsworthy for Congress to do this, what the Parliament did here is not something Congress could not legally do to a visiting exec in possession of information sealed by a foreign court.
- johnnyfaehell 8y agoIsn't all the information held within the US, therefore, a UK judge wouldn't be able to grant access? Also, one minute you're talking about the law and order approach then you're complaining that they used the law as it exists. The lesson of the day, don't go playing funny buggers with governments.
- DannyBee 8y agoThe UK can still compel them, by compelling Facebook's relevant country director. The method used here (physically detaining a non Facebook actor who is not a UK citizen who had access to the docs under a protective order and threatening them until they caved) is so far beyond unacceptable it's hard to fathom. As I said in the other thread, the only reason this could ever be acceptable of because of hate of Facebook, seen quite well I'm this thread. (As I also said in the other thread it is also hard to believe it was anything other than a deliberate deal between the UK land and sixfourthree)
- throwaway2048 8y agoI doubt anyone is going to get voted out over this, which is ultimately the only standard that has ever applied to the UK parliment's actions.
- Doctor_Fegg 8y agoDon't travel to the UK or offer your business to UK citizens if you don't like UK laws. It's not that hard.
- dlor 8y agoI think you might be missing the point. DannyBee says that requesting documents from Facebook in the UK would have been a fine option. But that's not what happened here! The documents were obtained from someone who was essentially a third party, that just happened to have access to them. Facebook was not willingly doing business with this person.
- Veen 8y ago
- CPLX 8y agoThey don't have to ask a judge, they're not private citizens, they're the legislature. They are the government, and they have the right to documents and information. What criteria, exactly, are you using to distinguish between "laws" and "sneaky laws"?
- nicky0 8y agoIt was parliament (or at least a parliamentary committee), not the government, that did this though wasn't it?
- mattnewton 8y agoThat’s the gp’s point I think, the U.K. doesn’t have the the same separation of powers between government branches as the US. With some minor exceptions, Parliament is the whole enchilada.
- eiaoa 8y ago> That’s the gp’s point I think, the U.K. doesn’t have the the same separation of powers between government branches as the US. With some minor exceptions, Parliament is the whole enchilada. An example of this is that, until recently, their "supreme court" was a committee in one of the houses of parliament: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lords_of_Appeal_in_Ordinary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lords_of_Appeal_in_Ordinary
- nicky0 8y agoExactly, and my point was that "government", in UK, means the current executive and means something different from "parliament". It seems the facebook seizure was not ordered by Theresa May's government, but instead by parliament itself exerting its powers directly. It's an unusual move and that is what makes this particularly interesting. I'm not sure why so many people have replied to me trying to insist that government and parliament mean the same thing. They do not.
- Ensorceled 8y ago
- throwaway2048 8y agoIt is not a sneaky measure, its well within the purview of Parliament in the British system. They asked Facebook to present documents and evidence, and Facebook refused. It is a terrible idea to refuse to present evidence before a body that has what amounts to unlimited power under British law, especially when public opinion of you is low, and falling.
- kevin_b_er 8y agoThe concept is called Parliamentary sovereignty. Parliament in this case is supreme over the judiciary. Its how the UK has operated for a long time.
- Jonnax 8y agoThe UK is not the United States.
- snowwrestler 8y agoIt's worth pointing out that the U.S. Congress can also directly subpoena documents and testimony without going through a judge.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoWe have plenty of laws from centuries ago that are still relevant and useful today. What exactly is "sneaky" about using them?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> If you have a suspicion that a company is breaking the law, you ask a judge for permission to inspect them. Uh, no. The only person the UK Parliament asks for permission for anything is the monarch, and that's almost entirely a formality. And, absent a US-style Constitution, what is there to ask a court about? Whether the action sought by Parliament comports with the law, which is the expressed will of Parliament?
- reaperducer 8y agoNo government should have to resort to 'sneaky' measures like this. That's tourist thinking. If you want to play in their country, you abide by their rules.