3 ms·
Exceptional piece of research. I'm still dazzled why the realisation of what China's "grand plan" was, came so late into mainstream political culture in the We
by baybal2 8y ago
Exceptional piece of research.
I'm still dazzled why the realisation of what China's "grand plan" was, came so late into mainstream political culture in the West.
Few month ago, I wrote a piece saying that China was long preparing (at least since 1991,) an economic war chest in case the country will be hit by sanctions like North Korea was, or even worse. A big portion of all national level economic programs since 1991 were there to aid and act upon that strategy. And they weren't even trying to conceal the original strategy paper, and if one can get access to state archives, they will find a lot of evidence that Chinese state did fully commit to it as early as 1992. The motto of the program is "the primacy of expansionism."
They correctly identified that US domination in 20th century came from how they moulded the world after WW2. Now, when the West wasted itself on two decades of useless "wars on X," they felt that:
1. "The world was messed up enough" to yield to China's own Marshal plan.
2. This is the last opportunity to act before US takes action
So, all those impressive t-bill, cash, gold, and FX reserves that the West gave China in the last 30 years, will now be used by China to buy its own Pax Sinica
- oblio 8y ago> Now, when the West wasted itself on two decades of useless "wars on X," they felt that "the world was messed up enough" to yield to China's own Marshal plan. That's an awfully Western centric view of things. The West didn't "waste itself" on things, they just plain didn't care about various regions, for various reasons. They babysat Germany and Japan after WW2 but Iraq and Afghanistan were comparatively thrown to the wolves. China mostly went where the West wouldn't go. I can't really blame them. Their moves are very rational as an actor on the world stage and in many cases their involvement is also helping the locals (many of which have miserable lives, as-is). And I'm neither American, nor Western, nor Chinese, so I'd consider myself a reasonably unbiased obverser.
- baybal2 8y ago>I can't really blame them. Their moves are very rational as an actor on the world stage and in many cases their involvement is also helping the locals (many of which have miserable lives, as-is). Indeed, as a strategy it is as straightforward and rational as it can be. When it is a detestable communist party that continuously follows upon plain, and rational strategies, and Western civil states can not despite their best efforts, you begin to question the rationale for living in the West. This in big part was the reason for my move to China. And the constantly growing expat community in China is the proof that I am not alone having that idea.
- adventured 8y ago> Now, when the West wasted itself on two decades of useless "wars on X," The West hasn't wasted itself on such any more than China is presently wasting itself on wars on X. Your premise falls apart when you look at what China is doing. China currently has equivalent wars going on against: drugs, porn, jokes, speech & expression broadly, homosexuality, neighboring territories, Islam, all forms of protest, worker rights, political activism, privacy, social rebellion, journalism and news. You know the Chinese war-on-all-things has gone wrong when the Communist Party is disappearing Marxist students who are activists for worker rights.[1] Or consider just one recent example [2] of their long war on porn. Offering $86,000 rewards for citizens to rat on their fellow citizens regarding porn: “I'm not going to work today,” wrote one potential porn-buster on Weibo. “I'll look everywhere for materials so I can report anyone who I find disagreeable. There’s money to be made in reporting, so what am I doing working myself to death?” "In August, the 27-year-old founder of video app Hot TV was served with a 7-year prison sentence for hosting 1,579 illegal videos on the platform, 28 of which were defined as pornographic – that’s one year in prison for every four indecent videos." "On Friday People's Daily, known as the mouthpiece of the Communist Party, published a glowing report on (mostly retired) members of a community in the Chinese city of Chengdu that spend 90 per cent of their day snooping around their neighbours' backyards and propagating the “Clean up the Pornographic, Strike the Illegal” campaign." [1] https://www.npr.org/2018/11/21/669509554/in-china-the-communist-partys-latest-unlikely-target-young-marxists https://www.npr.org/2018/11/21/669509554/in-china-the-commun... [2] https://www.abacusnews.com/digital-life/china-offering-it-citizens-us86000-snitch-porn/article/2174646 https://www.abacusnews.com/digital-life/china-offering-it-ci...
- baybal2 8y agoI don't challenge that the party is indeed messed up, and is shooting itself in the leg 2 times out of 3 when it comes to internal policy, but even with that in mind, they are still definitely doing better at strategic scale resource allocation in apples to apples comparison.
- adventured 8y ago> they are still definitely doing better at strategic scale resource allocation in apples to apples comparison There's zero evidence to support your claim. The boom that the last 30-40 years of global trade and their joining the WTO produced (ie filling in the extreme slack in their economy), just as well may have papered over immense inefficiencies and wasted uses of resources during the boom phase. The next 10-15 years will be a far better judge of how good the Chinese bureaucracy is at managing intricately via command & control economics. When you have hyper fast growth and vast slack to fill in, you can afford a lot of mistakes - which mostly go unnoticed. So far it's not looking good, in just the span of one decade they've become the world's most indebted nation as a means to continue faking their expansion. They've found they can no longer grow their economy acceptably without rapid debt expansion. The bureacracy keeps rolling from one looming asset disaster to the next trying to keep it all propped up, while households load up on debt at record pace. Sounds a lot like some of the more foolish financial mistakes made in the West over the last few decades. When you have to lock-down nearly all capital from leaving your nation, you know something very bad is happening in terms of resource allocation. Don't confuse temporarily having a bonanza of resources to spend, with being brilliant at how you spend it, they're two different things. As the slack has filled in, their having to turn to extreme debt to continue on the path they set indicates they've made structurally incorrect choices. That rapid debt acquisition means the clock is running out on their former approach. They can't come close to accomplishing what they want to with the resources they actually have to spend, so they've switched to borrowing very aggressively from future output (a future with a rapidly declining worker base to pay for it all), which is an indication of incompetence at resource utilization. The Belt and Road is a flailing, expensive mess so far. It's more likely to end up as the world's most expensive boondoggle. Their biggest industries - such as steel, iron, aluminum, cement, etc - are mostly examples of incompetence at resource allocation. They've been over-producing to a great degree in their state-controlled industrial segments for a long time. There's nothing efficient or prudent about it, it's a very expensive way to run industries (instead of shifting those resources to where they're needed for sustainable growth, versus subsidizing unneeded production). I'll take Germany, Sweden, Norway, Australia, Denmark and Canada against China any day of the week in terms of effecient resource allocation for the betterment of society. Not to mention those nations all have tremendous protections when it comes to human rights. The standard of living and quality of life is astronomical at the median in those nations compared to China. China still has half a billion people living on $5 per day or less. They have around 250 million people living on $3 per day or less. The bottom half billion people in China are among the poorest people on earth, and have among the fewest human rights. Human rights are a required top-line consideration for social well-being.