20 ms·
I still don't understand what problem decentralised currency is supposed to solve. As you say, I want cheap, convenient transaction at low cost, and specifical
by Barrin92 8y ago
I still don't understand what problem decentralised currency is supposed to solve.
As you say, I want cheap, convenient transaction at low cost, and specifically concerning privacy I want to know who I send my money, and I want legal recourse should anything fishy happen.
The privacy proposal of crypto in my opinion is bizarre. I am supposed to lay out my entire financial history in a public wallet (which I don't want), but trade with people who I don't know (which I don't want), and have all of it supervised by 'smart contracts', which are anything but smart and make it necessary to essentially put myself under surveillance?
- ftlio 8y agoIt's trying to solve the problem of having to involve a 3rd party in on-line transactions. Chargebacks are expensive to deal with. Jurisdictions are expensive to deal with. Standing up a multinational e-commerce site requires a lot of lawyers and accountants. Will the risk presented by crypto always be greater than the risk of involving trusted third parties? Maybe. Maybe not.
- walrus01 8y agoCounterpoint: There's a lot of people who will stop buying stuff online with such a system, once they have been bitten by a system that has truly irrevocable payments. Part of the reason why I trust buying random $25 used video games from eBay (using Paypal) is that I know I'm about 99% certain to get my money back if it never arrives, or arrives in poor condition. I can buy a used Cisco 48-port 1000BaseT/PoE switch on eBay and know that I have some degree of buyer protection. Or I can go to Newegg and buy a new $700 monitor and trust that if something goes terribly wrong with the transaction, Visa's buyer protection/chargeback system can be engaged. Moving to irrevocable online payments is basically the equivalent of handing a wad of cash to some stranger in a parking lot selling "new, sealed!" ipads out of the trunk of a car.
- CamTin 8y agoI totally agree with you in practical terms, but what you're really saying is that you prefer the governance offered by Paypal and the credit card networks to the governance provided by the government: IOW, it wouldn't even occur to you (or most sane people) to file a claim in court over a $25 Atari cart you tried to buy online. In the society these courts are designed to serve (peasant agricultural economies), the courts were where these issues were hashed out, and a fair bit of the "state-iness" of the state derived from its ability to solve these kinds of problems for people. Increasingly, this kind of justice is inaccessible to ordinary people except through "customer support" mechanisms at institutions like Amazon or Paypal or by tweeting at their CEOs. One of the very real problems that cryptocurrency enthusiasts are concerned about (but IMO totally failing to actually solve) is that it seems like a really bad idea to leave such basic functions of state in the hands of difficult-or-impossible-to-regulate transnational enterprises. When will these players realize that they've got more "state-iness" than most actual states, and how will they use it?
- mantas 8y agoYou won't need a claim either. Chargeback is easy. So in CryptoWorld, people should go to court and try get their money back from anonymous seller? That'd be a field day for scammers.
- CamTin 8y agoRight, this is why its totally unworkable as a solution to the problem of transnational corporations wielding too much power, and a totally crypto-ized global economy would probably just make that worse. It solves other problems fairly well (paying ransoms to anonymous cybercriminals, as an example), but also doesn't even try to solve the problem that ordinary people can't afford (or figure out how) to have small commercial disputes adjudicated by actual courts anymore, which is (IMO) the one of the reasons these corporations hold so much power. In the neoliberal world order, government exists to ease the flow of international capital ("These regulations make it hard for us to scale our sales beyond the {US,China,Germany}. Please Mr. President, we need common-sense solutions!"). It has jettisoned its role of solving real problems for ordinary people ("Lord Fontleroy, Biff's dog killed two of my pigs.") as it once did.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I can buy a used Cisco 48-port 1000BaseT/PoE switch on eBay and know that I have some degree of buyer protection. This is a basic insurance market. You can still buy the insurance separately if you want it -- sites like eBay would undoubtedly offer it with nothing more than a checkbox for about the same fee as the credit card companies currently charge for implicitly the same thing. The problem with the existing system is that it requires you to buy that insurance, even when it isn't necessary. If you order something from Newegg, they're ultimately going to send it or give you a refund, because they're a stable business and it's cheaper for them to make good to begin with than have a small claims court order them to. So you lose 3% in processing fees for nothing -- Newegg is no more likely to not make good than the payment processor is to not reverse the transaction. The existing system also basically makes micropayments impossible because the transaction costs are too high, but it's not actually all that serious of a problem if you get ripped off to the tune of $0.10 from time to time. The amount is small enough that it doesn't need to be insured, and that allows you to get a good feel for what kind of purchases are scams without actually losing any significant amount of money. It also creates an opportunity for curation services to vouch for verified sellers at a lower cost than insurance would have to be to cover the losses from less savvy individual buyers not knowing who to trust (or not caring when the insurance is mandatory).
- rcxdude 8y ago> This is a basic insurance market. You can still buy the insurance separately if you want it -- sites like eBay would undoubtedly offer it with nothing more than a checkbox for about the same fee as the credit card companies currently charge for implicitly the same thing. It's not the same thing. With chargebacks, in the case of fraud the payment processor almost always extracts the money from the seller, acting both as a deterrent and reducing the cost of the protection. If it was just insurance, it would be more expensive (because there would be less deterrent to (seller-side) fraud and it would cost more to recoup the costs).
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> It's not the same thing. With chargebacks, in the case of fraud the payment processor almost always extracts the money from the seller, acting both as a deterrent and reducing the cost of the protection. If it was just insurance, it would be more expensive (because there would be less deterrent to (seller-side) fraud and it would cost more to recoup the costs). It's still possible to do that by having the insurer escrow the payment in cases where you want the insurance, if that's actually more efficient. But sometimes it isn't. Doing it that way subjects you to buyer fraud where the buyer actually receives the item, claims not to have and has their money refunded. The cost of that has to be paid by honest sellers, which then have to charge higher prices to honest buyers. And an insurer who can't recover their costs from the seller has more incentive to vet the sellers (and buyers) so that they aren't insuring fraudulent transactions to begin with, which could plausibly have lower overhead than sellers eating the entire cost of buyer fraud. Different choices may be more efficient for different transactions. A transaction between a reputable buyer and a reputable seller will have low insurance costs even without escrow. A seller with less reputation would have higher insurance costs, but can mitigate the cost by offering to accept escrowed payments but only from more reputable buyers. A buyer with less reputation could do the opposite, buying from a more reputable seller at low insurance cost by waiving the ability to easily reverse the transaction. Forcing everyone into the same box only creates inefficiency.
- baddox 8y agoCounter to your counterpoint: the people selling you those games on eBay also know that you might be able to revoke your payment either fraudulently or because of events outside the seller’s control, thus the selling price is almost certainly higher than it would otherwise be. In other words, both buyer and seller are incurring a cost due to the existence of chargebacks. Whether that cost is worth it depends on the actual probability of fraud or problems occurring, and at the very least, it seems reasonable to have an option for both buyer and seller to agree to not support chargebacks.
- spookthesunset 8y ago> In other words, both buyer and seller are incurring a cost due to the existence of chargebacks The cost isn't due to chargebacks. It is due to the risk of fraud. Criminal behaviour like fraud extracts a toll on society at large and we all get to pay. The overhead added from chargebacks make both the buyer and seller internalize the potential risk of fraud. Without chargebacks, yeah prices might be slightly lower but society at large would get to foot the bill for fraud.
- baddox 8y agoIt could still be optional for parties who trust each other. Chargebacks is not the only way to establish trust in a transaction.
- stale2002 8y agoOf course you shouldn't be forced to use certain payment methods. ut that is irrelevant to the choices of other people. If other people want other payment methods, that is their choice.
- hoorayimhelping 8y agoThat's like saying "many people won't meet someone in the desert and sell drugs for cash after being burned by a shady deal." That is very true, but how is that relevant? Some people will still want to meet in the desert to sell drugs for cash, away from prying eyes and ears, despite the risk. The fact that many people still want all the conveniences of modern transactions doesn't change the fact that some people don't. I'm not even really sure what all these posts are arguing for. Someone asked what problem cryptocurrency is supposed to solve, and the GP answered it with a good and succinct answer: >It's trying to solve the problem of having to involve a 3rd party in on-line transactions.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoThis is what smart contracts are for. Make the contract valid only when the other party verified receipt.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoIt works the other way as well, there are some products businesses can't sell and communities they can't service because the risk of fraudulent chargebacks is so high.
- GenericsMotors 8y agoCan you elaborate with some examples?
- daveguy 8y agoChargebacks from the business side. Rip-off protection from the consumer side. I personally will not be quick to give up the ability to dispute charges. That is a feature that just isn't possible in bitcoin without involving a third party.
- mjevans 8y agoBoth of those are what escrow is for. A trusted and publicly audited thing where a payment is held until the services are rendered.
- Filligree 8y agoEscrow is far more expensive than chargebacks. And if we're involving a third party either way, I'd rather have the regulated, battle-tested, already existing banking system.
- wcoenen 8y agoChargebacks essentially are escrow. The merchant can't stop them from happening because the money is taken from the merchant account reserve, i.e. a minimum balance that the merchant can't withdraw. Sounds similar to money held by an escrow agent doesn't it? And credit card transactions are also expensive, between 1.5% and 3% and even higher[1]. It's just that the cost is hidden from the consumer by accounting for it in a higher product price. (Some merchants like gas stations may offer a cash discount, which can be used as a rough estimate of that hidden cost.) On top of this, merchants get charged a hefty fee (on the order of $50) for each chargeback that they receive. [1] https://www.creditdonkey.com/credit-card-processing-fees.html https://www.creditdonkey.com/credit-card-processing-fees.htm...
- adrianN 8y agoThe EU proposed limiting transaction fees to 0.2%. I don't know whether that is law already or not.
- village-idiot 8y agoChargebacks are also insanely useful. If my card is stolen I can get my money back, if my merchant tries to defraud me I have a recourse. I will never use bitcoin for consumer transactions for this exact reason.
- zorga 8y agoThose aren't free, they drive up prices by a few percent and frankly fraud only matters for large transactions and/or untrusted merchants. Bitcoin is cash, not credit, and avoiding 2-3% of fees tacked on by credit card companies is more than enough reason to want internet cash for purchases where you're not concerned with fraud.
- village-idiot 8y agoI know they’re not free, and I’m happy to pay for the service. I can name a large number of smallish purchases I would not have done online if I didn’t know that Visa would make it right should the unknown vendor stiff me. Bitcoin is piss poor cash, given the wild exchange rate swings and the ability for it to be stolen online. It literally has no property that I desire.
- zorga 8y ago> Bitcoin is piss poor cash Agree, but I'm not promoting Bitcoin, I think it's poorly designed by someone who doesn't understand the properties of good money. Another crytpo with better properties will supersede it. It's the idea of crypto that's great, not the particular implementation of that idea called Bitcoin. Once you know an trust a vendor, paying with cash will eventually be a few percent cheaper just as it often is as brick and mortar places sometimes when they offer cash discounts because they too don't like the fees the cards companies force on them. It's not an either or scenario, it's a both scenario; you should have the option of cash or credit online, just like you do in the real world.
- anigbrowl 8y agofrankly fraud only matters for large transactions Largeness is relative. The counter to your argument is that widespread use of existing payment methods means the market prefers them.
- cm2187 8y agoMiners are your 3rd party.
- rusk 8y agoIf so, they're nicely decoupled from the transaction.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoYour assuming a 3rd party is bad - commodity trade would not work without third party's validating that that ship load of Copper really is the xxxx tons of copper you paid for.
- esotericn 8y ago> I am supposed to lay out my entire financial history in a public wallet Not at all. The fact that some transactions on some cryptocurrencies function in this way is a flaw, no-one actually desires that.
- SquishyPanda23 8y agoA lot of people are interested in it because they have a particular view of economics. In particular, they like that Bitcoin (1) has a fixed monetary supply, and (2) is difficult to regulate and tax.
- village-idiot 8y agoOh no, bitcoin is insanely easy to tax and regulate, they’ve just not bothered yet. A permanent ledger of all transactions is the tax man’s Dream.
- SquishyPanda23 8y agoI think the difficulty largely comes from not being able to associate a public key with an individual.
- village-idiot 8y agoDe-anonymization is something that we already have a lot of experience with, specifically tying a device to an individual. There’s nothing special about a public key that makes this harder.
- glitch003 8y agoI can't say I agree. A gov can't pry the secret key to my coins from my brain (yet). You can much more easily freeze a bank account and garnish whatever you wish. Additionally, Satoshi himself advised to never re-use a bitcoin address. It's foolish and makes it easy to link your transactions to a single entity (you). If you use a HD wallet, which almost every bitcoin wallet software supports, and is the default in the majority of them, you will not reuse an address. This is because it becomes impossible to tell if you sent money to yourself or another person.
- village-idiot 8y agoCorrect me if I’m wrong, but I believe the following two things are true about bitcoin addresses: 1. Once I know your public key, it’s trivial to prove that an address belongs to you, since an address is nothing more than the hash of a public key. 2. If I don’t know your public key when you receive funds, figuring it out is impossible. But once you spend that money, I now know the public key that received those funds, since only the private key associated with the original address could sign a new transactions. Those two alone should make recreating the tree of transactions a purely mechanical process, with a much lower cost than what it took to create the original chain. At this point it’s a bit like any other de-anonymizes toon attack, with the benefit of some entities being known and coercable, and some users helpfully posting addresses on their social media accounts. On the garnishment front: this kind of depends on scope. But the one thing we’ve seen is that all monetary security goes out the window when the attacker can take possession of you. This is why using technical solutions to such scenarios have always struck me as a bit silly.
- hakfoo 8y agoIt seems like there are different messages for different audiences. The appeal of a trustless network is stronger in places with a history of surprise currency and banking-industry failures-- no one person can crash the system by fiat. OTOH, the use window is small-- situations where the currency is being undermined but electric/networking is reliable enough to do a large scale backup Bitcoin economy are pretty narrow. Venezuela might be the poster child for this. For another audience, the thought of "geographic independence" was appealing. It would cost the same and take basically the same time to pay someone in St. Petersberg, Russia or St. Petersberg, Florida. Really, this is still a space that conventional banking has been troublesome with. Things like the SEPA network help, but there are still loads of cases where it's cheapest to put cash in an envelope. Unfortunately, Bitcoin as-is is still pretty slow and expensive for that.
- PycptN2MH 8y agoThe inventor said it well: "The root problem with conventional currency is all the trust that's required to make it work. The central bank must be trusted not to debase the currency, but the history of fiat currencies is full of breaches of that trust. Banks must be trusted to hold our money and transfer it electronically, but they lend it out in waves of credit bubbles with barely a fraction in reserve. We have to trust them with our privacy, trust them not to let identity thieves drain our accounts. Their massive overhead costs make micropayments impossible." Most agree that Bitcoin privacy is currently unsatisfactory. If it is not improved it should not be adopted generally. Legal recourse and low-cost transactions are layered onto the base protocol.
- arcticbull 8y agoThe inventor was trivially wrong, though. This was all born out of looking at a complex system, failing to understand it, declaring you've got a better idea, then learning over the course of a decade why the current system exists and that in fact you did not have a better idea. (1) Trust is not a problem, it's a huge optimization. The sheer power consumption of cryptocurrencies is hard, demonstrable proof that trust is an efficiency. (2) Debasing money (aka inflation) is a feature. It's a regular haircut for unproductive capital, and is, as designed, completely irrelevant to people who invest their capital. Even in most people's biggest investment, their own homes. (3) Banks are trusted and regulated. Exchanges are totally unrelated fly-by-night banks set up because being your own bank sucks. This is not an improvement. (4) Fractional reserve lending is fine because the FDIC guarantees the funds in the event of a run. This is a further efficiency, allowing the economy to move faster with freer access to capital. (5) Identity thieves draining your account at a traditional bank has recourse. As we've seen in crypto, that's where this is a real risk - you've got nobody to hold accountable. (6) Micropayments aren't something people want as it turns out.
- jammygit 8y agoGood points, but I would argue that micropayments would be great if they required micro effort and no overhead. They would transform the ability of non profits to fundraise. Not that bitcoin offers that iirc, just saying.
- LowLevelHacker 8y agoGood God you sound stupid.
- anigbrowl 8y agoCentral banks and government in general. It is government which guarantees the validity of fiat currency, so if you want to undermine governmental authority then attacking the monopoly on currency issuance is an obvious place to start. I'm just describing this rather than endorsing it btw.
- masonicb00m 8y agoDebasement.
- TACIXAT 8y agoI'm a pretty huge bitcoin critic because I view it from the problems that I want to solve. I want fast, low fee micro transactions and it doesn't serve that need. If you look at another perspective though, of people whose economies are collapsing, or people living under authoritarian regimes, it serves a need.
- solotronics 8y agohave you seen Lightning network? it is a second layer on top of Bitcoin that allows near instantaneous transactions for basically zero fee. people are using it today to buy stuff although it is still in beta testing.
- Nursie 8y agoIt's a huge failure. It's difficult to use, it requires always-on nodes, there appear to be multiple failure modes where funds can be lost to the counterparty with no recourse, and it requires the commitment of large amounts of currency to fund its channels and make the system work. It's basically a joke at this point.
- ric2b 8y ago> It's difficult to use Not _that_ difficult. It's more complex to set-up than using Bitcoin directly but with an analogy to savings and checking accounts I think most people would be able to use it. > it requires always-on nodes First of all it's not always on, a phone that connects once a day or once a week is fine (the period depends on the channel parameters that your wallet software uses). And even then that's only if you want to 100% trustlessly receive funds. To send you don't need to do it and by using watch-towers you can receive without having to periodically go online as well. > and it requires the commitment of large amounts of currency to fund its channels and make the system work. Only as much as you want to send. > It's basically a joke at this point. To people that haven't tried it or are overly critical of an in-development protocol with a small network of interested volunteers behind it.
- zhoujianfu 8y ago
- ghostinmachine 8y agoI'm not sure why it wasn't the first thing that was said, but let me say it. It's to give freedom. Freedom to make and distribute your own currency without borders, rules or monopoly. An outcome of this would be elimination of an artificial recession. There's a reason why Bitcoin paper was published in 2008. Another outcome would be reduction in the authority of banks and governments. There's a reason why all the banking institutions and governments are quick to call it evil. Reason is that control of money grants banks and governments great control over citizenry. There's no denying that it's far from perfect and has to be updated to solve all the bugs, many resembling to fiats.
- not_kurt_godel 8y agoAn outcome of cryptocurrency would not be elimination of artificial recession as evidenced by the repeated losses of 75% of value practically overnight. Seriously, do you even understand the words you are saying or are you just blindly parrotting something you read on the Internet?
- ghostinmachine 8y agoI do understand. It's not an outcome of specifically cryptocurrency but distributed nature of it. The losses that we see are because of the uncertainty surrounding it. It's a form of currency and should be used as one. In the current market it's being used as more like trading stocks than currency. Currently it's not completely distributed, from the people hoarding it to the ICOs to the whales and to centralized exchanges, it all needs to be taken into account, those would be bugs. I would like the idea of limiting amount of money one can hold and spend in a limited period to avoid such disasters. This would limit the freedom too. But we will have to talk about how much freedom does one person/entity need, (yours ends where mine begins). It's not perfect yet, but it's a nice idea. If perfected it would a lot harder to artificially manipulate than the current system. At the very least, a lot many people would be responsible for any disaster instead of a few.
- adwn 8y ago> I would like the idea of limiting amount of money one can hold and spend in a limited period to avoid such disasters. This would limit the freedom too. But we will have to talk about how much freedom does one person/entity need, (yours ends where mine begins). And yet, two posts up you complained about control of people's freedom: >>> Reason is that control of money grants banks and governments great control over citizenry. Do you no see the irony in that contradiction? > If perfected [...] Hah! What a huge "if" you're smuggling into your hypothesis right there.
- stale2002 8y agoThe problem is a way to send censorship resistant financial transactions. If you don't find this to be useful, then you should consider yourself fortunate and privileged. In the same way that if you do not need TOR for your life, then you are also fortunate. But there are literally billions of people in the world, right now, who are living under what I'd describe as authoritarian regimes.
- kakarot 8y agoBitcoin doesn't solve anything. Its mission has been completely subverted by external financial interests, and its leadership relies on censorship and FUD to survive. Cryptocurrency in general, however, solves the problem of payment processors strangling businesses and individuals at the whim of CorpGov. It allows entities who are operating within what they believe to be moral and ethical bounds to do commerce without needing the blessing of a totalitarian state like China or the US.
- sekai 8y agoWhat leadership? BTC has no leadership. If you mean developers, you really overestimate their influence.
- kakarot 8y agoSounds like you aren't very familiar with Bitcoin. I'm talking about Core, and Blockstream. If you were truly familiar with what's been going in with Bitcoin for the last couple of years, those names alone would be enough. Considering they maintain the /r/Bitcoin subreddit and pay millions of dollars towards astroturfing campaigns and subversion tactics, considering how they have completely transformed the Bitcoin community into a mob with half a dozen talking points and bone to pick with every single other coin out there, I don't know how you could say I'm overestimating their influence. I strongly suggest reading a few of the links in the first paragraph of this post[0] to get an idea of what has been going on. [0] https://old.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/9lfjrb/frequently_asked_questions_and_information_thread/ https://old.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/9lfjrb/frequently_aske...
- rapnie 8y ago> I still don't understand what problem decentralised currency is supposed to solve. I agree with all your other points, but e.g. in China people may soon wish they still had a decentralized payment system. Especially if you have a low social credit score, and the government starts to decide in detail what you can and cannot buy.
- pryce 8y agoNo one except power companies and current holders of large amounts of cryptocurrency benefits by the staggering amount of energy being poured into this completely asinine model. If cryptocurrency is supposed to bring the benefits of decentralization to the masses and usher in an era where the "little guy" is more free, it needs to solve that equation somehow.
- glitch003 8y agoThere are many things being worked on to solve the energy usage. Proof of Stake is one, and different types of it are already in use at scale (dPoS on EOS, etc)
- bsder 8y ago> e.g. in China people may soon wish they still had a decentralized payment system. As there will be no way back from a bad social score, this is coming. The key problem to solve is how to create an exchange that the authorities can't shut down.
- lb1lf 8y ago-And that problem is difficult to solve even in a well-functioning democracy. When visiting Sweden recently, I was surprised to find a number of bars, coffee shops and the like only accepting digital payments - no cash. While this makes lots of sense from the vendor's perspective - handling cash is expensive and inconvenient - a customer may feel different about it. These vendors presumably decided that the benefits of not having to handle cash outweighed the risk of alienating a small percentage of their customers (As 'everybody' in Sweden carries debit cards and cell phones with e-payment solutions, few people rely on cash exclusively). Now imagine what happens if the authorities also held the power to say that you WOULD not accept cash. That would make anyone assisting someone with a low social score buy items normally not available to them an accessory to subversion of the state (or something similarly eerie-sounding). Not good. Unless you are The State.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI recommend you look into privacy coins because your comment makes it clear you are not aware of them. Crypto is about immutable transactions where no single entity can deny you your freedom by simply altering your balances. Right now, your bank can click a mouse and your money is gone. You can try to prove you had it but unless you have indisputable proof you’re at the mercy of the bank. Crypto has big challenges for sure, such as legal recourse, stability, reversible transactions and other issues but the problems it seeks to solve are real. They may not affect you personally, perhaps not now, but there is always that possibility that money could disappear and your rights denied. This already happens every day- just google PayPal freezes.
- koonsolo 8y agoWhich bank is going to make the world currency?
- thefounder 8y agoSome people want to use digital cash and that's what crypto coins are. As far as I'm concerned they should be stable(pegged to a known currency) and fast to transact to solve this problem. Bitcoin just doesn't make sense for paymenys due its volatility.
- mkirklions 8y agoThis sounds great until an irresponsible government prints money.
- thefounder 8y agoNot all the goverments are irresponsible. Just use a different currency(i.e eur). It's pretty clear to me now that in practice goverments do a better work(stability wise) than the free market.
- decentralised 8y agoThe problem it solves is that it enables two parties to exchange digital values automatically and without interference. The problem manifests itself in full view in situations where citizens are asked to leave their money or possessions in a country before they are allowed to leave or in situations where the inflation rate makes surviving on a fiat currency next to impossible (ie: Venezuela). In the western world, the problem of interference in your ability to do commerce with whoever you wish might be harder to detect but just recently SWIFT decided to enact the US government's capital controls on Iran for EU companies, despite the EU having declared they would stand by the agreement... For a EU based company or individual there is now very little chance to do legal commerce in Iran, Venezuela, Cuba, North Korea, Syria, Myanmar and a few other countries because of the US's influence on the money markets.
- LoSboccacc 8y ago> what problem decentralised currency is supposed to solve. for example the central european bank deciding to devalue the euro, making us all 20% poorer in a few short months of 2016 not that bitcoin solves the fluctuation issue, but it's one of the issues that having a central bank gives us the people in our microeconomics when the politicians go all in on macroeconomics
- ricardoreis 8y agoSo the question was: "What problem does X solve?" And your answer is: "Well, problem Y. Except it doesn't solve it." Or am I missing something?
- LoSboccacc 8y agoDecentralized might solve problem Y. Bitcoin which is a subset of decentralized currency doesn't solve Y. Other currencies might, depending on how their value is anchored.
- jasode 8y ago>I still don't understand what problem decentralised currency is supposed to solve. The problem(s) that proponents hope decentralized cryptocurrency will solve have grown and evolved. So far, Bitcoin doesn't seem to fully solve them but these are some of the bullet points the idealists want: (1) real (not nominal) "buying power" wealth protection : A currency that government couldn't inflate seemed to be the original and biggest motivation from the perspective of Satoshi Nakamoto. The genesis block[0] of Bitcoin has an embedded comment about government bailout (debasement) because of the 2008 financial crash. (2) transactions of buying and selling without intermediaries: The charitable version of this scenario would be sellers accepting payments without paying fees and rent to bank-owned networks like VISA/Mastercard. Or transfer funds between accounts without bank wire fees. Sellers can also sell controversial items without being "approved" by companies like PayPal or Stripe. (What some call "censorship" or "deplatforming" by denying access to the payments infrastructure.) The uncharitable version of this scenario is buying & selling illegal things like drugs on Silk Road. (3) privacy of transactions: This is somewhat related to (2) because of no intermediaries. If a shopper uses Google Checkout, Amazon Payments, Apple Pay, or VISA/Mastercard to make a payment, that information can be used against them. This doesn't necessarily have to be illegal drugs. Some people are worried that buying a legitimate item such as a certain book can be unfairly used against them. The age of pervasive data collection and machine learning means buying "50 Shades of Gray" could result in insurance companies charging you higher rates or employment background checking firms lowering your "hiring" score. The Chinese "social credit" system using pervasive data about its citizens might be an example. (4) bypass government currency controls: citizens of restrictive countries like Venezuela want to protect their savings from corruption by converting it into a cryptocurrency. This is related to (1). (5) universal basic income : I just threw this last one in here because HN front page sometimes has a proposal to use decentralized cryptocurrency as a way to implement UBI. I'm skeptical of cryptocurrencies promises but I wanted to try to fairly lay out its aspirations. Are there any more I missed? In any case, different participants of cryptocurrency have different priorities as to the benefits of decentralized trustless currency. Some prioritize wealth protection more than censorship-free payments. Or vice versa. [0] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Genesis_block#Raw_block_data https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Genesis_block#Raw_block_data
- 8y ago
- tsukikage 8y agoThere are many problems cryptocurrencies solve. You can make a list just by noting where actual turnover in the real-world crypto economies goes in practice: * How do I receive payment for illegal goods I am selling without going through traditional regulated entities that want to attach my real-world identity to the payment in their records? * How do I provide gambling services to customers in jurisdictions that prohibit this? * How do I profit from people willing to put their money into transparent pyramid schemes or straight-up scams, without risk of recourse from traditional police / legal systems? * How do I launder money? * How do I skim from the shadow economy i.e. in entities engaged in all of the above activities, without committing an obvious crime myself? Legal oversight can be an unwanted transaction overhead that introduces risk, and laws restrict freedom. Ask instead what problems decentralised currency is supposed to solve that are legal and moral to solve and cannot be solved more cheaply through traditional systems involving a regulated third party subject to the rule of law.
- mkirklions 8y agoYou didnt mention that governments print money. Lots of money. Thats my number 1.
- umanwizard 8y agoWhy's that a bad thing?
- sparkie 8y agoBecause a dollar is not always worth a dollar. A bitcoin is always worth a bitcoin. The dollar doesn't have a "reference rate," as it is subject to arbitrary inflation. The dollar has had several reference rates in the past, based on weight in silver, and later, gold. The purchasing power of a dollar has declined rapidly since these reference rates were abandoned. A bitcoin has a reference rate which is eventually 1 in 21M. There is an initial inflationary period until it reaches that, but we're already 1 in ~18M, so most of the inflation has already occurred. We will be very close to the 21M in another 13 years, and after that we will only be adding small fractions. If you had a dollar in 1918, it would be worth only a small fraction of a dollar today. 1/16 or 1/40, depending on what estimations you use. If past performance is anything to go off, then a dollar in 2118 will be worth 1/16th of a dollar today. If you hold onto 16 dollars today, they will have the purchasing power of 1 dollar in 2118. On the other hand, if you hold 16 bitcoin today, you have 16 of 18M of the bitcoin supply. In 2118, you will have 16 of the ~21M total supply. In the same 100 years, bitcoin will inflate by most 16%. The dollar will inflate by 160% in the same period, if the past century is anything to go off (it isn't, this century will be much much worse). Or put it in to shorter timeframe. If inflation is approximately linear over the 100 years, then every 6 1/4 years, your bitcoin will lose 1% of its purchasing power. In the same timescale, your dollar will lose 10%. Which of these are you going to save money with? The above is based on the assumption that demand for bitcoin will not increase in relation to demand for the dollar. Given Gresham's Law, this is highly unlikely.
- arendtio 8y agoI don't think you want to know who send your money. In fact, you don't even care. All you want to know is what the money is for. Online as well as in a supermarket, you are rarely even asked for an ID (age-restricted goods aside).
- ataturk 8y agoI can't believe I'm defending cryptos because I think they're a giant scam in their current form, but here goes: Millions of Chinese would like to have their wealth outside of the totalitarian control of their own government. That's probably the #1 use case--you can't trust government. Just because you grew up in a time in the West where everything has been fairly civil towards the average citizen, please understand that this has been largely an anomaly (also largely an illusion). This is why I support keeping cash around and why cash should still be necessary. If crytocurrency is worth anything, it has to be as portable and easy to use as cash is today. And governments tend to seize cash they find moving across borders and so forth, because portable wealth is dangerous to the elites.
- pteredactyl 8y agoRemove government monopoly of money.
- dwild 8y agoI keep saying this but personally I see bitcoin as a good way to transfer value, nothing else. As soon as you consider it that way, it does solve every issue you got with it. You buy bitcoin > You send bitcoin > He get bitcoin > He sell bitcoin, all that hopefully happens in less than a few hours, to avoid market fluctuation the most. The only wallet is at the exchange, hopefully for them, it's moving quickly too. > I am supposed to lay out my entire financial history in a public wallet Don't hold bitcoin, you make a wallet, you buy, you send, you scrap the wallet. > trade with people who I don't know Cryptocurrencies doesn't solve that, HTTPS solve that, you solve that by trust. Sure the old ways to transfer money require less trust from you because you can always revert it by calling your bank, but then it's the other side that need to trust you (and he has much less to works with).
- UncleMeat 8y agoIf you are going to go through an exchange anyway, how is BTC helping you? Both parties still need to trust coinbase or whatever and ultimately the transaction is identical to using venmo.
- dwild 8y agoI can't use Venmo, thus I can't exchange anything between you and me. Cryptocurrencies is this neutral third party that won't care about borders. Venmo could be your exchange, while mine would be something else. That's the beauty of it. We are lucky, we have ways to handle money transfer relatively easily between US and Canada (my country) so that's not so much an issue, but that issue exist.
- UncleMeat 8y agoOkay. So a bank. I bank with foo and can happily send money to you if you bank with bar. How does this function differently?
- mbreedlove 8y ago> I am supposed to lay out my entire financial history in a public wallet (which I don't want) Monero offers an obfuscated public ledger that prevents others from spying on the source, amount, or destination of the transaction.