9 ms·
The Fourth of July wasn’t strongly celebrated until the 90s (after Gulf War I) in the small southern town I was living in during the 80s/90s. Something about st
by seanmcdirmid 8y ago
The Fourth of July wasn’t strongly celebrated until the 90s (after Gulf War I) in the small southern town I was living in during the 80s/90s. Something about still being bitter about the Civil War (which we were taught was not about slavery, but states rights, ugh).
- geggam 8y agoIt was about the right of a state to ignore federal laws regarding slavery due to the economics involved. We are seeing another such issue crop up where the federal govt is declaring weed illegal and the states are saying it is legal. Funny how the DEA can still bust people in legal weed states isnt it ?
- callinyouin 8y agoThe states rights thing is pervasive. I was taught the same thing in a public school all the way up North in Michigan. (late 90s, early 2000s)
- krapp 8y agoIt's just true enough to not be an outright lie, while being enough of a lie of omission to serve its purpose as propaganda. Yes, the Civil War was about states' rights. Yes, the South was fighting for independence from what it saw as Northern political bias and Federal overreach. But all of those ancillary issues were about defending slavery as an economic and cultural institution.
- buu700 8y agoWell said. The meme of "it wasn't at all about states' rights and if you think it was you're a (racist|revisionist|CSA apologist)" is more confusing than persuasive. And that's my perspective as someone who grew up with "war about slavery" as the default interpretation, only learning about contemporary states' rights arguments in later history classes at my (public Virginia) high school. (And then only learning from HN/reddit that "Northern aggression" / "states' rights" propaganda was even still a thing.) I expect someone raised on that propaganda would be even more confused, likely enough to conclude that the speaker is lying or misinformed.
- int_19h 8y agoIt's misleading even then, when you look at the actual complaints of the states (as expressed in their declarations of independence). For example, most of them complained about the free states' pushback to the Fugitive Slave Act, which was also a states' rights issue - but the one where interests of the slaveholders aligned with a stronger federal government strong-arming states; and they didn't have any qualms about that. Similarly, in the Confederate constitution, there were some provisions added that specifically restricted the ability of the states to handle slavery in their jurisdiction - e.g. the "right of transit and sojourn" (which essentially meant that free states were forced to respect the "property right" of any slave-owning citizen of another state who comes to reside there) - this, of course, was in response to Dred Scott.
- wavefunction 8y agoThis exactly, the American Civil War was precipitated by Southern aggression via Dred Scott.
- gizmo686 8y agoSaying it was about slavery is also misleading (although less so than just saying states rights). At the time the civil war started, the North was willing to compromise on the issue of slavery [0]. The North did not fight to abolish slavery. Had the South surrendered earlier (or never seceded at all), they would have been able to keep their slaves [1]. The reason the North fought was to preserve the union (apparently not an answer on the citizenship test). I actually think that preserving the Union is, in some sense, a more technically correct answer, since the South did not start the war [2]. The South declared its independence. The North started the war to prevent the South from gaining its independence [3]. As an aside. Independent of my actual interperatation of history, I think it would be highly unreasonable to deny citizenship to someone for holding a controversial belief that is shared by a significant portion of the country. Like it or not "states rights" is an American interpretation of the Civil war, even if it is one that is not historically accurate. And we really do not want the government to be in a position of dictating the "correct" history. [0] You could argue about how trustworthy the North was. I would argue the main cause of the Civil war was that the South lost confidence that the North was (or would continue) to compromise on this issue. [1] At least for a while. With hindsight, I am sure that slavery would have eventually been abolished in the South as well, and it probably would have been the North that was the primary political force behind it. [2] Fine, they did open the attack of Fort Sumter when the Union refused to withdraw. You could therefor argue that the South did technically start the war, but I find that to be a bit of a stretch. [3] As I mentioned above, this was the primary motivation of the North. The North, at the start, did not continue this sentence with "...so that they could abolish slavery".
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Like it or not "states rights" is an American interpretation of the Civil war, even if it is one that is not historically accurate. More accurately, “states rights” was, at the time of the Civil War, a code word for protecting slavery that was revived during the Jim Crow era as a broader code for protecting segregation and systematic discrimination, and the faction which uses it that way has always been strong enough to play a major role in shaping the national mythology.
- enkid 8y ago
- pulisse 8y ago> But all of those ancillary issues were about defending slavery as an economic and cultural institution. It's insane how often this is disputed when the Confederate states explicitly asserted this in their various declarations of secession. Mississippi's, for example, begins[1]: > In the momentous step, which our State has taken of dissolving its connection with the government of which we so long formed a part, it is but just that we should declare the prominent reasons which have induced our course. > Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery - the greatest material interest of the world. Its labor supplies the product, which constitutes by far the largest and most important portions of commerce of the earth. These products are peculiar to the climate verging on the tropical regions, and by an imperious law of nature, none but the black race can bear exposure to the tropical sun. These products have become necessities of the world, and a blow at slavery is a blow at commerce and civilization. [1] http://www.civil-war.net/pages/mississippi_declaration.asp http://www.civil-war.net/pages/mississippi_declaration.asp
- code_duck 8y agoApparently the idea of giving field workers freedom of self determination and wages didn’t even occur to them.
- snovv_crash 8y agoIt was about states' rights, specifically states' to continue practicing slavery.
- greglindahl 8y agoFederal law protected these rights, and the rights to retrieve fugitive slaves. The southern states objected to northern states ignoring Dred Scott, which was a federal court ruling.
- snovv_crash 8y agoLegally, yes. Just because it is legal doesn't mean it is right though. Moreover, the US was way behind Euope on this issue and I suspect they wouldn't have lasted long until sanctions were imposed on slave-produced goods, especially tobacco and cotton.
- user982 8y agoWas your state one that replaced Martin Luther King Jr. Day with some variation of Robert E. Lee Day?
- paulddraper 8y agoFWIW, I've found that on the other hand, northern schools teach little about the non-slavery motivations for the Civil War. Many people don't realize that both the Confederacy and Union had slavery, or the the Emancipation Proclamation specifically exempted the Union's slaves (as it had to). This triggers a lack of balanced historical perspective and understanding. E.g. many of the naive arguments for razing Confederate history can be applied to US history, European colonist history, Native American history, etc. Without nuance, the conversation becomes a one-sided "we are good and our history is good vs they are bad and their history is bad".
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIt would be more correct to say that there were slave states that didn't succede from the USA. The president couldn't free slaves within the USA by executive order because they were not at war with the USA (enemy territory being where the president could use their power as commander-in-chief)...that instead required the 13th amendment. I went to school in the North as well, and in my opinion, they simply didn't dwell on the Civil War for as long as my Southern school did (a whole semester vs. a couple of weeks). It makes sense...the Civil War doesn't have much locality in Seattle while it has a lot of locality in Vicksburg.
- paulddraper 8y ago> It would be more correct to say that there were slave states that didn't succeded from the USA. Absolutely. Succession (being part of issue of "states' rights") was a huge part of the Civil War. > The president couldn't free slaves within the USA by executive order Indeed; I pointed that fact out myself. There's no question that the man Abraham Lincoln was anti-slavery but could not himself end it. There's also no question that the man Robert E. Lee opposed Virginia's succession but not himself stop it. The fact remains that as a whole the Union still had slaves, and that didn't change for the entirety of the Civil War. In fact, assuming you believe the Union's authority was legitimate, slavery was outlaws in the South years before it was in the North. My point is there's obviously things going on here other than just a war to end slavery, and it's important not to downplay that either. --- FWIW, I'd call Seattle "the West".
- danielvf 8y agoThe first day I saw more US flags than Confederate flags in my small southern town was the day after 9/11. As you said, the fervently believed myth was that the confederacy was about states rights - growing up I only met one person in twenty years who even went so far as making a rasict joke, and I knew plenty who flew a Confederate flag and absolutely believed that all men were created equal. I think maybe the myth ended up being a useful way of letting people keep their old flag and old team allegiance, while completely changing the what they actually believed. That said, the Fourth of July and Thanksgiving were always celebrated.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYa, I think the first gulf war was a turning point in Southern patriotism, and 9/11 even more so (though I wasn't in the south then). Its funny how the stereotype today of the south is of ultra-patriotism when it wasn't too long ago that the exact opposite was true.
- sudosteph 8y agoYeah, that's consistent with what I've experienced too. Though I almost wonder if its association with Dukes of Hazzard that really cemented it's place as an "identity" symbol for a certain group of southerners (lower/working class white male). The run on US flags after 9/11 was something else. I remember when my mom begrudgingly bought a flag magnet 2 weeks after it all. Apparently the neighbors were giving her side-eye for having the only flagless pickup truck on the street.
- mvexel 8y ago"States' rights" is actually one of the valid answers to question 74 on the naturalization civics test. ("Name one problem that led to the Civil War.") Now I wonder what process led to these 100 questions, and their valid answers. (I just took the test a few weeks ago, and becoming a U.S. citizen on Monday.) The full list of questions and valid answers is here: https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Office%20of%20Citizenship/Citizenship%20Resource%20Center%20Site/Publications/100q.pdf https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Office%20of%...
- nvader 8y agoCongratulations!
- oculusthrift 8y agoyep. states rights to make their own laws about slavery superseding the national law
- greglindahl 8y agoYes, this is main way that States Rights affected the Civil War: northern states ignoring federal law and federal court rulings about returning escaped slaves. I can see several folks in this very discussion who might be surprised by this bit of history. Edit: so far two different people think I am mischaracterizing what Southern states said at the time about their state's rights. I wasn't talking about that at all. I was talking about how I (and many modern historians) think about Southern states' reaction to Dred Scott and how Northern states ignored it. Please respond to what I said, instead of something I did not say.
- Delmania 8y agoThis is also wrong. The Civil War was about slavery. There's a speech in which a defining characteristic of the confederacy is slavery. Keep playing revisionist history.
- 8y ago
- tropo 8y agoThere is just as much "ugh" in saying that it was about slavery instead of state's rights. Either way, you're leaving out important things. This misleads by oversimplification. You'd be better off saying it was about geography! There is a band of soil running along today's black belt that is unusually good for growing certain labor-intensive crops, particularly cotton. That lead to a non-industrial economy. Meanwhile, water power to operate machinery was widely available in New England. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Belt_(U.S._region) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Belt_(U.S._region) So right off, you have a huge conflict over things like tariffs, and you'd have that even without adding the issue of slaves. The north preferred to have tariffs on manufactured goods, and the south preferred to have them on raw materials. The "state's right" in question was actually the nullification of a tariff. BTW, the usual story about slavery in the USA also leaves out the awkwardness of stuff like this slave owner: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthony_Johnson_(colonist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthony_Johnson_(colonist)
- mturmon 8y agoInstead of after-the-fact musings on the role of geography, it would be smart to read what the Confederate states themselves said their reasons were for seceding. For instance, Mississippi [1]. The first two sentences of the Mississippi secession document read: "In the momentous step which our State has taken of dissolving its connection with the government of which we so long formed a part, it is but just that we should declare the prominent reasons which have induced our course. Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery-- the greatest material interest of the world." [1] http://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/csa_missec.asp http://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/csa_missec.asp
- noobiemcfoob 8y agoThis argument always trots out Mississippi's declaration. Show me evidence from the CSA leadership as a whole, and I'd let the point stand without contention.
- jonnybgood 8y ago
- bunderbunder 8y agoThat has always seemed like such an odd and obvious bit of sophistry to me. States' right to do do what now?
- FlyMoreRockets 8y agoNo doubt, it was about slavery. However, it was also about economics. Slave labor really changes the equation when manual labor is needed for production. This is especially relevant in the current model, where businesses of a certain size can afford to overcome shipping costs and enjoy lowered costs of production in emerging economies.
- paulddraper 8y agoIndeed. Tariffs (primarily affecting manufactured goods) was a huge point of contention, rivaled only by the slavery issue. During the Civil War there was "Cotton diplomacy" [1] where the South tried to pull Britain and France onto its side, under the presumption that their need for cotton would win out. Despite the cotton famine [2] they managed to stay neutral. Anyway...economics (then and now) are king. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cotton_diplomacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cotton_diplomacy [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lancashire_Cotton_Famine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lancashire_Cotton_Famine
- bunderbunder 8y agoI've never really bought that story, in that form. It tacitly suggests that the South's economy was stronger with slavery than without. It seems more likely to me, though, that reliance on slavery was part of why the South's economy ended up being so weak in the first place. It allowed money to remain concentrated in the hands of a small, landed elite. That worked out extremely well for them relative to their neighbors, but also would have fueled a sort of falling tide that sinks all boats. Which isn't to say that it doesn't change the economic equation if you take it away. But it's more tenable to say that the reason people were willing to go to war over it was more about the economics of power than about economics in general.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> The Fourth of July wasn’t strongly celebrated until the 90s (after Gulf War I) in the small southern town I was living in during the 80s/90s Vacationed in Charleston a few months ago. Dropped into the Old Slave Mart Museum [1]. I learned something, there, that for the first time made the Civil War make sense (from the Southern perspective). Imagine a Southern plantation owner's balance sheet. What do you think would be the most valuable asset? I used to think it would be land, buildings and equipment. But it wasn't. It was enslaved people. Something like 90% of the wealth of Southern land owners was in their human capital. Most of those enslaved people weren't owned outright–they were leveraged. Most bills of sale I saw said 1/3 cash down with the rest to be paid in installments. Much of the down payment, it turns out, was also borrowed. (Enslaved people being mobile, fungible assets meant creditors valued them as collateral.) So, in summary, you had the wealthiest people in these states being leveraged to the point of ruin on their enslaved populations. That meant their banking system depended on the continuing value of the South's enslaved people. (New York, too, though to a lesser degree, but I digress.) So the calculus wasn't "we keep slaves and stay very rich, or give them up and become less rich." It was "slaves or bust." This is why the Gettysburg address hit like a thermobaric blast front--it amounted to a rebooting of the South's elite ranks. [1] http://www.oldslavemartmuseum.com http://www.oldslavemartmuseum.com
- jonnycomputer 8y agoI knew, of course, that slaves were integral to the economy of the south, and to the wealth of elites. But I had not known, though it is obvious in retrospect, how intertwined the trade was in the banking sector (like the real-estate market). All the more perverse.
- lsc 8y agoSure, that explains why the elites fought; what I still don't get was why the average white southern enlisted man fought. I mean, sure, it's clear why the elites wanted the war. But for the average white southern laborer, slavery did nothing but push down wages; It's hard to ask for a raise if the boss can just buy someone to do what you do. The explanations I've heard were nonsensical (that the average white southern man fought because it was in the interests of the elite southern man) or assume the southerner was just... evil (the average white southern man fought so that there would at least be something below him.) I find both of those explanations really unsatisfactory, because they assume that non-elite white southerners are either stupid or evil to the point where they will start an extremely brutal war who's explicit aims are to preserve the wealth of the elite at the cost of everyone else. This seems... unlikely.