16 ms·
For Decades, Southern States Saw Thanksgiving as an Act of Northern Aggression
- andrewclunn 8y agoSweet potatoes now, sweet potatoes forever!
- aylmao 8y agotldr; Thanksgiving was traditionally celebrated in the north, with "northern" food, and after it was made a national holiday by Lincoln the confederate states refused to acknowledge it. I'm curious about Native Americans though. A lot of their culture and resistance has been lost today, but back around the birth of the holiday I can imagine them finding it offensive and being vocal about it, if not due to politics and tradition, due to the hypocrisy of it.
- jt2190 8y agoSmithsonian magazine has a number of articles that try to bring more balance to the history. Everyone's history matters: The Wampanoag Indian Thanksgiving story deserves to be known https://www.smithsonianmag.com/blogs/national-museum-american-indian/2017/11/23/everyones-history-matters-and-wampanoag-indian-thanksgiving-story-deserves-be-known/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/blogs/national-museum-america...
- geggam 8y agoNative Americans are still one of the most ignored groups, I think they quit being vocal due to the fact it's a lost cause.
- faitswulff 8y ago> I think they quit being vocal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakota_Access_Pipeline_protests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dakota_Access_Pipeline_protest...
- geggam 8y agolost cause ?
- faitswulff 8y agoI'm just saying that Native Americans are still around and still vocal. Native Americans are still politically active and the first Native American women were even voted into office this year: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Native_Americans_in_the_United_States_Congress#Members-Elect_of_the_House_of_Representatives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Native_Americans_in_th...
- geggam 8y agoAs part Meskwaki and living in AZ next to several reservations I am aware. Still a lost cause
- stevenwoo 8y agoUm, not yet. The Cherokee are claiming half of Oklahoma https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/11/.../576238/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/11/.../576238... The Sioux have refused to accept what has turned into about a billion dollar fee offered by the US federal government in exchange for the Black Hills of South Dakota and since the Sioux have not accepted it, the tribe claim that they still own it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Hills_Land_Claim https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Hills_Land_Claim
- geggam 8y agoConsidering the trillions of dollars in land stolen from them I wouldnt call this any sort of compensation
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dbcurtis 8y agoRealise that Thanksgiving as we have mythologized it today is entirely synthetic. There are only one or two sentences about it on the Pilgrim history, and those are sparse on facts. The traditional menu is one that happened to be served one year at Harvard. For some reason lost to history, it became the de facto traditional menu.
- vinay427 8y agoThe menu differs so much by region, culture, and family that at this point it's honestly hard to describe any as a "de facto traditional menu."
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThe Fourth of July wasn’t strongly celebrated until the 90s (after Gulf War I) in the small southern town I was living in during the 80s/90s. Something about still being bitter about the Civil War (which we were taught was not about slavery, but states rights, ugh).
- geggam 8y agoIt was about the right of a state to ignore federal laws regarding slavery due to the economics involved. We are seeing another such issue crop up where the federal govt is declaring weed illegal and the states are saying it is legal. Funny how the DEA can still bust people in legal weed states isnt it ?
- callinyouin 8y agoThe states rights thing is pervasive. I was taught the same thing in a public school all the way up North in Michigan. (late 90s, early 2000s)
- krapp 8y agoIt's just true enough to not be an outright lie, while being enough of a lie of omission to serve its purpose as propaganda. Yes, the Civil War was about states' rights. Yes, the South was fighting for independence from what it saw as Northern political bias and Federal overreach. But all of those ancillary issues were about defending slavery as an economic and cultural institution.
- buu700 8y agoWell said. The meme of "it wasn't at all about states' rights and if you think it was you're a (racist|revisionist|CSA apologist)" is more confusing than persuasive. And that's my perspective as someone who grew up with "war about slavery" as the default interpretation, only learning about contemporary states' rights arguments in later history classes at my (public Virginia) high school. (And then only learning from HN/reddit that "Northern aggression" / "states' rights" propaganda was even still a thing.) I expect someone raised on that propaganda would be even more confused, likely enough to conclude that the speaker is lying or misinformed.
- alexpw 8y ago"Modern Thanksgiving was first officially called for in all states in 1863 by a presidential proclamation of Abraham Lincoln. [...]Lincoln proclaimed a national Thanksgiving on the final Thursday in November, explicitly in celebration of the bounties that had continued to fall on the Union and for the military successes in the war." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanksgiving https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanksgiving It's easy to see why the "Southern States Saw Thanksgiving as an Act of Nothern Aggression" from Lincoln's action. He extended the meaning of the celebration to include victory of the North over the South, and asked the South to observe it, according to wikipedia.
- cma 8y agoIn the actual words he seems to say notwithstanding the loss of life from war: >Population has steadily increased, notwithstanding the waste that has been made in the camp, the siege and the battle-field; and the country, rejoicing in the consciousness of augmented strength and vigor, is permitted to expect continuance of years with large increase of freedom. Freedom only decreased if you saw black slaves as non-human. They were a majority of the population in many southern states. "Southern states saw" in the headline is probably ignoring the black population, but I'm not sure. It was only many years later that there were large migrations, after the reconstruction promises passed them over, "vagrancy" was heavily outlawed, and they effectively lost the vote.
- omegaworks 8y ago>It was only many years later that there were large migrations, after the reconstruction promises passed them over, "vagrancy" was heavily outlawed, and they effectively lost the vote. That's a really careful glossing over of the coordinated white supremacist terror campaigns that drove newly emancipated black Americans from their homes in the South. Olivia Hooker, the last eyewitness to the only bombs dropped on continental America, passed just last Wednesday at the age of 103. Her story is an incredible reminder of the sheer capacity for hate that remains unaccounted for in America still today: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/13/opinion/olivia-hooker-tulsa-race-riot.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/13/opinion/olivia-hooker-tul...
- mistrial9 8y agovery surprising but .. an educated and ancestral U.S. Southener just said in response, "I have never heard of this"
- discoball 8y agoFor Decades, Southern States Saw People of Color as Sub-human. Therefore, who cares what southern states do. Down vote to your satisfaction.
- wavefunction 8y agoThis is an interesting subject. The 4th of July is not celebrated in Utah as it is in other states: instead that same energy and celebration goes into Utah's "Pioneer Days." This divergence from the rest of the nation provides some insight into the history of Utah and the people who settled it, and their relationship to the greater United States. Personally, I don't think it reflects positively but that's just my opinion on another interesting divergence in national tradition.
- ngngngng 8y agoNative Utahn here. 4th of July seems just the same here as it does anywhere else i've lived. We basically just have a round 2 on pioneer day.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoMore: The Mormons were intending to leave the United States and start their own country. When they came to Utah (1847), much of it was still Mexican territory. They celebrate the day that commemorates them trying to leave the US as hard as they celebrate the 4th of July. Note well: This does not make Utah Mormons less patriotic... just a bit historically schizophrenic.
- emilsedgh 8y agoAs an Iranian Jewish-born atheist who grew up in Iran and now lives in the U.S, I celebrate Hannuklah, Nowrooz (Iranian new year), Rosh Hashanah, Thanksgiving, Christmas, and any other fun holiday you would throw at us. I think we live in a world that nobody gives a fuck about reasons and true meanings behind things. Fuck history I wanna party!
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoWell, for what it's worth, I think the west needs more Muslims. I mean, why do we have weekends? It's basically Saturday because of the Jews, and Sunday because of the Christians. Well, the Muslims' holy day is Friday. Three day weekend every week? Yeah, sign me up. This is not an endorsement of Islam as a theology. But culturally, I'm down.
- tropo 8y agoAnother obscure Thanksgiving fact: Thanksgiving is commonly known as a celebration of a good harvest, but the reason why the harvest was good is seldom remembered. Plymouth Colony was originally communal. Marx was far from the first to think that "from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs" might be a good idea. Such thinking dates back to Plato at least, and in 1620 the colony actually tried it. Nobody wanted to do the work, though everybody had needs. After 2.5 years, with half the colony dead, Plymouth governor William Bradford decided to prioritize survival over the ideals of socialism. The resulting harvest was plentiful, giving reason to celebrate Thanksgiving. https://www.forbes.com/2008/11/27/thanksgiving-economy-history-oped-cx_jb_1127bowyer.html https://www.forbes.com/2008/11/27/thanksgiving-economy-histo... It's a lesson people are starting to forget. We'll probably try again, and maybe somehow things won't turn out the same as every previous time.
- FlyMoreRockets 8y agoFTFY > After 2.5 years, with half the colony dead... ...the socialist natives took pity on the starving Europeans and helped their fellow humans. Good luck with the rest of your rewrite of history.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't take this or any HN thread into ideological flamewar. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- pokemongoaway 8y agoPlease stop censoring me. I've asked and made good arguments for each of my comments and you just ignore me. You are in the wrong dang; you are the censor.
- pokemongoaway 8y agoDang's and HN's censorship is getting pretty disgusting. You're supposedly allowed to reply to comments with your support, but in reality that is a joke. They get killed before you can and then you cannot reply at all. What's with the censorship of thanosnose's comment in this thread and many others? You just don't like his politics, dang? I've more than proven myself too - and I'm still shadow banned... We've had extensive emailing and I've offered plenty of proof that others have tried to support my previous comments that got me the shadow ban (which you ignored). I've also learned how many others have been banned too. We will support each other's right to not constantly make new accounts to voice basic, consistent, and evidence-supported opinions, dang! Absolutely ridiculous.