5 ms·
>Apple is already privacy focused. Says you (and say them). >I can imagine what it could be (mistrust of closed source, big corporations) but they never say s
by andrepd 8y ago
>Apple is already privacy focused.
Says you (and say them).
>I can imagine what it could be (mistrust of closed source, big corporations) but they never say so.
Yes, that's exactly it. With proprietary software I have no idea what my device is doing. Maybe they're spying on me! Maybe they aren't! Who knows!
The reasoning behind the people that say "Apple respects privacy" is always "because they say so".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- EugeneOZ 8y ago"Says you" works in both directions. Apple at least has that case whith FBI, anti-proprietary activists have just their doubts. Would be interesting to read some story about traffic analysis with some suspicious activities, but all I see is just compilation of doubts and talks about what is possible.
- codedokode 8y agoApple also has a case where it transferred Chinese users' data to China government.
- natch 8y agoI am very curious to learn more details about how they handled this, with specifics.
- JKCalhoun 8y ago> Maybe they're spying on me! Maybe they aren't! Who knows! I suspect we would all know if Apple were spying on us. Really think there still secrets anymore?
- dleslie 8y agoOf course there are huge secrets that have yet to be revealed. If there's anything to learn from the 20th century it's that huge projects can be maintained in relative secrecy from the public so long as the denial is plausible. After all, it's become clear that "secret" is not sufficiently revealed when those convinced of its truth are regarded as cranks and crazies. I'm certain that decades hence we will be shocked to discover what is going on now, under our noses.
- donarb 8y agoWith a billion iOS devices out there, if Apple was truly collecting information about you and selling it to third parties, there would have to be some evidence that compromised data is out in the wild. To date, no one has found any. So it's pretty safe to say that yes, you can trust Apple.
- mynameisvlad 8y ago> With proprietary software I have no idea what my device is doing. Maybe they're spying on me! Maybe they aren't! Who knows! This is entirely untrue. You can sniff the outgoing connections to see what data is being sent. Here's instructions for how to do it on a Mac: https://medium.com/@jamesmarino/monitoring-ios-https-network-traffic-a5d9fbe0edfe https://medium.com/@jamesmarino/monitoring-ios-https-network... On Windows, a similar thing can be achieved through Fiddler.
- amelius 8y agoYou can't: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganography
- mynameisvlad 8y agoOh please. Take your tinfoil hat off. Hell, take your tinfoil suit off. Apple's biggest claim to fame in the last few years has been defending users' privacy. It is in their best interest to be as transparent about this as possible because any revelation that they are publicly saying X and privately doing the opposite is going to completely tank them as a company. They're not about to jeopardize their entire company by going so far as concealing tracking information in other information that is transmitted from the device. Especially while at the same time going so far as implementing many security and privacy features like FileVault, E2E encryption, and the Secure Enclave. Everything they have said and done, and analysis of the data that leaves their devices points to them not doing it. Sure, it's theoretically possible. But it's about as far from probable as Pluto is from Earth.
- andrepd 8y ago>Apple's biggest claim to fame in the last few years has been defending users' privacy. The vast majority of Apple's buyers don't know or don't care about privacy. To assert "this is their biggest claim to fame" is ludicrous. >It is in their best interest to be as transparent about this as possible This is still the only argument for Apple that I've ever seen. They maybe aren't doing this, because maybe it doesn't make business sense for them, and maybe we could detect it if they were. Nothing about this is solid; for me it's just wishful thinking. >any revelation that they are publicly saying X and privately doing the opposite is going to completely tank them as a company Literally hundreds of companies have been caught doing the exact same thing and next to none of them have "tanked". >Especially while at the same time going so far as implementing many security and privacy features like [...] Secure Enclave. The Secure Enclave is an unauditable chip running god knows what software. Completely outside your control; someone else has the power to dictate what it does and doesn't do. The notion of paying money for my device and having it subject to the control of someone else is... like buying a car with my own money and having it be controlled by someone else.
- mcintyre1994 8y agoNot a lawyer, but I'd assume Apple's marketing, public statements and explicit messaging on device about privacy would restrict them at least in markets like Europe? Surely they'd be into unlawful false advertising at this point.
- greglindahl 8y agoIn the US, you have to do what you say you are doing in your privacy policy, and the government enforces that.