10 ms·
Home prices vary inversely with interest rates. Here's how that works: 1) person tells bank they'd like a mortgage to buy a house. 2) banker asks for info on
by phkahler 8y ago
Home prices vary inversely with interest rates. Here's how that works:
1) person tells bank they'd like a mortgage to buy a house.
2) banker asks for info on income, expenses, etc.
3) banker estimates persons maximum monthly payment.
4) banker figures out max loan amount based on #3
5) buyer is encouraged by everyone to spend the full amount from #4
Everyone - the seller, their agent, your agent, the bank, and maybe some others - want you to spend every penny you can. Everyone benefits from higher prices except the buyer. Even if you're immune to it, there is enough pressure that the market as a whole tends toward the highest prices people can afford.
Now lets see how interest rates play in this. At step 4 above, the amount you can borrow for a given monthly payment is mathematically increased by lower interest rates. For a given amount of debt your payment should be lower if rates are lower - that's true - but they'll make up for it by pushing a larger loan.
Ultimately your payment is determined in step 3 and has nothing to do with interest rates or home prices. You will "pay" the same for your house (total payments) regardless of interest rates. The only thing the interest rate determines is who gets the money - the seller or the bank.
In a services and consumption based economy this is the primary way interest rates drive things. Sure, businesses will do their part too, but they're a smaller part of it.
- travisoneill1 8y agoEven if the majority of people choose the max they can afford, it doesn't follow that individuals can't freely choose cheaper houses for themselves.
- nly 8y agoIndividual action doesn't matter. If you're only willing to spend 30% of your take home pay on rent, whereas your sociodemographic twin is willing to pay 50%, they'll outbid you. Incidentally I currently spend 47% of my take-home on rent in London. At 32, buying a property is still out of my reach. There are statistics on this in this related BBC article https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42179119 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42179119
- malvosenior 8y agoI don’t think they’ll outbid you, they’ll buy a more expensive house.
- mamon 8y agoAnd you think you'll be able to find a cheaper house? No, sorry: sellers will raise their asking price to match (or exceed) the market average. So, your choice really is between paying the same price as everybody else or not buy a house at all.
- malvosenior 8y agoEvery house does not cost the same amount. Yes, the average price might go up, but in my experience people will buy the biggest house they can afford instead of over bidding on a smaller house (in most markets).
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThey will when supply is constrained.
- malvosenior 8y agoI think this is a minority of real estate markets (mainly SF and Vancouver). Even in NY there's enough of a spread that someone making 250k a year will have the option of buying a house under their max buying potential.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> They will when supply is constrained. The point of the article is supposed to be that the issue isn't supply constraints. If interest rates only raise prices significantly when supply can't respond to higher demand, how is the problem interest rates rather than supply constraints?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 8y ago>> Even if the majority of people choose the max they can afford, it doesn't follow that individuals can't freely choose cheaper houses for themselves. The entire market is affected by this. You might spend less on a house, but the price of that house has already been influenced by the overall market. Homes in that price range are still at the maximum for people in some income range.
- travisoneill1 8y agoCorrect. You will get less house for your money than you would if houses were not in high demand. Same as the price of everything else works. And if other people want to spend more than you on houses why shouldn't they?
- simonh 8y agoNobody is saying they shouldn’t, I have done exactly this, buying a house by taking the maximum mortgage I could afford to get the nices house I could get. We are just discussing the mechanism and forces at play and the role of interest rates.
- astura 8y agoNobody said they shouldn't, we are discussing how interest rates effect the housing market as a whole.
- mabbo 8y ago> Ultimately your payment is determined in step 3 and has nothing to do with interest rates. This presumes a single purchase. You've got to go 'macro economic' to see where this breaks down. When prices start rising because of increased max loan amounts, you get things like bidding wars. Toronto has been terrible for those in the last 5 years. Both the bank and the seller win when people start paying (and borrowing) twice as much as they would have for the same house 5 years ago. Belief that home values are higher and will rise causes them to do so (bubbles, yay). Example, personal: I bought my condo for under $600k 3.5 years ago. The neighbour is selling their nearly identical one today for just shy of $1m. (CAD$, but still insane). Interest rates are higher today than they were when I bought. My new neighbours will pay higher amounts to both the bank and the seller. There's more to prices than just interest rates.
- zippy5 8y agoHowever, the problem is that loans are an extrapolation of 30 years of income. So in a boom portion of the cycle, we over project an unsustainable income but in the bust portion, we under project. There is an inherit recency bias in the loan approval process. When coupled with an interest rates that are far below the historical median, there is an implication that a buyer can take out more debt than in any other economic conditions. This is a great resource to understand macroeconomic debt cycles: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PHe0bXAIuk0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PHe0bXAIuk0 However in a place like Toronto, I imagine there could be a lots of regional factor that would be more significant than interest rates: - Gentrification - Zoning Restrictions - Increase in Population - Geographic constraints (like bridges, freeways, school districts) Personally, I suspect you'll do quite well in Toronto but every housing market faces headwinds at some point.
- 01100011 8y agoAnd on the flip side, you can assume some level of inflation which makes that 30 year bet on your income less crazy. Sure, I don't expect to make 200k+ in inflation adjusted dollars for 30 years, but I might make that much after inflation devalues the dollar.
- 8y ago
- pjc50 8y agoNot everyone is mortgaged - quite a lot of the price rises are driven by foreign capital flight. A few places have figured this out and decided to tax it: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-02-20/british-columbia-extends-housing-crackdown-with-tax-increases https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-02-20/british-c...
- clofresh 8y agoI've noticed this annecdotally when trying to buy a home on separate occasions in the New York and LA metro areas. I'm not sure it's foreign capital, but the majority of winning bids were all cash offers above the asking price. I'd love to see a retrospective analysis on Vancouver's protective measures to see if they did actually help, or if buyers found loopholes, or it wasn't Chinese buyers to begin with.
- jedberg 8y agoI wish I could find the link now, but someone did a study on Vancouver and found that the tax had no effect on housing prices. The foreign buyers simply added it as another cost of parking their money outside of their country (usually China) and the math still worked in their favor. It brought in some extra money to Vancouver though.
- ttul 8y agoOf course it’s impossible to say with complete certainty, but... Vancouver’s housing market has stalled since the foreign buyer tax and vacancy taxes started to bite. Inventories are high and stubbornly stuck there rather than falling as they do toward the end of the year. Prices on high end homes are down a great deal - 20-30% for homes priced higher than $3M. I would say that at this early stage it looks like the new taxes are working precisely as intended.
- Jack000 8y agoI think the confounding factor is that the tax would move the market whether or not foreign buyers are an issue. The price drops are also mostly at the top end of the market, which benefits wealthy buyers.
- rustcharm 8y agoThis is why Government backed mortgages and mortgage interest deductions don't really save any homebuyers money, and just end up costing the taxpaying public.
- projectramo 8y agoYou have the mechanism right but I think you draw the wrong conclusion. Your max amount changes with interest rates. So if interest rates rise your max amount goes down for the same payment and house prices go down.
- phkahler 8y ago>> Home prices vary inversely with interest rates. That's exactly what I said. inversely means opposite.
- projectramo 8y agoWell then this is just false: “Ultimately your payment is determined in step 3 and has nothing to do with interest rates or home prices.” You can’t have it both ways.
- esotericn 8y ago> The only thing the interest rate determines is who gets the money - the seller or the bank. It seems here like you've forgotten that even though your payment may not vary, what you get will (e.g. will it be further out, smaller, apartment not house, worse neighbourhood)... Or, ultimately, at the bottom end, your 'maximum monthly payment' isn't enough to buy at all so you rent forever (London, for anyone who isn't in a well paying field). Consider - you'll probably be working 8 hours a week. For various reasons we settle on roughly that. But some people get paid very well and others don't. That matters regardless of whether everyone works 8 hours a week because most people don't retire early even if they could.
- robocat 8y ago> isn't enough to buy at all so you rent forever And landlords are willing to get a mortgage that can be paid for by the rent (modulo speculation). "you'll probably be working 8 hours a week" - what?
- esotericn 8y agoThe last bit is an analogy. The idea that your payment is fixed and so the only thing that varies is the proportion allocated to different external parties makes no sense, because you're not buying the same thing. People don't look at a house and say "I want that" and buy it. They look within their maximum payment range. What exists within that range is hugely influenced by external factors. The analogy with an 8h work week would be that everyone 'pays' 8 hours a day for their free time so every other factor is irrelevant. Of course it's not; the particular job you end up with for your 8 hours (influenced both by your personal skill but also the external market) has a massive impact on your QoL.
- simonh 8y agoI don’t think the poster is forgetting anything, just pointing out that the amount of money going into the housing market and bidding up house prices is directly based on interest rates.
- lordnacho 8y agoThe thing to think about is convexity. If everyone is maxing out their budget when rates are 2%, it causes a huge problem for their personal budget when rates go up to 4%. If the rate was originally 10% like a few decades ago, each rate increment would matter a lot less.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoYes, we could be in for a lot of pain if inflation and interest rates rise over the coming years.
- rsync 8y ago"Yes, we could be in for a lot of pain if inflation and interest rates rise over the coming years." This is true, but I think unlikely ... All macro trends - especially demographics and birthrates - point to large deflationary headwinds. The little bit of inflation that we experience currently is the result of massive manipulations like quantitative easing and related policies. Just look at the price of oil ... even the peak 2018 price is quite low when compared against the last ten years.[1] Nobody can know how this will pan out, but I think a reasonable guess is that as QE is allowed to unwind we experience recessionary forces that we are no longer willing to accept or able to withstand - given the increased fragility and interconnectedness of our economies. And so we will see QE3 and QE4 and so on, with related ZIRP[2], until we finally see a deflationary collapse. That could play out over decades. I don't know how you could shrewdly prepare for such a sequence of events, since the correct way to prepare for deflation is to have liquid, cash assets and those assets would be almost completely idle during the ZIRP period (like the one we are living in). I suspect the only way we would see real inflation is if political actors made political decisions to massively overshoot the QE (and related) policies. Even then, we would not see high interest rates unless some later actor decided to "correct" that inflation. [1] https://www.macrotrends.net/1369/crude-oil-price-history-chart https://www.macrotrends.net/1369/crude-oil-price-history-cha... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_interest-rate_policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_interest-rate_policy
- 8y ago
- mattm 8y agoIt's crazy how this isn't more common knowledge that the Economist needs to write an article about it. We're also seeing the same thing recently with tuition prices. There is more money available for student loans so schools just jack up the tuition to meet the supply of money available.
- Retric 8y agoThat’s not just a question of loans. Schools can always discount prices down to what people can pay. So, they charge families making twice as much more money each year.
- paulddraper 8y agoIt's insane what schools can get away with for price discrimination. Remember the uproar over Orbitz (and others) price discrimination based on Mac/iOS usage? [1] Schools have been doing the same thing in broad daylight for years and years with far greater consequence, basing their price on your parent's income levels.* And near zero public blowback. It's confusing. * This is all done through school scholarships, but there's practical difference between that and a more direct price adjustment. [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304458604577488822667325882 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304458604577488...
- closeparen 8y agoIt’s an informal social program. The rich subsidize everyone else.
- Retric 8y agoNot so much the rich as like social security the cost caps out fairly low. Save on the low end ~100$ to high end ~500$ a month from birth and collage is mostly paid for via compound interest. That’s expensive, but students with 100+k in debt mostly don’t go to affordable schools.
- brownbat 8y agoI expected this was true for the same reasoning when buying a home, but when I sampled the historical numbers, there was no strong relationship. Bankrate came to similar conclusions: https://www.bankrate.com/finance/mortgages/rising-rates-lower-house-prices.aspx https://www.bankrate.com/finance/mortgages/rising-rates-lowe... I think your reasoning is valid, so best I can figure it's because home prices and interest rates are both directly correlated with economic activity. So if the economy is heating up, that might drive up wages and interest rates and inflation, and you see interest rates and home prices go up in parallel. The model of two simple variables tugging on each other breaks down when you add other factors, hence the weak relationship.
- wtvanhest 8y agoLowering interest rates increase prices. Rising interest rates reduce volume until inflation catches up. People are unwilling to sell homes when they lose value because there is so much leverage
- jeromegv 8y agoUp until they have no choice but to sell, and in that case, have to sell at any cost.
- Apes 8y agoI don't believe your analysis. The relationship has such a high correlation, you can just look at the the graph and probably eyeball estimate the regression within 10% error. Banks and relators have such a massive conflict of interest in pretending that the inflated prices on housing are normal. Rising interest rates are causing housing sales volumes to plummet to record lows, and after over a year of pretending nothing was wrong, prices are finally starting to come down. But the people invested in the housing market want to pretend it's anything other than the interest rate, like a child caught with their hand in the cookie jar and making up nonsensical explanations on why it happened.
- brownbat 8y ago
- tomxor 8y ago> You will "pay" the same for your house (total payments) regardless of interest rates. There is a missing branch in your procedure... step 4b) Banker refuses loan because combination of interest rates and house prices are too high for person to afford with current income: > In 1991, 67% of British 25- to 34-year-olds owned property; today only 37% do. I suspect this varying cut-off threshold of a substantial portion of the population is largely responsible in the apparent non-simplistic relationship between the other variables.
- laurencerowe 8y agoI think that change is better explained by the higher deposits required under the present high asset price low interest rate regime. The UK base rate was around 12% in 1991 and it is 0.5% today. If you assume an equal mortgage payment you now need a deposit 4 or 5 times as large to get on the housing ladder.
- jnordwick 8y agoDo you have any experience with real estate or bonds, or is this just your pet theory. While this sounds great to people who love to hate on anything financial, it is entirely wrong. You're basically arguing that more risk (larger loan) is cheaper. But of course, if you were right, you could point to good data in this. (Remember to properly adjust for credit quality which is probably proportional to housing price.)
- closeparen 8y agoThe problem of “high house prices” is just imprecise language for “high cost of housing” - whether the cost is interest or principal is not terribly consequential.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The problem of “high house prices” is just imprecise language for “high cost of housing” - whether the cost is interest or principal is not terribly consequential. It actually is, because it affects what can be done about it. If costs are high because interest rates are high, buyers can lower their costs by paying down principal or taking a shorter mortgage. It's frequently the case that, because most of the payment is taxes, insurance and interest, a 30 year mortgage is e.g. $1500/month whereas a 15 year mortgage is only $1700/month, and the difference between them shrinks as interest rates rise (and original principal amounts fall). Which means more people can afford to stop having a mortgage payment after 15 years rather than 30. It should also result in less resistance to densification, because people are less worried about home values when they're lower to begin with.
- noitsnot 8y agoI question it because this is how our worked for me. Maybe other people want something they can barely afford most of the time? 1. I go to banker for mortgage. 2. Banker asks how much I would like to spend and gets financials. 3. Approved 4. I go to real estate agent and say this is what I was approved for. Never was there any pushback. I was far below my max limit.
- smileysteve 8y agoMost people seem to do #4 first; which includes a "how much do you want to spend" but then is easily passed to "how much can you afford" then to 1,2,3.
- mmcnl 8y agoThe article states there is a weak relationship between house prices and interest rates (with examples).
- nzealand 8y agoHistorically, it is more about construction costs and comparable rent prices. http://www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/data/Fig3-1.xls http://www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/data/Fig3-1.xls
- pjmorris 8y agoCan you describe how you reached your conclusion from the data in the spreadsheet? I don't see any of the three series correlating particularly strongly with house prices. My own pet theory is that adding the Fed's QE purchases to the graph would show stronger correlation than the series that are present.
- nzealand 8y agoPopulation and construction costs are a loose correlation with housing prices, but I dont see any correlation with interest rates. http://lenkiefer.com/2017/12/20/state-population-growth-and-house-prices/ http://lenkiefer.com/2017/12/20/state-population-growth-and-... Here is the graph showing QE vs housing prices. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=mbAe https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=mbAe
- pjmorris 8y agoThanks... I look at the QE vs. housing prices graph and see plausible correlation. My bias, supported by the graph: "With house prices dropping, the Fed steps in to bail mortgage lenders out, keeping prices at their elevated levels"
- arbuge 8y ago> Home prices vary inversely with interest rates. This is true if all else is equal. In theory, however, the Fed is supposed to raise interest rates when the economy is heating up, which implies buyers are being paid higher salaries, which implies their income (step 2 of your chain) is higher. In theory this could neutralize some or all of the effect of the interest rate increase.
- winter_blue 8y ago> ...want you to spend every penny you can. Everyone benefits from higher prices except the buyer. Even if you're immune to it, there is enough pressure that the market as a whole tends toward the highest prices people can afford. This is definitely an American cultural phenomenon. Taking on massive debt is no trivial matter, and I can't imagine people buckling to peer pressure on something that will affect them so significantly. It's dumb, financially unsound, and irresponsible. I know for a fact that South Asian/Indian heritage will (generally) never allow themselves to financially shafted like this. (The Indian people I know are usually very shrewd, extremely careful, deliberative, and reflective when it comes to major decisions like this.) What this sort of poor decision making and buckling to external pressure amounts to is a lack of diligence, and a serious failure to look out for your own self-interest. Why and how this lack of self-care has become a part of American culture is puzzling/baffling to me, and is probably a good topic for sociological or anthropological study and research. Perhaps the overflowing abundance of wealth in United States (and other similarly wealthy countries) has made people less careful and more reckless with their money? I'm reminded of an article that appeared on The Atlantic which talked about how many people love paycheck to paycheck (and have very little saved up, even for emergency expenses): https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/my-secret-shame/476415/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/my-secr... But as counter-examples, Germany and Japan are first-world countries where people have a habit of saving quite a lot. So this culture of poor financial decision-making (and generally poor self-care) is seeming more and more like a uniquely American thing.
- CalRobert 8y agoI just agreed to buy a house. It's very cheap. It's very small and strange, so thankfully banks wouldn't give a mortgage on it. It was built around 1800, most likely when several people nearby got together and gathered a lot of stones to erect walls, and peat from a nearby bog and oat straw (which was grown locally) to make a roof. Over the subsequent hundred years it had a couple rooms added until it reached its current form. The original owner almost certainly had no mortgage. How did they do it? Why can't I just gather materials and build my own house? Is it because of the inclosure acts? I'm not sure. It's also possible the house was owned by a wealthy local and used as housing for farm labour. I suspect a lot of people _need_ mortgages purely because mortgages exist, so you're going to be competing against others who have them. It's slightly reminiscent of the two income trap. When a household wanted a home in the 1950's, they usually were competing with other single-income households. Once two-income households became normal, it was much more difficult for single-income households to compete. Though this all still seems to relate to there being fewer houses than people would like to own.
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoWhy can't I just gather materials and build my own house? In the US, you certainly can, as long as you use approved materials and get the necessary permits and inspections. If you want to fell trees and gather rocks to build your home, you can also do that, but it becomes much harder to get it registered as a homestead. In either case (assuming you are living outside city limits), you will probably need an approved septic plan. You can build something that doesn't meet the local building codes, but it may be difficult or impossible to sell it later.
- djrobstep 8y ago> Why can't I just gather materials and build my own house? Indeed. This is why discussion of "supply" misses the point. - Many people would quite happily build their own house in the middle of Central Park. But they cannot, because government intervention prevents them. - Many homeless people would happily sleep in unused climate-controlled office buildings at night, but cannot, because government intervention prevents them. - Many people would happily live outside of cities, but can't for financial reasons (effectively, the government coerces them via property law, into moving into cities to do work). Supply is not the issue. There's plenty of supply already existing or easily created. The issue is that people are violently prevented from using it.
- refurb 8y agoThis is really evident in Canada right now with the mortgage “stress test”. Basically, new regulations were created that require home buyers to qualify at prime + 2%, even though mortgage rates might be prime + 0.5%. This was done because the govt was concerned about how much risk the banks were taking on. Since it was enacted (earlier this year I think), the brakes were slammed on housing prices and now major markets are starting to see price drops. Of course the stress test wasn’t the only factor.
- switch007 8y agoThat seems like an easy stress test? I think UK lenders test 3% + the rate at which your mortgage reverts to at the end of the fixed period (we have relatively short fixed period products: 2-5 years), which would typically total around 7-9%.
- candybar 8y agoSo there is both a theoretical and an empirical relationship between real estate prices and interest rates but they have nothing to do with mortgages per se - you will find that this roughly holds true even in countries where mortgages aren't available. The reason is that even in a world without mortgages, real estate tends to yield either payments (as an investment) or benefits (as the owner) that are roughly fixed and not entirely based on interest rates. If you consider the value of real estate to roughly equal the sum of discounted cashflows, this means the lower the interest, the higher the value. Note that in theory, only land prices move this way, not the value of improvements, since the value of improvements is strongly tied to the cost. So if you consider the value of housing theoretically as a sum of land and improvements, only the land portion is subject to interest rates. So some have observed here that empirically the connection between real estate prices and interest rates has been weak - this will be the case in real estate markets dominated by the cost of improvements (most US markets until fairly recently I believe).