8 ms·
Why 'flammable ice' could be the future of energy
- WalterSear 8y agoWhy wait for the clathrate gun to go off, when you can dig it up and ignite it yourself?
- kijin 8y agoMethane is a much more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide, so it might be less harmful to burn it (converting it into CO2) than to let it escape into the atmosphere intact. But we might not have enough time to dig it all up and burn it before the clathrate gun goes off anyway.
- Roritharr 8y agoThe clathrate gun is the most scary doomsday scenario that's very reasonably likely to expect to happen in my lifetime. It's also a good test for ones ability to cope with existential dread, just tell someone about it, point to the Wikipedia page and see how long it takes until they shutoff and say something like:"nah, we'll figure it out". On another note, how valid is my anxiety regarding it, are there any pointers based in fact that this will really not be much of an issue?
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y agoWe can offset the warming by a nuclear winter if necessary.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nnq 8y ago...well yeah, the worlwide famine and political instability coming after the massive climate change will kind of obviously lead to this, thank god for the nukes.
- the8472 8y agoYou know that doesn't just require detonating nukes in remote locations, which would be bad enough, but setting megacities on fire, right? And it's not something you can do repeatedly once the effects wear off. Climate change outlasts nuclear winter.
- aaaaaaaaaab 8y agoJust drop a dozen or so megaton bomb on the Yellowstone caldera and the rest will be taken care of.
- istjohn 8y agoThe Wikipedia page portrays the issue as one with potentially catastrophic consequences, but ultimately as one needing further research. Calthrate fields that previously raised concern were found to be emmitting methane for reasons unrelated to anthropogenic global warming. Calthrates certainly deserve scientific attention, and not enough is being done to address global warming, but we don't know that a calthrate gun has ever fired in the Earth's past, and current theories for how one might be triggered in the near future have yet to be fleshed out in any detail.
- jesperlang 8y agoHow is it the future of energy? As the article later states, "All the social and environmental issues associated with fossil fuels apply to gas hydrates ". It's later awkwardly explained as a transitional energy source, sure methane is more short lived but do we really want to gamble with the possible tippings that we have set ourselves up for?
- jamisteven 8y agoyea this article is shit
- masklinn 8y ago> sure methane is more short lived I don't know that this is helpful at all since it either burns or degrades to CO2, and is a significantly worse greenhouse gas before then.
- jesperlang 8y agoI should have rephrased that! The main point is it seem to put us in a very risky situation with methane release. They're mentioning how doing the extraction can potentially destabilize the whole reserve and lead to massive releases. Then there's also the eco system aspect. The environments surrounding the reserves have unique organisms. What's going to happen with that? Just because we don't see it, it doesn't seem to matter..
- strainer 8y agoIt is not emitted in similar quantities to CO2. It is remarkable that practically all of the charts of greenhouse gases show methane as a fraction already multiplied by its Global Warming Potential factor. Its sensible to present the gases already weighted, but when its not explicit enough and raw figures by weight are hard to come by - its pretty natural to do the math again and re-multiply by the GWP factor - resulting in a shocking discovery that methane is widely misunderstood or misreported. However, global anthropogenic emission of methane is about 300 Tera-grams per year [1]. Anthropogenic emission of CO2 is about 35 Giga-tonnes per year. 300 Tera-grams is 0.3 Giga-tonnes 300 Tera-grams of CH4 degrades in about 10 years into about 0.5 Gigatonnes of CO2. About 1.5%, one sixtieth of the CO2 problem which can last hundreds of years. Methane emissions present 10-15% of the immediate and near term problem - thats less than half, less than a quarter... seriously, its about an eighth. After 10-15 years the elimination of methane, eliminates about a sixtieth of the global warming emissions problem. This will be why the IPCC presents CO2 as the major issue, because they do find and show that it is. [1] (Table 1) http://rsta.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/roypta/369/1943/2058.full.pdf http://rsta.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/roypta/369/19...
- alkonaut 8y agoSo a new greenhouse-gas fuel is touted in a BBC headline as potentially “the future of energy”. Someone add 1988 to the headline.
- goodmachine 8y agoThis is how the world ends. Not with a bang or whimper, but with a fart. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis
- Retric 8y agoGlobal warming is bad in terms of infrastructure, but would not make earth uninhabitable or anything.
- starbeast 8y agoIs predicted to made several large populated areas uninhabitable due to the wet bulb temperature rising past the limits of human survivability for much of the year.
- jellicle 8y agoIf we burn or release the ocean methane deposits for any reason, most of the Earth's land surface would be uninhabitable to humans, meaning all unprotected humans would die. Maybe there would still be habitable zones near the poles. Not certainly, but maybe.
- Retric 8y ago[Citation needed] because as near as I can find that's really not on the table. Remember temperature is very nonlinear, eventually adding atmospheric methane has a reduced effect as their is enough of it to block the spectra and adding more does little.
- adrianN 8y agoThere is a chance that the oceans will warm more quickly than the phyplankton can survive. A massive die-off of phytoplankton would be catastrophic. It's our main source of oxygen and the basis for the marine food chain.
- Retric 8y ago
- plaidfuji 8y agoSo, a few years back when natural gas had just droppped to about $4/MMBtu due to the shale gas boom, I was doing research for a VC fund that wanted to invest in startups that converted methane to valuable products. One of the most promising routes was to upgrade it to methanol; from there you can make chemicals with higher value, not just fuels to burn. The problem is that oxidation of methane is very unselective, meaning once you break the C-H bond it’ll cascade into carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide very quickly. I think the current record for methanol yield from methane oxidation is something abysmal like 3%. The last slide of my presentation for them was about methane clathrates, basically reaffirming that yeah, this is definitely an area you should invest in because there’s literally an untapped ocean of methane that people will eventually dig up.
- hackerbabz 8y agoIf any engineers working on this are here, please quit your jobs or sabotage this project. I find it appalling that anyone would work to find new ways to add greenhouse gasses to our atmosphere.
- vibrato 8y agoEnergon cubes
- jrockway 8y agoInteresting video about making your own gas hydrates at home: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3trDB5hN4Ug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3trDB5hN4Ug
- justaaron 8y agoOh gee, more "burning stuff that's not hydrogen" aka one more producer of greenhouse gasses. Kickin' that can down the road.... I love one contributers assessment near the end of the article that it's "going to take awhile" to "transition" "transition" = not doing something about the problem. What part of "we have 10 years more or less to reduce our carbon emissions drastically to XYZ level or face tipping a very delicate chain reaction irrevocably on the side of disaster" is difficult to understand? Incrementalism won't cut it. We need a renewably sustainably produced electrical energy system with on-site hydrogen generation for what still must combust (likely, chainsaws and such, depending upon motor designs etc...) or as a storage means. Hydrogen is the only substance that, when combined with oxygen rapidly aka "burned" produces water. Methane produces water AND CO2, a greenhouse gas. Grow up.