5 ms·
I think there's a real reason here which the article doesn't mention: the more confused you are about what you're purchasing, the more likely you are to pay mor
by crazygringo 8y ago
I think there's a real reason here which the article doesn't mention: the more confused you are about what you're purchasing, the more likely you are to pay more and get less.
If the site can guide you to last year's model without you realizing, then they profit. If it isn't easy to discover there's a similar laptop for the same price but a faster processor, then they profit.
A lot of consumers will give up trying to understand, and simply pick a more (overly) expensive one because it'll "have to" be good if it's that expensive.
This effectively allows manufacturers to achieve price discrimination: those who don't have time to research for hours will pay more, those who really don't have money will take the time and figure out the best deal in the end. (It's the same way grocery store coupons allow those who really need to save costs pay less, as long as they'll go to the effort of clipping.)
So why doesn't Apple do this?
Because Apple is by-definition high end. They're not going after bargain hunters, so they can afford a simple, cleaner site where everything is clear and comparable. They don't need to do price discrimination as much. (Obviously they still do though, it's just by charging way more for upgrades, like maximum-sized-storage iPhones and MacBooks.)
- snegu 8y agoI highly doubt this is the strategy. There is somebody in charge of experience design in these organizations who is doing their very best to make the site easy to use. However, they are hampered by a confusing product selection (as mentioned in the article), marketing people who want to make sure their preferred items are prominently placed, tight timelines that don't allow for user testing, or legacy tech that restricts design options.
- jseliger 8y agoI think there's a real reason here which the article doesn't mention: the more confused you are about what you're purchasing, the more likely you are to pay more and get less. That could be true, but I also wonder how many people look at the weird bazaar that is the average website and then throw up their hands and buy Apple instead. Less hassle, etc.
- kylecordes 8y agoYes, intentional confusion is a dangerous game in a competitive environment. Though I suppose these folks must have carefully gathered metrics to compare the profits they gain from the confusion (if there really are any) versus what they lose when people leave without buying.
- clintonb 8y agoIf you have Apple money, you buy Apple (either for the performance/value or as a status symbol). It doesn't make sense to me that someone confused by a manufacturer's site would jump to Apple in disgust. Anecdotally, most of my family doesn't have Apple money, so they send me Amazon and Best Buy links asking if a low-end Windows machine is worth the $250.
- Veen 8y agoA few years ago I visited a large electronics retailer to buy a Windows laptop to put Linux on. I’d been a Linux user for years. But the service was so dire at the store I became irritated. No one knew what they were talking about. I waited twenty minutes to talk to a member of staff, who went to find another member of staff, and left me waiting an additional twenty minutes. I thought fuck this, left, and walked by an Apple store on the same street. I was curious and popped in to have a look. The experience was such a contrast that I bought a MacBook Air on the spot. Five years later and I’ve bought another MacBook, two iPhones, two iPads, and god knows how much software.
- pdimitar 8y agoYes. I feel many people really look at the price in a very black-and-white sort of way. Truth is, if people really want the device in question, they do find a way -- and they do buy it. I observed many times how even below-middle-class people around here in Eastern Europe could muster the money for a MacBook or a high-end iPhone with help from relatives or local short-term money lenders. (Sometimes from their boss as well -- many employers are happy to deduct 10-20% of your salary for 4-8 months until you repay the device.) Also what you said about service is something that much of the tech crowd here in HN seems to severely underestimate. Even I as a programmer and a few other hardware guys I know appreciate a semi-informed employee who comes to us and answers intelligently any questions we ask them. Those that don't try and swindle us usually get our money.
- clintonb 8y agoApple still offers older models, but make them slightly difficult to find: * https://www.apple.com/shop/browse/home/specialdeals/clearance https://www.apple.com/shop/browse/home/specialdeals/clearanc... * https://www.apple.com/shop/refurbished https://www.apple.com/shop/refurbished As a consumer, I greatly appreciate knowing that I'm getting a deal on last year's model rather than being tricked into said deal.
- wlesieutre 8y agoYou can hit MacBook Air -> Buy and the old non-retina model is on the same page as the new ones. You at least have to scroll down though, and comparing the features list makes it pretty clear that this is a cheaper old version.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoI think it’s because they simply don’t want to pay for decent web dev talent.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"the more confused you are about what you're purchasing, the more likely you are to pay more and get less." "Don't ascribe to malfeasance that which can be otherwise explained by incompetence" - Napoleon. Having worked in this area I would say it's simply a matter of zero product strategy, not some dark pattern. And I'm not sure I agree with the confusion bit though you could be right, I don't think so. Confusion is death to a sales funnel. Here's a product, oh, let's make a variation, oh, another variation with this cool new thing our M&A team bought, oops, power regs mean in that other country we need this - so let's make another model. But Microsoft wants a specific hardware version for their OS, so 10 more version. Hey have you seen this new stylus (!?) Marketing says 10% of Millennial want them, let's tweak the screen and make 5 more models with that. Basically, there's no product strategy. The 'web site' is basically just taking orders from Product, and simply 'doing their job' by organizing it in some way ... which may include some douchy designers view on how it ought to be displayed. Then Marketing Ops posts some vanity metrics and voila. Someone with a lot of power has to go in there and change that, and otherwise, it won't happen. If the culture is not there from the start, or from the top, it won't happen.
- crazygringo 8y agoSo I actually agree with you 100%... but in the sense that's it's working inadvertently. I'm very familiar with internal politics/chaos resulting in an explosion of models... ;) But the thing is: if this were hugely detrimental to the bottom line, it would get fixed. But it's not. To the contrary, it actually improves the bottom line, even if it wasn't designed to do so. So other things get fixed, but not this. And if I'm shopping for a new <insert superfluous consumer item here> then sure, confusion is death to a sales funnel because I can just not buy. But if I need a new laptop and can't afford Apple, then I've got 3-5 brands to choose from and their websites/models are equally confusing... ...and so I probably wind up spending more money that I needed and the companies come out winners. BUT... if another company comes along and goes after the value market with a simple-to-understand lineup, where the business model is massive, massive volume of a tiny number of models? And gains consumer trust? Kind of like Casper did with mattresses, another impossible-to-understand market? Or Warby Parker with glasses, where incumbents were waaay overpriced? Well then there's a ton of money to be made, my friend. Indeed, I'm actually surprised it hasn't happened yet.
- rmason 8y agoActually Apple used to be like all the rest before Steve Jobs came back. First thing he did was discontinue a lot of products, even entire categories like the Newton. I think everyone should go to three categories: 13 inch laptops in good, better and best. Have a comparison chart that clearly shows the differences. Do not make you hunt to see the differences. Then if you're making special models for say WalMart or Best Buy affix a letter code and then don't make it available through normal navigation. If I search for it on their site by entering the model number I can find it. Might even say something like 'as seen in Best Buy'. Now this would result in fewer individual models and the absolute sales yield might drop temporarily. But by concentrating on customer satisfaction over time people would recommend them higher and their sales would increase. One last thing - every single manufacturer in the checkout should have an option that says for $50 extra we won't load all the garbage you have to delete when you first start using the machine.
- kristianc 8y ago> So why doesn't Apple do this? I'd say Apple's product lineup is no less convoluted. Sure, the Apple site looks nicer, but the product lineup today is still pretty convoluted and it isn't easy to determine which is the 'right' option for you [1]. It's difficult at first glance to work out why the £949 MacBook Air would come with a 1.8 dual core, and the 'New' 13-inch would come with a 1.6 as standard. https://www.apple.com/uk/mac/compare/ https://www.apple.com/uk/mac/compare/