8 ms·
Clothing Manufacturing May Be Moving Back to West from Asia
- latchkey 8y agoLiving in Vietnam, I don't believe this article for a second. Clothing manufacturing is unbelievably massive here. It isn't going anywhere anytime soon. Clothing is a commodity item, even if it takes a week or a month to ship to the US, it does not matter. If you need it faster, raise the prices (or take a hit on the massive retail markup) and ship it faster (air vs. boat). Having also built a successful print on demand business, we did all our printing in the US because the customers were in the US and the shipping times would have been too great because of the on-demand nature. The garments themselves come from other countries. Notably, the people creating the designs and buying the FB ads, which target US consumers, are in SE Asia (mostly in Vietnam). Only people in the US will pay $25+ for a t-shirt that costs $1 to $4 to produce.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSomeone in 1920's UK: "Living in Manchester, I don't believe this for a second. Cloth and clothing manufacture has become unbelievably massive throughout Lancashire since the spinning jenny in 1760. Manchester wasn't called Cottonopolis for the last 100 years for nothing. It isn't going anywhere soon." They produced for all levels of the market from the cheapest to the most premium. Mostly cloth, but a big apparel industry on the back of it. By the time of WW2, almost half a million had left the industry. Through the 50s and 60s mills and garment makers were closing weekly. By the 1970s or 1980s there was essentially nothing left. Nothing in stores is UK made any more, except the highest end and bespoke. Cheap T's and the like will probably always come from wherever's cheapest. For the rest, never say never. :)
- perl4ever 8y agoI noticed some jeans I bought a while ago had a label that said they were made in Lesotho (which is not in Asia). A motorcycle I owned in 2009 was made in Thailand. A car I owned in 2011 was made in South Africa. These are all things being imported into the US. China and India make a lot of things because they are big, but that doesn't mean the rest of the world does nothing or that tomorrow large parts of the world will close up shop.
- freddie_mercury 8y agoSo you're saying it'll take 2-3 decades? Sounds like you're agreeing that it won't go anywhere fast and instead will take 20-40 years?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoDepends what you call fast. Fast enough to cause deprivation more than likely, and the usual bell curve. For a career, an industry almost completely exiting in half a working lifetime might be thought fast by many outside IT. :) Some will leave early, most when some tipping point is reached, and some will hang on for decades. Something different will fill the gap.
- sremani 8y ago10 years .. shorter supply chains is going to be trend in post-brettonwoods world. The free-traders and multilateral trade agreement people lost the fight both on left and right in USA. Prima facie evidence TPP.
- fiblye 8y agoI could see it being much faster than that. As someone working in automation, a lot of our recent work is involved with automating tech and car manufacturing in Vietnam. I could easily see a shift away from textiles and into more advanced manufacturing very soon.
- pytester 8y agoInvestors everywhere drool at the idea that automation can make employees redundant - they're expensive and one of the biggest sources of risk in a business. Employees make investors super jittery. I think the Trump trade war has only elevated those jitters. Investors are terrified at the prospect of paying an American $15 / hour what they used to pay $4 for in Vietnam. The demand for automation is very, very, very high because of this. This drives a lot of investment which pushes up developer wages. It also means that a lot of people seeking investment aren't 100% truthful about what is possible and what isn't in their press releases. Which is how we get this: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jul/06/artificial-intelligence-ai-humans-bots-tech-companies https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jul/06/artificia... I think that this charade of "we will eventually automate 100% of the world out of a job" is kind of the silicon valley religion. Challenging it means violating a taboo - it threatens the torrent of cash being funneled into our ecosystem and, frankly, undermines the very core of the power we hold.
- freddie_mercury 8y agoKeep in mind the numbers quoted in the article: 25% of those surveyed said 50% of their clothes will be "nearshored" by 2025. So within 7 years (ballpark number) 12.5% of clothes will be nearshored. That sounds pretty plausible. It's not exactly a titanic shift, more of a gradual one And looking at the chart backs up those kind of numbers. Fewer companies have 0-10% nearshored and more companies having 10-30% nearshored. Of course, the survey is a bit misleading because it isn't volume-weighted. If 100 boutiques use nearshoring but Walmart doesn't... Also keep in mind that "nearshoring" doesn't mean "moving back to the US and Western Europe". If you read the linked McKinsey study it means "moving to Mexico and Turkey because the US and Germany are still way too expensive even with full automation". I also live in Vietnam :)
- why_only_15 8y agoYour calculations weren't quite correct because you didn't account for all the different survey answers. If you account for all of them, right now about 21% [0] of clothes are nearshored, and in 7 years about 30% of clothes will be nearshored. That's about a 45% increase in the amount of clothing nearshored or 13% decrease in the amount of clothes manufactured overseas. Vietnam's share might still increase though because it may take more of the declining Asian share. [0]: Using the midpoint between the two survey options and 60% for 50%+: 6.21 + .45.03 + .35.04 + .25.05 + .15.15 + .075.18 + .025.33 = .21025 [1]: With the same method: .6.24 + .45.04 + .35.14 + .25.18 + .15.22 + .075.15 + .025.03 = .301
- esmi 8y agoThey’ve also been writing roughly the same article for years. Here’s one from 2014 https://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/business/article9148256.html https://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/business/article91482... It does contain some interesting things about the cost of cotton and this quote which struck me. Said Wang: “Except for human labor, all other production factors are cheaper in the U.S.” I wonder if that’s still the case. The parent article exists so maybe it is...
- SkyMarshal 8y ago>Only people in the US will pay $25+ for a t-shirt that costs $1 to $4 to produce. As a Westerner this drives me nuts about about buying clothes. Every time I buy any article of clothing I feel it right in the sphincter, getting ripped off 10x - 100x. Is there any way for folks in NA/Europe/etc to get clothes at or near cost?
- latchkey 8y agoYou should be annoyed. I routinely buy 'name brand' clothes here in Vietnam and I pay $4-5 for a shirt or shorts that have $50 price tags attached to them.
- nopinsight 8y agoJust curious. Are they made with the same specs or are they lower-quality counterfeits? I used to check out some cheap knock-offs in another SE Asian country and they were all lower quality than genuine items.
- latchkey 8y agoThe answer is 'it depends'. There is different grades of knockoffs and it is pretty easy to spot low quality ones. The fabric is thinner, the sewing isn't quite right. So far, I've only had issues with poorly made cheap shoes falling apart. Regular clothes have generally been excellent and I can't tell the difference.
- pjmlp 8y agoYes, you buy them directly from the Asian companies, just don't expect being able to change if they don't fit, becaus1 even when they accept to do it the round trip takes too long.
- arethuza 8y agoDon't know about the US, but here in the UK places like Primark and Mountain Warehouse have t-shirts for £6.
- nopinsight 8y agoWhat do you think of Sewbots, which made quite a few headlines last year? http://softwearautomation.com/products/ http://softwearautomation.com/products/ “A new t-shirt sewing robot can make as many shirts per hour as 17 factory workers” https://qz.com/1064679/a-new-t-shirt-sewing-robot-can-make-as-many-shirts-per-hour-as-17-factory-workers/ https://qz.com/1064679/a-new-t-shirt-sewing-robot-can-make-a...
- latchkey 8y agoDidn't Tesla over automate things? I think any downtime for that machine is going to be really expensive. The more those machines do, the more they cost when they aren't doing what they need to do. Human labor, is plentiful and cheap. A worker who is out sick can be immediately replaced by 100 others waiting in the wings.
- nopinsight 8y agoFactories can support redundancy too, can’t they? It means higher cost. But technology costs go down over time while labor costs typically go up in a given country. Tesla tried to automate too much too soon but it appears Sewbots are quite ready to be deployed and their capabilities and reliability will likely improve in the future.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoA worker needs to be trained, and willing to work. And has huge medical liabilities, along with tons of other clerical duties. With machines you don’t need to worry about them getting to work, sexual harassment, unemployment insurance, etc. Of course there is a point where humans make more sense than machines, but the formers cost keeps rising while the latter’s cost keeps dropping, so the trend is clear unless that dynamic changes.
- jgalt212 8y agoor kubernetes for sewbots
- runn1ng 8y agoVietnam is actually profiting from the trade war The tariffs are aimed at China, not at Vietnam. (However, Vietnam has terribly high import tariffs, especially on cars, and it is annoying US car manufacturers. And electronics is also surprisingly expensive here, maybe also because of the import tariffs?)
- latchkey 8y agoVietnam is now making their own cars too! Imported cars are 200%+ tax, which is great because it is keeping the numbers of cars lower (better for a motorbike based culture). Sure makes you pause at how wealthy people are here when you see a Lambo driving around Saigon. Vietnamese also generally can't drive well at all, the education and penalties are mediocre at best. Huge numbers of road deaths here. There is videos all the time of someone mistaking gas for brake or drunkly running over a few motorbikes [1] (Lucky she is rich, she will likely not face any jail time and the articles about it have magically stopped). [1] https://e.vnexpress.net/news/news/saigon-woman-arrested-in-driving-accident-that-killed-1-injured-5-3828910.html https://e.vnexpress.net/news/news/saigon-woman-arrested-in-d...
- vram22 8y agoWow, that sounds bad. I've read that bad driving is somewhat similar in Thailand. (Similar in India too.) Know anything about it?
- liftbigweights 8y agoTrade war has nothing to do with it. It's rising wages in china. For more than a decade, manufacturers ( even chinese companies ) have been shifting production to vietnam. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/18/business/worldbusiness/18invest.html https://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/18/business/worldbusiness/18... Labor costs a much cheaper in vietnam. https://www.statista.com/statistics/744071/manufacturing-labor-costs-per-hour-china-vietnam-mexico/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/744071/manufacturing-lab...
- m0llusk 8y agoClothing is fashion which is culture. The design, marketing, promotion, and customer relations and support or repair work best with local players. If a shirt can be sold for $25 then a fast moving and tuned in group with good client lists and promotional channels can and will dominate sales. The margins will be greatly reduced but the products will be superior. Customers are driven to best product fit not highest corporate margins.
- rb808 8y ago> Only people in the US will pay $25+ for a t-shirt that costs $1 to $4 to produce Does anyone have any solid numbers for this? When I've been in Asia buying cheap clothes usually the quality is terrible. Branded stores in Asia seemed similarly expensive still. In US outlet malls I regularly see Asian tourists from many countries buying clothes to take home.
- preommr 8y agoDoesn't really help much if most of it is coming back to the west to be automated.
- choward 8y agoWhy would you say that? Automation is a good thing for humanity and it's a lot more efficient than shipping from China. What doesn't it help? Is this a "jobs" argument?
- drb91 8y ago> Automation is a good thing for humanity Well, only if it serves the common goal of humanity... which at the present doesn’t seem like anything coherent.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoUnder capitalism automation is not really a good thing for humanity. Loads of middle class jobs disappeared due to it, leaving millions with lower wages and a more insecure life. But automation is good for the average HN reader I guess, for now. One day it will come for them too.
- nec4b 8y agoIt's great to have communist countries like North Korea or Cuba for comparison how well full employment without automatization works for people there.
- fatjokes 8y agoI get the vibe that Bloomberg (the news) is very supportive of the trade war in the sense that all the related headlines I've seen seem to emphasize the positives to America and the negatives to China. Too lazy to dig up references right now. By comparison, the NYTimes seems more balanced. Am I wrong?
- le_clochard 8y agoIn the contrary, being a business journal, BBL must remain accurate in reporting and analysis of business. Biased business reporting will directly impact reader trust, this revenues.
- scarface74 8y agoBecause Bloomberg would never publish a sensational story with no corroborating evidence including fake pictures. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2018-10-04/how-china-used-a-tiny-chip-to-infiltrate-amazon-and-apple-video https://www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2018-10-04/how-china-u...
- eesmith 8y agoI've heard this argument before, though with respect to the WSJ. I don't really believe it. There is still a bias because "reader trust" depends on what the readers want to read, yes? That is, most of the readers of Bloomberg, and of the WSJ, are - to use Marxian terms - aligned with the interests of capital owners, and not workers. Labor is an important part of business, yes? Yet a look at the Bloomberg home page shows no mention of union or worker rights issues. The word "worker" exists in the headline link "Jaguar's New Evoque Rides to Rescue of UK Workers" but the actual article is titled "Jaguar Land Rover's New Evoque SUV Rides to Rescue of U.K. Plant Amid Brexit Pinch", with no mention of workers. Why would Bloomberg cover more about the labor aspect of business if its readers don't want to know more about it, or are actively against it?
- ancorevard 8y agoI’ve seen many stories in Bloomberg about Marxism through the proxy of Venezuaela’s marxist policies. So far, it doesn’t seem like marxist ideologies are good for the common workers in that country either.
- scarface74 8y agoClothes manufacturing may move back to the US. But it will be automated. http://softwearautomation.com/ http://softwearautomation.com/
- cenal 8y agoAs will manufacturing in Asia.
- polskibus 8y agoIn this case logistics cost will be more important, so factories closer to customers will win business
- ksec 8y agoI don't think logistics or even storage were ever a large percentage in cost / unit. The highest two is rent, staff in retail, and marketing. Although the idea of Online Retailing were suppose to save on this, in reality it is merely moving the Rental cost to last mile delivery.... which is also expensive.
- thenanyu 8y agoA huge source of inefficiency is time to market. Fashion moves quickly and boats are not quick. Air freight is expensive, diving up unit prices.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- est 8y ago> Delivery to big Western markets takes about 30 days by sea Or 12 days by Sino-Europe rail. It's expensive though.
- mrweasel 8y agoThere where an article a few month back, from Norway I believe, where someone claimed that by raising shipping cost just slightly the saving by having certain products manufactured in China would be completely negated. The cost increase could be emission taxes on container ships. The take away seemed to be that right now China is very depended on keeping shipping costs low for a large number of goods. Otherwise they are no longer able to compete on price.
- est 8y agoThat's the whole point of globalization. Back in Medieval period, the Ottoman empires taxed the hell out of silk road, so Europe countries had to find alternative sea routes to India and China.
- sytelus 8y agoTLDR; This mainly affects luxury clothing items for which “Made in ...” label matters more. The fashion is becoming ultra fast as trends are set by items on Instagram and 30 day bulk shipping from China doesn’t cut it. The term is “nearshoreing” because it is cheaper to produce in Mexico for US market and in Turkey for German market. Still, US and Germany themselves not an option because they are 17% and 144% more expensive respectively. China is responding by opening factories in places like Ethiopia.
- desdiv 8y ago>China is responding by opening factories in places like Ethiopia. As well as places like Little Rock, Arkansas[0]. https://www.innovationintextiles.com/automated-sewbot-to-make-800000-adidas-tshirts-daily/ https://www.innovationintextiles.com/automated-sewbot-to-mak...
- withhighprod 8y agoOh my, this is funny. Chinese consumes one third of the worlds luxury commodities.
- b_tterc_p 8y agoWould China opening businesses outside of China due much to help the Chinese economy? I would assume most of the gain will flow to the local economy and the 1% Chinese elite
- kazinator 8y agoPerhaps in the form of whatever that 1% manages to spend at home rather than abroad, and whatever they can't hide from the local taxes.
- mtgx 8y agoOne of the most positive things to come out of advanced automation in manufacturing will be the decentralization of manufacturing and countries being able to make most of the products themselves again, instead of buying them all from China. Hopefully this will be just as true for chip and device making in the future, as then it should become much more difficult even for China to force companies to implement backdoors in the products they sell abroad. Because once those companies are discovered it would be game over for them.
- ksec 8y agoI think that is only possible for Clothes, Plants / Vegetables. Chip Fab are highly specialised, and only leading edge are from Intel, Samsung and TSMC.
- epicureanideal 8y agoAs the benefit to each next generation of chips becomes lower and lower though, that might not matter as much to some countries as independence. For example, I've read that Russia manufactures some of its own computer chips for military purposes where it doesn't trust imported chips. If any country wanted to, I'm guessing they could manufacture CPUs that would've been top of the line 10 years ago, and honestly, for most applications that would be good enough. It also might be that individual countries would manufacture chips for certain applications, and then they could buy the "world's top of the line" from Intel, Samsung, and TSMC just for high end business or gaming machines, which is a smaller market than the total market for all tablets, phones, IOT devices, etc.
- pluma 8y agoSo in summary, manufacturing is coming back but the jobs aren't? This trend was entirely predictable. Cheap human labor becomes expensive and unreliable at scale so it's only a stopgap until automation becomes affordable enough. Cutting delivery times and transportation costs helps shift the balance. Scandals and improving quality of life (i.e. workers become more expensive as labor laws improve, production becoming more expensive as environmental laws improve) also helped. It's the end goal for Uber, so why should labor-intensive factory jobs be any different? As soon as automation becomes more profitable than human labor the jobs will be gone.
- PeterisP 8y agoFor many industries automation is possible and affordable, but it's held back by the fact that you still can find places where manual labor is cheaper than dirt. As the quality of life rises worldwide and decent workers have better options than working for a handful of rice, we'll get mass automation. Not because of automation getting cheaper (though that's happening as well) but because of labor costs rising closer to living wages.
- virmundi 8y agoI'm curious about logistics in general. If the US rebuild its train system, by expanding it, would it make more economic sense to have production centered here? Could the US transport clothing from say, Indianapolis, to EU member states more efficiently, cleanly than China's proposed rail/road system?
- mikeash 8y agoThe US freight rail system is already excellent. This fact is often missed in the periodic “American trains suck so hard” pieces because it’s not visible to the average person the way passenger service is.
- virmundi 8y agoThank you for replying. Do we have the infrastructure to compete with large shipping vessels? Part of my curiosity is the switch over that supposed to happen soon in diesel fuel. If the price of fuel increases, will it make manufacturing in a central continent preferable?
- mikeash 8y agoI’m far from an expert, but it seems that ships win on price pretty strongly: https://www.maritime-executive.com/editorials/comparing-maritime-versus-railway-transportation-costs https://www.maritime-executive.com/editorials/comparing-mari... Apparently it’s considerably cheaper to ship coast to coast by sea even though it’s a lot farther. Rail’s big advantage there is speed. Fuel costs would hit both, but I don’t know which one would suffer more. In theory, rail could become independent of fuel costs by using electricity, but I don’t think electric trains are cost effective over such distances.
- m23khan 8y agoI can see nations such as India and Bangladesh getting into trade agreements with Western Governments to ensure them of continued quota in order to keep their masses employed and their economy intact. China is going to get screwed over severely for sure. India, being darling of free World will get this 'special status' definitely so reality would be, clothes made in West + India and Bangladesh.
- techie128 8y ago> India, being darling of free World... Please explain how exactly is India "darling of the free world"?