7 ms·
which is great for data privacy. ...and absolutely horrible for freedom. It used to be the case, and still widely accepted for a lot of other products, that ph
by userbinator 8y ago
which is great for data privacy.
...and absolutely horrible for freedom. It used to be the case, and still widely accepted for a lot of other products, that physical ownership actually meant something beyond just being a consumer. Now companies are turning the security against users, lest they also be attackers. From the point of view of the DRM-advocating media corporations, the user is an attacker. Locking down the platform to allow only "trusted" (not by you, but by them!) code only benefits when their goals align with yours; you may agree with them on not wanting things like ransomware, but not on things like them not allowing you to share a file between two apps or even run code you wrote yourself.
It's scarier than any security attack to see what used to be an open and free platform turned into a walled garden of corporate control and obedience.
(Insert famous Benjamin Franklin quote.)
- scarface74 8y agoTell that to the million of Windows users that have 10 toolbars on their browser, ransomware, etc....
- LeoNatan25 8y ago2001 called, it wants its outdated Windows memes back.
- scarface74 8y agoYes because there aren’t users that are downloading web extensions that are malware, getting infected with ransomware, and programs that secretly mine crypto currency. My mom was just looking for a printer driver (why are printer drivers even a thing on Windows in 2018?) and ended up with all kind of crap on her computer after going to the first site she saw on Google. A friends mother told me that when she is on her computer she can see someone else controlling it remotely.
- privateSFacct 8y ago"It's scarier than any security attack to see what used to be an open and free platform turned into a walled garden of corporate control and obedience." Most users threat posture is around security from adversaries who may gain control of their hardware. That security helps preserve their freedom, to store secrets more safely on the device etc. Users are generally much less concerned with their own ability to hack / boot an alternative OS etc. I suspect very few companies other than Apple will even have a chance of standing up to big gov demands, and even Apple may cave (though they seemed willing to stick to principal even in case of known domestic terrorist shooter which is one of the toughest arguments to make). If you need the freedom to be hacked and to hack your own hardware, consider an android or linux machine.
- xvector 8y ago> Now companies are turning the security against users, lest they also be attackers. This has always been the case, has it not? Modern security practices seem to operate under the assumption that the attacker can do almost anything the user can except sniff the password out of the user's head. I think that's a reasonable model to work under. Building a platform that makes it a near-guarantee that the only way to unlock a computer is to be in the user's brain is a commendable security model, and the fact that Apple is executing it so seamlessly (i.e. with minimal user interaction) is honestly incredible. Gone are the days when you need to jump through hoops for security. It's democratized and available to everyone. I would say that this is amazing for freedom. You could ask for little more than for every citizen to have state-of-the-art security. --- Of course, vote with your wallet. If you don't like DRM content, don't get it. If you like the T2 chip and need a new laptop, get a Mac. No one is depriving you of choice, here.
- extrapickles 8y agoThey even go beyond the assumption of sniffing passwords from users head on the iPhone. Thanks to the face/fingerprint reader, most people are incapable of divulging their pin/password to someone claiming to be the county password inspector. While in an absolute/legal sense it’s less secure, for day to day use by most people it’s more secure as there is no password for someone to watch you enter, or socialy compel you to give them.
- isostatic 8y agoDon't know about face id, but with finger ID you certainly need to know the pin number for all the cases that finger ID doesn't work. More than that, it's easier for a security guard to point the phone at your face / push your thumb on the sensor than get you to reveal a passcode
- CharlesW 8y ago> Don't know about face id, but with finger ID you certainly need to know the pin number for all the cases that finger ID doesn't work. This is the case with Face ID as well. I use my PIN more with Face ID than I did with Touch ID. > More than that, it's easier for a security guard to point the phone at your face / push your thumb on the sensor than get you to reveal a passcode It's fairly easy to discreetly disable, FWIW. Just "squeeze" your phone for two seconds (i.e. press the power button and either volume button) to disable Face ID. It also won't work if you're looking away or have your eyes closed.
- nneonneo 8y agoPlease read Apple’s white paper on the security chip: https://www.apple.com/mac/docs/Apple_T2_Security_Chip_Overview.pdf https://www.apple.com/mac/docs/Apple_T2_Security_Chip_Overvi... They provide a setting that lets you disable the boot security at will, allowing you to install Linux or any other alternative OS. Security features on macOS (as opposed to iOS) are generally optional, but enabled by default (as is the sensible choice). They don’t provide you the ability to reprogram the T2 itself, which is a shame but not entirely without merit - compromising the T2 chip would be far more dangerous than compromising the OS in terms of persistence.
- HankB99 8y agoI've read that the T2 chip also provides the mass storage interface and without documentation or drivers, Linux cannot be run from the internal drive. Devices with the T2 chip can be booted and run from USB connections with the security disabled but not an internal drive.
- nneonneo 8y agoYes, that's unfortunate - the lack of drivers means that Linux devs will once again have to reverse someone's proprietary software to develop their own drivers. It's not a fun state of affairs. Unfortunately, Apple is not likely to start fully supporting Linux on Mac hardware by providing drivers and documentation. But the point here is that they haven't done anything technically to prevent you from running Linux.
- floatboth 8y agoFrom what I remember, it acts as a "normal" NVMe device and you can just add its PCI ID and see the disk in Linux… but in 10 seconds after that it powers the system off because it detects something like an unauthorized OS. Sounds a bit like prevention.
- cmurf 8y agoUnacceptable. The user must disable Secure Boot to run Linux, which means the system becomes vulnerable to bootkit attacks. And, the typical scenario will be a user who leaves it disabled, making both macOS and Linux and possibly Windows (if also installed) more vulnerable to bootkit attacks. I'm quite sure Microsoft would be willing to provide Apple their UEFI public key, which is what pretty much all Linux shim bootloaders are signed with.
- geofft 8y ago> It used to be the case, and still widely accepted for a lot of other products, that physical ownership actually meant something beyond just being a consumer. It still does. The only thing is we've distinguished physical ownership and mere physical possession. It is a feature that if I leave my personal laptop at my desk at work while using the bathroom, my IT department can't rootkit it. It is an improvement to my freedom - both my computing freedom and my physical freedom - if I can leave a laptop in my hotel room while seeing tourist sights. It protects me from the government if a border control agent looking through my bag, or a cop who's seized my laptop, can't get in. (The iPhone is an existence proof that such defense against the government is possible, and it's weird that the usually pro-personal-liberty free software crowd hasn't decided that a free software implementation of the same thing is critically important.) Of course software freedom requires access control. My freedom over my possessions involves other people's lack of freedom over my possessions. I can't make sure my computer is running the code I want it to if everyone else can make my computer run the code they want it to. This control is essential liberty; pretending that anyone with physical access is an owner because it's easier than crypto and key management has been decades of temporary convenience, and I'm glad it's coming to an end. I can turn secure boot on and off with an admin password, which I set when I first booted the machine because that's what demonstrates physical ownership and not mere possession. (And systems that don't permit me to do so, like Microsoft or Apple ARM devices, are in fact an affront to software freedom.) But nobody else can.
- eikenberry 8y agoYou can turn it on or off, but if you want to do anything on your own you have to turn it off as your can't sign anything. If they were really giving you what you say they should make signing your own apps as easy as turning it on/off.
- lisper 8y agoThis can't be stressed enough. Freedom (indeed "ownership") means that I should be able to run any app I want on my device without having to create an account with Apple. It would be great if I could have both freedom and security, but Apple has decided that is not an option. I have to choose one or the other. I choose freedom.