4 ms·
I would be surprised if purchasing a mine for some particular mineral immediately after learning that your tech company will suddenly need an enormous amount of
by munk-a 8y ago
I would be surprised if purchasing a mine for some particular mineral immediately after learning that your tech company will suddenly need an enormous amount of that mineral in a closed door meeting, didn't constitute some sort of insider trading.
Similarly, if advanced real estate purposes were made with the intent of resale I'd imagine you'd also get hit with insider trading. I think it'd be pretty reasonable to prosecute them anyways since they are using insider knowledge of market movements to gain an edge in the real estate market.
- spyspy 8y agoReal estate as a whole needs newer and much stronger restrictions. It's an inarguable fact that it's a "housing market" and speculative investment tends to be bad for everyone.
- 1123581321 8y agoThat’s a very broad and speculative reading. Insider trading is about regulating the securities market, not about keeping all transactions by the insider information-balanced.
- sfifs 8y agoOr as Matt Levine says - it is about theft (ie trading on stolen information) not about fairness
- mlazos 8y agoFor a historical example I’m pretty sure Disney did this with purchasing land in Orlando before they announced they would build Disney World there. They even used fake names. Given in that case the company itself was doing the purchasing in secret so that seems a bit less shady.
- mason55 8y ago> I would be surprised if purchasing a mine for some particular mineral immediately after learning that your tech company will suddenly need an enormous amount of that mineral in a closed door meeting, didn't constitute some sort of insider trading. Then prepare to be surprised > Similarly, if advanced real estate purposes were made with the intent of resale I'd imagine you'd also get hit with insider trading You'd imagine wrong > I think it'd be pretty reasonable to prosecute them anyways since they are using insider knowledge of market movements to gain an edge in the real estate market. That's not what insider trading is in the eyes of the law. Insider trading applies strictly to securities. Commodities markets have laws against front-running. But that's about it. If you take information that your company is going to suddenly need a new metal and you go buy all the mines then about all your company can do is fire you.
- jonny_eh 8y agoThey may be able to sue you depending on your employment contract.
- lightedman 8y ago"I would be surprised if purchasing a mine for some particular mineral immediately after learning that your tech company will suddenly need an enormous amount of that mineral in a closed door meeting, didn't constitute some sort of insider trading." I do mining. It's not illegal by any means. How else would a company obtain the resources they need if not for looking for them, either in the earth or in the marketplace?
- triangleman 8y agoHey lightedman, just wanted to make sure you know you are shadowbanned and have been for years. I can see your comments because I have "showdead" turned on but most people can't.
- lightedman 8y agoThat's fine. I'm used to Nazi treatment from Nazi moderators and admins. :) It doesn't bother me one bit. The world will see to their comeuppance sooner or later.