10 ms·
The World Will Be Our Skinner Box
- CharlesDodgson 8y agodespite all my rage I'm still just a rat in a cage.
- dranoel0226 8y agoI have nothing to hide and why wouldn't I want ads that better reflect my preferences?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- inherentFloyd 8y agoWhy do you want ads at all?
- 21 8y agoBecause the alternative is paying. Do you want to pay for all the hundred sites you visit in a year?
- dkersten 8y agoNo, I would more carefully pick and choose which sites I care to visit since I have to pay for them. I can, of course, pick and choose the sites now based on how bad the advertisement is, but because advertisement is so prevalent, I don’t really get a choice because most sites use advertisement. Ironically, the sites I’d be most willing to pay for (like HN) are also the ones with few or no adverts.
- ashrk 8y agoThe most valuable ones mostly aren't ad supported or paid anyway, and without competition from ad supported sites even more free ones for more purposes would exist and thrive (e.g. if Reddit died all those free volunteer run forums that used to be such a big part of the Web would come back)
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoI don't want ads in the abstract, but I want them more than the alternatives I've seen offered. Ditto for capitalism and democracy :)
- eternalban 8y agoThis is the actual question to ask. Advertising is either a convenient scapegoat by ruling classes, or it is inherently destructive. Either way, a clear headed free society would ban advertising in its current form and seek other means of providing the utility of advertisement for goods and services. At the end of the day, that is all advertising is supposed to provide. Yet somehow this relatively insignificant aspect of society is put front and center as the reason for all sort of shenanigans.
- posix_me_less 8y agoYou are an outlier, most people like their privacy and do not want to be manipulated by advertisers.
- quotemstr 8y agoIs that so? If you look at people's behavior, most people seem to accept targeted advertising. Every bit of evidence I've seen indicates that the outrage against the practice comes from a small minority with a disproportionate voice --- much like many other sources of chronic public outrage today. Regular people, to the best of my knowledge, don't care.
- titzer 8y agoI think most people have no idea what is going on and literally would not be able to understand it even if it were laid out in black and white. Even then, most people "understand" that smoking causes cancer. Behavior is not always a good predictor of people's internal mental states. Addiction is real. Damn that dopamine. Is smoking somehow fine because lots of people do it and it kills you slow? (I say that as someone who can't help but have a cig now and then).
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoDisagree. I think the last fifty years proves that the vast majority of people will almost always go with convenience over some abstract ideal of "privacy".
- dpark 8y agoPeople don't care about privacy in the abstract but do care once it becomes concrete. If you ask someone if they are willing to let an impersonal algorithm analyze their data in exchange for a free service, the answer is generally yes. If you ask them if you can read their email and peruse their browsing history, the answer is almost always no. The problem privacy advocates have is forging a link between the abstract and the concrete. I don't really care that Experian compiles a list of my credit data. I really do care when they fuck up and leak it publicly. The tricky thing is that the former is a prerequisite for the latter, so I should care about that, too.
- titzer 8y agoIf you have nothing to hide, you also have nothing to say. You also have zero to gain by expressing your assent to what is happening already anyway. You are actually drowning out many people who have no voice in this matter but silently believe in very important things like human rights, of which privacy is absolutely key to freedom and free expression. I generally think open dialogue is a good thing, but your comment just bolsters those in positions of power to the detriment of everyone else for literally nothing other than reducing your own minor personal annoyance. Want better ads? Mail them a dossier on your life story and leave the rest of us out of it.
- calvertdw 8y agoThis makes me shudder. Companies with powerful AI and enough data could control the population in ways indiscernible to an individual. By organizing goods in stores and placing the right ads at the right time it could be possible to lead users on a treasure hunt to a political or economic opinion.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoHow do you know you're not in the vanguard of that attack on humanity? How do you know the comment you just posted isn't propaganda in service of your puppetmaster. Perhaps you're bringing about that which you fear, powerless in the grip of an omnipotent AI possessed by a faceless bureaucracy somewhere.
- dougmwne 8y agoI'll try to tackle the idea that you have nothing to hide. Let's assume that every last moment of your life has been collected, indexed, then either sold or hacked. It's all out there, for anyone to see. If you think this is implausible, consider that most people are never outside of arms reach of their gps/microphone/camera and that much of the data that's ever been collected has already been hacked or sold. Would you prefer to hide: -recordings of your sexual encounters from your family? -the raunchiest porn you've ever looked at from your co-workers? -your live GPS location from home burglars? -your bank account balance from friends? -your tax filings from scam artists? -your off-color remarks you made 15 years ago while drunk from the person conducting your job interview? -the drugs you tried in college from law enforcement? -The minor legal transgression you committed from the person looking to shut down your political protest? -the psychological trigger even you were unaware of from the deep learning algorithm designed to addict you to gambling. -your sexual orientation from the autocratic government of the vacation spot you visited? The only people who truly have nothing to hide are those who truly have nothing to lose. If that's you, then I'm sincerely sorry.
- api 8y agoThe Borg may turn out to be prophetic. We could turn into a hive mind of sorts. I've already been calling Internet fads, echo chambers, and meme outbreaks "Borgsongs." I seem to recall this term from STTNG for the omnipresent hive signal experienced by Borg.
- 21 8y agoImagine a neural network who could design memes/songs by directly measuring a bunch of test subject brains. Kind of like a focus group. A short story even asked the question, could you engineer a meme/song so powerful that it could literally make you go insane? We know this stuff exists (brainwashing, cults, ...), but can you super concentrate it?
- guscost 8y agoFor those who haven’t seen it, here’s the classic Funniest Joke in the World skit: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YeMnPyusuBE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YeMnPyusuBE
- api 8y agoThat stuff is kind of like adversarial examples for human brains, and it probably is possible to deeply study the brain and create super indoctrination techniques. At some point we are going to be forced to start regulating persuasion.
- dboon 8y agoThis is a core idea in Infinite Jest. I wouldn't recommend it to everyone, but if you fancy the writing style it is surreally poignant on today's addiction culture.
- zpallin 8y agoHowever, such memetic behavior such as fads, echo chambers, and meme outbreaks predates the internet and even modern technology. So, according to your logic, it would seem we have always been the Borg.
- 8y ago
- narrator 8y agoKind of reminds me about how they say the highest level of automation of self-driving cars will be no steering wheel. Who decided that that was higher on the scale and a good thing? The "progress" defined here is complete control over all actions of individuals in society by an AI god. These scales by which progress toward the future is measured are a key ingredient of social engineering. One task that Free Software Foundation type organizations could take upon themselves is to define a road map for future progress of technology that recognizes freedom and human dignity.
- dpark 8y ago> Kind of reminds me about how they say the highest level of automation of self-driving cars will be no steering wheel. Who decided that that was higher on the scale and a good thing? Everyone who's ever sat in traffic. It's a miserable experience and it is indeed a fundamentally better thing to be able to use that time in a more productive or entertaining fashion. Few people care if the steering wheel is entirely absent, so long as it's not needed and it's not in the way. > The "progress" defined here is complete control over all actions of individuals in society by an AI god. Who is defining progress that way? Everyone I know who wants a self-driving car wants it to go where they tell it to.
- GenghisSean 8y ago> Everyone who's ever sat in traffic. It's a miserable experience and it is indeed a fundamentally better thing to be able to use that time in a more productive or entertaining fashion. Few people care if the steering wheel is entirely absent, so long as it's not needed and it's not in the way. I'm sure many car enthusiasts care whether the steering wheel is entirely absent. Some people enjoy driving, albeit usually in times/places without much traffic. If someone who found driving therapeutic instead spends their commute time staring at a social media feed on their phone because that's their default action when they aren't sure what to do, would that be fundamentally better for them? > Who is defining progress that way? Everyone I know who wants a self-driving car wants it to go where they tell it to. Of course everyone wants self-driving cars to go where they tell it, but that is different from having control over where the car goes. What if the AI that controls the self-driving car takes 99% of people to their destination, but rounds up a few political dissidents and whisks them away to an unknown location. Most everyone would get what they want, but none of the passengers are able to control where the AI takes them. Like Stallman says, "Either the users control the program or the program controls the users."
- skymuse 8y agoI read some of google's patent mentioned in the text and thought it was interesting. They basically want a connected network of devices that communicate with each other and with google. Most of the devices follow the following algorithm: watch -> think -> act -> report. What is interesting is the 'report' phase of the algorithm. I think there is a battle between two competing AI philosophies. One philosophy thinks AI should be central: all devices need to talk to the overmind for learning. The other philosophy thinks AI should be local: the device should learn on its own, kind of like a biological agent. I think the 'biological agent' form of AI is interesting when it comes to privacy of information. Only you and the device have the data. The future of AI should be interesting with these two philosophies in mind.
- pacala 8y agoJudging by the relative success of biological and social systems, systems that communicate effectively with each other end up much smarter than systems that don't communicate as effectively. Smarter as in winning the competition for resources more often. The big question is whether we can build systems that communicate, but don't create vast disparities of information between overminds and everybody else. At this point the handful of information slurping mega-corporations have a huge information advantage compared with the average person. If nothing changes, this is the end of the humanistic world order based on the primacy of the individual brain.
- SkyMarshal 8y agoThe latter philosophy sounds like what Apple is working towards with their recent A12X chip direction.
- zapita 8y agoThere is a possible middle-ground between central and local AI: federated learning. Its goal is to provide the best of both worlds. Here's a recent paper: https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/04/federated-learning-collaborative.html https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/04/federated-learning-collabo...
- robocat 8y ago>One philosophy thinks AI should be central > The other philosophy thinks AI should be local I suspect is usually a mixture. For example Google Translate runs locally if you download a language pair, yet the training is not local. Google Gboard Swipe runs locally: in airplane mode I just added a new word to the dictionary and swipe recognised it, also contact names. However Google sends swipe information to a central location to improve the service...
- mpr6 8y agothe tools of our tools
- mauld 8y agoThis is scary, but it is important we recognize that we can be controlled and have our behaviour modified by altering our environment - and that is can be a good things. Who hasn't delete Steam from their computer for a few weeks, thrown out junk food or set up a good workspace in order to promote a behavior in ourselves we want to cultivate, to be more like the person we want to be? The important thing is that in those situations our environment remained under our control and conscious, and we need to ensure our personal and digital environment remain under our control, and its goals are transparent - and I am not sure companies like Google do or will always agree.
- core-questions 8y agoThe key thing to keep in mind here is incentives and motivation. You have a motivation toward self improvement, you make a change to your environment, monitor it, and see what happens. You want to increase your physical fitness, awareness, education, life position, finances, etc. and you make corresponding changes where you and yours are the primary beneficiaries. Google has a motivation to deliver value to their shareholders. They want to deliver more, so they take advantage of their privileged position in our lives and change our environment for us without asking, monitor it, and see what happens. They have far more capability for analysis and, considering the scale, far more financial motivation to make tiny adjustments that we would pass over in our own optimizations. Is it necessarily evil or bad for us? No, it doesn't have to be, but I have very little faith in Google to make any choices that even border on altruistic when it's far more profitable to exploit us. Let's remember that fundamentally they are an advertising company, and that drives most of the money in the business; advertising isn't just ads as we know them, but fundamentally the business of changing your mind, suggesting things, and influencing your behaviour to make you exchange some money for some service or good. When you have a privileged position of influence, and you're willing to sell it to literally anyone who signs up, there is clearly a lot of potential for abuse.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoNo, it doesn't have to be, but I have very little faith in Google to make any choices that even border on altruistic when it's far more profitable to exploit us. I think there's a case to be made here that Google's motivations can mirror those of the users and that it's in Google's best long term interest for that to be the case. It seems obvious to me that a company that can be aligned with their customer's desires will have the most longevity, which may mean forgoing temporary, short term revenue gains. I'm not so naiive to think that it currently is the state of things, or that it's simple for this to be the case - quite the opposite. Rather, my point is that there is no law of economics that guarantees users and corporations must be in conflict or that corporations will always do better financially by exploiting users to the users' detriment (or that a competitor that does that will beat one that doesn't).
- skybrian 8y agoIf you hired a human assistant (or had an assistant at work), they would know when you're working and generally what you're up to. It would make sense that a digital assistant would need to know these things, too. It's inherently a high-trust relationship. Of course, the risks are different when you're trusting a device from a large corporation to take on a role that a human would do. I wouldn't buy one, but some people will decide it's worth it, and I don't think they are losing their freedom by giving orders to a machine.
- pacala 8y agoIf I catch said human assistant reporting my daily activities to a third party, they will be terminated with extreme prejudice.
- skybrian 8y agoIt's not a third party. Google/Amazon is providing the service.
- pacala 8y agoThat's the definition of a third party.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoWho is the second party?
- pacala 8y agoThe human assistant.
- PeterisP 8y agoThe digital "assistant". If we're using the analogy of assistants, then the same logic applies as with real assistants. The device doing its job can have my information, but sending it back to the mothership, even if it's for the purposes of improving the service for such devices in general, then it's the equivalent of a real assistant babbling about my private stuff to their colleagues, which is immoral and a fireable offence.
- jpm_sd 8y agoAll Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace I like to think (and the sooner the better!) of a cybernetic meadow where mammals and computers live together in mutually programming harmony like pure water touching clear sky. I like to think (right now, please!) of a cybernetic forest filled with pines and electronics where deer stroll peacefully past computers as if they were flowers with spinning blossoms. I like to think (it has to be!) of a cybernetic ecology where we are free of our labors and joined back to nature, returned to our mammal brothers and sisters, and all watched over by machines of loving grace. by Richard Brautigan (1967)
- elvinyung 8y agoFoucault, of course, talks about this. In Discipline and Punish: >But the Panopticon was also a laboratory; it could be used as a machine to carry out experiments, to alter behaviour, to train or correct individuals. To experiment with medicines and monitor their effects. To try out different punishments on prisoners, according to their crimes and character, and to seek the most effective ones. To teach different techniques simultaneously to the workers, to decide which is the best. To try out pedagogical experiments – and in particular to take up once again the well-debated problem of secluded education, by using orphans ... It's interesting to note that the argument made in this post is exactly what Deleuze said two decades after Foucault [1], that the mechanisms of "discipline" are moving outside of enclosed spaces because of the ever-longer trails of data that we leave everywhere. [1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/778828 https://www.jstor.org/stable/778828
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoSomething just occurred to me: it seems like a lot of the outrage over ads and privacy is just intellectual elitism: "Sure, I am too aware of these techniques and mentally strong to ever be influenced by marketing, but what about the rest of humanity? Google will control their minds like a virus and soon destroy the world!"