6 ms·
When having fun on Twitter went awry for Brent
- jmmcd 8y agoIn the end, they're optimistic that Twitter can be a positive and fun experience, but I don't share that optimism.
- smacktoward 8y agoMe neither. There are a bunch of core design decisions baked deep into Twitter that all encourage users to be confrontational and produce drive-by snark. I’m not sure how you remove those design decisions without turning Twitter into something that’s no longer Twitter.
- ColonelBlimp 8y agoWhat core design decisions? It's a real question. I closed my Twitter account when I realised it made me unnecesarily unhappy but without really knowing why.
- Quarrelsome 8y agoCharacter limit and somewhat unadulterated spread of popular tweets would be my guess. Encourages "drive by snark" and shows stuff to people that are likely to snark.
- smacktoward 8y agoI wrote a whole thing on that subject :-D You can read it here: https://jasonlefkowitz.net/2013/02/i-kind-of-hate-twitter/ https://jasonlefkowitz.net/2013/02/i-kind-of-hate-twitter/
- eksemplar 8y agoI agree, this article is basically a long list of unfortunate and terrible things. If you can’t even keep the happy achievements of a guy with downs from descending into an angry internet mob, then there really isn’t much hope for a positive future for twitter, is there?
- partiallypro 8y agoThat's because the article is focused on the negatives, not the positives. There are negative people everywhere, in life. You have bad waitresses and good waitresses, people that cut you off in traffic and people that let you in. It's part of being alive.
- danso 8y agoThey were on Twitter for at least a year. Presumably they had a number of positive experiences too mundane to mention in a story focused on the unforeseen consequences. I think in general, Twitter can be a good experience up until the time your tweets reach a broad audience, at which point, you run into the two problems of not being able to please everyone, and, offended people being the loudest people (in reviews, and every other kind of online discussion).
- gambiting 8y agoTwitter is literally cancer. I'm genuienly scared of it - why would you go and share your opinion on it, if it can literally result in waking up the next day to find out you've been fired for your job and millions of people are talking about how awful human being you are, because someone read something out of context. It's just far too much risk to be yourself on it and write what you think - it can only lead to bad things.
- izzydata 8y agoYour Twitter is a self curated feed of the people you want to see. The idea that people intentionally seek out stuff to hate is a people problem and not a platform problem.
- gambiting 8y agoSure, but I quite like to comment on things that interest me. I can do that safely here or some smaller forums that I frequent - like, there's nearly zero chance that a comment on HN will go viral and will be seen by millions of people. HN doesn't have that effortless re-sharing functionality twitter has, so controversial comments don't snowball into viral sensations within hours, they just can't. But on Twitter, that is a real risk - if I comment on a tweet by celebrity or a journalist and someone takes an issue with it, it can be retweeted instantly and at no effort. That's the risk coming from the way the platform is designed.
- cvwright 8y ago> Your Twitter is a self curated feed of the people you want to see. While that may have originally been the intention of the site, and it might even be what Twitter still publicly claims to do, that is not at all what they actually give you now. A couple of years ago, Twitter was awesome for keeping up with interesting new work in my topic area. More recently, it's a sh!t show of angry, snarky people I don't know, ranting about things that I either don't care about or could easily find somewhere else. Maybe these people are all friends of a friend of a friend. I don't know and I don't care. I only log in when I have something to post -- usually some sort of shameless self promotion for a new paper or a talk.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSo far, my experience of Twitter has been overwhelmingly positive. As detailed elsewhere in this discussion, I have a disability and I have two special needs sons. I don't share your pessimism.
- mabbo 8y ago> "Do you want a medal?" one woman quipped. > "Do you mean a man rather than a child Brent? It comes across as a man rather than a woman and I'm sure you don't believe that women can't choose their clothes and hair!" the academic tweeted. As difficult as it must be to live with Down's Syndrome, I feel so much more pity towards the kind of people who gets pleasure criticizing the mentally disabled on the internet.
- gadders 8y agoI'm not even sure if they knew he was disabled. I think it was more a reflex to call people out for perceived wrongs.
- weberc2 8y agoThe article was pretty clear about the first case, but it was unclear about the second. But yes, "call out culture" is tedious and ugly and narcissistic. Some people feel the need to correct anything that can be perceived as unorthodox to their political views, especially when it clearly wasn't meant as a political comment in the first place.
- gadders 8y agoYeah, that need to correct random people on the internet happens a lot: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-35581577 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-35581577
- kazagistar 8y agoAlmost everything is a bit political. But yeah, sometimes it's just not really appropriate to comment on those politics. But with enough people, someone is inevitably going to screw up and do it anyways.
- mikestew 8y agoIn the first case, disabled or not, who the fuck asked you, lady? Oh, she was "mortified" when she found out the details. She ought to be mortified that she shit-posts to random people that she's obviously never met. In the second case, I'd bet real money the academic was not apologetic in the slightest. You know the type, Jesus Christ/Mohammed/Buddha himself could come and gently point out, "you're, umm, doing it wrong" and the response would be, "yeah, but..." In summary, I don't think the abilities of the target played into it. Those are just the kind of people most of us try to avoid interaction with, and they are demonstrating why.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ahqu 8y agoI can't help but wonder what the hell did the family expect in this case. The internet is not full of assholes... Life is full of assholes, and the internet lets us all express ourselves anonymously. That's all there is to it
- dasil003 8y agoI think it's more nuanced than that. How about: we are all assholes sometimes, the internet (and Twitter in particular) makes it harder to keep those reactions in check.
- booleanbetrayal 8y agoTwitter is the worst platform ever. It brings out the absolute worst in people, rewarding for shock.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoWhen I read something like this my first instinct is always to do a root-cause-analysis (5 why's) like I would with a software problem. I recommend trying it. What went wrong? - An innocent person has heard hurtful things about himself on twitter - Why? (Is it Twitter is too negative? Or Twitter exposes you to greater range/quantity of remarks? Or because his mom made an account for him? ) All good questions, let's go with the first one - Why is twitter negative? (Is it just a convenient place to expose the negativity people always feel? Is it just a certain subset of bad users who enjoy creating drama for kicks? Or does the environment lead to escalating miscommunication/conflict?) - Why does the environment lead to escalating miscommunication/conflict? (Because you might not recognize if a tweet is by somebody with down syndrome when an online medium? Because it's easy to misunderstand somebody if you judge them on isolated remarks? Because a lot of discussion is on emotional topics which leads to impulsive tweets? Because it's easier to get angry at a remark than a person?) ...
- jimworm 8y agoFor me, the more shocking discovery in that article is that there are actually organisations that consider genetic screening for Down's Syndrome to be eugenic discrimination. Although people with Down's syndrome have a high likelihood of passing on Down's syndrome if they do have children, inherited cases are extremely rare.
- camillomiller 8y agoStories like these tend to convince me that the total balance of having social networks in the world is utterly negative. They are the equivalent of leverage in options trading for human interactions and communications.
- Yhippa 8y agoTwitter has changed so much since the beginning. It used to be a "smaller" community of people who posted content or brain-thoughts in good faith. Over time it's gotten so incredibly edgy and hostile in almost every type of content whether it be technology, sports, or some other thing. Tragedy of the commons.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWonderful article. More power to Jacqui and Brent. I'm seriously impressed with the position they take here on various matters. She's a minister and she seems to walk the walk more than most I've known. That heartens me. I've known a few people like that and they are always wonderfully life giving to be acquainted with. I live with a serious disability and I have raised two special needs sons. They are adults and still live with me. Neither has ever had a job, though they nursed me back to health after doctors essentially wrote me off for dead. So I have some firsthand experience with the challenges involved in trying to talk about life with a disability or a special needs relative. It's challenging in all situations. I don't know that it is really worse on the internet. It certainly gets magnified by the fact that you can be talking at so very many more people than you are likely to be dealing with in meat space. But I am generally more open online than in person about the special needs in the family. I find it vastly worse to deal with the crap in person. In most cases, ignorant, appalling remarks on the internet won't materially harm me in the same way and to the same degree that ignorance and prejudice IRL can rapidly become a huge problem. There are ways in which I do feel materially harmed by such on the internet, but it's just vastly more problematic in a very immediate way to have people in meat space putting their ignorance in my way.
- telesilla 8y agoWhat I found most interesting in this article is the awareness that because of early testing, Down's Syndrome is going to be less common. That's a really heavy question for society to consider: this is a genuine issue of technology having serious implications. Ironically, the article ends with "often, disabled people find that whatever they do becomes political to others".