9 ms·
This is a fine thing to do with $1.8B and that amount could be used in worse ways. Still: Together, the federal and state governments should make a new commitm
by jseliger 8y ago
This is a fine thing to do with $1.8B and that amount could be used in worse ways. Still:
Together, the federal and state governments should make a new commitment to improving access to college and reducing the often prohibitive burdens debt places on so many students and families.
There may be no better investment that we can make in the future of the American dream — and the promise of equal opportunity for all.
At the moment, zero incentivizes colleges to reduce costs. If they can get a student in the door, the federal government will ensure that student loans are available and that the college gets paid no matter what happens to the student. Regulators, in the meantime, work hard to ensure that colleges and especially universities face little competition.
So we get an array of problems: we are all, in a way, paying for the party: https://jakeseliger.com/2014/04/27/paying-for-the-party-elizabeth-armstrong-and-laura-hamilton https://jakeseliger.com/2014/04/27/paying-for-the-party-eliz.... Already prestigious schools like Hopkins compete primarily to raise their own prestige, rather than improve access. Why do most such schools admit fewer students per capita than they did in 1950? Why are they so interested in discriminatory children-of-alumni admissions?
While I don't want to look a gift horse in the mouth, I've been involved in post-secondary education for too long, and read too many books on it (Tyler Cowen's The Great Stagnation is recommended, as is his book The Complacent Class), to think that "more money, same system" is the answer. We need comprehensive, systemic reform, starting with the accreditation bodies, before we pour more money in.
- closeparen 8y agoGraduation rates as they are, college access is probably too high. Increasing selectivity would prevent the waste of time and money on programs people aren’t equipped to complete.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoYou can't expect the edus to say no to easy money. And the students are raised to think they are entitled tto success, whether they are cut out for that path or not. It's PC to say "everybody gets a degree." The reality is, that's a very expensive empty promise.
- sjg007 8y agoWe should really improve K-12 education. The fact that kids are not qualified for college after 18 years in public school is a travesty.
- cdoxsey 8y agoThe fact that so many jobs require a college degree is a travesty. We should get teenagers into the workforce sooner and provide more relevant and on-the-job training.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoThos jobs will be replaced by AI. But let me see a Roomba fix your broken toilet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 8y agoIt's not that they're not qualified. They're just not college material __and__ there's not enough mid / highend jobs for them. At the same time, the trades are hurting for good people. But the entitled are too good to be fully employed. They'd rather taken on debt. Given where AI is headed the higher edu route is not going to improve. Yet BHO, who knows better, kept beating the "higher edu for all" drum.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThey're not entitled, they’re just not being compensated enough to do labor which has quite a bit of negative effects on your health and quality of life compared to office jobs. Once you see people opting for the trades, then you will know they are getting proper compensation.
- 8y ago
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "At the moment, zero incentivizes colleges to reduce costs. If they can get a student in the door" This has been the standard for a while now. Why does higher edu charge more? Because they can!!! The market has been injected with cheap money and relatively under qualified candidates. The edus make out. The lenders make out. The students loose. And the public is completely clueless as to why. Most actuallt believe more / even cheaper loans are the solution.
- docbrown 8y ago>This has been the standard for a while now. Why does higher edu charge more? Because they can!!! Partially true but there are many other reasons why. Personally, I always thought it was administrative bloat which in turn put higher costs on the students. A 2015 study[0] shows that the real culprit could be as simple as less state support per research institution.[1] >more than half of core educational expenses at “public” 4-year universities are now funded through tuition, a private source of capital, they have effectively become subsidized private institutions. [0] https://www.demos.org/publication/pulling-higher-ed-ladder-myth-and-reality-crisis-college-affordability https://www.demos.org/publication/pulling-higher-ed-ladder-m... [1] https://www.demos.org/sites/default/files/imce/Pulling%20Up%20the%20Higher%20Ed%20Ladder%20Fig%205.png https://www.demos.org/sites/default/files/imce/Pulling%20Up%...
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "A 2015 study[0] shows that the real culprit could be as simple as less state support per research institution" But that's still a "because they can" reason.
- cwbrandsma 8y agoOr have to. They built up with a certain amount of support from the government in mind, then the government dropped the ball. The schools then increase because they have too. But that doesn't explain the rising costs of private colleges. At the same time, as the father of a high school senior, you quickly find very few kids pay the sticker price.
- kristianp 8y agoIt is just insane that 1.8B should be spent on just Johns Hopkins. This doesn't sound like anywhere near the most efficient way to help the most students who are missing out on places because the institution looks at their ability to pay. Does Bloomberg have an alterior motive to limit his donations to just his Alma Mater? Does he just want a wing of the library named after him or something? I'm frustrated reading this article, it compares poorly to the Gates foundation model of trying to help the maximum number of people per dollar.
- evanelias 8y ago> Does he just want a wing of the library named after him or something No, as there are already numerous Hopkins things bearing Bloomberg's name for many years -- including a 7-story physics/astronomy building, and the entire graduate public health school. The new $1.8B is in addition to previous total gifts of $1.5B. Bloomberg previously established a scholarship program for high-achieving incoming undergrads, but it was limited in size to a few dozen students a year. It sounds like the new money will allow this to expand to all students in need. Some universities like Harvard already did this, but Hopkins never did, due to its endowment being smaller than its peer institutions. This could be very good for the future of Baltimore. Many decades ago, a decent percentage of Hopkins undergrads came from Baltimore public schools, and that percentage has plummeted precipitously as Baltimore's fortunes declined. I do understand your overall point, but it's Bloomberg's money, and it's his decision how to spend it. I'd also suspect he gives money to other causes, although perhaps not on this scale.
- Retric 8y ago> it's Bloomberg's money A large chunk of that money is subsidized by tax payers, as he would not keep the 1.8 Billion if he had bought a sports team or other vanity project that was not tax deductible. I am not saying spending taxpayer money to promote giving is a bad idea, but it is an expensive one that’s generally forgotten about.
- joemi 8y ago
- eli_gottlieb 8y ago>So we get an array of problems: we are all, in a way, paying for the party: https://jakeseliger.com/2014/04/27/paying-for-the-party-eliz... https://jakeseliger.com/2014/04/27/paying-for-the-party-eliz.... Already prestigious schools like Hopkins compete primarily to raise their own prestige, rather than improve access. Why do most such schools admit fewer students per capita than they did in 1950? Why are they so interested in discriminatory children-of-alumni admissions? Thanks for raising these issues, as a well-evidenced contrast to the "usual" complaint that our society provides too much access to higher education. I largely agree with your analysis. The question isn't too much or too little. It's: who gets how much of what? If some students are deprived of vocational opportunities while others are stuck in understaffed, lower-tier institutions than their abilities warrant, society is leaving productivity and human well-being on the table in both cases.
- evanelias 8y agoI understand you're referring to the broader picture, but in the specific case of Hopkins and Bloomberg's gift, the pattern-matching feels a bit off. > Why do most such schools admit fewer students per capita than they did in 1950? This is just one data point, but I'm a Hopkins alum, and the current freshman class is 30% larger than my freshman class was in 2001. That exceeds the growth rate of the US population over the same time period, although I'm not sure about the equivalent growth rate of college-freshman-aged population specifically. Admissions growth requires new dorm construction, which typically involves a large donation for naming rights. > Why are they so interested in discriminatory children-of-alumni admissions? I think this effect is more pronounced in the Ivy League, partially due to the schools being much older. I only ever met a handful of legacy students at Hopkins. Related to legacy admissions, from what I remember, the JHU alumni giving rate is a bit sub-par, which is a contributing factor to its endowment being smaller than peer schools'. There are even several cases of campus buildings going nameless for decades while awaiting a donor. One example, a building constructed in 1988 was called "New Engineering Building" until a donor was found in 2012. Another example, two dorms built in the early 80s are still called "Building A" and "Building B". (All the other dorms are named after alums...)
- ericmcer 8y agoYeah it feels insane to me. Like if the price of milk went up to $50 a gallon the solution would be to increase supply, figure out alternative products, etc. A stupid solution would be to build a system of loans, government subsidies and other programs that allow people to pay the $50, but that seems to be our go to way to solve problems.
- geezerjay 8y agoI have yo agree. The first thing that crossed my mind when I saw the $1.8B figure was "with that kind of cash why doesn't he just launch his own university?". I mean, that astronomical level of cash is more than enough to keep a lot of high-paying jobs for some decades without any revenue at all, not to mention building the infrastructure. I'm sure he would be more than welcomed in any midsized city if he reached out to any local government asking for help building a college campus.
- netcan 8y agoIn this case it isn't "we," it's a specific person and it's a reflection of his take on the world. I don't think there's any doubt that I think he outline his own thinking pretty well. He wants elite colleges to stay as they are now, but more meritocratic in their admissions. Same elite institution, students from lower income backgrounds. It's an establishment-oriented donation, not a startup idea. He explains it pretty clearly.
- netcan 8y agoIn this case it isn't "we," it's a specific person and it's a reflection of his take on the world. I think he outlined his own thinking pretty well. He wants elite colleges to stay as they are now, but more meritocratic in their admissions. Same elite institution, but with students from lower income backgrounds. It's obviously an establishment-oriented donation, not a "radically transform education" idea or an "effective altruism" oriented idea. He explains his own thinking pretty clearly.