7 ms·
Why affordable housing is scarce in progressive cities
- someguydave 8y agoProgressives should explain why good neighborhoods and schools and high home values are more important than inclusive housing policies.
- kasey_junk 8y ago“Progressives” largely believe those things aren’t mutually exclusive. So why should they explain your position?
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoHigh home values and inclusive housing policies are directly opposed. They exclude anyone who can't afford high housing prices.
- kasey_junk 8y agoYet there is public housing in Chelsea NYC. We can argue about how to do ‘inclusive housing’ but the idea that it immediately precludes high home prices doesn’t hold up to basic inspection.
- someguydave 8y agoLand use regulation doesn't preclude high home prices, it precludes low home prices. Excluding people who can only buy or rent a low priced house is an exclusive policy. Balancing that exclusive policy with a little bit of inclusive policy in form of a government/"low income" apartment does not make the overall housing policy inclusive.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Yet there is public housing in Chelsea NYC. This is a classic political maneuver. Build two units out of a thousand with regulated prices, then declare victory because you can point to one person paying an affordable price, even though it's being sold below market at restricted volumes and isn't available to everyone. If the same units were available at that price but in unrestricted quantity to every member of the public, the high prices of competing housing would fall.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> a shortage of new construction, a lack of tenant protection "Tenant protection" -- especially rent control -- is a nontrivial cause of the shortage of new construction. High rents are a signal to developers that there is money to be made constructing new housing. If it's not possible to make the money, they won't do the construction, which is what rent control causes. You get a population of existing residents with rent controlled apartments, who then have no incentive to fix the housing shortage or eliminate rent control, but insufficient construction going on and consequently even higher prices for people who didn't get a rent controlled apartment in 1975. (Restrictive zoning is another, independent cause of the same problem, and the two compound each other.)
- dvdhnt 8y agoI’m not saying you’re wrong, but saying there’s no benefit to building new housing because there’s not a fortune to be made, well that just seems like capitalist-apologizing. We’ve built a system where humans are expected to somehow accrue interest at the whim of the capitalist overlord. The soul of rent control is pretty important, so maybe rent control needs to evolve? I’m hard pressed to defend it completely because it seems like dancing around the fundamental problem of capitalism not being in alignment with the best interests of society.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I’m not saying you’re wrong, but saying there’s no benefit to building new housing because there’s not a fortune to be made, well that just seems like capitalist-apologizing. It's just math. The land costs a million dollars, the construction costs $500K, therefore the net present value of the future rents (less property taxes, insurance, etc.) has to be $1.5M, or the construction does not occur. Rent control puts the marginal construction project below the break-even point. > We’ve built a system where humans are expected to somehow accrue interest at the whim of the capitalist overlord. The soul of rent control is pretty important, so maybe rent control needs to evolve? The soul of rent control is bad math. If you want lower rents, adopt policies that encourage housing construction until rents are suitably low. At which point, who needs rent control?
- 8y ago
- shse 8y agoCities are full. US population has doubled since 1960. If we get rid of zoning we will end up with overpopulated cities like Hong-Kong, Jakarta, Moscow, Tokyo.
- angersock 8y agoCheck out Houston.
- jayd16 8y agoIsn't Houston left leaning?
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Isn't Houston left leaning? No. Houston is centrist, which for a city is right-leaning.
- shse 8y agoThey have deed restrictions.
- techsupporter 8y agoAnd aren’t most of those deed restrictions for perpetuity so, unlike zoning, the property can never be used for something else?
- ajmurmann 8y agoThat sounds amazing!
- shse 8y agoThat’s how it will look like https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AoPpFfXwx_o https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AoPpFfXwx_o
- skybrian 8y agoA philosophical question: is it ever okay for someone to have to move away to find affordable housing? Or do we say that once someone becomes resident of a community, they should be able to live there forever? (This isn't just renting; there are similar issues with home owners and property tax increases.)
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoI think the greater context here misses the trauma behind being forced to move out of a home. Being separated from your social network, familiar surroundings, into a new and unknown environment can be highly traumatizing to the people who move and the community which loses its members. Children have their educations interrupted, elders lose a family of support, adults need to forge new friendships in a time where we know the majority of friendships occur in childhood. The greater question is if it's okay for someone to undergo the trauma of being moved because they can no longer afford the geographic location that they didn't choose to be born and raised into.
- skybrian 8y agoDoes it have to be a trauma? After all, most people don't live with their parents forever. Finding your own place is a rite of passage. Most college students graduate and move somewhere else. One way of preventing trauma would be to make sure people don't have to move. Another way would be to make moving something to look forward to, rather than a trauma.
- orcdork 8y agoYes, of course having to move due to no longer being able to afford living in the place you've lived on for say 10+ years, downsizing probably not only in living space, but also quality of surroundings, is comparable to leaving your college dorm in your early 20s. I guess one way of preventing trauma is pretending it doesn't exist by making ridiculus comparisons.
- skybrian 8y ago
- jayd16 8y agoThese article are pretty ridiculous and I see this political bent more and more on here. The article/book makes a huge leap in assuming progressive cities are somehow worse at housing. The reality is people actually want to live there. The most densely populated cities in the US, and in general all cities, lean left politically. Finding new housing is important but we're really losing perspective on how successful these policies have been historically. Its a silly as writing an article about NASCAR crashes. They must be terrible drivers.
- Domark 8y agoThe problem is, I've been hearing about these problems since I lived there in 1995. 1995 would have given an intelligent species enough time to build a money-losing, poor-people housing skyscraper or two. Yes building vertically in crowded places is a challenge and expensive but those are just excuses. Since 1995 they could have figured out a way to get the job done, so now we have to examine what the problems are.
- jayd16 8y agoBut again, you're starting at the point of assuming failure, when in fact these cities are the most dense. Feel free to examine but the core assumption that this is obviously the wrong way to do it is baseless.
- mynegation 8y agoI am all for vertical build but this idea is scary. The standards for maintaining tall buildings are especially high. There is a high chance this ends up being Kowloon city or going down in flames like Grenfell Tower. Let alone the political optics of putting a lot of poor people into a very limited space.
- gaadd33 8y agoIsn't that what the "towers in a park" style of public housing from the 60s and 70s are? From that we've found that it isn't a good solution, eg Cabrini–Green Homes or Robert Taylor Homes I think people have been looking into these issues for far longer than 1995.
- kokokokoko 8y agoIf it is bad policy, then can someone help explain why unaffordable housing is currently a world-wide issue?
- expertentipp 8y agoApparently supply-demand laws are more universal than those of Newton and self-regulating free market will soon reach climax ejaculating on our faces.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> If it is bad policy, then can someone help explain why unaffordable housing is currently a world-wide issue? 1) Because the incentives for enacting the bad policies are widespread, so the bad policies are widespread, so the problem is widespread. 2) It isn't. See cities like Houston and Tokyo which have lower housing costs than San Francisco or NYC.
- kokokokoko 8y agoIt does appear to also be a problem in Tokyo [1] Houston's economy is still recovering from a natural disaster [2] Are we sure this is not simply the product of a global shift towards populations migrating to urban centers? And maybe we might want to look at what is causing this rapid migration? For example economic growth has almost always gone hand in hand with rapid urban migration. "We know of no coun- tries that either achieved high incomes or rapid growth without substantial urbanization, often quite rapid." [3] So it appears that your solution to reducing housing prices, caused by economic growth, is to increase construction, which causes economic growth, which causes urbanization, which then leads us back to rising housing prices. What am I missing here? [1] http://japanpropertycentral.com/2018/02/rent-in-tokyo-reaches-record-high/ http://japanpropertycentral.com/2018/02/rent-in-tokyo-reache... [2] http://cokinoslaw.com/flood-hurricane-harveys-180-billion-impact-houstons-economy/ http://cokinoslaw.com/flood-hurricane-harveys-180-billion-im... [3] https://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTPREMNET/Resources/489960-1338997241035/Growth_Commission_Vol1_Urbanization_Growth.pdf https://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTPREMNET/Resources/489...
- zeroname 8y ago> Why affordable housing is scarce in progressive cities Because progressives don't like the poor, they just hate the rich.
- darren0 8y agoCan some explain why affordable housing is a problem that requires government policies to prevent? For example, I can't afford a home in Malibu, so I don't live there. I don't understand the issue. Why does government need to step in and fix this?
- saosebastiao 8y agoLack of affordable housing is a problem that government policies cause. Why not fix it?
- psadri 8y agoIt is a problem when not just Malibu, but the entirety of Los Angeles becomes unaffordable. Then people with less means need to live very far away from where they work, etc.
- darren0 8y agoI grew up in LA and left because it was unaffordable. So I don't understand the "crisis." Why can't people just move. Seems like the crisis is that maybe people have no mobility and are forced to work in over priced cities. But I don't understand why that is the case.
- brigade 8y agoRather than stepping in, the government really needs to step out of preventing infill development. AKA, the problem is created in a large part because of the government’s existing policies, thus they should change.
- zagzagal 8y agoWhile not a federal, or even state issue it is very much a locality issue. One which is unique to a given locality and is well within their rights to legislate. It's for the same reason right to farm laws exist, no community wants to give up its right of self direction to outsiders. Even if in many ways it's not to benifit of its neighbors.
- 8y ago
- Shivetya 8y agoWhen community activist groups combined with grand standing politicians can intimidate builders into giving up a fourth if not more of their units at below costs and best yet turned over to "management groups" appointed by the activist groups who are but extensions of the politicians election machine what do you expect? You can find stories similar to such all over the place. San Francisco recently had a 117 unit fall apart after all the conditions and accommodations of all "aggrieved" parties got their share and drove the costs beyond profitability. of course you get the typical political bs from the politicians and activist who always claim "if developers are willing to work with us they can get approved quickly" but that is the rub, the approval usually requires far too much outlay on the builder which in combination of set asides for "affordable" units then forces the rest of the units up a tier or two eliminating the market the developer was aiming for. this isn't about affordable anything, its about political power and money. many of these "activist" groups which claim to represent the people and use that as a basis to go to court to block builders are in fact merely extensions of various political election campaigns.
- hristov 8y agoThis is a very insightful article. Every discussion about high prices in cities usually ends into a big argument about rent control, but, in my opinion this is rarely the real issue. Rent control laws in the US are rather weak, and the percentage of rent controlled units is ever decreasing. I think this article points to a much more important issue. And that is existing real estate owners acting to keep the value of their holdings as high as possible, i.e., to keep prices as high as possible. A lot of the wealth in America is locked up in real estate and this is especially the case in large cities. The landowner lobby (although they do not call themselves that) is quite powerful. Actually the fact that rent control comes up so often as an issue is just another piece of evidence that the landowner lobby is so powerful that they are able to completely control the conversation. When faced with what is basically an accusation that they are gouging the population they turn it around and declare that the few weak laws that slightly reduce their ability to gouge are really the problem. And while rent control is a point of contention, the real way the landowner lobby keeps prices high is by restricting new construction. This is a much more important factor than rent control. A very important issue here is that homeowners and landlords are much more active in most political processes. If one person decides that he will dedicate his life on ownership of land and will make that the main source of his income, he will easily see that it is important to devote time and energy in a lot of the rather tedious local political processes. If a second person decides to dedicate his life to some type of profession or art instead, then local politics tend to become a bore and a time waster. But then the second person is not at the table when important decisions are made and his interests are negatively impacted. So the general answer is to be more active in politics. But how to be more active in politics? Here is an issue that the article did not really touch upon. The most important requirement for more construction and higher density living is the availability of infrastructure. Nobody will approve high density buildings without the infrastructure, nobody wants to create Mumbai style tenement cities. And the most important and most expensive part of infrastructure is transportation. Look at any successful large city in the world -- they are usually defined by their subway system. After all the subway is the only sane way to move large number of people around in a very dense environment. In fact the main battle against development of LA has been fought for the last 20-30 years over the LA subway. There have been some very successful attempts to slow down and block the development of the subway launched mostly by neighborhood groups. As a result the subway came in much later than originally planned and the most important and most desired line (the purple line) is still only a tiny fraction of what it should be. So if you want to help create more housing it is always best to vote in favor of new transportation projects, especially high density high efficiency projects, like the subway.
- dogma1138 8y ago“Progressive” gentrified, upper middle class and above and predominantly white while I have no idological problems when these form naturally through a free market I would call them exactly progressive either.
- oldmancoyote 8y agoHow important is this issue to HN readers? 41 points and 94 comments in 6 hours on a Sunday afternoon shows a powerful gut reaction.