3 ms·
Dude...people are down-modding you because you're being a jerk, not because of some misunderstood intricacy of your brilliant scientific argument. First off, a
by timr 19y ago
Dude...people are down-modding you because you're being a jerk, not because of some misunderstood intricacy of your brilliant scientific argument.
First off, a quick search tells me that Kawecki has been publishing on this topic for years:
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=kawecki%20quinine%20learning&ie=UTF-8&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&sa=N&tab=ws http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=kawecki%20quinine%20lear...
He's had numerous publications in PNAS, Science, Evolution, and other top-tier journals, building this hypothesis step-by-step. So perhaps you should back off your rhetoric about the research being a "joke" just a tad, okay? (At the least, perhaps you should go read one of his other papers before you decide that the man is a fraud.)
Now, to directly address your argument: "intelligence" is not a single trait. It's a complex, emergent phenomena, presumably involving many genes, in many different genetic loci. It's therefore highly unlikely that selection for the abstract trait of "intelligence" is also going to select for a decreased lifespan (another complex trait).
Thus, even if you're right, and even if the whole result is attributable to single-trait selection for "intelligence", it's still an interesting result. You've done nothing do "debunk" the interesting premise of the article -- that selection for intelligence appears to decrease overall fitness in flies.
Your obsession with single-trait selection seems to rest on the notion that if the result could be attributable to linkage, then it doesn't count. That's silly. We can debate the mechanism of action, but there appears to be a very real trade-off between learning ability and survival in this particular species. Arguing that it might only be a consequence of selection is to completely miss the point.
(Aside: I think it's interesting that you've now latched on to a subtle difference in wording between the NYT article and the claims made by the researcher. The NYT may have (debatably) been exaggerating the claims of the researchers, but your posts have all jumped to the conclusion that the original research was a "joke". Bad form, man.)
- Alex3917 19y agoFair enough, I apologize for being a jerk. That said, if the NYT had really said that "selection for intelligence appears to decrease overall fitness in flies" then I would have had no issue with the article. However, what the article actually said was that, "Learning also turns out to have dangerous side effects that make its evolution even more puzzling." That's not a minor error or a small exaggeration, it's outright fraud. And what's more, the entirety of this new article is based off the false premise of the original. That's why I'm upset. Anyways, my apologies to the researcher. My issue is mainly with the NYT.
- xlnt 19y agodon't back down or apologize because some jerk yelled at you "for being a jerk". :( you made good points, which does not constitute being a jerk. he made invalid points about how the guy has a reputation and history that don't address whether the particular ideas at issue are true; plus, he literally called you a jerk, which is name calling.