4 ms·
> On most Internal Pentests, I generally get Domain Admin within a day or two. Enterprise Admin shortly thereafter. Sounds realistic, from how most Windows sho
by fulafel 8y ago
> On most Internal Pentests, I generally get Domain Admin within a day or two. Enterprise Admin shortly thereafter.
Sounds realistic, from how most Windows shops are run.
Would it help to stop using AD to manage the IT infra, or have tiny domains (say, max 10 computers) without centralised control, and no company-internal workstation networks? Maybe throw in a rule that devices are recycled (to be wiped) frequently, say every 6 months.
- swiley 8y ago> Maybe throw in a rule that devices are recycled (to be wiped) frequently, say every 6 months. That would be doable if setting up devtools at most places didn't take an entire day.
- fulafel 8y agoThe first choice strategy obviously would be to automate this stuff. Because it's hard to mandate a flag day where everything must be automated, a transitional strategy might be: document each dev setup so well stepwise that you can outsource it to the IT dept or other internal support org. Maybe the dev team can provide a screencast of it, for example. The support org would then have an incentive to automate it to replace manual work, along with a measurable payoff for it.
- swiley 8y agoNO! now the automation has to be maintained and set up. The first choice strategy is to simplify the tools and application! Always with software people there is this tendency to add more abstraction and machinery when encountering complex abstractions and machinery. You only exacerbate the problem by doing this!
- spydum 8y agoContainers help solve this, no?
- Symbiote 8y agoIn a previous job I was asked to use a configuration management tool to automate setup and installation of a development environment. (Never did it though.) This would have been easy on a Linux desktop: installing Java, Maven, an IDE, and changing some settings files for the corporate proxy and artifact repository etc is very basic for Ansible, Puppet or Chef. It's probably achievable on Windows or OS X, although I'm not sufficiently familiar with them. Heavy customization of the IDE could be trickier; the configuration system doesn't necessarily stay very stable between releases. Maybe something that's part of a larger, well-designed system, like KDevelop, would be easiest.
- MBCook 8y agoAn entire day? I’ve seen it where it was EXPECTED that it normally took THREE WEEKS or so for a developer to have the set up correct to be able to develop the application they were hired for. It was a Java web app. Not some weird special embedded hardware or something. The app was just that (pointlessly) complicated to set up. Even in production it took quite a while despite being automated buy and installer and people having lots of experience installing it. Edit: sorry about the duplicated text. I’ve fixed it. I’m not a Java hater, I am in Java developer. I actually like the language. But the way this particular app is designed and configured, along with the Extertal systems that had to be reconfigured to be able to run at (which could have been eliminated) meant that setting up the system for developmental just took a ton of trial and error.
- raesene9 8y agoThe thing is that things like Active Directory are very useful in managing large numbers of systems and users. Ditching them would make IT much more expensive to run and, as many companies view operational IT as an expense to be minimized, that's a hard argument to carry.
- fulafel 8y agoThat's the conventional wisdom, but it really depends on what the alternative is. Many things done by an IT-dept provided environment often have negative value for many/most users and most of them can be dropped, or replaced with something less centrally managed.
- raesene9 8y agoOf course it depends on the alternatives. Less central management == more costs, right? you need more people to administer disparate systems Most corporations view IT operations as an overhead. What do you do with overheads.... you minimize them :) That said from a security standpoint, all those little disparate systems aren't really any easier to secure, in fact they're likely harder, it's just the consequences of compromise may be lower
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 8y agoLess automation, more sloppiness. I don’t think anyone particularly needs all the endpoints, either. Just enough of a foothold to go after networked applications.