7 ms·
UK austerity has inflicted 'great misery' on citizens, UN says
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoI'd take a little belt tightening over the youth unemployment Greece or Spain has any day.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ubernostrum 8y agoConsidering that the youth unemployment rates there correlate with policies that didn't just involve "tightening" the belt but arguably cutting off all circulation, you might want to re-think that. (much of Europe has been victimized by the cult of "austerity", and several countries have probably lost an entire generation's productivity thanks to these policies)
- nopriorarrests 8y ago>much of Europe has been victimized by the cult of "austerity" What cult? Capital markets decided that Greece is too risky to lend money to at reasonable rate. Same happened with Spain and Italy, but they were saved by European Central Bank which became a lender of last resort and bought plenty of their bonds, driving interest rate lower. It's not like Italy and Spain can easily tap capital markets borrowing trillions of euros at 1% interest rate, but decided not to do so because of 'cult of austerity'.
- grey-area 8y agoThe ECB has printed €2.4 trillion since 2015 and very little of that has gone to Greece, Italy or Spain. The tap was turned off for Greece by the EU when they refused to help them with debt (mostly owed to German banks) - this was a political decision, as was that to impose stringent austerity on Greece, on people who could not afford it (pensioners etc). It didn't have to happen that way, it was a deliberate choice. This had nothing to do with free markets (which really are not very free, they are massively impacted by central bank actions).
- nopriorarrests 8y ago>It didn't have to happen that way, it was a deliberate choice. What was the other choice? ECB printing money and lending it to Greece fully knowing it will be never paid back?
- Devils_Avocado 8y agoThe other choice was to let the Greek govt default on its debts; there're almost 300billion reasons why Germany & France didn't want to do that...
- nopriorarrests 8y agoNothing stops Greek government from defaulting. Just miss your next coupon payment, and viola. But once you default, you have to balance your budget, because nobody will lend to you, and until 2017 Greece were running a deficit. Default would cause even more pain than so much hated austerity.
- Devils_Avocado 8y agoNope. They already tried that, the troika rushed in to stop even the suggestion of that being a possibility.
- raverbashing 8y ago> to impose stringent austerity on Greece, on people who could not afford it (pensioners etc) So, if they can't afford austerity what makes you think they will repay debts in the future? "Pensioners" yes, usually from an inflated public sector. Untouchables. Who pays the price? The youth What about passing needed reforms? LOL, of course not, that will hurt the inflated public sector and their pensioners, never mind no one wants to invest there anymore. And the worse thing is, if you turn the tap on, you'll probably get the lovely results of "Abenomics", that is, people investing in BS like (existing or low demand) real estate or on non efficiency improving activities (like buying old computer parts for old systems) Before the "evil" ECB that lends with few guarantees those countries were paying the real cost of their debts (incl. currency devaluation) But then it was "Evil Germany" that could borrow with low interest rates while they had to pay high rates.
- em500 8y ago"Victimized by 'austerity'" is heavily overplayed. Even with 'austerity' policies, government spending in Greece is still around 50% of national income. Neither their own citizens (via taxes) nor foreigners (via lending) are willing to finance such spending, so what alternatives to decreasing spending would you suggest?
- atoav 8y agoIsn't it weird how austerity often targets the poor, while e.g. salaries of bureaucrats or politicians, as well as military and police spending are rarely part of these strategies. One can discuss about austerity as an effective strategy to slim-fit a nation. Making the government and public processes more effective, streamlined and effective, using less manpower to reach the same goal and increasing the efficency, speed and simplicity at the same time – this is a good goal. BUT this is definitly not what usually happens when governments say they need to save money, because those who know how to make the processes more efficient usually don't like to cut their own jobs/salaries/responsibilities. So they just cut some public service that affects nobody meaning-/powerful instead and sell it as a big reform.
- makomk 8y agoAside from how terrible this kind of "there are worse things elsewhere" argument is in general, this isn't even a choice. Like, a little belt tightening trashed the Greek economy. Utterly wrecked it. Did more damage and for longer than the 2008 global financial crisis.
- gordaco 8y agoSpain was no different, and from what I'm seeing, I think that there will pass many years before the damage of the "little belt tightening" is undone.
- emmelaich 8y agoIt was already wrecked and heading for a cliff. Austerity brings the cliff closer and reduces it's height. You'll notice the fall and blame austerity but it's better than the alternative.
- rtpg 8y agoEconomy is in a recession. Austerity means that the government is spending _even less_ into the economy. How do you think that makes the cliff less high? Not bailing out the banks during 2008 would have been austerity. It would also have made things probably twice as bad (2008 was bad, but the 30s were way worse, like 30% unemployment bad) There is no actual logical path between austerity and improved short or midterm economic performance. It’s feel good politics, simple and easy to understand but also plain wrong
- emmelaich 8y ago> ... government is spending _even less_ into the economy. Where do they get that money to spend? Money spent by individuals and companies is usually better spent than that by the government. (given a law-abiding high trust society) Money that passes through government is not magically imbued with some extra quality. More the opposite. Remember that story about it being cheaper to hire a taxi than go by train for two or passengers in Greece? That the Greek train system had more employees than passengers and lost a billion per year? https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-16834815 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-16834815 Of course I don't want to go overboard here; money spent wisely by the government on the public good can be more effectively (productively) than the individual or company.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoIs that really the only choice? The UK is one of the richest countries in the world. Part of the reason for that is a long period of generally pro-business, economically conservative government. That's good in many ways, because in a modern economy, business and investment is needed to drive improvements in individual living standards. But doing that relies on a sensible long-term strategy that can be used to achieve social goals. There is no point in cutting healthcare spending for preventative services, for example, if those cuts result in higher long-term costs. Cutting spending on disability benefits doesn't magically save money – it just transfers the cost of disability support to charities and carers, while in many cases destroying the lives of people who have worked and contributed for many years. The thing is, when you say "a little belt tightening", this actually means that people in the UK with the lowest incomes start to suffer and in some cases die. I struggle to believe that it is good long-term economic policy to have a large share of the population struggling to afford basic essentials, while the richest demographics continue to increase their wealth. In the most recent UK budget, I received a large tax cut despite being a relatively high earner. Indeed, UK policy seems to be continuing to shift in that direction, and the only possible reason I can see for that is a deliberate, ideological attempt to enact a policy of minimal public spending. The UK has many economic and structural problems which could be dealt with, but it's hard to see how continuing to redistribute wealth to the richest parts of the country is going to do that. And of course we now have an entire government that will be paralysed by the economic and political aspects of Brexit for the next decade, so I guess there's no immediate chance of salvation.
- raesene9 8y agoit's a real shame that the concept of raising certain taxes in the UK (specifically income tax and corporation tax) has become an anathema to british politicians. We still need to get the money from somewhere, so instead of fairly increasing progressive taxes, we get lots of little (often unfair) hidden tax rises and huge cuts in public spending. The weird part is, the british public go along with this. The Conservatives are actively talking about more corporation tax cuts at a time where we still have a large defecit and huge problems with underspending in the public sector.
- 8y ago
- emmelaich 8y agoYes, it's easy to avoid austerity by borrowing off the next generation.
- RobertoG 8y agoI know that the 'borrowing off the next generation' is a popular sentence, but, does that means anything at all? Would you prefer to live in a country with a high public debt and industry, infrastructure and an educated population or in a dessert with zero public debt? What even means the 'public debt' number when a country have its own currency and inflation is under control? Nothing at all.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y ago> What even means the 'public debt' number when a country have its own currency and inflation is under control? This is a question that you have to ask when using the analogy between a country's finances and e.g. a household. It _can_ mean that one part of the country (government, central banks) has created and loaned money to _other parts of the same country_. In other words, liquidity and investment. i.e. good things! This is fundamentally unlike a household.
- emmelaich 8y agoMany municipal councils in the USA have enormous debts due to generous pension schemes and inflated wages and salaries. That's about the most direct example of 'borrowing off the next generation' Someone has to pay the debts, and it mostly won't be those who benefited from it.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y agoThe idea that a country's budget can be compared to a family's budget is a big fallacy. They are fundamentally different.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThe idea that they are fundamentally different is also wrong, or did you think we don't need to service our debt?
- jahaja 8y agoBut it's the same belt for all three? I find it both fascinating and unsettling that there seem to be so many smart people that prefer and defends punitive action so reflexively that they will go to great lengths to give it the benefit of the doubt, even without ever doing some background research. Austerity is a great example of this. They intentionally starved the Greek economy to make a political point rather than produce an economically rational deal. Yet, at every anecdata like, HN, The office lunch table, etc. too many assume with confidence they have only themselves to blame and parrot obvious propaganda about the lazy, barely working, tax-dodging Greeks that's applied to them all, bottom-up.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoAusterity is not 'punitive', nor is your assessment of the OP's comment as 'reflective' necessarily correct. "They intentionally starved the Greek economy to make a political point" Greeks are smart people, that they are begging for free money from Germany does not mean that Germany is 'starving' anyone. "parrot obvious propaganda about the lazy, barely working, tax-dodging Greeks that's applied to them all, bottom-up." It's not propaganda - or at least not the 'non tax paying' part. Not only does Greece not have a functional tax system, they also demand to retire earlier with full benefits than workers in other nations. The Greeks have nobody to blame but themselves. Also when you say 'do a deal' what you mean is 'give Greece more free money' - i.e. throw good money after bad. The Germans would in fact, do a deal with the Greeks if they instituted proper economic reforms, by the way, which would not necessarily have to include austerity, but would definitely have to include reform of the tax system, possibly tourism industry etc. etc.. But Greece cannot do that, they are not functional enough to pull it off. The easiest option would be simply to devalue their currency, which they cannot do ... which might give you a clue as to the real source of economic Imperialism that is the Eurozone. Countries that cannot keep their books straight for whatever reason, but are otherwise functional, may have an intrinsic need to devalue their currency. It might be the best way for them to move forward - but the EU does not allow for that ... ... so maybe the Eurozone should be more of a 'trade zone' and less of a currency/political union, as so many people would like.
- 8y ago
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoIn Greece and Spain, the youth unemployment goes hand to hand with the belt tightening.
- RobertoG 8y agoLike in everywhere else. Employment is, obviously, a function of investment.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoYouth unemployment goes hand in hand with dysfunctional economies. The government does not create jobs by mass spending. In Canada we have marginally less 'government spending' and lower taxes and we have a very low unemployment rate. Now, a country certainly could operate effectively with higher rates of government spending, but my point is that this is not really the factor. Spain does not have a competitive economy and that's that.
- RobertoG 8y ago"Spain does not have a competitive economy and that's that." Competitive how? Salaries are lower than in Canada. Competitive with who? Do you mean the productivity is low? That's a function of industry development, that is impossible without investment.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThere are innumerable variables. Productivity is not just a function of investment. Spain doesn't form large organizations like they do in Germany and the UK. More people in Germany for example are employed in large organizations wherein they can create more sophisticated products like cars. Do they have extensive coop/internship programs for young people to work at large organizations? Is the civil service actually productive? My experience with our own Spanish office is that they are slack. I would say professionally disorganized. They'd probably just accuse me of bad 'life work balance' , which is fine. But the office hours, long lunches, absenteeism ... nobody really ever seemed to be doing anything. And FYI the work days were long .... Now that is anecdotal - my personal experience, I know that a lot of places hum along obvious, but most of my Spanish friends would concur with what I'm saying though probably not my language. Call it weather, culture, whatever but there's a different culture outlook and this cannot be ignored. Here's a good take that matched my sentiment [1] The problem with this 'investment' argument as it relates to Greece, Spain etc. is that only systems that are prepared for investment can possibly make good with it. Think of a company like a startup: should every startup receive $100M - would that make everyone successful? No - because most startups don't have 'product market fit' and they are not creating value. If a nation has the wherewithal and are ready for investment, well that's another thing. And of course consider how that capital is distributed ... by governments often to their civil servants and pensioners, which might be good, but it's also not exactly going to result in any kind of industrial development. [1] https://elpais.com/elpais/2014/12/17/inenglish/1418816737_691083.html https://elpais.com/elpais/2014/12/17/inenglish/1418816737_69...
- Sharlin 8y agoI might give this argument a little more credence had the ”little belt tightening” measures not been so transparently politically motivated wealth transfers from the poor to the rich. Funny how ”belt tightening” always applies to the least powerful.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThe poorest UK households have also seen their post-tax incomes rise faster than any other group since 2010. https://fullfact.org/media/uploads/Post_tax_incomes.png https://fullfact.org/media/uploads/Post_tax_incomes.png
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y ago> I'd take a little belt tightening over North Korea or Somalia. False dichotomy right there. Why not also include say, Sweden, France or Germany as more realistic comparisons?
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoSweden, France and Germany aren't valid comparisons because they weren't affected by the financial crisis like we were. In fact you could argue Germany has benefited from the problems of the problem economies because they have kept the Euro weak.
- RobertoG 8y agoHave you considered the possibility that youth unemployment is a consequence of belt tightening?
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThen why haven't we had it in the UK like the Mediterranean countries have?
- dingaling 8y agoRegardless of the actual story, which I do feel has merit, there are examples of why it is perilous to rely on one news source: "whose family couldn’t get school meals in Dumfries, Scotland, because of their immigration status" Actually they couldn't get free school meals, just like anyone else with a household income over £16k. A subtle omission but one that makes it sound like they were excluded from food entirely: https://www.mygov.scot/school-meals/ https://www.mygov.scot/school-meals/
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoFamilies below the income cut-off don't get fsm if they're working at all in Wales, not quite sure how that's supposed to work.
- ptx 8y agoI felt that was implied and obvious from context, since the entire article was about poverty. (But perhaps also because school meals are always free where I come from.)
- DanBC 8y ago> just like anyone else with a household income over £16k You've assumed that this child has been refused free school meals because of their financial status. The rapporteur is talking about the mis-application of "no recourse to public funds" rules. A family that has NRPF should still be able to get free school meals, but sometimes the schools don't understand this. This is a family who is poor, and who should be getting free school meals, but who aren't.
- dogma1138 8y agoNo recourse to public funds applies to only specific work immigration permits all of which would have salary requirements that would make them ineligible to receive these benefits in the first place. In fact applying for or using public funds while on an NRPF visa violates its terms and could result in deportation.
- 8y ago
- DuskStar 8y agoThis report is so horribly biased. The "austerity" in question is a decline in spending as a proportion of GDP since 2009, NOT actual cuts. That's normal when recovering from a recession!
- Nimitz14 8y agoWhen you're in recession you're supposed to stimulate growth by increasing spending. So no, you're wrong, it's the opposite of normal.
- DuskStar 8y agoAnd what do you do when coming out of a recession? Reduce spending or hold steady in absolute terms... Like what the British budget has done since the spending peak in the middle of the recession.
- RobertoG 8y agoA recession means that not enough money is spent in the economy. In that situation, a government should increase the spending, not use the situation as an excuse for cutting the public sector because ideological reasons. Or do you think that the intention is to restore those services when the economy goes better?
- DuskStar 8y agoWe're ten years from the start of the last recession. Should spending still be high to stimulate the economy, or are they perhaps not in a recession anymore? This isn't a case of a government reducing spending in response to an economic downturn. It's a government INCREASING spending due to that downturn, and then not further increasing it when the economy recovers.
- DanBC 8y agoThe government has not increased spending. The government has decreased spending.
- martinald 8y agoIt's a strange world where rising public sector spending as a % of GDP is looked at as horrific spending cuts. People are blaming the wrong thing - it's long age which is causing this. Even though spending is rising, it's not rising 'fast' enough to keep up with the giant bill senior citizens are creating for the NHS and DWP. As the govt has massively ramped up NHS spending and locked pension rises at a historicallg high level, it means every department that isn't catering to this is seeing larger cuts. Not really sure if just endlessly rising public sector spending to cope with old age can work long term.
- CJefferson 8y agoSimple measurements of money spent don't show the whole picture (as the article discusses). Many of the harshest cuts were against services for the poor, while other expenses (military, pension support for richer citizens) saw raises in spending above inflation.
- throw2016 8y agoWonder how long before he is sacked. Rare instance of establishment official bucking the narrative. These kind of reports are usually made about 'inconvenient regimes'. Austerity [1] is a dubious predatory ideology pushed by neoliberal economists parroting the mantra of freemarkets, privatization while pushing crude policies that benefit special interests. The modus operandi is defund public services, raise a ruckus about ensuing chaos and build the rationale for privatization. A country with its own currency is a not a household. In the case of the US the dollar being the global reserve currency provides even more freedom compared to any other country. Simplistic household type comparisons by agenda driven economists about complex modern economies are grossly misleading. You cannot bailout banks to the tune of trillions and them impose austerity on the population, this is not capitalism or freemarkets, its gross corruption. Where did this money come from? What about all the scares of 'runway inflation' by such massive injections, why were creditors bailed out and not debtors? Why shouldn't these funds be spent on the people the government represent and not special interests? Mark Blyth [1], Michael Hudson [2], Steve Keen and Joseph Stiglitz [3] are doing a lot of work on neoliberal economics and dubious policies like austerity. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQuHSQXxsjM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQuHSQXxsjM [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBi00-LBUnQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBi00-LBUnQ [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HzCRCX_gwII https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HzCRCX_gwII
- blunte 8y agoAs long as most gains and profits go to a small percentage of people ("the top x%"), no sort of retraction/austerity measure will provide long term large scale benefit. It will only exacerbate the situation. The first problem is measurement. Most current economic measurement methodologies don't consider history well enough - particularly where public funds have been used for infrastructure benefits. Using the US as an example, the modern status quo of life is built upon the interstate highway system. That's just one (very big) example of how public works/infrastructure has benefited the entire society - especially the business owners who can be more efficient due to well-oiled transportation systems. Perhaps some other rail-based system would be even more effective, but that's beside the point. But as humans are wont to forget the past, many people have forgotten that it took bold investment at a time when money was scarce to provide a foundation for the next 40+ years. So the fairly recent proclamations of small business owners that they built their own fortunes conveniently forgets that the entire population's investment some decades ago primed the situation that they find themselves in now. Austerity says the reverse: we will not spend anything on anyone out of public funds (unless some powerful group deems it necessary... such as where military is concerned). But what it fails to recognize is that the more people you have dying around you, the lower your health becomes. Ignoring ethical discussions, there are practical boundaries to questions of "how much is enough" for people on the upper end and "what is the minimum to live a better-than-horrible life" on the bottom end. I do not enjoy paying practically double the tax rate in Netherlands as I did in the US, but I find daily life SO much better (and safer) here. Being a king of a ghetto is no life. I'd rather the people cooking my food and washing my dishes at the restaurant not be hating my existence because they're so miserable. In fact, I'd rather them feel essentially equal so that when I compliment them on the food or service they feel pleased to have a conversation with me. That is living.
- dorchadas 8y ago> As long as most gains and profits go to a small percentage of people ("the top x%"), no sort of retraction/austerity measure will provide long term large scale benefit. It will only exacerbate the situation. Exactly. It seems common sense that the economy will grow when the people have money to spend...Which means the people who spend (i.e. not the high socioeconomic people) need money to spend.