4 ms·
Why levy high taxes on low mpg vehicles? Wouldn’t it make more sense to increase fuel taxes? Who cares if someone has a massive SUV if they drive it 2 miles p
by Scoundreller 8y ago
Why levy high taxes on low mpg vehicles? Wouldn’t it make more sense to increase fuel taxes?
Who cares if someone has a massive SUV if they drive it 2 miles per day? It’s the 50 mile per day driver that you really want to discourage from buying a gas guzzler.
Sincerely, a dude that bikes to work 90% of the time unless the weather is particularly deplorable (or has a big load go bring home)
- WalterBright 8y agoYes, it always seems inefficent to put controls on the rate of pollution rather than on the amount of pollution.
- Gibbon1 8y agoI actually think excise taxes on new vehicles is more effective since it forces people to put everything on the balance sheet when committing to buy. Makes sense because people don't commit to creating pollution/CO2 emissions when they fill their tank, they did it when they bought the car. On the other end you can do what California is doing which is paying people a couple of grand towards a down payment if they replace an older ICE car with an electric car. Would be a good idea if the state would also identify and target longer distance commuters for buyouts.
- coredog64 8y agoTwo negatives here. The first is that people rarely pay cash for a car, so unless you are levying a huge tax, it just rolls up into another $20/month. Significant over the long term, but not really an inducement to change behavior. The second is that this turns into a form of environmental redlining. Poor folks who need a car get priced out of the new car market. They then get stuck in older, less efficient, and less safe vehicles. Mass transit may eventually fix this, but in most parts of the US you’d have to raze entire cities to get a working mass transit system.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Why levy high taxes on low mpg vehicles? Wouldn’t it make more sense to increase fuel taxes? It makes sense to do both, because it's necessary to catch the average driver without pinching either end too hard. It doesn't take much to convince the heaviest drivers to buy more efficient vehicles -- it may not even take anything, since the fuel savings is already thousands of dollars for them regardless of any taxes. But they're still paying the fuel taxes even with the more efficient vehicle. Meanwhile the average driver would need a much higher fuel cost to convince them to buy the more efficient vehicle -- high enough that it would hammer the innocent heavy drivers who have already bought more efficient vehicles. On the other hand, a combination of fuel tax and incentives for purchasing more efficient vehicles will convince the average driver to switch without putting too severe a burden on heavy drivers who have already done the right thing. It's also generally not good to discourage productive usage. Better to get consumption from 100 gallons to 60 by going from 30MPG to 50 than by only being able to drive 1800 miles instead of 3000 and losing whatever value the extra 1200 miles of travel was worth. And of course it would be the opposite if you tried to do it entirely through a fee on inefficient vehicles -- the amount required to convince the median driver on its own without a fuel tax would be too much burden for vehicles with light usage. Which is why you want a balance of both.
- Scoundreller 8y ago> It doesn't take much to convince the heaviest drivers to buy more efficient vehicles Require them to buy 1000km of fuel when buying the vehicle. Plus second hand owners won’t feel the extra taxes on new cars, not directly anyway.
- CydeWeys 8y agoHuh, that's an interesting idea and I like it. It'll give people a visceral feeling of how much more expensive the inefficient vehicles will be to operate. Have this amount be printed prominently on the price sticker, and maybe consider increasing the distance. Depending on the country and inefficiency of the vehicle in question, the extra amount for pre-purchasing the fuel will only be low to high 3 digit dollars.
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoBehavioral economics, in short. It's the reason why people rent a $1k TV that lasts for 10 years at $50 (5%) a month ($6k spent) or pay 2% a month on a creditcard. We tend to overlook the small amounts and get slapped in the face by the large amounts.