3 ms·
Removing CO2 might be necessary to stop global warming. But what chance does this sort of ambitious effort have when more and more states don't even want to de
by joe_the_user 8y ago
Removing CO2 might be necessary to stop global warming.
But what chance does this sort of ambitious effort have when more and more states don't even want to deal with the ordinary problem of reducing CO2 output?
It seems to me that anyone caring about climate change needs to have a generally pro-science position politically.
- trowway 8y agoI'm going to give an unpopular opinion that doesn't get voiced very often. And that is that climate science sucks. There exist fundamental truths that I believe we can all agree on. The green house effect is real Humans spew things into the atmosphere that increase the greenhouse effect Therefore, we can safely say that humans are contributing to an effect that causes the earthto warm. The problem is that quantifying that effect is pretty much impossibly difficult to the level of detail that we need to make informed decisions about long term policy. And anyone who believes otherwise is bullshitting themselves. There are lots of reasons to burn less fossil fuels, but throwing in reasons that are based on bad science detracts from those efforts. To be clear, claiming that we know the earth is going to be 3 degrees warmer in 100 years (pick whatever numers you want) is preposterous. As people who develop models we must all know heep inside that we can make them say whatever we want. And if you make them say what the politicians want, you get more funding. There is good science mixed in, but the problem we have is that (I'll use the US example) the left believes that the sky is falling because it's a convenient argument to arouse people into protecting the environment. And the right are in the pockets of oil companies, and will say whatever they're told to. So, should we do the right thing (protect the environment) for the wrong reasons? I would argue no, because eventually nature will prove us wrong and the battle will be that much harder. The reason that nothing changes is because the right can point to bad science, and they are right. We owe it to ourselves to do better
- abraae 8y agoThese arguments are so tedious. The vast majority of scientists do agree that global warming is real and that humans are causing it. Yet the go-to argument for deniers is to claim that the science is not there. Not being a scientist myself, I have to assume that you're talking out your ass, and the scientists are correct.
- virmundi 8y agoI agree. Most of the time when the science is settled, it’s settled. For example all scientists knew that once we figured out black body radiation Newtonian physicist is complete. Nothing new was required. Even Lord Kelvin proclaimed that simple outstanding problem was entirely explainable by the physics of his day.
- yongjik 8y agoYeah, once physicists figured out quantum mechanics, cannon makers and bridge builders cried in dismay, because their previous measurements - based on previously trusted Newtonian mechanics - stopped working. "Serves them well!" people snickered. "Risking one's career on unsettled science!"
- trowway 8y agoYou're not listening, and that is part of the problem. We cannot have discussions, because the politics have polarized us. I'm not arguing that the earth isn't warming. I'm not arguing that humans aren't involved. I'm saying that there is a detrimental feedback loop between politics and science. This feedback loop means that we can't have reasonable discussions. Dismissing dissenting views as "climate change deniers" is a problem for science. And FWIW, though I'm a nobody, I have had private dinners with people who are somebodies (also, I respect that I'm an anonymous user on the internet which definitely helps my credibility - but I'll try anyway) - the people who have written IPCC reports and been in climate science research for decades. They share the opinions that I'm expressing, but dare not say them because they need grants; it's a delicate balance. The political feedback loop is a problem. It gets in the way of good science. Using predictive models can give us insight, but nature is pretty good at making fools of humans, and it's arrogant to believe that we can predict the future of something like the weather given the nature of the problem - we can't run controlled experiments, the data is super noisy and difficult to wrangle, and
- cbkeller 8y ago> dare not say them because they need grants Without trying to get into a flame war here, this claim is very iffy. As a scientist myself, there's (for better or worse) nothing better to make a career out of than showing where other scientists have made a mistake.
- torpfactory 8y agoScience doesn’t work like that: “As people who develop models we must all know heep inside that we can make them say whatever we want.” You don’t like the assumptions the model made? Fine, make an argument as to why they’re the wrong assumptions or the model is flawed. The model with the best predictive power wins the day.
- aldoushuxley001 8y agoThe irony being that IPCC models have a terrible track record of predictive success. So it seems maybe the best models dont win, but rather the most politically beneficial model wins
- torpfactory 8y agoI dunno man I just went and double checked the first IPCC report from 1990 and their estimates are pretty good... http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/publications_ipcc_first_assessment_1990_wg1.shtml http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/publications_ipcc_f...
- cameldrv 8y agoI believe in the basic consensus that the earth is warming due to human activity. Getting the magnitude right is very hard though, because it’s a complex system, we only have one data series, we have never experienced current or future conditions before, we can’t do controlled experiments, and our data is noisy and sometimes difficult to calibrate. This puts you in a situation where you may be able to predict direction accurately, but magnitude is very tough. Methane from melting permafrost and hydrates at the bottom of the ocean are just two examples that might cause a gross underestimate of warming impact.
- null000 8y agoThe error bars are not large enough to be seriously confident that the problem can be ignored, though. Basically everything we have says that: * Humans are causing basically all of the warming happening, either directly or indirectly * All of that warming will eventually be enough to kill most or all of us within 40-100 years, especially if nothing is done, but even still eventually if we stick to current commitments. There's literally no reason to faff about anymore - we have direct, quantifiable evidence that people are being killed and displaced by climate change related events today, and it will only get worse as time goes on. Hurricanes are stronger, wild fires are wilder, sea levels are rising and driving people off of low lying islands, glaciers are melting, the northwest passage has stayed opened for literally the first time in living memory, coral reefs are overheating to death, species are migrating north or just straight up going extinct. This is a problem now and immediately that the human race needs to address in force.
- thomasfedb 8y agoClimate science critics who refuse to be satisfied with models might find themselves filled with regret if those models are realised.
- torpfactory 8y agoWith respect to global warming, I don’t think we’ll get there politically. There are too many people and politicians that either don’t have a scientific worldview or are on the payroll (so to speak, not literally but via campaign funding) of fossil fuel companies. We may, however, get there via improved economics and technology happening in renewable energy right now. With an unreasonable amount of luck, we might buy ourselves enough time to make peace with the human condition and find a replacement for global capitalism that does a better job of integrating the reality of our needs and the planet’s.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoPolitically we have subsidies. Economically subsidized competition. It’s all very feasible and can be done rather quickly. We did / are doing it with wind and solar and can do so with negative carbon.
- shoo 8y ago> Removing CO2 might be necessary to stop global warming. > But what chance does this sort of ambitious effort have when more and more states don't even want to deal with the ordinary problem of reducing CO2 output? There are cheaper geo-engineering methods that don't attempt to directly reverse the problem, just (locally) mitigate some of the consequences, that could be done unilaterally by a state. E.g. stratospheric aerosol injection (less glamorous but a much cheaper than parking sunlight-filtering-satellites between the earth and the sun). > Unlike the control of greenhouse gas emissions, which must be undertaken by all major emitting nations to be effective and is likely to be costly, geoengineering could be undertaken quickly and unilaterally by a single party, at relatively low cost. Unilateral geoengineering, however, is highly likely to impose costs on other countries and run risks with the entire planet’s climate system. https://www.cfr.org/content/thinktank/GeoEng_Jan2709.pdf https://www.cfr.org/content/thinktank/GeoEng_Jan2709.pdf
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoDid you read the article? The person interview specifically mentions aerosol injections and possible unforeseen consequences of bio-engineering. It seems rather stupid to duct tape your leaking ship knowing that you’ll arrive at the port soon.
- shoo 8y agoi didn't read the article, but i did attend a couple of lectures last year about geoengineering proposals. i agree that e.g. aerosol injection proposals seem rather stupid, won't actually fix the problem, but may just mitigate some of the many consequences of the problem, and also cause entirely new problems. on the other hand, i suspect it is much more likely that geoengineering proposals will actually happen in preference to hypothetical negative emission technology, as geoengineering doesn't need a group of countries to agree on doing it, and (some of them) are relatively cheap and easy to do using existing technology.
- bigbluedots 8y agoWhy would they reduce emissions if the emissions can be removed from the atmosphere later?