7 ms·
Climate Solutions: Is It Feasible to Remove Enough CO2 from the Air?
- User23 8y agoWe should remember that we are currently in an ice age[1]. If climatology can be reduced to an effective engineering practice that would be awesome, but we should remember that a frozen Earth will be far worse for most human beings than a hothouse Earth. In the worst case scenarios of Global Warming, the burdens and costs will be largely born by the developed world, both in terms of geographical changes such as sea level rise as well as absorbing migrants from more southerly regions. And the developed world is up to those challenges. On the other hand, when, not if, the reglaciation occurs, it will be devastating to the entire human population of the planet. It would be darkly comical if unintentional human warming were staving off the next freezing period, and we brought catastrophe on our planet by trying to fix it. Humility is called for. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaternary_glaciation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaternary_glaciation
- brokensegue 8y agoyour citation doesn't seem to back up your claim
- zerealshadowban 8y agoWe do live in an interglacial [1] period, which is a slightly warmer, shorter time in the midst of an ice age. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interglacial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interglacial
- User23 8y agoFor added reference, this is due to astronomical[1], atmospheric, and tectonic causes [2]. Obviously human beings have no control over astronomical or tectonic factors. The claim that the atmospheric factor can override both the astronomical and tectonic factors isn't implausible, but it should be understood that the atmosphere isn't the only or even the primary factor determining the climate. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milankovitch_cycles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milankovitch_cycles [2] https://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/ice_ages.html https://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/ice_ages.html
- cbkeller 8y agoWoah woah woah, hold up. Geologist here. The effects of Milankovitch cyclicity and tectonics on climate are entirely mediated through the atmosphere.
- zerealshadowban 8y agoThe distinction between proximate and ultimate causes is deeply relevant for science and scientists. For instance, when oceans change, such as el nino, la nina, reversals of enduring currents, or even new connections between seas due to tectonic transformations, that is properly a cause of climate change -- regardless of how much that change is, in fine, mediated by the atmosphere. Atmospheric changes are demonstrably not the only, nor the ultimate causes, of climate change.
- krastanov 8y agoThe worst case scenario is more like a "Clathrate gun" doomsday. While the worst case is improbable, I do believe the priors you use to evaluate the risk and cost of global warming might be a bit optimistic. And it seems contradictory to say that the brunt of costs will be paid by the developed world and then admit that the costs include the migrant from locations on Earth rendered uninhabitable. Lastly, you are assuming that the political climate will permit us to deal intelligently, compassionately, and fiscally efficiently with migrants. The current political climate seems to contradict that assumption. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis
- User23 8y agoMay as well worry about the solar wind blowing the atmosphere away. That's also possible after all. It's surprising to me that in a technologically astute and optimistic forum like this one, there would be so much resistance to the idea that engineering solutions to heating would be easier than engineering solutions to cooling. Because anthropogenic or not, the climate is going to change, and keep changing, so either we adapt, we engineer it, or we die.
- krastanov 8y agoYou missed my point. Of course it would be great to have a solution for every eventuality. However, the climate rapidly warming is the imminent danger. And it is the rate of change, not the final value, that is the most worrisome.
- User23 8y agoI didn't miss your point, and on the principle of charity I'm going to assume you didn't miss mine.
- systoll 8y agoIf we were to somehow go too far in the other direction, undoing all that CO2 removal wouldn't even be a challenge -- It'd be a return to the current status quo.
- ip26 8y agoBut how will we ever get the public to drive more SUV's and buy more disposable goods from the other side of the planet!?
- hirundo 8y agoGod help us when the fraction of gases in the atmosphere can be set by the political process. How often do we get a ruling class that you would trust with that decision? And if we can't trust them consistently on that, it may become our species' resolution of the Fermi paradox.
- krastanov 8y agoThis is a bit bombastic. Democracies are not perfect, but they have been mostly functional, and the ruling class (while not great) does not have such a bad record: ozone depleting chemicals, leaded gasoline, OSHA rules, drug and food safety standards. Just like you, I am disappointed by the slow progress, but if we are to be taken seriously with our concerns we should not exaggerate.
- gameswithgo 8y ago>How often do we get a ruling class that you would trust with that decision? Right now the ruling class of big oil is setting the fraction of gases in the atmosphere, and doing a terrible job of it. But at least it isn't the government?
- ip26 8y agoIt doesn't seem particularly fraught with ambiguity? We know what the composition was going back many hundreds of years. Presumably it would not be hard to agree something like, "OK we target the pre-industrial revolution composition" and that would be that.
- stouset 8y ago> …presumably it would not be hard to agree… This seems like a particularly bold claim given that we currently live in a political climate where we can’t even seem to agree on basic matters of reality.
- zerealshadowban 8y agoWe should remember that CO2 is an essential fertilizer for plants and phytoplankton, all of which thrive when there is much more CO2 in the atmosphere. Their photosynthesis processes evolved in and are ideal for an environment with CO2 concentrations at least 5-10x the current levels. At or below 150 ppm of CO2 in the air, all land-based plants would go extinct.
- sintaxi 8y agoExactly. I wouldn't reduce the CO2 even if it was possible.
- roter 8y agoPerhaps only if we consider CO2 in isolation without attendant water, temperature, and mineral stresses. And perhaps not on longer time scales [0]. And perhaps not everywhere [1]. [0] http://science.sciencemag.org/content/360/6386/317 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/360/6386/317 [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate2995 https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate2995
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThey might thrive, if and only if, they can move to an area where they have their needed heat, water and light exposures. If atmospheric CO2 is 5x or 10x everything will need to be migrating an awful lot of miles northwards. To soils and locations that may not be suitable for ph or mineral reasons. Plants almost certainly can't migrate fast enough for current rates of change, let alone more. So there's agriculture screwed. At or above 1,000ppm, or 2.5x current outside levels, human performance starts to decline. People will complain of drowsiness and stuffiness. Those levels can occur in buildings already. I don't look forward to a future where opening a window for fresh air delivers stuffiness, and inside buildings rise commensurately. Who knows how many pollinating species will go extinct, and at what levels, as they can no longer breathe enough to fuel their activities.
- tzs 8y ago> Their photosynthesis processes evolved in and are ideal for an environment with CO2 concentrations at least 5-10x the current levels Wait a second. For the last few million years CO2 levels have been in the 180-300 ppm range (except for recently where they have gone above that). What makes you think that plants that initially evolved hundreds of millions of years ago in very high CO2 environments did not continue evolving as CO2 levels changed, so that the plants we now have find 180-300 ppm to be ideal?
- protomyth 8y agoShouldn’t we be removing it from the oceans since they’ve been absorbing the excess according to some old articles on HN?
- jorblumesea 8y agoCO2 from the air ends up being absorbed in the oceans. It's really just about; what is the most efficient way to remove CO2 from the carbon cycle. Currently removing from the air has appeared most promising. Perhaps that will change in time.
- zerealshadowban 8y agoThe largest and, long-term, most effective carbon sink are phytoplankton. They are responsible for half of all photosynthesis, thus absorbing tremendous quantities of CO2. As they individually die, they over millions of years accumulate thick carbon-filled layers at the bottom of oceans. This is the ultimate origin of oil deposits, by the way.
- rsa4046 8y agoAt a pH of ~8, the majority of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) exists as bicarbonate. Inorganic removal of a mole of HCO3- from surface seawater via precipitation of CaCO3 yields a mole of CO2 back to the atmosphere. Easier to fix CO2 via the classic silicate weathering reaction, which grabs 2 moles of CO2 per mole of silicate weathered (using CaSiO3 as a trivial example). This is the essential feedback from continental weathering: the Earth's thermostat.
- noobermin 8y agoThere is this amazing organism that removes CO_2 from the air for free.
- dogma1138 8y agoAnd then release it back when it dies, biomass sequestering doesn’t work well unless you can find something that would not decompose and then you need to figure out what to do with it.
- noobermin 8y agoHow do they release it back? A process that takes a few hours (burning) or a process that takes years? How did the hydrocarbons get in the ground in the first place? You can't be serious with "something that would not decompose". Entropy literally disfavors it. The point is to tamper the rate, not to completely turn all C into diamond and jettison it into the sun.
- joe_the_user 8y agoRemoving CO2 might be necessary to stop global warming. But what chance does this sort of ambitious effort have when more and more states don't even want to deal with the ordinary problem of reducing CO2 output? It seems to me that anyone caring about climate change needs to have a generally pro-science position politically.
- trowway 8y agoI'm going to give an unpopular opinion that doesn't get voiced very often. And that is that climate science sucks. There exist fundamental truths that I believe we can all agree on. The green house effect is real Humans spew things into the atmosphere that increase the greenhouse effect Therefore, we can safely say that humans are contributing to an effect that causes the earthto warm. The problem is that quantifying that effect is pretty much impossibly difficult to the level of detail that we need to make informed decisions about long term policy. And anyone who believes otherwise is bullshitting themselves. There are lots of reasons to burn less fossil fuels, but throwing in reasons that are based on bad science detracts from those efforts. To be clear, claiming that we know the earth is going to be 3 degrees warmer in 100 years (pick whatever numers you want) is preposterous. As people who develop models we must all know heep inside that we can make them say whatever we want. And if you make them say what the politicians want, you get more funding. There is good science mixed in, but the problem we have is that (I'll use the US example) the left believes that the sky is falling because it's a convenient argument to arouse people into protecting the environment. And the right are in the pockets of oil companies, and will say whatever they're told to. So, should we do the right thing (protect the environment) for the wrong reasons? I would argue no, because eventually nature will prove us wrong and the battle will be that much harder. The reason that nothing changes is because the right can point to bad science, and they are right. We owe it to ourselves to do better
- abraae 8y agoThese arguments are so tedious. The vast majority of scientists do agree that global warming is real and that humans are causing it. Yet the go-to argument for deniers is to claim that the science is not there. Not being a scientist myself, I have to assume that you're talking out your ass, and the scientists are correct.
- shoo 8y agoI'm reading "The Ends of the World: Supervolcanoes, Lethal Oceans, and the Search for Past Apocalypses" by Peter Brannen. Most of the book focuses on past mass extinction events, but there's a bit of discussion and comparison to what's going on in the world now. It's written in a fairly popular-science-y style, but there's lots of references to further reading. Some quotes: > [...] humanity has not yet come anywhere even remotely close to the death tolls of the major mass extinctions of the past half-billion years ... yet. In the past 400 years, there have been documented extinctions of some 800 species. This is a tragedy, to be sure, and likely a massive undercount, but when divided by the 1.9 million species known, 800 extinct species amounts to an extinction of less than one-tenth of 1 percent - a far cry from the End-Permian, during which, generously rounding up, almost 100 percent of complex life on earth was killed. re: the End-Permian mass extinction > "Five hundred million years is a really, really, _really_ long time. And [the End-Permian mass extinction] is the single worst event in the last 500 million years of earth history. So your scenario should not be sort of a bad-day scenario. [...] It's closer to a one-in-a-billion event." > [...] End-Permian sites across the planet from the ancient ocean [...] similarly recorded a carbon cycle jackknifing. Where did all this extra light carbon in the atmosphere come from? One way is to kill all the plants, plankton, and animals in the world. [...] But the carbon isotope swing at the End-Permian mass extinction is so severe that many other scientists think that the collapse of the biosphere isn't enough to explain it. > [...] At the end of the Permian, Siberia briefly turned inside out as the Traps covered Russia in more than 2 million square miles of lava. > [...] "Basically the entire global economy rests on how quickly we can get carbon out of the ground and put it in the atmosphere", Ridgwell told me. "That's basically the global enterprise. And there's a lot of people doing it. Geologically, it's a really impressive effort." > But as exceptional as humans are, estimates of the carbon released in the End-Permian mass extinction range from an utterly catastrophic 10,000 gigatons of carbon -- twice as much as we could ever burn -- up to a mind-meltingly unfathomable 48,000 gigatons. > [...] "So taking the modern ocean and adding 40,000 gigatons of carbon -- like in the End-Permian -- it would take you from, say, 300 ppm to 30,000 ppm CO_2," Payne said. We both started laughing. This number is incomprehensible. > [...] For now, typical estimates place End-Permian atmospheric carbon dioxide somewhere around 8,000 parts per million [...] > [...] In the long term the oceans can keep up with a huge buildup of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, as long as it happens slowly enough. The gradual process of weathering breaks down rocks on land, washing them into the ocean and, in doing so, buffer the seas against acidification [...]" > "Well, the rate at which we're injecting CO_2 into the atmosphere today, according to our best estimates, is ten times faster than it was during the End-Permian. And rates matter. So today we're creating a very difficult environment for life to adapt, and we're imposing that change maybe ten times faster than the worst events in Earth's history". For reference, the human endeavour is injecting roughly 40 gigatons of CO_2 into the atmosphere every year.
- philipswood 8y agoI wouldn't mind living in this future. I'm haunted by a beautiful idea: Imagine standing outside in sunlight. Above the clouds in the course of the sun is a faint band a bit wider than the sun. Specks, motes. Thousands of them. Across the band some glitter, some are dark - like dark specks. Those covering the sun are almost all dark. If you carefully look at them through a filter that let's you see the sun's disk, you can make out a fuzzy outline not too unlighy the continents, with a few extra spots in between. Earth has a ring. An artifical one, much wider than the ones Saturn has - more like a ribbon, actually. The motes are each large flat reflective surfaces. Flat disks made of reflective plastic films. Microns thick with as much area as is practical to make launch and unfold at scale. They orient themselves using current flowing around their rim using electricity generated from solar power on their main body. The current in the rims orient them relative to earth's magnetic field. They also act like solar sails when needed, using solar wind for minor maneuvering and they use small micro ion drives for positioning. Each is a pixel. It can reflect sunlight completely away from the surface of the earth. Or to a targeted spot on it. They can match their rotation to their orbit and cast a variable shadow: from a slim wisp to their full area. All in all. All of them together can dim the sunlight falling on the earth by up to 2%, but with precise control per region. Many targeted on the same spot can boil (or slowly evaporate) large bodies of water or heat large volumes of air within specific control. They can be weapons. Terrible ones: melting metal and rock for small focused regions. But mostly they are tools - gardening tools. Weather, and more importantly climate is something that they are used to steer. After wrecking the sort of balance we found when we started here we were responsible for establishing a new balance. Most of their work is reducing the incident solar radiation falling on the earth's surface. They dim the radiant energy on the surface in line with the current climate control program. For the continents they mostly just reduce incoming energy. Over the ocean some areas are dimmed less to help cloud formation. This extends their influence immensely as we then increase the earth's albedo using the extra cloud cover, reflecting a lot more light than ocean does. They fiercely shield whatever glaciers we could save. The ones on the night side are used for controlled lighting in a few cases. The baby drone-planted forests are sometimes given extra sunlight. And a few cities are given the occasional extra light when safe. The ones not positioned for blocking sunlight focus light and heat to manage weather systems. Parts of the garden's weather systems can be managed. On the one side of a continent clouds are formed by heating the ocean. These clouds are shielded and shepherded through shielded corridors and allowed to condense and rain in the interior. In places large inland water bodies were made. In other places river like canals were melted through rock. The natural forests and areas we could save are given special status:Bonsai, and we try to keep them vaguely in line with what they originally were, at great cost. But much desert is farmable and a lot of previously rough terrain is being manicured. Some spots of the garden are never tame and recalcitrantly fights back. There is a degree of success in using them to manage ocean currents, but it's difficult and doesn't always work. They don't have the strength and finesse required to do that at scale. We need other tools for that. Wind currents are easier. They follow simple temperature gradients and with trial and error and a lot of computer modeling these are mostly directly managed. Weather is at a coarse (and often fine) level controllable within the constraints set by climate regulation control. A new stable balance against the current level of atmospheric composition can be maintained - within reasonable constraints. We still need to spend decades or centuries cleaning up our carbon dioxide mess. New forests, huge atmosphere altering factories and sublimation pits help, but it is a long term project.
- null000 8y agoJesus Christ hacker news, get your shit together. Way to many Climate Change denialists/minimizers here to be anything but appalling, considering the reputation of the site's user base. Scientists agree: Climate change is terrifying, climate change is human caused, and climate change is here now today, threatening to be the effective end of our species in a number of decades you can count on your hands. On top of which, it only takes mildly pessimistic scenarios to reach time spans you will probably live to see.
- ulisesrmzroche 8y agoThey'll never fucking get it. They cling to their masters and love the whip.