5 ms·
I wish Diane well in her future endeavors and I certainly agree it would be great to see more women in the C suite. I would be curious to know if her passions
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
I wish Diane well in her future endeavors and I certainly agree it would be great to see more women in the C suite.
I would be curious to know if her passions are intertwined with her departure, specifically if she felt that Google had structural issues with women in leadership roles. She is essentially being fired as the lead of this organization and being replaced with a fairly prototypical male lead. I am not implying that Thomas isn't qualified, his LinkedIn profile suggests he have very relevant experience, Diane also has the experience in her resume as well. What will help Thomas succeed in this role?
The bottom line is I would like to see more women in leadership positions and I am sad to see us lose one. I would like to understand (although I realize that isn't possible) if her departure was preventable, and if so what would have had to be different.
- tw04 8y ago>Diane also has the experience in her resume as well. Nothing in her resume actually suggests she had the experience for what Google needed. VMware became popular in a similar way to Redhat, in that it solved a technical issue nobody else was solving at the time. It didn't have explosive growth until EMC took over and with it EMC management style/structure. She was just along for the ride the second the company was sold to EMC. >What will help Thomas succeed in this role? He was in a position of power in what is one of the most successful sales organizations in the history of tech. I don't like Oracle, in fact my post history will show that I loathe them. But their salesforce has absolutely dominated the tech industry for 2 decades+. Google needs someone that knows how to sell to enterprise, they don't just need another nerd at the top. Based on my experiences with Diane she was an extremely gifted technical talent and an extremely poor saleswoman and leader.
- threeseed 8y agoGCP doesn't need to figure out how to sell to enterprises. They need to offer a better product with more features, support etc. Because adoption within the enterprise isn't driven by the CEO or CTO. It's driven by individual architects and developers.
- ttmb 8y agoYMMV widely. It's not at all uncommon to have large software and infrastructure deals signed by CTOs and Business Analyst type people based on advertised product features and compliance certifications, without ever speaking to architects, engineers and implementors about technology fit, compatibility, etc.
- pm90 8y agoUmmmm... no. Most non software firms consider technology as a cost center. Most don’t care about the technical merits of the platform; all they care is cost and support. This is why IBM cloud is seeing adoption despite not being as full featured as aws or gcp.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoThe resume I was talking about is, as I see it; Diane was a founder of VMWare. VMWare was very successful at getting Enterprise customers to convert their massive single use servers into "Liquid IT" where VMWare instances ran the world. NetApp, when I was there, was selling a bunch of NAS into clouds of servers running VMWare. Then she left VMWare and started BeBop, a company that was dedicated to getting Enterprises to move their applications into virtualized compute clusters. When she was acquired/hired by Google is seemed like a slam dunk that she was the person who was going to make Google Cloud the premier service for Enterprise companies to host their infrastructure on. As I read it, that was very much in line with where Google saw Google Cloud going. Then we see from the market analysts that Microsoft has (according to the analysts here, I can't really vouch for them) edged Google into third place in the 'Cloud' market by capturing Enterprises moving their applications to the enterprise space. Then we see Google replacing their head of cloud with a high power sales guy. And as always, "reading the tea leaves" as an analyst might say, is always an inexact science. So folks outside the situation (like myself) can't know what is really going on. > Based on my experiences with Diane she was an extremely gifted technical talent and an extremely poor saleswoman and leader. This seems to be a pretty damning statement, as someone who has direct experience with Diane, what did you see that she could have done differently?
- the__prestige 8y ago> until EMC took over and with it EMC management style/structure. She was just along for the ride the second the company was sold to EMC. This is not true. Diane was the founder of VMware. VMware is a virtualization technology that runs independently of underlying hardware and infrastructure. It could succeed only because it was able to convince its customers and partners that it is neutral to all forms of infrastructure, whether it is compute, networking or storage related. Most of said partners - companies as IBM, HP, Netapp etc. - are direct competitors of EMC. This is the reason that EMC allowed VMware to operate independently, be listed on the stock exchange as a independent entity and have its own operating culture. And Diane was the main reason that VMware maintained this kind of independence. Source: I was a VMware employee.
- thoughtexplorer 8y ago> The bottom line is I would like to see more women in leadership positions and I am sad to see us lose one. Absolutely. But let's be real, the odds are likely that Google tried to bend over backwards to make it work. They want more women in those roles and generally.
- readams 8y agoDiane Greene is not being fired. She's been enormously positive for Google Cloud.
- nl 8y agoDianne Greene was the best thing ever to happen to Google Cloud. She’s widely respected within Google and she interviewed her successor. That’s not being fired.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoOkay, you are correct, let's not say she was fired, she was separated from the company. Separations can happen for several reasons and they have different terms, I recognize that most people associate "fired" with incompetence or misconduct and that likely wasn't the case here[1]. Generally, with senior leaders, they have a set of objectives that they are tasked with working toward, and every year is a negotiation over whether or not they are meeting their objectives. When they aren't meeting those objectives (or perhaps enough of those objectives) then there is a discussion about next steps. Which is a euphemism for "this isn't working for us, we need to replace you with someone who can meet these objectives." Now is that getting fired? or laid off? I think it's semantics. At the end of the day you don't have a job with the company any more. Few senior leaders that I've interacted with have ever called out the company for telling them they were going to lose their job. If you have reached that level you should have the maturity to understand that it is a fact of life that this happens. Scott McNealy used to send congratulations to people who were promoted into the senior ranks with "One step up, one step closer to the door." That reflected the reality that there are few alternative positions within a company for someone who is leading a big chunk of the company. When the separation is the idea of the employee (which is to say they quit), the notification pattern seems proactive on the employee's side. A press release that the employee is moving on and that the company is working on finding a successor, and then sometime later we get the "I'm actually leaving now, and here is my successor." press release. But there is no hard and fast rule. Bottom line is that the term 'fired' has the connotation of malfeasance and that doesn't seem to be the case here, I should have used "likely involuntary separation" but that seems a bit wordy, although it avoids the baggage of the word fired. [1] As we can see from documents about Andy Rubin's departure, all of the press at the time read like Andy was just moving on to bigger and better things, when in fact he was being separated from the company because of credible accusations of sexual harassment. My point being that we on the outside can't know why a senior leader is leaving really, the copy in the press releases is carefully crafted regardless of the actual reasons.