4 ms·
> The US car industry is notorious for poor engineering standards and quality, largely driven by profit incentives. That certainly used to be the case, 20+ yea
by adventured 8y ago
> The US car industry is notorious for poor engineering standards and quality, largely driven by profit incentives.
That certainly used to be the case, 20+ years ago. US auto makers have dramatically improved since the mid 1990s.
On reliability today Buick outranks BMW, Infiniti, Toyota and Mercedes. Chevrolet outranks Toyota, Audi, Honda, Hyundai and BMW. Ford & GMC are better than Subaru and Acura, comparable to Mercedes, and slightly better than Volkswagen. Lincoln is better than Honda, Nissan and Audi.
https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/jd-power-2018-us-vehicle-dependability-study https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/jd-power-201...
- lazulicurio 8y agoPurely anecdotal, but as someone in the space I'd attribute those improvements largely to better manufacturing technology rather than better management. Servos, feedback control, reliability testing, etc. have improved a lot since the 90s. But American management still tends to be rather Taylorist. With electronic components being more popular you're seeing quality issues crop back up from T1/T2 suppliers because the focus is on technology instead of process. But the AOI/ICT I've seen in the automotive space are fairly crude compared to the number of potential failures you can have with electronic components. Playing whack-a-mole doesn't work. You need people close to the process who care enough to notice when something is not quite right, and are empowered to do something about it. Kaizen is to manufacturing what Agile/Scrum is to software development. As soon as management hears "improved efficiency" they tend to focus on the dollar signs rather than the message about people and process.
- jnurmine 8y agoThis sounded quite interesting and surprising as a result. I could not access the results so I did some quick googling. The source is JD Power and they are claimed to have bad methodology. From what I read they don't weigh issues, so an infotainment issue is on the same level as a more severe mechanical issue. There's a ranking from Consumer Reports but it requires a subscription as well, and it is probably somewhat biased since to my understanding one needs to be a subscriber to answer the questions in the first place. A better method would be to pool data from several insurance companies, but I could not find such a thing. I could imagine that publishing this data would be of great interest to insurance companies. That way, they could steer people into using cars which are cheaper to the insurance companies. An objective study would certainly be of interest to someone who needs a car to move around. It's costly and not to mention frustrating when a car breaks down.
- robdachshund 8y agoThere is no way gm has better reliability than honda. They had dangerous problems with their cars for years. Things like steering wheels popping off while you are on the interstate. JD power is dubious; look at consumer reports.